Swift Reform with VHDM?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Do VC units get a Swift Reform if they are a target of VHDM?

  • Other. (Please explain.)

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    38

Soren

Black Knight
Feb 9, 2009
327
Morton, IL, USA
Zombies
209
I know there has been at least one thread discussing it, but I'd like to see what the percentatges are for Swift Reforms with VHDM.

If you take the poll, please, post your reasoning with page references. This is a test after-all. :konrad:
 
On the topic of VDM, can all units move 8", or move as you normally would, with a cap of 8"

I.E. if a corpse cart is affected by VDM, can it move 4" or 8"?
 
I believe you can make swift reforms. In my opinion there's nothing holding you back, as it's just a special kind of move that's made in the remaining moves.

I have an another question about moving with VDM... Does the spell mean I can move 8" in any direction, or does it mean I get a move of 8" that can be divided because of moving sideways etc. For instance, I have a unit of Crypt Horrors which is affected by VDM. Can the unit move 8" backwards, or is it reduced to 4" movement because of the rules of moving backwards? I hope you understood what I mean.

- Cheers, Skarsnik.
 
I vote "Yes. Swift Reforms are allowed in the Remaining Moves sub-phase." - as a swift reform is a manoeuvre that takes place traditionally in the remaining moves subphase. My question though: Do you still have to take the leadership test? - If so, what happens if you fail? - do you still get to keep the ~8" of movement provided by the spell in addition to the reform? Doubtful as if you fail a SR your reform is treated as a standard reform and movement is lost in the process.
 
Sorry to bring this back up, but I didn't notice it first time around. I say that, no you cannot reform as the spell specifically states a 'normal move'. The way I look at it, that means no maneuvers. Thoughts?
 
Chaos_Born, I agree. No reforms. However, we are the clear minority, 6 out of 18 which is a minuscule amount of the 216 views. I guess it is harder to click a poll than I thought. :scared:
 
You can not reform. Reread VHDM it says "As if it where" not that it is the same as the remaining moves subphase. Same reason you can not Danse Hexwraiths through units
 
I believe there are two elements to this thread.
1) a "move" that is occurring during the magic phase. This is why hexswraiths do not get their Spectral Hunters attack (pg 47 " moves through... In the Remaining Moves sub-phase.")
2) a move "of up to 8" in the same way as a normal move made in the Remaining Moves sub-phase." This allows any legal move (including backwards, sideways, reforms, marches, etc.) That could normally occur during the Remaining Moves sub-phase.

examples:
vdm on hexwraiths would allow them an 8" move (in which they could move forward through an enemy unit and free reform on the other side, but not benefit from spectral hunters.)
Vdm on a unit with Fly would allow them a glide of 8" instead of their normal 10".
Vdm on a unit of ghouls would allow them a march of up to 8".
 
But vanhels states that it must be a 'normal move'. In the BRB there are two different sections, 'moving troops' (or something similar) and 'maneuvers'. From this, I always assumed that wheeling, reforming etc is not the same as moving.
 
Maneuvers and reforms are aspects of movement that allow you to change the direction a unit is facing and its formation. They have rules that apply specifically to them (such as requiring a musician, or the restriction on how far a model can move during reforms).
 
It is my belief that they included the term "normal" to prevent people from trying to charge with this move, or from trying to move a unit in a manner they normally couldn't ( such as through enemy units or impassable terrain).
 
I think it was the 'remaining moves' part that was discounting charges (since you can't go within 1" in the remaining moves phase) and the 'normal' part was put in to discount maneuvers. Could be wrong but I see no reason to doubt that assumption
 
They magically surge forth beyond there control ! xD

The caster who forces them to move is powerful but I doubt he could puppet master then to move sideways and turn around!

he's good but give him a break! :mummy:

I agree its just a normal everyday move nothing fancy just helps close melee gap a bit xD
 
I think that the intent was to stop VHDM from being used for charges.

I think that you could do a reform, swift reform, move sideways, etc. The wording is "same way as a normal move in the Remaining Moves sub-phase." I think that it is a little cheesy to do a swift reform, but I would call it as allowable.
 
Chaos_Born said:
But vanhels states that it must be a 'normal move'. In the BRB there are two different sections, 'moving troops' (or something similar) and 'maneuvers'. From this, I always assumed that wheeling, reforming etc is not the same as moving.

Wheeling is a normal move. How is it not? You think Vanhels would mean simply 8 inches straight forward? If they intended that, they would have just said that.
 
Chaos_Born said:
I was saying that wheeling is a maneuver, rather than just a basic move

So then you are saying they cannot wheel during a move using Vanhels?
 
Yep. Look at page 14 of BRB. That page is titled 'Maneuvers' and includes both wheels and reforms. Then in the first sentance it says 'As with a normal move, a unit cannot carry out a maneuver if doing so would...'. This is clearly separating the two things, so maneuvers (so a wheel or a reform) are not normal moves, thus are not allowed by vanhels
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu