Terrorghiest shriek in close combat

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Oh no, sorry I typed it wrongly!

I meant to say: "Normal shooting can't even target some one else while you are busy in CC. Referring to how Direct Damage spells work, which they can, even if you are..."

But my point was: that simple word "may target..." or the Banshee's "Can only target..." when referring to Close Combat screams/shrieks is that the only restriction you have regarding Close Combat howls is to target someone in B2B while you are engaged to them. Any other time, you may target normally. And by normally I mean Any Unit, with an 8'' Range, in Line of Sight.
 
FAQ is out and the first question is...

Q: Can the Ghostly Howl of a Tomb Banshee or the Death Shriek of
a Terrorgheist be used against an enemy unit locked in a close combat
that the Tomb Banshee or Terrorgheist is not themselves involved in?
(p31/48)
A: Yes.
 
What about death shriek targeting a unit that your not engaged with. seems like this is still open?
 
Um, he can only scream at stuff in range, in line of sight or stuff he's in base to base with if in combat. I may be misunderstanding your meaning so please explain.
 
"If the Terrorgheist is engaged in combat, its Death Shriek may target a unit in base contact"

It says "may" not must .. so if its engaged in combat it does not have to scream against the unit it is fighting?
 
TobiasRathein said:

I would thought that would have been covered in the update but it wasn't.

you see since it says may im getting overruled saying that just means it don't have to scream not that it can scream at another target that it is not engaged with.
 
Aedin said:
TobiasRathein said:

I would thought that would have been covered in the update but it wasn't.

you see since it says may im getting overruled saying that just means it don't have to scream not that it can scream at another target that it is not engaged with.

If you're getting over-ruled by someone this means that person lacks the ability to comprehend what he/she/it is reading. In other words, said person is probably a moron. It's pretty cut and dry.

They may scream at the unit they're in base contact with, not they have to. This means they can scream out of combat.
 
TobiasRathein said:
Aedin said:
TobiasRathein said:

I would thought that would have been covered in the update but it wasn't.

you see since it says may im getting overruled saying that just means it don't have to scream not that it can scream at another target that it is not engaged with.

If you're getting over-ruled by someone this means that person lacks the ability to comprehend what he/she/it is reading. In other words, said person is probably a moron. It's pretty cut and dry.

They may scream at the unit they're in base contact with, not they have to. This means they can scream out of combat.

You do realize, Tobias, that in the last FAQ we had for our army GW said that Banshees could ONLY scream in combat with a unit they were in base to base with? This was before Terrorgheist came out. So people interpreting the way Aedin is experiencing do have some basis for their argument. I would not dismiss them for Morons. Much like your considering the failure to include ethereal's in the latest FAQ to mean they are not 'suppose' to be included.

I'm starting to really regret that GW even made the attempt to give us an FAQ. :thumbsdown:
 
That's fair, Yorga. I didn't consider previous iterations of the rules. The FAQ has created as many issues as it fixed. :(

Edit :
Read my last post from that thread to see where I stand, Yorga.
 
Ya Yorga I think you hit the nail right on the head on the previous interpretation of the banshee being used as a "past precedence" type of thinking.

Unfortunately, I don't think the FAQ cleared up all the questions with the Terrorghiest clearly and in some instances with the other rules just generated more questions than answers.

This FAQ was disappointing in its completeness to say the least.
 
I am pretty happy with the FAQ but GW still has a lot to learn about doing FAQs in general. They could learn a thing or two from Magic the gathering. There is a FAQ under the online profile for each card in 'the gatherer' which can be easily updated at any time. So no waiting months or years on FAQs that then turn out to be less than perfect. It would be relatively easy to implement so not sure why GW doesn't do something like this?
 
Aedin said:
"If the Terrorgheist is engaged in combat, its Death Shriek may target a unit in base contact"

It says "may" not must .. so if its engaged in combat it does not have to scream against the unit it is fighting?

Correct, but only in the sense that it does not have to scream. In this case "may" just allows you to choose whether or not to scream.

No rule exist that allows you to scream out of combat
 
Friendly Dead said:
Aedin said:
"If the Terrorgheist is engaged in combat, its Death Shriek may target a unit in base contact"

It says "may" not must .. so if its engaged in combat it does not have to scream against the unit it is fighting?

Correct, but only in the sense that it does not have to scream. In this case "may" just allows you to choose whether or not to scream.

No rule exist that allows you to scream out of combat

Oh, you mean just like we couldn't scream into combats with the Terrorgheist, right?
 
TobiasRathein said:
Friendly Dead said:
Aedin said:
"If the Terrorgheist is engaged in combat, its Death Shriek may target a unit in base contact"

It says "may" not must .. so if its engaged in combat it does not have to scream against the unit it is fighting?

Correct, but only in the sense that it does not have to scream. In this case "may" just allows you to choose whether or not to scream.

No rule exist that allows you to scream out of combat

Oh, you mean just like we couldn't scream into combats with the Terrorgheist, right?

First of all. Not every situation is accounted for in the rules. Just because it's possible to tear the rule apart to suit doesn't mean you should. I really hope this is a theoretical argument on your part....

Second of all the question about screaming into combats was because of there was no precise rules for target restrictions on special attacks.

There's however very clear rules for targeting with special attacks when engaged in close combat. Take Steam Tank's attacks or breath weapon as an example. A special attack is still and attack and must follow the basic rules for attacks.
 
Right, and people used that argument against screaming into combats. It was proven to be wrong.

As has been said before, the only targeting restrictions for Deathly Shriek are plain as day in the book. Within 8" and LoS. Remember that the Deathly Shriek is a magical attack and, for all intents and purposes, essentially ignores other targeting restrictions not outlined in its own rules.
 
TobiasRathein said:
Right, and people used that argument against screaming into combats. It was proven to be wrong.

As has been said before, the only targeting restrictions for Deathly Shriek are plain as day in the book. Within 8" and LoS. Remember that the Deathly Shriek is a magical attack and, for all intents and purposes, essentially ignores other targeting restrictions not outlined in its own rules.

Yup....


and here we go again

There is no restriction on targeting with special attacks except those listed in the rule for that special attack. If the intention was that you could only target the unit you are in close combat with it would say "only" instead of "may".
 
TobiasRathein said:
Right, and people used that argument against screaming into combats. It was proven to be wrong.

As has been said before, the only targeting restrictions for Deathly Shriek are plain as day in the book. Within 8" and LoS. Remember that the Deathly Shriek is a magical attack and, for all intents and purposes, essentially ignores other targeting restrictions not outlined in its own rules.

Tobias:

If the Terrorghiest IS in close combat and you need LOS to target a unit, just HOW do you target a unit out of combat considering the Terrorghiest practically has it's head on the ground? Where is your LOS that allows you to target any other unit than the one it is fighting?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu