Hi All,
For once in a blue moon, i actually won a battle using 8th Edition a few weeks ago! Against O&G. However, the win came at the cost of some significant debate about the rules, which i would appreciate peoples thoughts on. This post is for 'Character Movement', another post will follow for 'Unit Movement and the Edge of the Table'.
For a while, my friends and i have been playing using the following rules - Once a character has joined a unit (and providing he has a compatible base size), he is able to move freely within the front rank of the unit in the movement phase provided that that movement does not exceed thier total movement allowance (example: A unit with a 4" moves 1", and with the remaining 3" elects to move his character from one end of the first rank to the other end).
Now in the recent game, my opponent opted to do this as part of a march move. This didnt make sense to me fluff wise as the unit would have been in strict marching formation (less likely to be flexible with movement), but i let it pass. I knew he had done so to line up his Orc Warlord with killing blow against my WK BSB with Regen banner (to spanner up my ghoul deathstar). As i was then in charge distance in my turn, i successfully charged, but, using the same logic as my opponent, i chose to move my WK BSB out of reach of his lord (to elsewhere in the 1st rank). I was then told that i couldnt do this. Why not i ask?
So then we start pouring through the BRB, and we cant find anything that describes how a character can move within a unit. From this, i have surmised that a character can only move thier position within the unit they have joined under the following circumstances (feel free to add as appropriate):
1) The unit reforms (for whatever reason);
2) Using the Make Way! rule if a charge manouver puts the character out of BTB contact with the opposing unit;
3) If he leaves the unit in one turn and then rejoins the unit in a subsequent turn; or
4) If the unit the character is in declines a challenge and the challenger elects to move the character to the back rank.
Therefore, am i right in thinking that you cannot move a character within a unit as part of a normal move, march or charge (or flee i guess)?
Ultimately, my opponent allowed me to move my WK BSB in the end, and so, on that basis, tru balance was ultimately restored. But i really want to clear this up before our next game so that can make sure that we use the right rules.
Thanks All!
For once in a blue moon, i actually won a battle using 8th Edition a few weeks ago! Against O&G. However, the win came at the cost of some significant debate about the rules, which i would appreciate peoples thoughts on. This post is for 'Character Movement', another post will follow for 'Unit Movement and the Edge of the Table'.
For a while, my friends and i have been playing using the following rules - Once a character has joined a unit (and providing he has a compatible base size), he is able to move freely within the front rank of the unit in the movement phase provided that that movement does not exceed thier total movement allowance (example: A unit with a 4" moves 1", and with the remaining 3" elects to move his character from one end of the first rank to the other end).
Now in the recent game, my opponent opted to do this as part of a march move. This didnt make sense to me fluff wise as the unit would have been in strict marching formation (less likely to be flexible with movement), but i let it pass. I knew he had done so to line up his Orc Warlord with killing blow against my WK BSB with Regen banner (to spanner up my ghoul deathstar). As i was then in charge distance in my turn, i successfully charged, but, using the same logic as my opponent, i chose to move my WK BSB out of reach of his lord (to elsewhere in the 1st rank). I was then told that i couldnt do this. Why not i ask?
So then we start pouring through the BRB, and we cant find anything that describes how a character can move within a unit. From this, i have surmised that a character can only move thier position within the unit they have joined under the following circumstances (feel free to add as appropriate):
1) The unit reforms (for whatever reason);
2) Using the Make Way! rule if a charge manouver puts the character out of BTB contact with the opposing unit;
3) If he leaves the unit in one turn and then rejoins the unit in a subsequent turn; or
4) If the unit the character is in declines a challenge and the challenger elects to move the character to the back rank.
Therefore, am i right in thinking that you cannot move a character within a unit as part of a normal move, march or charge (or flee i guess)?
Ultimately, my opponent allowed me to move my WK BSB in the end, and so, on that basis, tru balance was ultimately restored. But i really want to clear this up before our next game so that can make sure that we use the right rules.
Thanks All!