Stuck With Skeletons - Now What!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Rael

Ghoul
Mar 8, 2008
113
Toronto, Canada
Zombies
60
Watsup guys,

This is not going to be a whine fest on how over-costed Skellies are or not. I have about 90 Skellies that I got to put to use for my core. The thing is, what exactly do I do with them? Spears or swords is an option. What size formations do I use? Do I start small and raise them or dom start big and just maintain?

I'm not a total win at all costs player but like to maximize what I got. I'm trying to get some kind of synergy with the rest of my army as well.In 2500 pts I will be using 7 Blood Knights, 40 gw Grave Guard, 4 Fell Bats, 5 Wraiths. Also will be using a caster Lord with Lord of the Dead power.

I'm leaning towards two 6x6 blocks with spears or two 7x6 blocks with spears. They don't necessarily have to start at that size but will grow to it. The thing is I'm aware that they won't do much anyway but like I said I'm stuck with them as my core.


What do you guys think?
 
The way I see it, spears are only useful if you have enough ranks to benefit from the extra rank of supporting attacks. That means for a normal spear unit, you need 3 ranks. For a horde, you need 4 ranks (that means for hordes you need 40 spear skellies for spears to be worth it)
Most players prefer Hs/shields. What I am doing because I have already assembled 20 spear skellies is mixing them in with hw skellies so I can field HW/Shield skeleton regiments.
The War Banner, Banner of Hellfire and Banner of Eternal Flame are useful cheap banners to give to such units.
 
Yesir, I solely field Skelly because zombies are worthless imo, and ghouls I simply HATE the look and fluff of in this book (they are undead now but alive wth!?) I've fielded hordes before but they dont last long before getting flanked or destroyed due to combat rez, cause when your Skelly lose they lose like champs... so the hs helps alleviate that.
 
I'd use 2 units of 45,five wide and 9 deep.Use them as anvils,I'd go HW&Shield to minimize losses.Their main job being to deny steadfast..then support them with VGs and/or Knights as hammers.
You could also bring a vamp w/ FL:Metal..to increase their AS.
 
You can field them in horde formation with spears so you get 4 effective ranks to attack when you didn't charge (2 normal + 1 horde + 1 spears). However I would not recommend doing so, because if you try to maximize your attacks you also maximize your frontage and thus the attacks back at you. With skellies being very bad at killing things unless super augmented the enemy is probably having more benefit of the horde than you do.

I'd do it as Lasombra suggested: as anvils five wide and X deep
 
I never take spears but if you really wanted to, buff them with Wildform so they do some damage.
Handweapon/shield is the way to go with them. I normally go with a bunker of 20 for my caster and 2 blocks of 29-32 depending on what I feel like bringing to the table. I try to keep my units at a decent enough size but cheap enough to grab support units (2 units of 5 wolves, 3 fell bats). 5 wide is the way to go.
I bring Lord of the Dead on both of my vamps (forbidden lore hero and fighter lord or hybrid lord).
Wraiths will soon be in my units as they provide a cheap, hitty, resilient source of CR to our units.
 
So I've seen some mathhammer for skellies vs ghouls, but I don't believe that I've ever seen hammer for additional wounds saved by 6+ from hw&s compared to additional wounds caused by spears.

Anyone want to volunteer to provide some? I think it would be interesting to see when/if spears become effective.
 
For some reason I keep thinking of giving my lord the forbidden lore power and using the metal spell that increases spear Skellies armor save to 3+.

What would the mathammer statistics say about the spear Skellies with the above spell vs the hand weapon & shield Skellies with the above spell?
 
I believe even with the 3+ it would be more beneficial to have hand weapons unless you also make use of enchanted blades of aiban. I almost always take a vampire with lore of metel because i find its really great when you turn your units of skeles and GG into absolute rocks :P
 
Skeletons, HW/Shiled, 5 wide, 6 deep, full command, war banner or hellfire/eternal flame.
I use the war banner in conjunction with a wight king BSB and a vampire lord. that way you minimise the number of enemy models that can hit the unit, instead they have to hit the characters at T5 and a possible 2+AS or 4+ ward save or the champion. The characters then deal the pain and the skeletons deliver passive bonuses and deny steadfast.
If you want the skeletons themselves to do some damage you need beast or shadow to either buff the skeletons or debuff the enemy. If you feel confident in using them in combination ith magic to deal damage then you can consider spears I guess, although I prefer the safe way I use them that does not rely on magic or anything else that is random :)
 
Anyone notice that our spear skellies cost as much as HE spearmen? Who would you rather field? :skull: But in all honesty I think that the parry save is the best option as they work as a more defensive unit.
 
I run my skeletons in hordes of 48. 10 wide, 5 deep. The extra two spots are filled with a wight king and a vampire (lord or another cc variant). The vampire has either tomb blade or blood drinker.

Any challenges issued are taken by the unit champion, just to be res by the vamp, and the other character moves in to help support the two sides of the charge arc, to minimize the number of attacks allocated to each.

I generally run spear skeletons. Though they may not kill a lot, more attacks mean more opportunity. Your opponent will get the same number of attacks either way, so you might as well try your best to balance it out.
 
Make sure you have the Helm of Commandment in your list. It's really the only way to make Skeletons competent in close combat, and WS7 troops can hold their own against a surprising amount of other core in the Warhammer world. I typically like HW+S too, but if you have Spears, remember that you still have the option switch between them in-game because of the "I'm using this one" rule. So, if you pay the extra points, you get a bit of versatility as well.
 
Unfortunately, the "I'm using this one" rule is not in 8th edition. Really sad, too, as it made alot more sense than "Your troops have trained long and hard with their halberds, they are definitely going to use them and not their shields once they get in combat!" mentality that the company has dropped on us. Tsk tsk.
 
You need to go atleast 8 deep...I can't stress this enough.If you do manage to win combat and your enemy is steadfast your gonna kick yourself.
You need to be able to take casualties on the way in and still have more ranks.
HW&S is better b/c it costs less,this is a really big deal when you are fielding large units,since most of them won't see combat anyway.
I have been fielding mine 10 deep with great success,you can even offer the enemy a flank..once they get stuck in,countercharge with Cavalry or VG/coach.
I've noticed that even when they see the counter coming players have a hard time resisting an open flank...especially if you advance in a way that seems careless.
 
FirestormXL said:
Yesir, I solely field Skelly because zombies are worthless imo, and ghouls I simply HATE the look and fluff of in this book (they are undead now but alive wth!?) I've fielded hordes before but they dont last long before getting flanked or destroyed due to combat rez, cause when your Skelly lose they lose like champs... so the hs helps alleviate that.

Totally agree on the skeletons. I love them, and I hate ghouls.


The Helm of the Commandant is a must. I keep my Lord in the DEADLY Grave Guard with Blood drinker and helm. So they slaughter a unit and beat them off (or the opponent avoids) and I make the Skeletons WS7. WS7 S3 can do damage, especially if they have rerolls (Vanhel's, Strigoi Standard (though I seem to recall it not being cheap enough for skeletons, I may be wrong), or other spells).

Also keep in mind if you take the WS10 sword on the guy with the Helm, those skeletosn will be WS10... and all those WS4 stuff will hit on 5's. That's huge.

Personally I do go spear horde, it needs magic support, but it can work quite nicely. They have the same S and T as a Dark Elf warrior and corsair... so I'm kind of taken by surpise that people think it is somehow horrible. Make them WS7 or 10 and they can be shockingly good. 40 attacks, even at S3 when they need 3's to hit are imposing (especially if augmented in other ways).

I've heard of people trying out Lore of Beasts (+1S and +1T spell) and I think that could make them lethal units when their WS is boosted, but I'd need to think it over.
 
Seneschal said:
Unfortunately, the "I'm using this one" rule is not in 8th edition. Really sad, too, as it made alot more sense than "Your troops have trained long and hard with their halberds, they are definitely going to use them and not their shields once they get in combat!" mentality that the company has dropped on us. Tsk tsk.

Ah, yes I see that now. Pg. 89 clearly states that a unit must use its special close combat weapons. That's quite a bother really, I quite liked being able to pick which weapon to use.
 
You can however choose which special close combat weapon you use if you have multiple (i.e. choosing between a spear and a great weapon)
 
CoOp3000 said:
So I've seen some mathhammer for skellies vs ghouls, but I don't believe that I've ever seen hammer for additional wounds saved by 6+ from hw&s compared to additional wounds caused by spears.

Anyone want to volunteer to provide some? I think it would be interesting to see when/if spears become effective.

Haven't seen anyone reply to this, so I thought I'd give it a whack.

Basically, to compare HW vs Spears, you're comparing wounds the enemy inflicts (and are saved) vs enemies slain by your extra rank. The simple formula would be for every 6 wounds the enemy inflicts on your spear skellies, your extra rank would need to kill one enemy (since 6+ would mean that only 5 skellies would die instead of 6, thus every 6 wounds = 1 skeleton saved by HW that would die if equipped with spear). If they can't do this, then HW are better.

Whether or not it is worth it would depend on the enemy unit, however since skellies have low killing power, it's generally better for CR to use the HW.
For example, let's say you are fighting a somewhat weak unit (WS 2, T2 no armor) while in non-horde formation with spears: your extra rank grants 5 extra attacks, 50% to hit, 67% to wound = 33% to wound/atk, times 5 atks = 1.67 wounds. Since you need 1 wound for every 6 caused by them, spears are worth it unless they inflict more than 10 wounds (6*1.67) with all their attacks. If they (somehow) were expected to inflict more than 10 wounds, then the parry save would go further in preserving CR then the extra dmg from spears would in generating CR.

Now let's say you're fighting a tougher unit (WS 3 T 4 4+ AS):
50% to hit, 33% to wound, 50% for them to fail armor, times 5 atks = .41 wounds inflicted with you extra rank. This means spears are worth it as long as they don't inflict more than 2.5 wounds with all their attacks (6*.41=2.5), which they probably will.

This shows what you probably knew intuitively that spears are better against easy to kill/not very killy units while HW are better against tougher/stronger foes.


Rael said:
What would the mathammer statistics say about the spear Skellies with the above spell vs the hand weapon & shield Skellies with the above spell?

The formula for which is better is still the same with improved armor spell(for every 6 wounds inflicted on spears, 1 enemy slain from the extra rank). What you're doing is decreasing the number of wounds inflicted (by how much depends on the enemy :D) while keeping the number of wounds caused the same, thus in general, pushing towards spears being the better option.
Buffing skeletons will push to make spears more viable since it will either a) make the extra rank inflict more punishment and thus be more worthwhile or b) decrease the wounds taken, making the parry save less necessary. But once again, it will depend on the enemy on which one is more useful even with buffs.

Hope this helps!
 
yeha i am also stuck with skeletons :P but i'll be honest i really like them, would you guys say a good skele supporter would have lore of metal and HOC ? or anythign to add to it ?
 
I would say a good skeleton supporter could be a lot of options. I really like using master of the dead, VDM, and SUH from our lore. A vital part of using skeletons is humming Fantasia Sorcerer's Apprentice while tons of them pop up like daisies. Including a fighter hero is also really good support :D.
 
I'm a big fan of putting this combo together for skeletons (admittedly I haven't played much 8th ed fantasy so there are probably better combos):

Lord w/:
Red Fury
Eternal Hatred
Sword of Striking (... the +2 attack version...)
Nightshroud
Crown of the Damned

Vampire w/:
Forbidden Lore (Beasts)
Helm of Command

If I can get savage beast of horros off my Lord ends up with 9 WS7, S8 attacks with a reroll to hit & the ability to generate additional attacks (potentially 18 kills? yes please). Failing that, Wyssan's Wildform & the Helm will buff the skeletons out & allow them to stand their own against most foes for a round.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu