Terrorghiest shriek in close combat

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Johnny-Crass said:
6th edition LOS was garbage. Goblins and snotlings shielding black orcs? Yeah that makes sense. No TLOS is the better system and if people would use an ounce of logic they would understand that 'modeling for advantage' is a lot harder than it seems.

Difficult or not, it shouldn't be possible to bend the rules of the game around how someone builds their model.

I think things like Snotlings and insect/ rat swarms had the "Small" rule, meaning they did not block LOS. But still, goblins screening black orcs, or infantry screening cavalry isn't much of a stretch when you consider the "fog of war" and that a unit kicks up dust and such. The mass of troops obscures vision to what lies beyond and presents a more immediate threat. So even if your troops can tell that there are some horsemen in the background, they're not really able to accurately target them. In game terms, they do not have "LOS."

You could make allowances for model types screening other types (For example: "Small" Models < Warbeasts = Swarms < Infantry < Monstrous Beasts = War Machines < Monstrous Infantry = Cavalry < Chariots = Monstrous Cavalry < Monsters < Large Targets) but at the end of the day, the way a model is posed (whether the original sculpt or a conversion) and what it's standing on shouldn't factor into the equation at all.

That way a commando-crawling Giant can still be seen over a unit of cavalry, and a general mounted on a horse rearing up, atop a rocky base, doesn't get to see over other cavalry models.
 
But that does not make any sense! And show me a model that is built solely for advantage. I mean solely, no thought on a cool conversion or making it true to the art. A model that is built so one can gain a tactical edge. I bet you can not find one. True line of sight works just fine as long as you use even part of your brain about things.
 
Johnny-Crass said:
But that does not make any sense! And show me a model that is built solely for advantage. I mean solely, no thought on a cool conversion or making it true to the art. A model that is built so one can gain a tactical edge. I bet you can not find one. True line of sight works just fine as long as you use even part of your brain about things.

Whether or not it's actually a cool conversion isn't the point. My point is that these two models:
Terrorgheist+2.webp

(by David Olorenshaw)

merenwen1.jpg

(by Merenwen)

technically have different LOS rules based on how they are built, when they are the exact same model in game terms.

I understand that the players probably don't count one as being higher than the other, or play it for an advantage (and I wouldn't either, nor would I begrudge someone their awesome conversion). But according to RAW one Terrorgheist can see over cavalry models, and the other can't. In my opinion, that is just fundamentally wrong and I wish the LOS rules weren't so literal to the point that the 'hobby" aspect of this hobby could ever be construed as a detriment to gameplay.
 
@Infernal Skull
I love the top model, and I would love to play against it. This is a good example of why conversions should be encouraged. It looks awesome.

In truth 8" is a very short range so it's very limited when you would be able to scream over another unit anyway. The bottom model will be able to see through forrest with top-heavy trees too.

But yes, LOS is measured differently from those two models and that's completely OK and by the rules. Actually I think the most opposition to this is found amongst other vampire players having a slight case of jealousy.
 
Smogg said:
@Infernal Skull
In truth 8" is a very short range so it's very limited when you would be able to scream over another unit anyway. The bottom model will be able to see through forrest with top-heavy trees too.

But yes, LOS is measured differently from those two models and that's completely OK and by the rules. Actually I think the most opposition to this is found amongst other vampire players having a slight case of jealousy.

Charging is the main concern. The Terrorgheist can fly with a potential 18" charge range (more likely 13" on average). Flying models can charge over units, so the higher model has an advantage because it can better see over units when declaring its charges.
 
I guess I just don't understand what is concerning about it. Any other flying monster in warhammer of that size would be able to declare the charge without any problems.
 
I just modeled 5 of these for my dark elf army:

http://www.avatars-of-war.com/eng/web/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&prodcode=pl04&prodname=Harpies+of+Apocalypse&id=118&Itemid=143

and mounted them on 2-2.5 inch piano wire to give them a flying look. They now see over other troops (including cavalry) with ease. Oh well... :tongue:
 
Count Matthewzilla said:
Those are wicked looking harpies. I wish I played an army that could use those. Simply pretty. :suck:

They painted up very nice! Especially when I coated them with Minwax Polyshade Tudor Satin. It went into all the deep crevases and gave the harpies a dirty animal look to suit their background. These models have wicked looking maws that lend to a light dry brushing of bone color to make the teeth really stand out. I gave them pure black orbs for eyes. They sort of look like the hags from the Evil Dead series of movies. One harpy has a severed head clutched in her foot talons. One of her talons pierces an eye. So much detail! :thumbsup:

The ONLY thing I hate about the models is the material is a resin-plastic. It does not glue well even with Gorilla super glue. Wash all the parts off to insure the mold release agent is removed from the parts. You will still likely have to pin the wings. But once the model is done it is very light and can be glued to something like piano wire and not fall over. The models come with clear plastic rods but I did not use those. Even with those their height is up enough to see over other troops.
 
Thanks for the heads up. I'm used to working with resin plastics. I've been doing resin models since before I picked up warham. :) I don't have an army to use them, but I would build them anyway. They just look great.
 
Count Matthewzilla said:
Thanks for the heads up. I'm used to working with resin plastics. I've been doing resin models since before I picked up warham. :) I don't have an army to use them, but I would build them anyway. They just look great.

They would make great furies in a demon army too. Just need some spare 25mm bases.
 
Count Matthewzilla said:
OMG. that would work. I do have a split daemons army with my brother in law that's about 2000 pts. I have slaanesh he has tzeentch. Hmm...

You can buy them here in the US (if that is where you live) from Cool Minis or Not's on line store. Those folks ship very timely. The harpies are pricey though.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu