Some questions on new book

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Monechetti

Zombie
Mar 27, 2008
10
Zombies
7
Hello Carpe Noctem,

I've played VC since 5th ed, and not really changed my style too much over the years. I've always played with lots of skeletons as core, and invested in Black Knights with Blood Dragon vampires. My general tactic was to run over anything I could and cross my fingers my opponent never had bolt throwers :mrgreen:

Anyway, with this latest book, there are options that I think are worth considering, and I'm curious what other VC players are...well, playing. I like the zombies, I think their beat-you-in-combat ability is cool and very fluffy, but are they worth it? The main thing I keep reading/hearing is ghouls, ghouls, ghouls, so much so that even local chiselers who have never played another army in their life have decided to play VC because of the supposed inherent bustedness of ghoulkin armies. Is this the case? I'm still gluing my new guys together, and deciding what direction I want to go, but I'm curious what others' thoughts are on army comp and the viability of NOT playing ghouls.
 
I use an army very much like yours, Monechetti. I've never seen the real attraction of ghouls. Not only are they unfluffy for my BD army, but I like Skeleton's simple sheildwall and the ability to take magic banners over the Ghoul's basic 2 attacks. And besides, for an extra point you can give your Skeletons spears, giving them the same number of frontal attacks as a Ghoul unit. And, llets face it, your skeletons are not gonna charge very often.

And by the way, welcome to Carpe Noctem.
 
You can do well without Ghouls. My proper list has one unit of 12 to babysit a Corpse Cart-Necromancer, and I've won vs most armies I've faced (the exception being a Star Dragon and Slaaneshi Daemon list, which I only ahcieved winning draws against). Ghoul heavy armies are very popular because they're easy. Use lots of Ghouls, get free march, opponents scared, possibly an easy game. But you'll do fine with regular units.

To be honest though, a Ghoul is generall superior to a Skeleton. Increased WS and T more than make up for the lack of save, and 2 poison attacks is golden. I can't actually think of any reason to take Skeletons over Ghouls, except that I have loads of Skeleton models.
 
I use mostly skeletons too. IMO the new skellie models are superior to their ghoul counterparts. That alone is worth taking skellies for :mrgreen:. Maybe I´ll give ghouls a shot one of those days, but now im content with my skeletons.
 
@Veskarin - I agree, and with the new price to include the basic equipment for the skeletons, I like them a lot. For fluff reasons I want to do a very mounted army, a la Brets, Red Duke, whatever. For that, I want to run KoBK and Black Knights, and I just don't feel Ghouls look thematically binding. Of course, however, that doesn't mean the army will play well :D

Also, thanks for the welcome, glad to be amongst VC players in tactics!

@EvC - I do see the inherit value of T4 and 2xPoison attacks on the ghouls over the simplicity of the Skeletons, but my fear is that ranked, non-armored units will simply wither to arrow fire unless you really do a ghoulkin reliant list, and I feel the vampires could do more, but I'm probably wrong, as I haven't even set an army on the field yet since the new book.

I very much appreciate the input though. It helps me think about what I want to end up fielding.
 
Strenght 3 shooting:
Skeletons: 6 hits means 3 wounds, means 2 unsaved wounds.
Ghouls: 6 hits means 2 unsaved wounds.
The skeletons and ghouls are the same against St3 shooting.

Against strength 4 shooting:
Skeletons: 6 hits means 4 wounds, means 3.34 unsaved wounds.
Ghouls: 6 hits means 3 unsaved wounds against ghouls.
The gouls are slighty better than the skeletons against St4 shooting.

And in HtH:

Against WS3 ST3 attacks:
Skeletons: 6 attacks means 4 hits, means 2 wounds, means 1 unsaved wound.
Ghouls: 6 attacks means 3 hits, means 1 unsaved wound.
Again are equals in combat

Against WS3 ST4 attacks:
Skeletons: 6 attacks means 4 impacts, means 2.67 wounds, means 1.78 unsaved wounds
Ghouls: 6 attacks means 3 impacts, means 1.5 unsaved wounds
The ghouls are a bit better than skeletons.

Against WS4+ ST3 attacks:
Skeletons: 6 attacks means 4 hits, means 2 wounds, means 1 unsaved wound.
Ghouls: 6 attacks means 4 hits, means 1.34 unsaved wound.
The skeletons are a bit better here.

Against WS4+ ST4 attacks:
Skeletons: 6 attacks means 4 impacts, means 2.67 wounds, means 1.78 unsaved wounds
Ghouls: 6 attacks means 4 impacts, means 2 unsaved wounds
Again the skeletons are a bit better here.

Resuming: against shooting and WS3 the ghouls are a bit better than the skeletons, the skeletons are better against WS4.

But if you analyse the hitting power of both units, the ghouls are far more better than the skeletons. They have twice the number of attacks and have poison (the same ST so this not count). A better WS means they can hit more easy the WS2 and can hit WS 5 & 6 with 4+ instead of the 5+ of the skeletons.

The only real plus of the skeletons are they musician, standard and the magic banner they can hold.
 
in CC if the Ghouls strike first, either thanks to the myriad of aws abilities we have available or charging, then their offensive power will turn into defensive success.

While skellies can indeed take spears for one point to gain the extra attack, don't forget that they lose 1 AS in frontal cc when doing so.

against hanguns the ghouls really come out on top as the skellies have no save what so ever, the T4 of the ghouls comes out on top.

However, don't underestimate the power of that 25 point banner. Double US anyone?
 
@Abhorash_Chile

Thanks for the breakdown. I can see where having the 4 toughness would come in handy, and I know poison is really, really nice if you can get your sixes. It's cool to see the numbers though on how usable each of them are in different situations.

@Dead of Night

The idea of being able to join a unit of skeletons and having a banner is very appealing to me, I have to admit. Also, admittedly, I have a big problem getting past form over function - that is, I like the look of a unit of skellies with a banner and a vampire in the front rank over the look of ghouls. Of course, that doesn't make it a better choice tactically ^_^ Either way, I'm getting the feeling that the general consensus is that ghouls are better in more cases, at least enough to warrant trying them out. I have some from the spearhead and some old ones, too, so I think I'll field them a few games and see where it gets me.

That being said, I'm curious what peoples' views are on corpse carts and Varghulfs. I realize they are tactically different in nearly every way, and play different roles, but how many are people using of the Cart? I was personally thinking of taking 2:3 ratio of carts to undead blocks (core blocks I mean) but I realize that might be excessive. And beyond that, the Varghulf seems absurdly powerful, but how good is it? Is it better than a coach or a unit of Banshees and Wraiths (which just seems so cool to me).
 
Varghulf is best against the units which cannot take rank bonuses, i.e. skirmishers, fast cavalry. Its special rule of not giving flank bonuses to the enemies, combined with T5, is effective against flanking forces. I have not tried it against heavy cavalry so far, but I can see that a unit with outnumber and standard would be difficult for Varghulf to defeat. (That is why I have never tried it)

I have had a lot of experience with the Varghulf against Wood Elves. Wardancers have done over 50 attacks and with a few lucky regeneration saves, Varghulf prevailed without even taking 1 wound. Even if it looses the combat, it can take regeneration save against the CR wounds. That also helps the Varghulf to survive until my slower rank-file units arrive. So, right now, Varghulf is not only to sweep through the flanks but also, if there are any monsters or heavy hitters, I use my Varghulf to pin them where they are for 1 round. The rest of my army arrives until the Varghulf is killed.

About the Corpse Carts, I have tried them and they are not to attack but to defend only. Actually, they are only a support force. They should not get in touch with the enemy unless another unit is already in combat. With 2D6 S2 hits, their chance of causing even 1 wound is very dice dependent, but T4, 5+ Armor Save and Regeneration guarantees a survival even if a charge is taken. Their bound spell is certainly useful. Especially for defensive purposes.

Personally, I see the "+1 to raised" option for Corpse Cart is for slow armies. I use a ghoul army and Ghoukin means the Corpse Cart will have hard times in following the speed of ghouls. And D6 or D6+1 does not make a huge difference for raising. But if you raise ethereals, cavalry or other non-infantry but also non-vampire units, it means 2 Wounds are restored to the unit instead of 1. That would be really efective, if only Corpse Cart had M6 or higher.

"-1 to cast" option will not be enough against magic heavy armies and if an army is weak or moderate at magic, vampires are already strong enough to handle them. We really do not need the Corpse Carts.

Those are my opinions on Varghulf and Corpse Cart. I was very excited when I first saw the Cart but now it is only a cause of disappointment. And Varghulf is a success story. However, more and more enemies start to take flaming weapons against Vampires to negate the Varghulf's Regeneration.
 
I just play a cav based army, my main unit in a 1-1.5k game being an enourmous one of BK. The Skeletons are just there to absorb charges and die (again...) while my cav go in and destroy everything else. Works like a charm. Going back to the Ghouls vs. Skellies, the Skeletons have a much greater 'charge absorbtion' power than GHouls due to command, spears and magic banners. I beleive that this purpose is the one that skeletons are designed for, to I don't see why one should take Ghouls to do it. Of course, in another style of army the choice of Ghouls may be better, but thats just my 50th of a dollar.
 
On the bone vs ghoul question I am on the side of Skeletons as they look great ranked up, fit the theme, have command and magic banner option, armour. Ghouls have a slight improvement in ws and t and poison (usful if you can roll 6's which I cant). When they could skirmish they were great now I find it hard to justify them ranked up and in the main part of an "undead" army

On the other question of the corse cart if you are taking 2 of them go bale fires as their effect is cumulative so that would mean -2 to all the enemies spell casting in the area, that will really hurt them (bar tomb kings and warrior priests)
 
Ghouls or Skeletons can be great. If you want a fast offensive army, preferably supported by Vamps that like it up close and personal, then Ghouls are ideal. If you'd prefer to take your time then strike, and want more guarantee's Skeletons fit the job nicely. A static +6 combat res skeleton block really fits the bill for a strong vampire lord to sit in.

Zombies to are fantastic, I've vanhelsed a unit into the flank of a 20odd unit of Longbeards with dwarf lord. They autobroke the dwarves who ran into one of my other units. (admitedly the zombies were WS7 ;) ) Cheap, cheerfull, and against anything str5 or better are generally going to perform just as well as skeletons would anyway.

Corpse Carts are very usefull, personally I stick one with a Necro in a ghoul bunker, it advances quickly behind my lords ghoul unit, and spreads it's always strike first and -1 to cast for enemy wizards. Both effects can win games. Don't underestimate that -1, a spell that fails by one is a spell you don't have to dispel. Don't forget most VC will be wanting to cast Invocation on 1 dice. That -1 really screws that up. Personally I'm expecting to face a lot of VC in the near future, so it's definately staying in my list!

Varghulf's are also great, I use mine to keep the Black knights marching, they also hit hard and make ideal support to my lycni BSB vampire, knights or whatver needs that little extra smackage! :P

Hope some of that helps. :)
 
Interesting. I guess I've decided to look into using Ghouls. Everyone seems stoked on them for sure, and I'll defer to general consensus to start building around ^_^

So, to that end, I'm thinking a rough start to my list would look something like this, to capitalize on the army's seemingly counterintuitive mobility:
(keep in mind this is just a VERY rough idea, an outline, I suppose)

Vampire with Ghoulkin, possibly Ghoul summoning as well, in one of two units of Ghouls, with frontages of 6, 18 or 24 deep.

A Corpse Cart with Balefire to move behind-ish the Ghoul units.

A smattering of Dire Wolves, 7 strong, no Doom Wolves.

A unit of Fell Bats, 7 strong, with a Vampire on a Hellsteed, with Crown of Command

A unit of Black Knights, 6-12, not sure. Wight Lord with Sword of Kings and the banner that allows marching. Along with this unit I like the idea of a unit of Cairn Wraiths with an Ethereal Vampire, probably built like a caster, but I'm not sure. Hand of Dust is interesting to me.

I fear that the core would be too fragile, but I would really like to sweep up the middle and do a refused flank with the mobile units.

Zombies are always interesting to me, as are Skellies. I've never really used Bat Swarms, but I could try them, I suppose. I believe it possible to use the Varghulf interchangeably with the Cairn Wraith unit, though obviously it's not the EXACT same effect, it's still a mobile rare choice that is devastating in concert with something else. Any thoughts? Again, I want to point out that this is about as rough a list as I could get, just to sort of set some ideas down so I wouldn't forget. Other obvious things I would like to try are combinations like Red Fury and a Tomb Blade, Hand of Dust and Hunter in the Dark, and so on. Any other cool interactions anyone has seen they wouldn't mind giving up? :grin:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu