Oh boy, here we go. I am a bit of a gamer though not a lot on PC. Played Dawn of war back in 2005ish was good fun, and half life 1 and 2 also great on pc in their time.
I agree Vampire the Masquerade Bloodlines is the best vampire game ever made and is still awesome. Played it several times through as different vampire sects and loved it.
These days I do all my gaming on PS3 and have played I am guessing hundreds of games. Currently have probably 80 or 90 but have traded many in in the past.
I agree Shadow of the Colossus and Ico are great.
Space marine was really good fun, highly recommend it.
The batman games, excellent, Arkham Asylum significantly better than Arkham city though. Much better villans, better story, better pacing (no cat woman though which I liked in Arkham city).
Persona games are good I hear, I have only played number 4. Persona 4 Golden is great if you are one of the lucky few to own a PSVita.
Catherine is an awesome adult oriented game from the team which makes the persona games. Seriously mature, a puzzle game crossed with a dating simulator, a great story, and some interesting moral choices.
Infamous 1 and 2 probably 2 of the best open world and superhero games available anywhere.
X men Origins Wolverine. One of the best movie based games ever, very satisfying combat.
Dragons Dogma is a really great action RPG and I enjoyed it a lot more than Skyrim. Kind of a bit like a cross between Skyrim and Dark Souls without the extreme difficulty of Dark Souls. I would really highly recomment Dragon's Dogma to anyone who hasn't played it (watch a review if you want more info, gametrailers has a pretty fair/good review).
The new Tomb Raider reeboot is an excellent game, as long as you are not an old TR fan expecting it to be the same thing. Really fantastic though, borrows quite heavily from the Uncharted series, Which is another excellent series with really entertaining story telling.
Sorry for the rant. Many other games to recommend if anyone is interested
