The Golden Bat Competition Summer 2012 - Brand New Rules and Design!

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Status
Not open for further replies.

Disciple of Nagash

Libidinosus
Administrator
True Blood
Feb 12, 2008
28,011
Yorkshire
Zombies
13,979
The Golden Bat Competition 2012

Wait…..what?!

No doubt a few of you are wondering why this announcement is going out when it is far to early to start the next Golden Bat. Well don’t worry, I haven’t gone insane (well by my standards anyway). The reason is that the Golden Bat is going to be revamped (pun intended xd), to make solve a few problems and more importantly make it much more fun!

I am going to explain everything indepth, to give you all an idea what has happened and why, therefore I will apologise in advance. You can either skim, or read indepth, the choice is yours! However if you stick around and read all this, there will be boobs at the end.


So what’s going on….why are things changing?

Basically the current Golden Bat, whilst fun, has gotten to the point where it is really only accessible to a minority of people. Many members have expressed the point that there is no point entering against others that are painting at a professional standard, and there ends up being a small core of people who stand a chance, and the rest of the majority don’t. This is not to say they begrudge the skills of the winners, it is just the feel the competition doesn’t give them a chance in anyway.

I will admit at this point I am guilty of not picking up on this, and I sincerely apologise to our members for this. I did want to make the GB the best it could be, and have at some point not realised the side effects. I want to say thank you Redarmy27 and Santawraith for bringing this to my attention, they have been noting the comments your plogs and PMs, and have taken action to have it resolved.

There was also the additional point, that the Golden Bat is a competition mainly for Carpe Noctem, therefore is it fair for someone just to sign up only for the competition and sweep away with the prizes never to post again? No it isn’t, and I have been made aware of some unscrupulous people who actually go from forum to forum doing just that.

Finally some people could not enter because of the time limits, there just wasn’t enough time to make that awe inspiring model!


Ok I get that, what next?

As far as I am concerned, the current members come first. They are the ones who hang around, continue to post and make CN the great site it is. I do of course want new members and for us to grow, but that is not something that should be done at the detriment of existing members. With that in mind the GB was designed with the following in mind:

* Make the GB viable for people of varying skills, not just those with super saiyan painting skills.
* Give people more time, so they can fit it around real life and don’t have to rush.
* Recognise other skills. Painting is of course important, but what about the concept behind the model? What about the time taken in the basing of the model?
* Do all the above whilst recognising we do have some very skilled painters and still give them the chance to compete.

Finally and most importantly:

MAKE IT FUN!!

The GB has gotten to the point where it is a little too serious. It should be relaxed so people have fun, have a laugh and whether they win or lose, enjoy themselves.

Sounds impossible? Well by the power of Greyskull it is not! The following are some revised rules, which I would like all of you to check and think over. I would like to stress they are NOT set in stone. If there are enough concerns, or good ideas etc they can be reviewed. The current format comes from a discussion in the True Blood forum, so hopefully should be ok.



Down to business – The Changes

I am going to list the changes using a number as a reference – if you would like to comment and reply, please reference this number rather than quoting otherwise this thread will be massive!

1. Valid Period: You can now enter models that you have painted between September 2011 – July 2012. This gives members plenty of time to plan and implement or use models they have already done during this period.

2. Cost to enter: Members will need to have a minimum of 30 posts to enter (at time of submission).

3. Entering: All entries will be made to the Staff, there will not be a sign up thread anymore. Entries will need to be emailed or a link provided to myself via PM. You will be able to submit your entry in July 2012 - details provided closer to the time (so if you do your model before then, hold onto it, take pics etc). This means that no pictures will be seen by other members until we are ready to vote.

4. Tiers. This will probably be the biggest change. Rather than putting everyone in together, when submitting entries members need to specify which category they would like to enter, which will consist of the following:

General: This covers most members from beginners to those who have turned out a full army. Basically your skills are around tabletop standard.

Master: You are a painting god. You have progressed to such skills as NMM, seamless blending etc. You want to really pit your skills against your peers.

Now you have to be honest with yourself when submitting. We are trying to create the competition as far as possible, and so someone like Redarmy27 submitting in the General tier is not going to work. For example with my monkey like yet reasonable painting skills, I would enter in General.

“But” I hear you say, “what about those who do try to be cheeky? What happens if I am not sure?”

Well we are not just leaving upto chance. Once all entries are received members of the mod team (most like Santawraith / Redarmy27) will review each model and confirm it is suitable for the category that is being entered. Now following this, what will happen next is the one area that we have concerns about, but we feel it is the best way to go about things.

a. You will get confirmation you entry and tier choice is fine.
b. You will be advised via PM the model is not suitable to the tier due to the skill level, it will be moved to the higher tier to be fair to others. If this is not agreed to, the model cannot be entered.
c. You will be advised via PM, that we recommend that the model is moved to the lower tier. We don’t want to hurt anyone’s feelings, but we do want to give you a fair chance. If we think your model will not be fairly judged against the others in the same tier, it is only right we let you know, and we will do so as tactfully as possible. You then have the choice to accept our recommendation, or remain in the tier you applied for understanding your chances of winning will be impaired.

You can see our concerns, as we don’t want to hurt people’s feelings. However I looked at this, and thought if it was me, I would want to be told. I would then choose to move my model to a lower tier if it gave me a fair chance, plus I have something to work towards next year.

5. Anonymous and secreting voting. I think that is self explanatory, when the pictures are put up to vote, usernames will not be posted with them, and members will not be allowed to state it is thier model. This keeps voting impartial, ensuring people don't vote for people they like rather than the model. Once the voting has finished, of course the members will be revealed. Secondly all votes will be secret, you will not be able to see the score until the end. The rules will be amended (to be posted shortly) to reflect this.

6. More awards! By this I don't necessarily mean money or vouchers, as we have a set fund to work with from Mantic. But we will have more awards that are not just based on painting skill for example. Some of them may not even be judged by the forum, but by specially selected judges. The ones we have decided on are below, though come the competition we may and some more if we get more good ideas!

All awards below consists of a medal for your profile, and 50 Zombie Points

The Spanktastic Award
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Decided by Disciple of Nagash
The winners for this will be chosen by Disciple of Nagash, who will be looking for the most perverted entry! It is based on the model itself, not the painting.

Terraformer
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Voted for by forum members.
This prize will be voted for by the forum members. The criteria is looking for the best based model, how ingenuitive the member is with the terrain on thier model. The model itself is not to be considered when voting.

The Mods Choice
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Chosen by CN's Dark Art Mods.
Throughout the year the Dark Art mods get to know many members, and this is where they recognise someone they feel deserves the notice. Perhaps they have vastly improved, or gone that extra step. Whatever the reason, the mods will grant this award to one they feel deserve it, and state the reason why.

The WTF?! Award
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Voted for by forum members.
If you dont know what WTF stands for, we're not telling you! There are some members out there that like to not only think outside the box, they like to step outside the realm of sanity, and design or paint in a way that makes you go....well WTF?! This prize is for those people. It is not based on skill but on the idea behind the entry.

The Nightmare Award
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Voted for by forum members.
There are some models out there that just give us the heebie jeebies. They are the ones that make us look away from our monitors and keeps us awake a night, and this award is for them. This is based on a combination of both the model choice and the possibly the painting. That is not to say a conversion can't win this, as I have seen some unpainted models that gave me the creeps!

Living Doll Award
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Voted for by forum members.
I know many of you like to go for realism over fantasy, and this award is specially for you. This is for the model that looks like it is about to stand up and start walking and talking!

The Joker Award
Judged across all entrants regardless of category or tier. Voted for by forum members.
We like a good laugh, me especially. We all remember a funny model, the older ones of us will always remember the Zombie Bat-Pope. So for those that take the time to have some fun and make us laugh, this is a chance to be recognised. Again it is not based on painting skill.

Wow, that's a lot of awards! But more importantly it makes things more interesting, more fun, and gives pretty much every entrant a fair chance to walk away with a prize.

7. Limit consecutive wins. If the same person comes back and kicks everyones butt it can get tiresome, but on the flipside we don't want to stop pushing people to strive harder. Therefore the following rules are now in place for winners:

If you win the NAME 1 or the NAME 2 category, then next year you must go up the next tier. Winning that class means you should spend the next year honing your skils, and challenge yourself for the next level. It also means that those in the class you have won have fair chance next year. The exception to this is the NAME 3 category. If you are in this category, you will be up against some immense competition. If you have the skill to win this year after year, then fair enough!

8. New sections. I know many members want to be able to show and paint non-VC models. After all many members collect other armies, or have even strayed off the dark path and collected something else altogether! There will therefore be additional categories for non-VC fantasy and 40K, however only the VC categories will have actual prizes.


I will be following this post shortly with what models are allowed, clearly layout on categories etc.

Please bear in mind as this is the first time we are trying this, it may need some tweaking. So we ask all members to understand this.

Please feel free to post any feedback or questions.

Now....boobies:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qPNaJLhmj6g&feature=related
 
Sounds great.
Allot more to get out of it now and I can feel comfortable with my level of ability where I don't look at another's army and feel mine may look a bit better with the lights off. :redface:
Light is not my Friend.
Green stuff and awesome making is where I am at.

So just a quick question here.
A model which has been designed with the purpose of fitting in both a VC and a Empire army (using VC bits in the construction such as torso) will that still fall under VC for the Competition?
 
Sounds great DoN. I think it will make more people participate in the competition now that we got tiers. I'll of course be happily entering this year again, if only I could figure out what unit to enter.

Especially glad to hear that there will be non-VC categories as well, as that gives me a platform to show some of my other stuff, maybe 40k or one of my other fantasy armies.

I also like the idea of limiting entry to those who stuck around here longer so there are no price-grabbers who then go "poof" once they get their goodies for uber-painting skills.

Two little things though:
With that long period of time where the entry may be taken from, what about those of us like me who run a painting log? Some people would surely recognize one or the other model... or maybe even the workspace depending on the availability of lightboxes.

Additionally I think 30 Posts is not enough to get rid of price grabbers, the restriction should be a bit highter imo. Maybe you could also consider something along the lines of "Only members that have joined more than 3 months ago". 3 months of course is just a quick random example. The exact limit would have to be discussed.

Anyway, these are my 2 cents for the competition. I'm glad you're keeping it alive... or unliving, whatever.

I'm looking forward to it already.

Cheers
 
Rule #2: I agree with the Duke; I was at 30 posts in my first day or so. If I was one of those unsavory people who swoop in and steal all the prizes from the forumites, I could easily get to 30. My current post count is high enough (at 201), and I joined end of January. I think I'm a fairly regular poster/viewer since I've joined, so I don't think that 200 posts is crazy-high at all...

Plus it ensures that someone has been here (and relatively active) for at least a month prior to submitting, which is what I think you are going for anyways.

Just my two cents.
Brahm
 
Rule 2: I was a lurker on Carpe Noctem for a while but only joined to enter the Golden Bat competition a few years ago.

Despite joining several years ago my post count is not yet over 200, but I would say I'm an active member, I just don't post a lot. Be wary of setting the barrier too high.

Also, I was disappointed to find there were no boobs by the end of your post DoN.
 
Isn't the minimum post limit to be able to trade set at 50? How about using that limit here too?

Also I agree with Dogmar, us who run plogs with regular update will likley not be so anonymous. But I guess it is hard get away from since one could recognize painters just by their paint styles.

Otherwise it sounds great :thumbsup:
 
@ Dogmar and Mad´at, I would enjoy the guessing game xD

I really wanted to enter last year, but real life didn´t agree with me.
Hopefully this year will be different.
 
Sounds like some good changes there.
I have to agree that 200 posts is a little high, I've been a member of the Lustria Online forum for about 3 years and haven't made it to 200 yet!

I also like the idea of being able to compete in a different category from the likes of U_M and Redarmy!
Not saying I don't like 'em, but they are a little better than me..

Cheers, Monkey

P.S. I don't see any boobs DoN:mad2:
 
Liked the changes, but I´d like to know if there´ll be different "categories" for the model type. Such as lone model, unit (something as the first rank with the command) and monster/chariot for those of us that got the conven throne, zombie dragon and so... and in the case of lone models/characters, I think it MUST BE legal in respect of the base. No huge diorama bases for a model that uses a 20 mm one, for example.

If the division of model categories should be adopted, would be legal to enter more than one, like one model for each?

I think 200 posts is too high. For those of us like me that are more lurkers than posters, would be impossible to participate, and I have already entered 2 competitions; I just don´t like to post everywhere. Maybe 50 would be more suitable, if 30 should be considered too low. I also may agree with the time, maybe the 3 months that was suggested, but no more than this.
 
But the whole point is your meant to be forum active.

Dan_Lee himself has a lower posts count and said he only joined for the Golden Bat and had been lurking.
If you wish to take part in a community event you should be involved in said community.
30 posts is nothing at all and easily doable in a day.

Now I don't mean to seem unfair but you yourself have entered 2 Golden Bats but I have never seen you in the forums.
This is meant to inspire activity after all.
Just go out into the site and mingle with folks, its what 95% of us here do, we are not asking for the moon after all and it is easily achievable.
 
Duke Danse Macabre said:
But the whole point is your meant to be forum active.

You don't need to be super-forum-active, everybody's busy. We're not trying to be elitist with these rules, just trying to discourage people from one-post-winning the competition.

You make a fair point, however, so I wonder, DoN, if perhaps instead of a post-buy-in there should be both a post-buy-in and a minimum account age? Say two week-age minimum and 30 posts, and if any are very close to the boundary we can look into the case to see if they are "one-post-winners" or genuine new members. How does that sound?
 
I myself am very much of a lurker, as I've been on CN for several months, but with few posts, and I should probably contribute more, but a lot of the time I can't find the time, or I can't really find anything I want to comment on. I like to think I'm not bad at painting, and I want to enter the Golden Bat, mainly to just test myself and possibly achieve something amazing. But as I haven't posted 50 or 200 times, I won't be able to enter diddly.
So, instead, I have this suggestion: a category/tier for people who don't post very often and/or aren't the forum very long. There will be NO prizes for anyone who enters this category/tier, so that will discourage people just wanting prizes, and so only people who want to test their painting skills (such as myself, and as I suspect, many others) will enter.

Now how does that sound?
As another point, surely one of the main points of painting competition is to encourage people to join the forum?
 
150 - 200 is hardly super active.
You can do that in about 3 months of not being bothered and posting only a day or 2 a week on things that interest you.
The point is people can post 30 in a day without trouble and then still don the exact same thing they were before.

2 week age is abouts the time they will join anyway as they will have a month to get their entree in.
It would need to be longer than that.
2 - 3 months range and 100 posts would be fair.

A Lurkers Comp category sounds decent as well.
 
Lurker category sounds good. But I do agree that if SOMEONE wants to get around the rules, simply looking at their account age won't help; I could create an account now, not do a damned thing, enter the GB, and then not log in again until next year to do the same. Perhaps if we look at "time spent online"? I'm depressed to say that I've spent nearly 3 days "straight" online according to my user profile, so even lurkers (who don't post) will have some sort of "decent" time spent online.

Using my friend Black Bard as an example; he joined back in early September of 2011 and has spent 10hrs & 30mins online. He's got an active plog, posts about once a week (32 in total; says .17/day, however I know he logs on once a week to peek at stuff & usually does all of his posting during that one log-in time) and is the one that turned me on to this site...

What can we gather from that? I KNOW that Bard deserves to be in the GB, but thus far he wouldn't qualify...?

Brahm
 
Having people post 2-3 times a day for a few months just to get them 200 posts will simply clog the forum up with posts that aren't contributing.

I like the forum, but I'm only interested in rules debates and occasionally a painting or modeling thread. The end result being that two years after joining I've yet to get 200 posts. But I'm on the forum once or twice a day, have entered the golden bat twice and have even sent an article to the invocation just before it was put on hold.

For the record, it was after seeing the golden bat covered in the invocation that I decided to enter and thus stop lurking and join the forum.
 
Time online does not require you to do anything but log in though:

Time Spent Online: 2 Weeks, 1 Day, 20 Hours, 26 Minutes, 18 Seconds

Is mine..... I'm nover here.... Honest. :redface:
Ok I log in every day.

Well they will have to post to be active so its a catch 22.
I hate the idea of say someone with Redarmy27 skill level just turning up and cleaning house as they are currently able to do.
 
It's an interesting debate, but one I don't think we are going to be easily solve.

200 posts is too high in my opinion. We want this competition to encourage the new members as well, and for those who have families and real lift responsibilities it will not necessarily be easy to do that.

As long as members have contributed reasonably outside the GB then I am happy with that. I think the first time is going to be a trial and error exercise. If it is raised too high it will put members off, however if it is a reasonable amount, then members will be ok to just post a little more if they are short.

With that in mind I would agree to 50 posts, so for those around 20-30 posts it is reasonable. But going from 20-30 to 200 posts in a couple of months is far too much.

Also - first post updated with boobies.......:devil2:
 
I have to concur - if we are to really get on board with making this better we would be wise not to exclude a lot of forum members. 30 posts to me is acceptable, 50 is acceptable too but 200 is way too much. When I think how long it took me to reach 200 and the contributions I made prior to reaching it, I think it would be a travesty to exclude honest, loyal and active members. I would sooner have 30 quality, thoughtful responses to painting problems than 200 posts in something like the LOL Thread. I know this is an extreme example but we do have to be careful as to who we exclude. We are after all a community who is passionate about a hobby, therefore we have to let the community share their talents!
 
Sounds like some really good changes to me but I can also see that there might be problems with the tier system as it will be very hard to decide where to draw the line as far as skill goes. Since painting skills vary greatly I think there is a risk that someone who might have been a top contender in the general tier gets put in the pro tier only to be at the bottom. I'm not sure I think that is very fair either.
 
Well 50 is better but I still rather of pushed for 100.

Well allot of it comes down to people being honest about ability.
I'm a good painter but I can't paint to display standards (I can't blend to save my life) which is why for instance I have commissioned untitled_musketeer to do a model for me but I am confident enough to say in sculpting I am good enough to be top.
Either way I am sure there will be a couple people judging what tier and not just one guy.

My money is on DoN, Redarmy and U_M making the judgement call being chief and best painters but we will soon see.
 
Extra effort will be made when determining the correct tier for an entry to be placed. I know I will be looking for different techniques in coloration, color symmetry, blending, ect ect. While I'm not perfect, I have been around a bit to see what things a "pro" painter can pull off compared to a "normal" painter. I've judged some actual contests in real life and have attended workshops/ trainers as well. I'm quite sure the "panel" will seek feedback from each other to determine the appropriate tier.

Also, when you enter your model, don't be afraid to declare your tier or your thoughts on which you should be placed. We most certainly won't bite at all. We encourage your feedback.

As a P&M, I'm personally taking a very protective stance in regards to the happiness of my P&M’ers this year. I want everyone who enters to have a fun time and be encouraged to expand their skills. Anyone whom I suspect of coming to "headhunt" this contest as a "pro" painter to knock everyone out will deal with me:vampire3:. I will also be researching entries to make sure they are legitimate and not someone looking to score an easy win, take the contest, make a profit and simply move onto another forum.

I certainly don’t want a repeat of the PM’s I got last year where I had to hear the genuine and disheartening voices of great forum members who felt incredibly put off about entering and being swept away. Everyone has a chance in these contests. We’re all a big happy family here.

Let’s have fun with this!

Jake
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu