Teach an Old Dog New Tricks

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Battle report thread HERE.

I'll say right now that the skeletons pulled out in ways zombies never could have. They parried a ridiculous number of wounds over the course of the tournament, and won combats where zombies would have just stuck there and died. No question the zombies did better. Didn't have room to fit wraiths (list was tight enough as it was).

Funny, I had a similar experience with Skellies in my last game. It was against Skaven, and even just the added combat power of a Cairn Wraith was enough to let them legitimately threaten Clanrat blocks, who they could break by denying steadfast. They were actually useful in combat as opposed to being a straight-up tar pit, and mine wound up parrying way more wounds than they had any right to (like the one memorable time when they took only two wounds from charging a Hellpit).

I used to have absolutely zero faith in my Skeleton block, but they've been redeeming themselves of late. I'll probably make a batrep of my last game when grad school isn't leeching all my time away.
 
Funny, I had a similar experience with Skellies in my last game. It was against Skaven, and even just the added combat power of a Cairn Wraith was enough to let them legitimately threaten Clanrat blocks, who they could break by denying steadfast. They were actually useful in combat as opposed to being a straight-up tar pit, and mine wound up parrying way more wounds than they had any right to (like the one memorable time when they took only two wounds from charging a Hellpit).

I used to have absolutely zero faith in my Skeleton block, but they've been redeeming themselves of late. I'll probably make a batrep of my last game when grad school isn't leeching all my time away.

I never expect my skeletons to do ANYTHING in combat save tie something up. The trick is that sometimes they surprise me. Yeah on average they're just slightly more expensive zombies, but average rolls aren't everything. If you're thinking of probability distributions the the chance that those skeletons will take far less wounds than they ought to is very real. Multiply that over several rounds of grinding out in combat every game, and 5-6 games per tournament, and you're bound to have a couple instances where the skeletons go hog wild on the parries and beat something several times their point value on SCR.

Not to mention their utility against solo characters with great weapons. Charge in, challenge, horse kicks champ to death, hero doesn't get to go, 1 wound to 3 ranks + banner + charge and they're testing on LD5 to hold. "Unkillable BSB" my ass!


(My favourite is to stand on a chair and yell "SHIELDS UP BOYS" before rolling my parries. Makes it so much more epic when they crush it out of the park. Skeeleetoooooooooonnnnnnnnnnnns!!!)
 
I really don't see your point on the infantry. We can just van hal's dance to one inch away from the opponents units then force them to charge us or get charged?
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
I really don't see your point on the infantry. We can just van hal's dance to one inch away from the opponents units then force them to charge us or get charged?

A good opponent will see that coming and shut it down. Unless you 6-dice bubbled VHDM, which is crazy for its own reasons.

Basically a cav build is just more reliable. It's got fewer bad matchups, more flexibility, and more reliability. You don't rely on a spell to get into your opponent's face in time, and it's harder to out-maneuver you with another fast list.

That said, in a 20-0 system I've seen the infantry builds be quite solid because they have strong point-denial capabilities. I just dramatically prefer the cav build instead.
 
That's your opinion. Infantry builds are just as good and I argue more flexible and reliable. Your healing and character hopping is way more reliable in infantry armies. So many character tricks for foot armies that cavalry can't do. Besides, a solid redirector defense stops cavalry bus dead. We've had these debates in previous threads and you even said you have to rethink infantry after hearing VC infantry outplayed CavBus at masters and had the top scoring vampire army.

Also, we are better getting charged then charging because of the way healing and champions work. So a black knight bus is way riskier due to timing of heals and model count. @Quinten has it right.
 
Heh - i can agree with both of you. Cavalry build is flexible - i agree with Pirate, but i agree with najo - it is far from being reliable. Infantry is way more forgiving to less experienced player - with lots of ways to correct some bad placement, or some heavier losses. With cavalry, if something goes wrong, you usually have spectacular disaster. I`m playing VC cav heavy from 6th edition, and i seened too many massacres inflicted - on my opponent, and unfortunately on me - so i cannot defend cavalry reliability.
 
I'm in the camp that they are equal but different. Pirate keeps saying the bus cavalry is superior. I'm just laying out overlooked things about infantry to keep things real.

One other element that should be considered, any cavalry unit reveals its tactical options earlier than infantry because they need to charge. They tell you opponent, unless they, are fast cavalry, that I am going here!

Infantry armies don't do that. They can use redirectors and flankers to mess with enemy and then choose the terms of battle on their formation and where characters are at when they get ready to charge or be charged.
 
cavalry unit reveals its tactical options earlier than infantry because they need to charge
If you have BK and characters inside it without lances, charging or being charged is not big difference. The point is as you wroted - neither cavalry or infantry is superior, cause both have pros and cons while they both can do generaly the same trick - carry our killers into combat. Interestingly - while from the first sight they are different, in fact whole thing is the same. Put main combat unit into enemy, boost it with magic and start killing.

Whole VC army is heavy combat oriented but cavalry oriented army can start earning the point on the enemy sooner than infantry one - thats why many players favours cavalry over infantry with their agressive style of play.
 
If you have BK and characters inside it without lances, charging or being charged is not big difference. The point is as you wroted - neither cavalry or infantry is superior, cause both have pros and cons while they both can do generaly the same trick - carry our killers into combat. Interestingly - while from the first sight they are different, in fact whole thing is the same. Put main combat unit into enemy, boost it with magic and start killing.

Whole VC army is heavy combat oriented but cavalry oriented army can start earning the point on the enemy sooner than infantry one - thats why many players favours cavalry over infantry with their agressive style of play.
Yes, all true. But the difference is with Van Hel's, book of arkhan, and multiple units your characters can join and move through, you end up with infantry armies being in combat by round 2 and more places for your characters to hop too. Infantry also has better rank bonuses. Black knights and mounted vampires can't do all of that stuff the same, especially the jumping from one unit into the next and moving into the front rank. That is huge with VC characters.
 
I'm pretty surprised that Steadfast isn't more of a problem for the cav bus strategy. An army like Skaven could just field huge blocks of cheap infantry to tie down your block for days. Especially if you run 3-wide, you have absolutely no rank bonus and will be hacking it out until they either fail their re-rollable LD10 break test or are reduced to less than one rank.

Now of course, you could manage to get your bus into combat with the other guy's general and just assassinate him, but that's not always so easy in practice, especially if your opponent is packing a bunch of units to clog up the field.
 
Lol, I forgot about steadfast. Reason is my infantry armies break it a lot. Steadfast is a huge problem for cavalry and the reason I switched to infantry at one point actually. Now, to be fair, enough blenders can grind out a lot of damage and kill most units in droves, and when I've ran a cavalry bus I've gone five wide and three ranks deep. So you grind off enough of the unit to get it steadfast broke in 2-3 rounds. The other thing you do with cavalry is hit a support unit while sending infantry up to engage, then between tactics and overruns have the cavalry and infantry hit the unit at the right time together, if done right your blenders grind enough to come the crumble the infantry might cause. Hit hard enough and you break steadfast and them.

But I typically run skeletons five wide and eight deep!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bravo_10
Steadfast is always problem if we aiming for insta break or overruns. Having acces to cheap redirectors it is not problem for being tied for turn or two in some elite block of infantry as long as blenders killing it at good rate and redirectors controlling the rest of enemy units.

I`m testing dual VL blenders +baby v blender BSB. Results are promising, but still have some pain with harassment type armies - WE/DE in particular.
 
The one thing I do like about the cav bus is that it means your general can't be turned into a rat by the Dreaded 13th Spell. Which has happened to me. On multiple occasions. Once when I had 20 guys still in his unit.

I used to hate the Skaven so much...
 
  • Like
Reactions: najo
Steadfast is always problem if we aiming for insta break or overruns. Having acces to cheap redirectors it is not problem for being tied for turn or two in some elite block of infantry as long as blenders killing it at good rate and redirectors controlling the rest of enemy units.

I`m testing dual VL blenders +baby v blender BSB. Results are promising, but still have some pain with harassment type armies - WE/DE in particular.

Those armies are why I take vargheists over terrorgheists. Essentially, the varg packs flush the enemy into the way of the bus, and the bus just smashes them out.

As for steadfast, that's certainly the weakness of the cav build. Or...was. Two blenders in a cav bus and it really doesn't matter if things are steadfast since you'll kill them in two combats flat. Push a vigour though on the bus and you're pushing 8-10 wounds per blender, which turns the bus from a blender into a woodchipper. And if they chaff you just choose not to make way with your blenders. That way you can control the angle over overrun better, and might even stick there in combat where your opponent can't shoot at you.

Which is the real downside of the cav bus. You can deal with chaff through Gaze, vargheists, and your own chaff. What you can't deal with so well is gunlines. It's a lot easier to chew through a bus than it is to chew through 50 skeletons or 34 grave guard. Then you're praying as you roll 4++ wards for those super expensive vampires.



I'll agree with @najo here that both builds have their weaknesses. It's really going to depend on the matchups and the meta. The foot VC build at the masters I think really benefitted from the Swedish, 20-0 system, in that most of his opponents were running lists that couldn't really stand up to him in combat. People were running these giant denial blocks that an MMU army would struggle against, but which he could just plow his vampire buses into and savage.

I'd be somewhat more concerned about my bus build in that meta, in that there were soooooo many dwarfs who really give me a hard time. Two organ guns will chew through a bus really fast if I'm not careful. Then cannons are flying through the unit, and vampires don't like playing catch with cannons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Asmodeus and najo

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu