Trickey question about Rune Maw Banner

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
And now you walked into my trap

If spirit leech is cast on a character with Talisman of Endurance in a unit with Liche Bone Penant what is his wardsave? Please explain your answer. He is in the unit right? So he gets the magic res. You see the idea of magic res makes your whole argument invalid as it carries over to characters in the unit.
 
He gets the resistance because anyone in a unit gets the benefit of magic resistance to their saves when saving against magic, there is no mention of 'when a spell targets a unit'

If magic resistance said 'when a spell targets the unit with magic resistance they get +X to their save' then spirit leach would happily snipe without worrying about MR, because it doesn't target units. Fortunately MR is worded very differently to that.
 
Gragragra!!!!!

I can not tell if you are just yanking my chain or really debating this

Asuming the latter I just have to say look at the "Characters In Units" section.

I would pull a number for the page but I am at work. :D
 
I don't care if the character counts as being part of the unit, the spell isn't targeting the unit. It's targeting a model. Even if it targets the friggin banner bearer or some RnF dude it isn't targeting 'the unit'. It's targeting 'a model'
 
The model is part of the unit, but the spell isn't targeting the unit. In order for the banner to take effect it must target the unit as a whole. Targeting a unit is a very specific thing that most spells do. Spirit leach is not one of those spells
 
Johnny is right on this one. The character IS part of the unit. He is in no way a seperate unit within the unit. Yeah you can single him out but he is still part of the unit and gets the banners protection. It doesn't say anything in the banners decription about having to target the unit as a "whole". The character is in the the unit. He is part of the unit. He is not seperate from the unit. And for info it was ruled exactly as Johnny has stated at the last Colonial GT I was at. I was the Ogre player.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu