*cracks knuckles*
The Nifty
1. Book of Arkhan. Always and forever.
2. Wristbands of Black Gold/Armour of Night (joint). Again, they're not stellar apart, but together they make a solo-running Vampire Lord a halfway sensible proposition as opposed to suicide.
3. Royal Standard of Strigos/Staff of Damnation (joint). Together, on a decent cavalry unit, these hurt. They hurt a lot.
4. Banner of the Endless Nightmare. By itself, in isolation, it's not that impressive. But I have this friend who plays Dwarfs. He has this Hammerer unit that starts with something like +8 combat resolution and has three of his characters hiding in it. Want any Victory Points from his army? Kill that unit. Bit of a bugger when you don't have missile troops. Now I can do it too: an Army Standard with this banner plus a regular standard with the War Banner plus four ranks outnumbering is 8. And that's before my standard bearer or any other characters I feel like tossing in there attack. Or show up with Walking Death for even more fun.
Plus I take 25-man Skeleton blocks as standard. It's nice to have all those ranks count.
5. Banner of the Dead Legion. I love this thing. I have a fifteen-strong Grave Guard unit that packs it as a nasty surprise for anyone who thinks they're going to snag that outnumbering bonus or not be reduced to Insane Courage if they lose combat.
The Naff
1. Frostblade. Frostblade, Frostblade, Frostblade. I am not going to sink my entire magic item allowance into a glorified Killing Blow that doesn't ignore armour saves. Give me the Sword of Kings and Beguile and I'll take my chances, thanks.
2. Carstein Ring. It's quite good. It's just that, well, without a Ward save you're probably going to need it very, very quickly, and it's too expensive to take with Walach's Hauberk, so the best Ward you'll be looking at is a 6+. And no other magic items. Yeah. Plus, y'know, we lost it hundreds of years ago. Leave it on the historical character where it belongs.
3. Standard of Everlasting Death. I mean, what? Seriously, why? Even the units where it's worthwhile (cavalry, since you can't raise them very efficiently) are better off with something that helps them not lose the combat in the first place.
4. Flag of Blood Keep. I like it, I see what it's for, but I'd really rather spam low-level Invocations into those Blood Knights to restore the wounds they've lost. Maybe after I've been on the wrong end of some Repeater Bolt Throwers I'll think differently, but maybe not...
5. Drakenhof Banner. Again, there's nothing necessarily wrong with it, but it's just so expensive and I don't see myself having that many points to burn. Besides, it's not like they don't all get back up again now.