So what do you think of the new book?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

What do you think of the new book?


  • Total voters
    306

Disciple of Nagash

Libidinosus
Administrator
True Blood
Feb 12, 2008
28,011
Yorkshire
Zombies
13,979
So I have got my hand on the new book today.

Result: I'm relatively happy.

I won't pretend that the new book is perfect and everything I had hoped for, I still think an option for a more power vampire ancient / lord in higher end games and a few other things.

A quick overview:

Special Characters
Probably the area of most disappointment. It is still a Carstein bonanza, even more annoying on that level is that characters are basically carbon copies from the last edition. (Even more annoying for me is that Mannfred if better than Vlad, Vlad was his sire - make him better!!).
Still the return of Kemmler and Krell are welcome, and even better they seem to be decent characters. Kemmler certainly seems to be well worth it, I can see his use as a secondary Lord to a combat Vamp Lord, or those who just want a bunker general. Krell, seems playable but the best thing about him is his gorgeous model.

Characters
I'm pretty satisfied here. In fact I would go to say that the only thing missing for me is a stronger Lord level as previously mentioned. The Vamp Lord and Wight King are still solid choice, in fact I think the Wight King is still probably the best hero in warhammer for his points.
Vampires are better with their additional attack, Wraiths and Banshees are good choices as well.
The best change tho is the Necro. He is now what we always needed, a basic caster that we can use without the silly limitations of the previous book :thumbsup:

One thing even better about our vamps, is that they are more durable. Armour though expensive is now available to buy as standard, and even better the Hunger rule gives them a chance to regain lost wounds without magic.

Vampire Powers
Firstly - it is still separate to our magic allowance - yes! Secondly, I personally feel that this editions powers are more useful than the previous. By that I mean I can see more of the different powers being use instead of the same two of three. A couple to note are Aura of Dark Majesty - now well worth its points (same effect as last edition, half the points!), Quickblood - will no doubt become a firm favourite and Fear Incarnate.
Some of the powers have weakened from the previous iterations, but I would say there is only one that in my eyes is really not worth its points, and that is Master of the Black Arts. It is really only a backup should you roll poorly on the Winds of Magic, and the cost associated to this power really puts me off.

Magic
Magic is a two way affair for me.
You have the usual offensive spells, but the two main spells have seriously been affected:

IoN: For me, I love the changes. As far as I am concerned if used right this is a really potent spell. Instead of affecting just one unit it affects everything in a radius, which you can increase upto 18" (so it combines the old Summon Undead Horde). Not only that, the amount of models raised far outclass the old IoN. Cast by a level 4 wizard and you have on average 7 wounds healed per unit. If you have multiple units, that is a massive number of healed wounds. As usual certain units can be healed by one wound, but to be fair those units are generally powerful enough to warrant this. The fact that you can now heal multiple Black Knights and Dire Wolves is great.

Vanhels: This the problem one for me. On a positive side this spell provides two effects in one cast, combat bonuses (lasting unit the next VC magic phase)and allowing the unit to move if not in combat. However you can no longer charge with the spell :'( This is quite a big impact on one of our key elements that has been around for forever, and one that will seriously impact some of our usual VC tactics.


Magic Items
I am a little gutted in this area. So many key and traditional items gone. The few remaining are actually reasonably good. Our uber sword can really make your lord nasty, and as long as you kill one model during the game everything is dandy. For a vamp lord, that shouldn't be too much of a tall order.

Probably the most decent items are the Nightshroud, basically ensures your characters can hit first no matter what and the Rod of Flaming Death. It did everything it previously did, and also acts like the fire spell where if the unit moves after every model takes an additional hit.

So not totally screwed, but just sad to see so many favourites go. I should note in fairness that a lot of the items (not all) we lost do have equivalents in the common list.

Core
I'm pretty happy in this section. Ghouls still are their usual tough selves. Yes they are a bit more expensive and cannot be raised above their numbers, but in my mind it now gives them a place. Instead of anvils their role are harder hitting flankers, smaller units hunting down enemy skirmishers. Basically enemy units where Skellies and Zombies can't get it done, but a character is overkill.

Zombies - Fantastic changes. They may not kill much (they are zombies after all), but they will stick around for longer with their increased toughness and more numbers due to their lowered points cost. The ability to pit a character in there is great to provide kills.

Dire Wolves - Inclusion of core, ability to heal more than one and their slavering charge rule means the puppies are now viable choices again.

Skellies - Our poor skellies probably got the worst out of the lot. The extra points for marginally better stats than zombies means they will often be overlooked. Still, they are ok for their points (now reduced), and can take command and magical banners for extra CR. With a necro with the master of the dead, they can be made into huge tarpits.


Special
I'm very happy in this section. Our specials have a decent mixture of anvil units, heavy hitters, cavalry, flying units and more. I won't go into all of them, but a few notable points:

CC - slightly better than previous, especially with the Rigour Mortis spell. Unholy Lodestone is the new upgrade of choice, allowing you to re-roll the D6 for IoN cast within range.

GG - Cheaper, and the GW upgrade is also cheaper :thumbsup:

BK - Also cheaper

Crypt Horrors / Vargheists - these units are nasty. Vargheists are like flying Ogres with 4 attacks each, and Crypt Horrors are as touch as a Wight King to shift with regen on top.

Fell Bats - Cheaper in points :thumbsup:

Batswarms - these little guys are the dark horse of the whole armylist. Any enemy unit in base contact as ASL, which in combats with multiple units really makes them worthwhile

Spirit Hosts - Lots cheaper in points :thumbsup:

Hexwraiths - Superb. These will become our new uber unit, and I guarantee they will be universally hated and moaned about by our opponents. Fast moving ethereal cav, can move through friendly and enemy units, damages enemy units when moving through them, and their attacks are flaming and allow no armour save. Considering they are only 9 points more than Black Knights, they are well worth their points. (I would like to note that GW have nicked these from CN's Legion of Nagash, as we created something very similar xd)


Rare
I'm pretty happy with this section as well.

The usual four of Varghulf, Blood Knights, Cairn Wraiths and Black Coach are all still there, still pretty much the same. There are slight tweaks to their rules, slight reduction in some points but they are basically the same.

The Terrorgheist as previously discussed is a solid choice.

The new Mortis engine is very good. The bonuses it confers are much better than the Coven throne, and is a great if unstable addition.


Finally, possibly the biggest and best rule - the loss of our general no longer means the crumbling of our army xD As long as you have another user with the Lore of Vampires, they can take over the next turn. Most VC armies will most likely have 2-3 users, so our general is no longer the glaring weakpoint that he used to be.


So all in all, I'm pretty happy. I can see a variety of builds, there are enough changes to the powers to bring back my beloved Lahmians, and the new models are some of the best GW has produced for VC in my opinion.

So, well done GW :thumbsup:
 
Still reading through it, there is allot I like and allot I don't so of a mixed opinion but there is enough to shake up the way we play and make it much more enjoyable.

I will need to hammer the book tonight and see where it takes me by the end before I give my full view on each part of the book not including the lore.....
That will take more time in addition to the rules for everything.
 
Love this book!

Favorites:
- zombies good again!
- Many more list building options.
- magic items are useful or fun (or both)
- Cool new toys
- A lot of synergy in the list

Meh:
- special characters

Unhappy about:
- there is no difference between character wraiths & banshees and unit wraiths & banshees besides points value. Could have at least given the character versions a magic item allowance.
 
Im quite happy wih the book.
Combat lords are better with an extra attack, always strikes first power for the re rolls and not having to purchase powers for the mundane armour which I shall be using with the nighshroud. A little disappointed that vampire lords are only level 1 wizards though.
Wight Kings are still pretty cool.
Yay for necromancers!
Im quite content with the points reduction to the skellies. They may not kill much, if anything, but at least they'll stay around a bit longer because of their increased numbers.
Dire wolves getting vangaurd and slavering charge back is a nice bonus. My 20 dogs might be a bit more useful now.
Grave Guard going down in price is quite nice. Shall be buying 40 mantic revenants for the HW shield grave guard on monday (for only a little bit more than 10 GW Grave Guard which more than makes up for them not looking as lovely as the Grave Guard).
The new stuff I wont be using. No because I think they are bad, but because monsters or other such big things dont really appeal to me.
I was somewhat disappointed with the magic items and Vlad though.
Over all the typical army that I bring to the table has icreased in size quite a bit, which makes me a very happy little vampire.
 
From everything I've read online, it sounds like a decent book. Most of the changes are for the better. We will no doubt have to make some serious adjustments and the loss of a few key items/functions that have been around forever (and ever) is a bit disappointing.

I will wait until I get my book before voting though. Which should be Tuesday (I dunno why my FLGS doesn't have it yet, but they don't).
 
it seems my vamps are back on the shelf and i wont be getting the new book. Where is the nerf everything got better. Curse GW and Phil Kelly whats with all the Vc buffs we needed a nerf bad.
 
We got that nerf with 8th ed. We were no where near as powerful as we were in 7th. We got more nerfs where they were needed in this book. Ghouls, which many would have claimed were undercosted, went up. The cost of a vampire caster went up significantly. Spammable spells went away. Vanhels doesnt allow charging. No more Drakenhof or helm. Pretty much anything you could claim as being over powered went up in cost or just plain went.
We got buffs to. They were where we needed them and in no way do they make us over powered. Id put us maybe a bit above orcs and goblins but a bit below ogres. We are fine and your posts complaining that we are overpowered and need a nerf are getting somewhat tiring.
 
Pladvoncarstein said:
it seems my vamps are back on the shelf and i wont be getting the new book. Where is the nerf everything got better. Curse GW and Phil Kelly whats with all the Vc buffs we needed a nerf bad.

You can always decide to restrict yourself in ways to bring the army down to your desired level of strength. Every army has its stronger choices, picking them and then calling the list too strong isn't much use.

I quite like the book, myself. There will certainly be a lot of new things to try out. This was actually my first purchased 8th edition hardback book, and I must say that I am impressed with it, which soothes the pain of the price tag.

There will be fun to have with this book, I believe. :clown:
 
i havent read the book so apologies, but i have been studying on here what everyones saying because im thinking of possibly buying it and getting back into the hobby ... so heres my 5 cents

i think zombies should be augmented by how many kills they make ie after their first sight of brains/blood their strength/aggression should increase to represent their desperate scramble to satisfy their cannabalistic hunger and the more they kill the more hungry they get and they shouldnt have weapons. itd be great to have them wandering around the battlefield uncontrollably too like goblin fanatics until they get a sniff of blood then flock to it. skeletons and zombies deserve to be terrifying on the battlefield but they get no respect and are just a joke!

those huge 40x40mm models are pretty ugly - why cant they just give back carrion for flying attacks?

and give skeletons bows/crossbows for gods sake!

i havent ever played or collected a VC list, i used to collect and play undead back in the 90s. never got into VC, got put off a bit by the division and stopped my undead hobby when VC were released. the whole reason i liked undead was because it brought all my favourite supernatural stuff under one army. why cant you have skeleton archers or crossbows?! i demand to know!

the army list will always be broken IMO because GW only care about squeezing money out of people. its a failing business on the brink of going bust and needs our support..they say dont bite the hand that feeds but they cant really help themselves as theyve been put in that situation by mismanagement


i just dont think the split from undead to VC and TC was very well done in the first place and the whole thing was massively rushed, during that dark period where they re-released and re-did everything ten times over in the space of a year or two and now their stuck with a crappy system that doesnt work so well which, 3 or 4 versions on they are still having to make major tweaks to, and introduce completley new units to to try and save. they are slowly going back to the old undead rules (ie everything stays close to the necro and vampires are immense combatists with a bit of magical know-how none of this vampire wizard/necro stuff)

all that having been said i think the black knight models are absolutely beautiful and im sure the new rulebook will be very welcome.

shame its £25! most people will only have just managed to save up/buy/paint/playtest their armies over the next year before they make more rules tweaks in 2014 which you know theyll do.
 
MasterSpark said:
Pladvoncarstein said:
it seems my vamps are back on the shelf and i wont be getting the new book. Where is the nerf everything got better. Curse GW and Phil Kelly whats with all the Vc buffs we needed a nerf bad.

You can always decide to restrict yourself in ways to bring the army down to your desired level of strength. Every army has its stronger choices, picking them and then calling the list too strong isn't much use.

I quite like the book, myself. There will certainly be a lot of new things to try out. This was actually my first purchased 8th edition hardback book, and I must say that I am impressed with it, which soothes the pain of the price tag.

There will be fun to have with this book, I believe. :clown:

I see what your trying to say but before i could always use only zombies but tnow they have been upgraded I cannot do that now. Its impossible not to make a super overpowered lord now unless i take a load of not so good ones. Every new unit is awesome accept the hex wraiths which will die to magic too easy (good thing)

You guys tell me then what can beat us now because I cant think of anything. Even dark eleves are gonna be a push over
 
Things I hate:

-That cover, looks terrible, just terrible, and when half the reason for upped prices for armybooks is 'production quality' it's a bit insulting.

-Coven thing, totally pointless compared to the engine, seems like a waste.

-Continues the 8th ed tradition of gutting unique items, no shock of course but still blows.

-Wraths and Banshees are the same but for different points, why, just why GW?

Things I love:

+MY ZOMBIES ARE NO LONGER JOKE UNITS! YAY! Yea they won't kill much but I never use them to kill I use them as tarpits and they've become the stickiest of tarpits.

+Bat Swarms. Holy crap these guys came out of nowhere to be useful!

+Our general is no longer our lynchpin, this is by far the best change we could have gotten.

+The magic items we DO have are all pretty nifty, so I can be ok with this 'gutting'.

+Our lore is pretty cool, maybe not the best Lore but I've seen worse.

+A lot more synergy, we've officially gone beyond the days of 'skeleton party or swarm of ghouls, pick your path and deal with it'

+Hexwraths are wonderful looking both crunch and fluff wise, look forward to using them with gusto.

+Isabella, one of my faves, got a lovely boost to be a competitive choice and not just kinda a tag-along, very happy.

+This is as someone who picked the 'swarm of ghouls' path before, I am VERY happy for their points boost and capped unit size. As said right in the OP this changes them from another swarm unit to the fast dangerous flankers they always should have been. A ghoul and zombie strike combo should be wonderfully painful.

All in all our boosts and improvements outweighed any problems we have, so all in all gotta give this book a solid A.
 
I fully disagree Pladvoncarstein.

I would not in anyway say we are over powered. I agree with IoN spam and other things, we were in the 7th. Pietr's post sums it up perfectly. Most things people moaned about have been taken away from us. We have been given some other, lowered powered tools to balance it out, otherwise our army would be useless without it.

I think actually using this army on the battlefield will show us not to be the most powerful, but around mid-tier.
 
Voltaire said:
What will beat us is as simple as it has always been - a better tactician.

Im afriad a better tactition will still struggle. Theres no way around an always strike first vamp riding a ghostly chariot with 2 strong hand maidens, that you cannot shoot or strike at without a chance of attacking yourself or haveing you skills dropped. This would not be so bad if it didnt combine with aura of dark majesty or any other leadership droppers.
 
Pladvoncarstein said:
Voltaire said:
What will beat us is as simple as it has always been - a better tactician.

Im afriad a better tactition will still struggle. Theres no way around an always strike first vamp riding a ghostly chariot with 2 strong hand maidens, that you cannot shoot or strike at without a chance of attacking yourself or haveing you skills dropped. This would not be so bad if it didnt combine with aura of dark majesty or any other leadership droppers.

weight of fire will drop it easily, as will magic. the Throne looks solid on paper but people will find a way around its strengths, nothing in this game is so powerful that better tactics cannot defeat it
 
I still disagree completely. A reasonable amount of ranged firepower is going to eat it and its a chariot so its not exactly fast. It's a challenge but its a worthwhile challenge because destroying it represents a easy way of picking up a vast number of points and the opportunity to catch our general out on his own.
 
Pladvoncarstein said:
MasterSpark said:
Pladvoncarstein said:
it seems my vamps are back on the shelf and i wont be getting the new book. Where is the nerf everything got better. Curse GW and Phil Kelly whats with all the Vc buffs we needed a nerf bad.

You can always decide to restrict yourself in ways to bring the army down to your desired level of strength. Every army has its stronger choices, picking them and then calling the list too strong isn't much use.

I quite like the book, myself. There will certainly be a lot of new things to try out. This was actually my first purchased 8th edition hardback book, and I must say that I am impressed with it, which soothes the pain of the price tag.

There will be fun to have with this book, I believe. :clown:

I see what your trying to say but before i could always use only zombies but tnow they have been upgraded I cannot do that now. Its impossible not to make a super overpowered lord now unless i take a load of not so good ones. Every new unit is awesome accept the hex wraiths which will die to magic too easy (good thing)

You guys tell me then what can beat us now because I cant think of anything. Even dark eleves are gonna be a push over


You Complained for ages about wanting a nerf.
They took most of the old items, banners and broken builds we had, increased allot of our point costs to bring us in line but they also added a few new units so our army could have more than one build and your still complaining.
You have not said a positive thing yet.
If you want to be nerfed so bad go play with Wood Elves..... I'm sure then you will feel at home.

We have allot of weaknesses in our army now, more than before in fact, only thing that will cover them is learning the army and the tactics needed to react to other forces like everyone else does.
Everyone Can beat everybody.





Glitterbomber said:
Things I hate:

-That cover, looks terrible, just terrible, and when half the reason for upped prices for armybooks is 'production quality' it's a bit insulting.

-Coven thing, totally pointless compared to the engine, seems like a waste.

-Continues the 8th ed tradition of gutting unique items, no shock of course but still blows.

-Wraths and Banshees are the same but for different points, why, just why GW?

Things I love:

+MY ZOMBIES ARE NO LONGER JOKE UNITS! YAY! Yea they won't kill much but I never use them to kill I use them as tarpits and they've become the stickiest of tarpits.

+Bat Swarms. Holy crap these guys came out of nowhere to be useful!

+Our general is no longer our lynchpin, this is by far the best change we could have gotten.

+The magic items we DO have are all pretty nifty, so I can be ok with this 'gutting'.

+Our lore is pretty cool, maybe not the best Lore but I've seen worse.

+A lot more synergy, we've officially gone beyond the days of 'skeleton party or swarm of ghouls, pick your path and deal with it'

+Hexwraths are wonderful looking both crunch and fluff wise, look forward to using them with gusto.

+Isabella, one of my faves, got a lovely boost to be a competitive choice and not just kinda a tag-along, very happy.

+This is as someone who picked the 'swarm of ghouls' path before, I am VERY happy for their points boost and capped unit size. As said right in the OP this changes them from another swarm unit to the fast dangerous flankers they always should have been. A ghoul and zombie strike combo should be wonderfully painful.

All in all our boosts and improvements outweighed any problems we have, so all in all gotta give this book a solid A.



The cover of the book is horrible, I will give you that but allot of the new artwork in the book looks great.

The coven throne is more of a Lahmian thing given to add character and you have to remember it is powerful in its own right, it has all its abilities and a 4+ ward to boot on a mount.

Being able to take wraiths and Banshees as heros is great because now I do not have to spend the points on units and can add them to regular units to cause havoc with my foes, a scream attack in combat coming from a skellie unit?..... Yes please!

Now I don't fully agree with you on the items or the changing in our casting lore but overall I am happier than i thought I would be.... Just wish we got a new Zombie kit, that would of made everything legend. :thumbsup:
 
I love it. I will not repeat what's been said as I agree with DoN's breakdown of what is good or not. We got balance, we got synergy and best of all so many choices I don't know what kind of list to build!
 
The front cover of the army book really is getting a lot of criticism. I can't for the life of me see what's that bad with it. I like it more than the 7th edition cover.

Might be down to taste. :redface:
 
Duke Danse Macabre said:
overall I am happier than i thought I would be....

I am pleased, I never quite understood why you were on such a downer about the new book. ;) I love the new book, and have it sitting in front of me now. First game tomorrow and we'll really see what it's like! :D
 
MasterSpark said:
The front cover of the army book really is getting a lot of criticism. I can't for the life of me see what's that bad with it. I like it more than the 7th edition cover.

Might be down to taste. :redface:

Seconded. I REALLY like it. I also like how all 8th Ed. Armybooks are similar in style and feature a Lord/Hero as focus. Uniformity is a big plus to me.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu