So that must mean...

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

El Syf

Vargheist
Dec 4, 2011
673
Eastbourne
Zombies
418
Forge world doing the Primarchs got me thinking, if they're not sacred anymore surely that can be applied to Uber fantasy characters and we can have Neferata and 1st gen vamps? I know normally this is considered very wishful thinking but if Horus can have offical rules why can't Abhorash? Please move if this thread is in the wrong place :suck:
 
That's a good point. Primarchs have always been sacrosanct (for some stupid reason) but now Forge World seem confident enough to do what the fans want, maybe they'll follow-through...
 
If they bring it into fantasy I am not sure they can deliver the goods.
In 40k there is allot not said so lore is allot more open, allot has already been said in fantasy though and each book brings more and more glaring errors, for this reason I am not sure I would ever want it to happen.
 
I'm not sure this is such a good idea is it...?
While I also wish that every now and then I could take the Legendary characters in the Warhammer world out to beat up my opponents. But realistically I don't think it would work.
How are they going to write rules (and balance them for games) for such enourmously uber characters?
 
Well, the Primarch profiles from the new horus Heresy book are good but not too overpowered, and they are not unbeatable. So, from a purely stats and gameplay POV, its do-able.

That said, I have a vision of Sigmar in my head not unlike that of Sauron from the Lord of the Rings movie. He swings his hammer and kills 20 men with every hit. It would be a shame to tie a legend like that down to somethuing so mundane as a stat line. Takes all the mystique away.

Although, it can be argued that they have already done it with Vanashesh. All the evidence suggests he is Vlad von Carstein, and he is a playable special character (with a pretty ordinary profile).........
 
If you read the Sigmar books he wasn't that ridiculous in combat, sure he could do the occasional awesome move with his hammer, but it never killed scores of men in one blow. He was powerful, but not ridiculously so (he didn't become a god till later) Legends often are fairly ordinary people when you see them first hand.

Also, a retcon is not a glaring error, its an update, which is sometimes a good thing, sometimes a bad thing.
 
Whisky Priest said:
Well, the Primarch profiles from the new horus Heresy book are good but not too overpowered, and they are not unbeatable. So, from a purely stats and gameplay POV, its do-able.

That said, I have a vision of Sigmar in my head not unlike that of Sauron from the Lord of the Rings movie. He swings his hammer and kills 20 men with every hit. It would be a shame to tie a legend like that down to somethuing so mundane as a stat line. Takes all the mystique away.

Although, it can be argued that they have already done it with Vanashesh. All the evidence suggests he is Vlad von Carstein, and he is a playable special character (with a pretty ordinary profile).........


To be honest I did not anticipate them doing such a good job of the Primarchs back then when I wrote it, maybe there is hope after all?

Well not really just the evidence as it even says in Nights Dark Masters that Vlad is him in as many words, rare you get such a straight answer like that from GW ever.....




In his books Sigmar is normally losing and for no reason at all manages to hit the good side win button where before they stood no chance at all..... Its bloody annoying.
 
Maybe sigmar was not overpowered but nagash certainly was. Problem is that in the fantasy universe anyone can kill anyone but in the game minor differences in stat lines almost make it impossible to defeat another character. Nagash created the undead, one character that gave birth to two different factions. Teclis may be overpowered but if so then nagash is on a completely different level. To make rules for nagash would be to make him much worse than he is. They may try the ctan method though, if something is too powerful to exist in the game have a shard of it.
 
Aren said:
Maybe sigmar was not overpowered but nagash certainly was. Problem is that in the fantasy universe anyone can kill anyone but in the game minor differences in stat lines almost make it impossible to defeat another character. Nagash created the undead, one character that gave birth to two different factions. Teclis may be overpowered but if so then nagash is on a completely different level. To make rules for nagash would be to make him much worse than he is. They may try the ctan method though, if something is too powerful to exist in the game have a shard of it.

One of the old edition undead lists (before the VC / TC split) had Nagash in it as a character. He was represented on the tabletop by a 40mm base giant skeleton (which looked a little bit silly imho). Can't remeber what his profile wasv - but it approached the low end greater daemon level as I recall.
 
yeah he was his stats was about the same as lord of change and the model was realy bad but if forgeworld did a nagash that would be cool he could have loremaster of TK,Vamps and death hed be undead teclis lol
 
Like I said, they made him not powerful enough. Hr should be way more powerful than teclis, I don't recall teclis creating two new factions basically from scratch.
 
Aren said:
Like I said, they made him not powerful enough. Hr should be way more powerful than teclis, I don't recall teclis creating two new factions basically from scratch.

If I was designing Nagash now, I personally wouldn't give him a combat monster profile - he was, after all, just a priest when human. So WS3, S&T 4 or 5, 4 or 5 wounds etc.

What I would give him though is awesome magical power (via access to spell lists and special abilities representing the more powerful magical knowledge) as that is where his area of expertise was.
 
Whisky Priest said:
Aren said:
Like I said, they made him not powerful enough. Hr should be way more powerful than teclis, I don't recall teclis creating two new factions basically from scratch.

If I was designing Nagash now, I personally wouldn't give him a combat monster profile - he was, after all, just a priest when human. So WS3, S&T 4 or 5, 4 or 5 wounds etc.

What I would give him though is awesome magical power (via access to spell lists and special abilities representing the more powerful magical knowledge) as that is where his area of expertise was.

When human you were right, however after all his enchantments, the fact he gained power in a way similar to what vampires do sending his strength and toughness through the roof before he bacame 8ft tall.
Nagash the Priest and Nagash the Necromancer was a different Kettle of fish.
He became a man that can go toe to toe with a greater daomon and win in both magic and combat.

Hell just look at his old stats from when he was in an army book.
Things have come a long way since then and characters have only become more powerful, if we were to see him in rules for a forge world campaign which I hope we do I would expect him to be a tier above the primarchs where as Aborash, Vashanesh and the gang would be on the Primarch tier themselves each with their own specialties.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu