OK, this is going to be a very long post.
Get of W said:
Duke Danse Macabre said:
Well I feel i may of ranted on here a bit but the end result in my mind is Abhorash is the greatest warrior if you do not factor in magic items or spells, once that comes into it then you have a whole different ball game.
I agree but I think you have to factor in the lot.
Magic sword, Gods blessing/curse etc etc.
Being in a tank or riding a dragon does not make you a great warrior, its your own skill that makes you great.
Malochai said:
Duke Danse Macabre said:
Want to compare Aenarion?... He started to get issues from picking up a sword and all elves are warped by chaos, wood elves seek to hide away from the world, dark elves are warped to the extreme and high elves have been made arrogant to the point where they scorn the actions and help of others.
Well I feel i may of ranted on here a bit but the end result in my mind is Abhorash is the greatest warrior if you do not factor in magic items or spells, once that comes into it then you have a whole different ball game.
I'm not too sure; Aenarion may have been made even fiercer than he already was by the power of The Widowmaker, but he was already an astounding warrior to begin with. The elves fought the daemons for a century at least before, whilst devastated at the death of Astarielle, he drew forth Khaine's blade from the Blighted Isle. For over a century he led the elves in a way against the daemons and stopped the elven race from falling - I'm not sure even Abhorash could do that!
Granted, in the end, it was Caledor and his cabal of mages who took the daemons from Ulthuan and the world, but in defending him, even with the Widowmaker, Aenarion banished four greater daemons.
Now, as for the actual question, I'm not necessarily sure that Abhorash is the
strongest. I will give that he is perhaps the most the most
skilled, but the two are not the same.
He was given god like power from a weapon, Riding a powerful dragon with a army of dragons behind him with the most powerful casters of the age.
Not exactly a shining example of his ability, more so the strength of his gods and those around him.
yes he was powerful but he became corrupted by the influence caused by taking the weapon and his people are now cursed to die out.
Abhorash on the other hand is a great warrior much like he but realys on his own abilities and strength, no magical trickery, no riding a dragon into battle, no mountain of magical equipment, just his skill against yours which is how it should be.
In addition to this as well he has lived with his curse and beaten it with his strength of will, obviously something Aenarion was lacking seeing as he damned his race, ruined the high elves, and planted the seeds which would cause his son and wife to split away by encouraging the love of battle and other more perverse lusts during his time as king.
At best he achieved a Pythic victory, after all it was Caledor who won the victory by his actions which Aenarion did not want him to do, Caledor who no longer trusted the person who was his friend who was now blood thirst, vengeful and filled with hate who set the tone for the Dark Elves to come. Aenarion who was tempted to strike against his friend for taking this action but only stayed his hand because he had no choice but to go along with it or all would be lost.
With such a history and a hunger for blood and vengeance like his i would say he was more of a vampire than Abhorash, at least he was in control of himself after being tricked into the curse.
To me, this is why Abhorash is the greatest warrior, he has not done the greatest deed (and neither did Aenarion) but his determination, force of will, code of honour and ability without that of magical aids makes him the greatest warrior.
Disciple of Nagash said:
Sorry, when I meant strongest, I meant a combination a package of skill, speed strength - so basically who is the better warrior.
DDM does raise a very valid point though - is a warrior who is deadly because of a magical weapon really deserve to be recognised as such? Should it perhaps be the weapon that is known as deadly?
So in that case we split it into two categories:
Stripped down. No magical items. Just their own bodies and say the mundane weapon they are most skilled with. In this category I would say for pretty much certain Abhorash must be top.
Fully kitted. So with their
known gear. I have to admit that Abby (he's manly enough to live with it

) may have a disadvantage her, as some of the magical bling out there is seriously OP. Aenarion my be the favourite here.
As for Archaeon, didn't he get his arse handed to him by Grimgor (that's right isn't it?)
EDIT: Oh and for discussions sake, let's ignore the good guy auto-win.
It is good to have a few categories.
MasterSpark said:
If plot armour is out the window I'd give the bare knuckle title to the Bloodthirster. It's always portrayed as an ultimate test and obstacle for a warrior to prove himself against and it's always foiled by some divine power boost at the last minute. I know that game stats aren't all that useful for fluff discussions but when you consider those stats for something that big - it would be
absolutely insane.
I've always been a Bloodthirster fanboy, though.
Could not really call a blood thirster a warrior in my mind, they are rage mad manifest gifted with abilities and created by gods, they are not warriors but constructs.
How can you claim to have skill if you were built like that, you are simply you, nothing more, nothing less.
Besides, great dragons are said to be on Par with Greater Daemons and Abhorash killed a Dragon in a one on one fight after days of battling and threw its corpse down the side of a mountain.
MasterSpark said:
Get of W said:
True but it should be considered or we'd have to imagine Abhorash without the vampirism :tongue:
Right, so we've got Archaeon without the chaos gods behind him, Abhorash without his vampirism and the Bloodthirster without... well, he was made just like he is right now, so I guess that's not more than fair, right? :devil2:
Well if we went from that with all of them without their magic or bloodlines etc the blood thirster is out straight away, its made of magic and has no ability of its past what it is given, it is another faceless monster in a expanse littered with them.
Archaeon would be essentially a tough warrior priest. chaos hero character, Abhorash is the greatest warrior of his race (He was great before he became greater, thats why he was turned) a drilled general and loyal to the end.
It may be a tough fight but I would still narrowly back Abhorash.
They would both be mortal with no gifts, now where one is a digruntled warrior priest the other is the captain of the greatest warriors in the realm and the greatest of them to boot, now its either going to be close as they are both very strong willed but on the point of skill as a warrior I would back Abhorash, he is a man that rose up and gained his skill and iron resolve, a Hellborg of a earlier time where as Archaeon is a strong willed traitor that read to many books and got angry about it, he had nowhere near the experience fighting and he most certainly had not led troops into battle.