SOPA, PIPA and ACTA

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I purchase all of my music/games, even paying in some cases where it was provided for free (Radioheads In Rainbows, steams Humble Indie Bundle, Pogos Alice

All of these were "you pay what you want to" options, and in each case I paid a pretty fair price for them.

I dont really pirate music or games at all, and yes, I am against Piracy- I just dont like the idea of one nation taking arbitary control over what gets to be on the internet.

If the United Nations wants to meet and discuss Piracy, and create an international organisation to regulate the internet, I would be happy to support that. If its just America taking things into their own hands on behalf of everyone, I am very against that.
 
I've found that a lot of musicians, or at least of the genres I listen to, use free downloads of their music as advertising for their live shows where they make the real money, or convince us to buy merch. Even when you do have to pay for albums its usually dirt cheap. I find musicians have accepted the fact that people will download it for free and work to earn their respect and therefore they will buy stuff from them and see them live.
The music industry is not in danger.
 
These legislations can go beyond fighting piracy, though. ACTA in particular will likely make ISPs monitor your web activity in order to keep themselves out of trouble with the IP-industry. If you're monitored to be trespassing on anyone's IP (uploading a video of yourself with a movie theme in the background, for example) you could be fined and have your IP address' Internet access closed. If repeated reports of IP infringement are made against your own personal website it will be shut down until you yourself can prove that you are innocent.

Piracy *is* wrong, but that kind of countermeasure isn't any better.
 
One point that seems to get shoved under the carpet as it were in the piracy debate, is the fact that while hollywood complains, they still make much more money today than they did when I was a kid, and there is a whole lot more movies being made as well. Loosing money my ass... Those greedy bastards define "loosing" based on the idiotic prinicple that everything that has been downloaded would otherwise have been paid for. I honestly couldn't have paid for all the stuff I've downloaded over the years (even if I wanted too), and I've even only watched about 60-70% of it.
It should be said though, that I do have a pretty substantial DVD/Blue-Ray collection, so I'm not against paying for a quality product, but the idea that I would have paid for all that I have downloaded, if I couldn't download and "pre-view" it, is just laughable.

The thing is though, that the movie industry would like you continuously pay a substantial amount of money, for a product you don't really know the content off until after you have paid, unless you have already paid to see the said movie at at movie theater, in which case it gets even more expensive.. In addition to paying, you are also subjected to 15-20 minutes of commercials, before the movie starts, which I believe they owe us some compensation for.

Since people started downloading movies, it seems to me that hollywood has just grown, and that would not be possible if the money was not there. It is now quite common for 1-2 new movies to be released each week, which was definitely not the case when I was younger, and the budget of the movies are much larger as well (at least in a substantial number of cases).

It seems a bit strange too me that hollywood is complaining so much, since they seems to have much more capital floating around than previously, and all this money has to come from somewhere, namely us, their so-called "valued" customers... They should instead have started using the internet as a cheap (nearly free) distributing channel years ago, thus lowering prices for us, which in return would allow us to buy MORE movies instead.

I came across this the other day, which was I very good argument against PIPA and it's like: http://www.ted.com/talks/defend_our_freedom_to_share_or_why_sopa_is_a_bad_idea.html
 
In my country the government is going to sign ACTA no matter what people say. People are protesting on the streets to defend freedom in the internet, and posting info on the web wherever they can (I post too), but democracy is just a name, it no longer means politicians will act for the good will of all people. They pass laws which in general serves to take money from the poor and give it to the rich.
 
Veland said:
In my country the government is going to sign ACTA no matter what people say. People are protesting on the streets to defend freedom in the internet, and posting info on the web wherever they can (I post too), but democracy is just a name, it no longer means politicians will act for the good will of all people. They pass laws which in general serves to take money from the poor and give it to the rich.

Which country is this? Have they come so far somewhere that Acta is ready to be signed??
Here in norway, the government voted to make it easier for the government to monitor "suspicious" activity on the internet last year, and although we have seen little effect from it yet, the day might come when we find ourselves with a more "abusive" government, and then it will bee too late to do much about it.
Politicians are too easy to buy for those in power, and are all too often without a spine to begin with. Career politicians should be outlawed in my opinion, as their idealism fades all too quickly, and then corruption inevitably sets in, making a misery for the rest of us. There are possibly a few exceptions, but I don't think those very rare instances are enough to justify career politicians as a concept.
 
Many countries have already signed ACTA, but it hasn't been voted into power yet. That voting will happen some time in February.
 
I reckon high level government officials should be drafted- kind of like Jury Duty, and make it so they have a fairly normal salary instead of the huge salaries they get.
 
Sanai said:
The Rich fund the election campaigns. America isnt a Democracy, their elections are more like an Auction than a true Election.

True. The two-party system is laughable, and the fact that it is near impossible for any others to be featured in the big televised debates, is designed so on purpose, to keep the monopoly between the Republicans and Democrats.

Just look at the line of presidential candidates that the Republicans have come up with over the years, most of those guys scare the shit out of me. These are the kind of candidates that the two-party system keeps in the loop.

Even though I have no influence on american politics, or it much on my life, I'd love to one day see a candidate to run for president, that was an Atheist. Just for that fact alone, he'd have my vote if I was an american.
 
MasterSpark said:
Many countries have already signed ACTA, but it hasn't been voted into power yet. That voting will happen some time in February.

Are we talking about EU countries here? I remember reading something about it being attempted to "sneak" this piece of legislation into the EU, with the people's representatives not being allowed to even read it first. This might not be entirely accurate though, but the principle of it is...
 
Sanai said:
I reckon high level government officials should be drafted- kind of like Jury Duty, and make it so they have a fairly normal salary instead of the huge salaries they get.

I'd bet that draft process got rigged somehow. hehe

I'm fine with people being voted in as it were, but politicians should preferably have some "real world" experience first, and then not being allowed at the higher orders of government for too long. If they sit too long, they begin to gather power about themselves, and that becomes much of their focus. Case in point, how many american presidents only wished for one term in office? They nearly always go for a second, no matter the costs etc...
 
Uziel said:
Are we talking about EU countries here? I remember reading something about it being attempted to "sneak" this piece of legislation into the EU, with the people's representatives not being allowed to even read it first. This might not be entirely accurate though, but the principle of it is...

Yes, EU countries as well as others such as Canada, the US and Japan. There's been a lot of talk about how the people that have been active in the negotiating of this legislation are not the same as those who were elected to represent their people. I don't know, really, but it sounds like a big mess and a hole in the faked democracy.

Edit: And it's pretty much thanks to Wikileaks that the notion of ACTA even made it out of the closed doors behind which it was discussed.
 
MasterSpark said:
Uziel said:
Are we talking about EU countries here? I remember reading something about it being attempted to "sneak" this piece of legislation into the EU, with the people's representatives not being allowed to even read it first. This might not be entirely accurate though, but the principle of it is...

Yes, EU countries as well as others such as Canada, the US and Japan. There's been a lot of talk about how the people that have been active in the negotiating of this legislation are not the same as those who were elected to represent their people. I don't know, really, but it sounds like a big mess and a hole in the faked democracy.

Edit: And it's pretty much thanks to Wikileaks that the notion of ACTA even made it out of the closed doors behind which it was discussed.

I didn't realize that Acta had been voted on yet, at least not in the EU.
Here is something about how they wanted to "sneak" it into effect though: http://acta.ffii.org/?p=924
 
Uziel said:
Veland said:
In my country the government is going to sign ACTA no matter what people say. People are protesting on the streets to defend freedom in the internet, and posting info on the web wherever they can (I post too), but democracy is just a name, it no longer means politicians will act for the good will of all people. They pass laws which in general serves to take money from the poor and give it to the rich.

Which country is this? Have they come so far somewhere that Acta is ready to be signed??
Here in norway, the government voted to make it easier for the government to monitor "suspicious" activity on the internet last year, and although we have seen little effect from it yet, the day might come when we find ourselves with a more "abusive" government, and then it will bee too late to do much about it.
Politicians are too easy to buy for those in power, and are all too often without a spine to begin with. Career politicians should be outlawed in my opinion, as their idealism fades all too quickly, and then corruption inevitably sets in, making a misery for the rest of us. There are possibly a few exceptions, but I don't think those very rare instances are enough to justify career politicians as a concept.

I'm Polish. It's EU. Democracy is turning into totalitary system here, and I just can't imagine why we are forced to give up our freedom by our own government. The law is here quite oppressive against copyright infringement, you can be sued when they have a proof against you which is already enough for me. Now the new law will enable government agencies to spy on anyone who they think might me connected to any copyright infringements, which can and WILL be abused. The compromising materials collected without your knowledge for years will be used against you at any time - but now it's not just that you've uploaded something copy-protected, or downloaded copy-protected software. Now it's gonna be anything your IP address will appear to be connected to, and they have info from "interested parties" that it should be monitored. So they will be able to start monitoring you anytime, without you and even the courts knowing. And on our taxpayers' cost, the government agencies and police will be able to control you, to let some corporations sue you and get more money from this. It's insane!
 
Harland said:
I just founf a (recent) article that EU has voted down ACTA. When I find it I'll show you!

I really hope that that is true. although norway is not a member of the EU, our spineless politicians tend to let the EU dictate our policies at home due to the EEA agreement, even though we can veto stuff if we wish too..
 
Various European nations are signing ACTA tomorrow.
http://www.thejournal.ie/ireland-and-eu-to-sign-controversial-acta-treaty-tomorrow-336764-Jan2012/
 
I'm following a blog written by one of Sweden's representatives at the EU parliament, and according to him the legislation has not been shot down yet at all. He promises to update frequently now that it reaches the final presentation and voting, and I'll relay what I read over to you.

Edit: I'll add that he is also quite critical of the proposed legislation.
 
Wargamer said:
Various European nations are signing ACTA tomorrow.
http://www.thejournal.ie/ireland-and-eu-to-sign-controversial-acta-treaty-tomorrow-336764-Jan2012/

"Temporarily down for maintenance..."

Damn. How have they managed to keep this so low keep in the news in general? People must have been paid off in large scale for things to remain so quiet...
 
I seem to have been a bit mistaken by what I had read earlier about the date of voting, by the way. According to the blog I'm following the legislation will be formally turned over to the EU parliament now in February, but from there it will first be handled by various sections of the parliament due to the many areas that it will affect. After that will the final voting be held, which is preliminary set to a date in June.
 
MasterSpark said:
I seem to have been a bit mistaken by what I had read earlier about the date of voting, by the way. According to the blog I'm following the legislation will be formally turned over to the EU parliament now in February, but from there it will first be handled by various sections of the parliament due to the many areas that it will affect. After that will the final voting be held, which is preliminary set to a date in June.

Yea, I googled it. Seems the first ACTA draft was voted down by a vast majority in the EU.

http://www.interesting-people.org/archives/interesting-people/201003/msg00056.html
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu