Thoughts on Swedish Comp

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

PureSphinx

Ghoul
Jul 16, 2014
178
Zombies
153
Hey, sorry if this is the wrong place to post this. Just posted it over at Druchii.net and wanted input from here as well.

So, I haven't yet played the comp but I have built a few lists with my three armies, and I'd like to play with my group. However, one of my group (the High Elf player, of course) says "Swedish comp is dumb because it's like someone saying 'oh I don't know how to play against it I'm bad so I'll make this comp to make it so if I lose I still win' so I won't play." I see where he is coming from, but I don't necessarily agree. My three armies are DE, VC, and beasts.

Now, he considers those armies to be upper tier, middle tier, and lower tier, respectively. So from his point of view if he is taking a BotWD deathstar with accompanying bolt throwers and a bunch of loremasters, dragons, and phoenixes, that my Beastmen should be able to beat it without doing the cookie cutter list, I just suck and that's why I can't win. However we all know (and he admitted that they are bottom tier) that the beasts will be hard pressed to pull through no matter how good the generalship, because they simply aren't as good as the cheese some lists bring to the table.

On the other hand, if I took a Witch Elf and Executioner star list with warlock spam and Pegasus lords, he claims that as long as he deploys right and gets flank charges that his list of the most overcosted, inefficient goblins (another army he claims to be bottom tier) will still just win because he got that deployment and flank charge, without Swedish comp.

So basically what he is saying is that anyone who plays Swedish comp sucks and that it adds nothing to the game, even though for people like me who like themed lists and like the idea of incentive to make the game fun it seems like the way to go. Thoughts on this? Is Swedish comp really that un-fun? Are the armies so far apart that they need Swedish comp? Is Swedish balanced? More balanced than vanilla at least? Id like to think so since I want to use fleemasters and corsair core without execs or witches and still have a fighting chance against the turbo cheese, but I don't really know what to think yet, and I'd like to see some opinions.
 
Exactly as it recommends in the document: difference in score x10. Meaning that if one person made the cheesiest list possible and one person took 400 zombies and a Necromancer the zombies would have to be within 200 VP turn six to win. (Comp score 0 to comp score 20)

Edit: 100 VP, not 200. iPods man...
 
Last edited:
I would say that your friend is completely wrong. If only bad players use the comp Sweden should not have won this years ETC :tongue:

In Sweden I would say that almost 90% of all tournaments is played using the Swedish comp. We usually play that you get 150vp per differences in comp. But it is also important to note that we usually have a lower and upper limit. For example a tournament can ha a comp span between 10-15 so if you have higher comp than 15 you don´t get extra points for that. The comp really allows people to field units that you otherwise never would see. I played a triple Stonehorn-list with a unit of Yheeties during my last tournament. When would you ever see that in a uncomped environment? The comp is not perfect, but it changes several times a year to try and adjust to the ever-changing metas. I think that the game really befits with the use of comp since the armies have different power levels and you get much more varied lists. One of my friends just started playing dwarfs and he is using a dubbel anvil list, believe me it is much scarier that it sounds. Good luck finding that kind of list in an uncomped environment :clown:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu