Suggestion for the forum names

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Jun 24, 2012
118
Zombies
99
As a new user I am finding it effortful figuring out which forums are for what because of the names of each of them. So this is just a minor suggestion for naming each of them in a slightly more straight forward fashion.

And in the words of Ron Burgandy:
a3.bp.blogspot.com__UynBjCBqJKI_TFwYpIRI2_I_AAAAAAAAAro_421C05lZWKk_s400_Ron_burgundy.webp

I'm gonna put it out there; if you like it, you can take it, if you don't, send it right back.
 
There are descriptions under each forum name to help out users that are unsure. See the bolded text under the "flavored" forum name.

example:
The Teachings of Abhorash
Tactics Forum: Discussion on various ways to combat the enemies of the Vampire Counts.

Laws of the Night
Rules Forum: Any questions or discussions about rules of Warhammer
 
I see those. They are confusing to someone who doesn't know their way around.

As an example I'm a new user and I see:
Bloodlines (2 users browsing)
General Discussion Forum: Contains any Vampire Counts general discussion. Not for tactical discussions!
Moderated By: Capt Rubber Ducky is found in the Council of the Night section. That means something but I don't know what. It is called General Discussion and we are on a Vampire Counts website but no discussion of tactics? So, I look for the tactics forum which should say something along those lines but what I see is three other possible places.

Necarch Workshop - "A forum for the development of ideas and thoughts around new or existing units and (special) characters."
Well that could be tactics, right?

To War!
Sweet. I've found the right place.

The Teachings of Abhorash - Tactics Forum: Discussion on various ways to combat the enemies of the Vampire Counts.
Okay, so this is tactics, but is this all about tactics against specific armies? I'll just keep looking.

Know Thy Enemy - Alternate Armies Tactics and Army List Forum: The place to discuss tactics and army lists for armies other than Vampire Counts
This can't be it. Sounds like that last forum.


I know I am really simplifying things but if you think about what the average internet goer experiences when it gets here and my italic thought process might not be far from the mark. I came to this forum well over a year ago and I just now registered because the information is wonderful. Back when I was more casual, there was barrier to entry that maybe the site holders didn't realize. I only suggest this because I new and maybe a pair of fresh eyes seeing this make it a good one. Simplification is good for traffic and getting fresh user loyalty.

I have been here in and out a good week and I'm still not sure about some things. And, I notice threads have to get moved a lot. Which, again, confusion. It caused me to not really look around in this forum that much and I stick to doing searches.

That's all I've really got to say about it. Imagine it with fresh eyes again. It might be good. The theme is great but maybe look at some of those forum descriptions and make em a little more clear.
 
Hey DoN! You got a minute to look at these ideas? I'd have to admit, that when I first joined I had a hard time with a couple of the areas, but after I learned where everything was, I just didn't look back I guess.

Upon reading some of them, I think I see your point ( and sparked a memory :D )

So something like this might work better?

Are there any others that seem ambiguous?

Bloodlines
Vampire Counts General Discussion Forum:
Contains any Vampire Counts general discussion. Not for tactical discussions!

The Cattle
Non-VC General Discussion Forum:
For any other armies/specialist games general discussion. Not for tactical discussions!

The Necrarch Workshop
Gaming Development Forum:
A forum for the development of new ideas and thoughts for units and (special/custom) characters.

The Teachings of Abhorash
Vampire Count Tactics Forum:
Effectively using your Vampire Counts to defeat your enemies.

Know Thy Enemy
Non-VC Tactics and Army List Forum: The place to discuss tactics and army lists for armies other than Vampire Counts.
 
What types of threads do you want in the non-tactical forums? The books, models, and lore, more or less? Maybe mention that. I think that would lessen the initial confusion.
 
We actually started the forum with simple, non-fluffy titles and later changed it.

Perhaps what would help would be an amended email welcoming new members with a list of what the forum has to offer. Go over the large categories so at least members know where to start looking.

Also, I would suggest that the overarching forum titles should have a Description.

Example:
The Master's Chamber
New members introduction, Announcements, tech support
(truebloods doesn't need to be mentioned, as any true blood shouldn't need these descriptors)

Council of the Night
Non-tactical discussions on Warhammer, Semi-Quarterly Magazine, non-warhammer talk

etc. Keep it as simple and direct as possible in the descriptions. I see a number of the descriptors are overly long and not to the point, I can draft up how I would do it if it would help. Technical writing ftw.
 
When I joined CN I was similarly befuzzled by the forum names to begin with; I find my way around (somehow) fine now, but I agree it could be confusing.

I wouldn't want their names to change to simple "General Discussion" and "VC Tactics" though; that'd remove a lot of the charm of the forum.
 
There will always be some overlap between certain boards which are more general in their outlook. There could be some tightening up of these boards, such as Bloodlines, but on the whole, I haven't found any of the descriptions particularly confusing, so I think that it's usually clear where to post.

Regarding the example of the Workshop which was raised earlier in the thread, development has always been associated with fan made rules on every gaming forum I've been a member of, so there's no ambiguity there in my opinion.
 
The names are just names, and that's fine and bring character to the forum (of which that, it is oozing).

I don't think it is the names or the division of topics, I think the confusion comes from the descriptions not helping get you into the right forum you want to find.
 
I'm just not seeing the problem with the descriptions I'm afraid. I'll quote your earlier post to explain:

Ben E. Violent said:
As an example I'm a new user and I see:
Bloodlines (2 users browsing)
General Discussion Forum: Contains any Vampire Counts general discussion. Not for tactical discussions!
Moderated By: Capt Rubber Ducky is found in the Council of the Night section. That means something but I don't know what. It is called General Discussion and we are on a Vampire Counts website but no discussion of tactics? So, I look for the tactics forum which should say something along those lines but what I see is three other possible places.

Bloodlines is a general discussion board for anything about Vampires which does not fit into tactics, background, modelling, role playing, battle reports, or army list building.

I agree that this is a bit vague, in the sense that general discussion is always thus, but it's clearly not for tactical discussion, it even says so, thus what's the problem?

Necarch Workshop - "A forum for the development of ideas and thoughts around new or existing units and (special) characters."
Well that could be tactics, right?

No, it couldn't be tactics. As I explained above, development equates to creating your own rules, or modifying existing ones. I agree that there's no harm with making it more specific, but there's no ambiguity to suggest that it's a tactical discussion board.

To War!
Sweet. I've found the right place.

The Teachings of Abhorash - Tactics Forum: Discussion on various ways to combat the enemies of the Vampire Counts.
Okay, so this is tactics, but is this all about tactics against specific armies? I'll just keep looking.

I think that you're reading this too literally. The threads there are not necessarily specific to dealing with any one particular army. Some are, but some are talking about upgrades and unit usage against all comers.

Again, the description could be tidied up a little, but it's clearly the right place to discuss tactics pertaining to Vampire Counts.

Know Thy Enemy - Alternate Armies Tactics and Army List Forum: The place to discuss tactics and army lists for armies other than Vampire Counts
This can't be it. Sounds like that last forum.

In other words, you reached the right conclusion. In view of having reached the right conclusion, I can't see the problem here, so I'm a bit confused.

I have been here in and out a good week and I'm still not sure about some things. And, I notice threads have to get moved a lot. Which, again, confusion. It caused me to not really look around in this forum that much and I stick to doing searches.

I moderate on a forum with far stricter rules than this one, and threads are still moved a lot. No matter how clear you make the descriptions, you will still get lots of users who post in the wrong board, either through error, laziness, refusing to read, or just not caring.

Tidying up the descriptions might reduce this problem, but then again it might not. The two may well be correlated, but that does not equate to causation.

None of this is to say that everyone should just sit back and leave everything unchanged, and if the moderators decide to change some of the descriptions to make them clearer, I wouldn't be opposed, but I do not think that it's as complicated to find your way around as you seem to be suggesting.
 
I think Ben has very valid points. If you are a veteran to multiple forums of this sort, then you would have additional information that newcomers would not.

Such things would be:
1) Tactics generally have their own, devoted area.
2) Ditto Rules.

Two examples, although I could keep going.

The description "A forum for the development of ideas and thoughts around new or existing units and (special) characters." very well could be tactics, if you didn't know that tactics normally has a devoted section, or haven't read that far. Its my position that the descriptions are more for newcomers to the game and newcomers to the forum; not for veternal forum goers.

Knowing nothing about say, Ogre Stronghold, I know certain things about their structure and could figure out easily where to post something. I would not need much in the way of help finding where to go.
 
Grish it clearly says Development forum as the sub-heading for the Necrarch Workshop, and it says Tactics Forum: as the sub-heading for The Teachings of Abhorash. It's really very clear for newbies and veterans alike.

The only way to simplify would be to change all the titles (not the descriptions) of the boards to something along the lines of:

Rules Development
Tactics
Army Lists
Battle Reports

etc....

You could do that if you really wanted to, but it's not exactly particularly imaginative.

New members just need to do a fair bit of reading before they post on any forum to understand where everything should be posted. It takes a bit of time, but that's as it should be. It's always a good idea to get a feel for a forum before you start posting.
 
I still think the idea of an introductory PM is a great idea. In there you could put some pretty blunt explanations of all the areas with examples and such to reduce newb confusion. This way it will be less daunting for new users to create threads but won't clutter up the main index any.
 
Irisado said:
I do not think that it's as complicated to find your way around as you seem to be suggesting.

It's not about being hard, it's about being not easy enough.

It's crazy simple internet-is-lazy logic that's true all over the place. If a new user needs to take a while to figure things out, they might not register. If they can't find what they came for, they won't come back. That is the reason I suggested this.

I think an intro PM would be dandy. Keep in mind, that's assuming they want to register.
 
Ben E. Violent said:
It's not about being hard, it's about being not easy enough.

There's a fine line between making things easy, and coming across as being patronising though, and that's what I think could happen if you start simplifying everything to the nth degree.

It's crazy simple internet-is-lazy logic that's true all over the place. If a new user needs to take a while to figure things out, they might not register. If they can't find what they came for, they won't come back. That is the reason I suggested this.

If people cannot be bothered to read, are they really the sort of user that's suitable for an online forum? My view is that they are not, and it's better for them to be put off if they just expect instant gratification. You can't get to know how a community works just like that, it does take a little while to become integrated into it, and this is normal.

I think an intro PM would be dandy. Keep in mind, that's assuming they want to register.

A better way to go about this would be to have an introductory sticky which explains to newbies how the forum works, how to post, what the different rankings are, how BBcode works, and so on. A sticky could also be viewed by guests.
 
*Steps into the fray*
Okay, this has degenerated from a discussion into an argument. Allow me to settle this.

I would like to refer everyone to the post of our poor, outspoken mod C_B. I am of the opinion that an introductory PM is certainly the way forwards. A sticky is less practical because it would clutter up whichever forum it went in. A PM would be quick and private... it would explain everything that the new member would need to know succinctly. With a thread there is also a danger that the member won't see it, whereas the chance of that with a PM is extremely minimal.
 
I think Harland is right in that this is degenerating quickly. I'd say that we should put this discussion on hold until one of the admins can get back round to looking at this and give an official verdict.
 
There did use to be an intro PM, however the plugin coding needed to be updated. I will get working on that.

In regards to the descriptions, whilst we certainly will not get rid of the fluffy names, I see no harm in reviewing the descriptions and double checking they are as clear as possible.
 
Just to advise that a review has taken place in the True Blood Section.

The general consensus is that the existing names and descriptions work ok, however to be on the safe side a welcome PM will be set up to clear things up for new members.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu