Some questions from a recent battle

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Jun 17, 2010
43
Zombies
44
Hi All,

For once in a blue moon, i actually won a battle using 8th Edition a few weeks ago! Against O&G. However, the win came at the cost of some significant debate about the rules, which i would appreciate peoples thoughts on. This post is for 'Character Movement', another post will follow for 'Unit Movement and the Edge of the Table'.

For a while, my friends and i have been playing using the following rules - Once a character has joined a unit (and providing he has a compatible base size), he is able to move freely within the front rank of the unit in the movement phase provided that that movement does not exceed thier total movement allowance (example: A unit with a 4" moves 1", and with the remaining 3" elects to move his character from one end of the first rank to the other end).

Now in the recent game, my opponent opted to do this as part of a march move. This didnt make sense to me fluff wise as the unit would have been in strict marching formation (less likely to be flexible with movement), but i let it pass. I knew he had done so to line up his Orc Warlord with killing blow against my WK BSB with Regen banner (to spanner up my ghoul deathstar). As i was then in charge distance in my turn, i successfully charged, but, using the same logic as my opponent, i chose to move my WK BSB out of reach of his lord (to elsewhere in the 1st rank). I was then told that i couldnt do this. Why not i ask?

So then we start pouring through the BRB, and we cant find anything that describes how a character can move within a unit. From this, i have surmised that a character can only move thier position within the unit they have joined under the following circumstances (feel free to add as appropriate):

1) The unit reforms (for whatever reason);
2) Using the Make Way! rule if a charge manouver puts the character out of BTB contact with the opposing unit;
3) If he leaves the unit in one turn and then rejoins the unit in a subsequent turn; or
4) If the unit the character is in declines a challenge and the challenger elects to move the character to the back rank.

Therefore, am i right in thinking that you cannot move a character within a unit as part of a normal move, march or charge (or flee i guess)?

Ultimately, my opponent allowed me to move my WK BSB in the end, and so, on that basis, tru balance was ultimately restored. But i really want to clear this up before our next game so that can make sure that we use the right rules.

Thanks All!
 
I daresay that while there is nothing specifically allowing a character to move, there is nothing preventing you rearranging the models in a unit, provided you stay within the usual rules for Command models, etc. There are no hard & fast rules stipulating where you must put your characters & command models within the front rank, just that there is where they must be.

"Once a character has joined a unit (and providing he has a compatible base size), he is able to move freely within the front rank of the unit in the movement phase provided that that movement does not exceed their total movement allowance (example: A unit with a 4" moves 1", and with the remaining 3" elects to move his character from one end of the first rank to the other end)."

That seems a sensible way to resolve it, though a frustrating one for those of us who remember it being nice & concise in 7th Ed.

"Now in the recent game, my opponent opted to do this as part of a march move. This didnt make sense to me fluff wise as the unit would have been in strict marching formation (less likely to be flexible with movement)..."

It's easy enough to explain away, the character is just ahead of the troops, commanding them & shoving them about. They march where he tells them to march, and they shift when he tells them to shift.

I would agree that the character is not allowed to reposition during a Charge move, it's too late for fudging around when heads are for the breaking.
 
I disagree with Ophidicus. In my playing group and dare I say the swedish tournament scene we play it using these conditions that you listed.

Vlad the Acolyte said:
1) The unit reforms (for whatever reason);
2) Using the Make Way! rule if a charge manouver puts the character out of BTB contact with the opposing unit;
3) If he leaves the unit in one turn and then rejoins the unit in a subsequent turn; or
4) If the unit the character is in declines a challenge and the challenger elects to move the character to the back rank.

These are the only times a characters position is changed within a unit.
 
Thanks for the comments. A bit more difficult this one then.

Ophidicus said "I daresay that while there is nothing specifically allowing a character to move, there is nothing preventing you rearranging the models in a unit, provided you stay within the usual rules for Command models, etc. There are no hard & fast rules stipulating where you must put your characters & command models within the front rank, just that there is where they must be". Are you therefore saying that an absence of a rule in the BRB means that there is no reason why you cant do it? This sounds controversial...

I have to say that i am with Ghurt on this one, but then, i would do.

Any other perspectives or thoughts on this one?
 
"Are you therefore saying that an absence of a rule in the BRB means that there is no reason why you cant do it? This sounds controversial..."

It is.

What I would counter this with is that this is not the matter of the absence of a rule, but rather the absence of a condition governing activities within the rules. Naturally, one could counter this with 'such a condition is itself a rule', which would be fair enough, but the absence of one condition does not imply the presence of the opposite. I say that you must follow the rules, and obey the conditions. There is no condition governing this particular situation, so there is no need to infer that such a condition exists, simply because nothing says that the condition does not exist. "It doesn't say you can't," vs. "It doesn't say you can," is a pretty futile argument, & I won't get into it.

We know that Command models (always) and Characters (secondary to command) must remain in the front rank. There is no stipulation on where in the front rank they may be. Similarly, there is no stipulation that they must remain in this order. Hence they may be in any position within the designated area without being in breach of the rules. Given that they may be in any position at any time (subject to other rules), they are permitted to change this position if they wish (at an appropriate time, i.e. Movement phase). Nothing prevents them changing position, hence changing position is within the rules.

It's a bit of a circular argument, but then most such debates are.

Happy 1000th post to me.
 
Permissive rule set, i.e. you need permission to perform actions. Presence of other permissifying conditions (E.g. Make Way) confirms that you need to be allowed to move a character as you see fit, otherwise there would be no point to any of these rules and you could move them at any time as you please. So, as Ghurt says, there are only a few cases where you can move characters- so plan ahead!
 
I'm on the permissive side. The reason it is "less clear" in 8th vs 7th is intentional I would say..."make way" being the only way to do it without affecting the unit as a whole I think.
 
I don't think Make Way is a valid example, as it specifically permits characters to move in a situation in which he is otherwise prevented from moving, namely the enemy Combat phase. He would not normally be permitted to move in this situation, regardless of whether or not he could at other times.

"otherwise there would be no point to any of these rules"
There are parameters which must be kept to, I do not suggest breaching them.

"...and you could move them at any time as you please."
Nor do I suggest this. My suggestion is that "at any time when it is permissible for the unit to move, models may move within the unit," namely during the unit's own movement phase, .

There are restrictions on when you are not allowed to move, such as when in base-to-base contact with an enemy. These are generally made clear, and that would appear to imply that when these strictures are not in place, such strictures do not apply.

'Permissive ruleset' is not itself a rule of Warhammer. It does not say it in any WFB literature of which I am aware. The rules do not state a default condition of 'permission' or 'restriction', i.e. there is no 'if it doesn't say you can, you can't' or likewise 'if it doesn't say you can't you can'. We can only infer one of these, based on subjective readings, and tastes. To the best of my knowledge the players decide whether the ruleset is 'permissive' or 'restrictive'. What I suggest is within the rules as they are read, namely the parameters of forming a unit, and position within it.
 
Well every gaminggroup can play how they want, but Im afraid that if you go to a tournament and try and move your characters freely in their units then youre gonna get disappointed that your opponent will try to stop you from doing it. Probably calling the ref if you insist on moving them.

In Warhammer you are allowed to make certain actions, you cant do anything that is not in the book, for example: you cant say your character begins to fly because he has grown wings, you need to have the fly special rule on him.
 
I am aware that variations exist. I will, if an opponent wishes to reposition a character with a unit, allow him to do so because he is working within the parameters of the rules. Just as I would be if I were to do so. It is acceptable. I f my opponent objects, he is welcome to do so. I will oblige him.

It really does get on my wick when I make clear that I am working within the parameters set by the rules. Please refrain from extrapolating my attitude towards working within the given parameters to inferring that I favour abusing the rules. I have no intention of abusing the rules.

I trust my attitude is shared, and that we will have no more such inferences regarding myself or any other player based on their interpretations.

"...you cant do anything that is not in the book..."

Pray tell, on what page of the rulebook is this specific parameter? I seem to haver skipped it.
 
I have to say I agree with Ophidicus,I posted a question regarding stacking r.I.p spells (specifically curse of years) and pretty much all of the responses I had was yes you can,notably because and I checked this myself there is NOTHING in the brb book that addresses this question o says you can't ,my feelings and logic on things like this is games workshop employees have designed and playtested this game,the reason something such as moving chars in you front rank doesn't have a rule is because it's so obvious it is possible it doesn't need one,why wouldn't they be a able? As said above just because it's not there doesn't mean it can't (with in reason) the only time it even mentions Chars moving as Ophidicus states very well is in combat,the movement phase has very different rules to the combat phase,so why would this one reference apply?

I pretty much play in my local GW and I do the above example all the time and no one including employes have ever mentioned this :)

I'd say that you can do this and rule lawyers,seriously,chill out :) and ghurt the wing flying thing is silly,it's like saying "my slaan is going to sprout a runefang out of his arm because it doesn't say I. The book he can't" don't mean to offend you,just made mr laugh :)
 
I'm no expert by any means, but it seems to me that in the given scenerio both players were moving their units in an attempt to "sabotage" the other. The orc player moves his unit with killing blow to the exact rank of the WK knowing full well that this gives him the advantage and then in response the VC player moves the WK to another position to evade this.

In my mind, you should only bend the rules or lack there of in a situation where the rules are either incompatible, unfair, or restricting. This specific scenerio however is brought about by the players trying to "meta-game" against one another. From a "fluff" point of view, the Orc knows he can swing an axe and lop of the head of most anything he swings it at with a bit of luck, but he doesn't know where he should be exactly to kill a "specific" unit in a regiment ahead of him that is getting ready to charge. Neither does the WK know that he needs to move out of the way of the character with killing blow. In this case, I think the best solution for both would be to say that no, you cannot reorder the position of the unit. Perhaps in a different scenerio when the outcome would not affect the combat so heavily it would be allowable, but when the players are making their models dance around one another to give themselves an edge and having to run through the BRB just to decide if they are even able to do so, I think it's better to just let it go and continue to play as you normally would.
 
Page 13 says models and units must move in a straight line unless performing a manoeuvre,the only manoeuvre that allows you to reorder a unit and still move is fast reform.The way I read it even using the characters remaining move to shift position is incorrect,as he is reforming the unit for free(they must move as well in order to trade places).Also the units models all use the lowest movement on the unit unless seperating,and move as a single entity with the models in set relation.Seems clear enough to me.Permissive rules interpretation is a black hole as well,"It doesn't say I can't!! AND it seems right to me that I should be able to,therefore I decree it so." is insufficient argument,you could fill a library with things it doesn't say you can't do.
 
Indeed, movement is clearly defined. While I like Oph's suggestions, his made-up quotes are not actual rules. Movement is clearly defined, and the only time you get to rearrange the formation of a unit is during a reform.
 
If that is how you wish to play, fair enough. I maintain that my method is legitimate, and I feel I have already made clear why.

I have not 'made up' any quotes in this thread though. I have not quoted the rulebook (cos it doesn't say anything on this subject), but I have quoted other posts. Unfortunately those posts... erm... aren't there any more. It/they appear to have been deleted.

I do very much enjoy making stuff up, it is one of the few genuine pleasures in my life, but I do avoid it when it comes to debates on rules & such. I have no intention to be misleading or dishonest.
 
Well I was specifically referring to a couple of quotes here which aren't labelled as rules quotes but are in speech marks which may give an aura of authenticity. Plus I thought I had indeed seen some more definitive posts, but if some have been deleted by my fellow moderators that may well have confused me (I shall have to look into this!) ;)
 
Well then I guess we can agree on that we disagree with each other in this matter Ophidicus.
There is no clear rule in the book that says you cant do it, but if you dont think its heavily implied that you cant, and your opponents all play this way, then go ahead and play as you like!
 
The thing is,when the hero joins the unit he is now a part of it,and no longer moves independantly b/c he is no longer a seperate unit.So unless challenging or making way,the character has no other type of independant unit save for leaving the unit.While in it he functions under the same restrictions as other RNF and can only be moved by reforming.I think the fact that he is no longer counted as seperate except for the ability to disband is the clarifying factor.
 
I appreciate all of the comments posted above on this very tricky question. I particularly appreciate the comments from Ophidicus, as i always find that opposite points of view help others to form thier our own opinions in light of the facts that have been presented.

On balance, however, i think Baltizan said it best.

...
Baltizan said:
I think it's better to just let it go and continue to play as you normally would.

Ultimately, its playing the game in good spirit that matters. Therefore, i think the lesson from all of this is to go with the flow. Maybe at worst, clarify how both players prefer to play with regards to character movement before the game begins.

Thanks again everyone!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu