Triumph & Treachery

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Yeah! That would have been amazing!! Even just one!

However what I really want to do is run a bastiladon and a skink priest as mercenaries! Not because it would be really good, but because I really want those models!
 
Corien Sumatris said:
Yeah, it's just way too expensive for house rules, or even a hard cover. I mean it shouldn't have been more than $50.

My local gamestore owner said he would sell one to me for $60 so I am getting it.
 
Was sitting in my local games workshop painting today, and when I arrived a T&T game was already well underway. Though I spent most of my time painting I overheard alot of the action and took short breaks from painting to spectate. Was a 5 way game (2 Lizardmen players, 1 WoC player, 1 Ogre Player and 1 Helf Player). They started at 10am and finished at about 4pm, but it looked like a hell of a lot more fun than plain old vanilla fantasy- there was alot of good natured banter and alot of careful thinking and planning about who to designate as enemy each phase.

From what I could see, the T&T rules worked very smoothly and were easy to use & remember- the only difficulty people had was remembering to roll each phase for treachery cards, though that was just due to inexperience.

Having read through the book, the rules are nice and simple with no ambiguity or conflicts of wording that I have been able to spot so far. People like me who love fluff, backstory and example battles in books will like the expansion book (it especially has alot of ideas and inspiration for themed armies and regiments, such as the Bretonian army of Tancred, Duc de Quenelles, who after facing Heinrich Kemmler and Throt the Unclean in battle, dedicated his life to thwarting Kemmler, eventually falling in battle and being cursed to undeath by the Lichemaster, or Asarnil, a High Elf Dragonlord who became a mercenary after he was exiled from Ulthuan.)

People who expect the book to be entirely filled with rules will be disappointed- about 10-20% of the book is rules, the rest is fluff and descriptions of great battles (complete with full details of the armies that fought them, the people who led those armies and pictures of the regiments themselves).

Personally I feel that the rules taking up a small portion of the book is actually a blessing in disguise- it makes them easy to learn and easy to implement, and avoids being over complicated. T&T elegantly solves many of the issues of multiplayer games by making you simply declare one player as your target each phase- i.e. if you declare my Skaven as your enemy in the movement phase you can only declare charges against my skaven in that movement phase, and if you declare Bobs High Elves your enemy in the magic phase, then your spells must target him while he gets all of the dispel dice.

Many people attemtping to houserule things (myself included) would have probably come up with some convoluted system in which 3 way combats are fought and dispel dice are divided between all players and etc, which would severely imbalance the game.

The coins in the expansion unfortunately are layered pieces of cardboard (though still nice looking) but the cards themselves are beautiful- they seem to be of higher quality than the battle magic cards, and have considerably more colour and art on them.


Overall, I would say that T&T is a well designed expansion, though its value for money is slightly questionable- at $140 australian, it is not a cheap expansion. However, the fact that it provides everything you need for 3-5 players (you can even use it for regular 2 player battles, and the only thing stopping you from player battles with 6 or more sides is the number of 5 "whos turn is it next" cards, which you could just improvise your way past easily by deciding who goes next with playing cards or a dice roll.... though if you went up to 7 players you would have to invent your own scenarios as most scenarios involve the board being divided up into its 6 realm of battle tile sized segments.

How anyone would find the time and space to play with more than 5 players is beyond me though- Warhammer is time consuming even with 5 (or just 2 players!).


In summary, slightly expensive expansion, easy to understand and well designed rules, nice book/fluff/artwork.


... and two previously unseen terrain pieces are clearly visible in the pictures (and are used as central parts of two of the "famous battle" scenarios). They appear to be fairly nice looking but simple plastic kits, one representing a sorcerous portal, the other representing a magic circle. The magic circle has gargoyles similar (but larger) than those on the Storm of Magic Throne, and the portal appears to be the structure that the skaven tore down to make their screaming bell. I am guessing they will probably be released in one box like the storm of magic fulcrums?
 
£50 for a set of rules I could easily have made up myself, requiring more than two people and requiring you to have friends that play Warhammer? Seems to be just another pointless waste of money for people with boring jobs who have nothing better to spend their money on, because charities don't exist. :rolleyes:
 
At the very least it looks fun and the tokens and cards are employed in gameplay rather than being a nice extra it looks good and I bought it before finding out what it is, plus so much fluff in the book makes it rather appealing, I've paid £10 or £20 on books just for fluff so its got to be worth something. Although £50 is outrageous its GW and having seen a lot of toys and stuff nowadays in stores GW is starting to look very cheap, especially in terms of model quality. So you can expect to see this outrageous price seeming cheap when you compare to other things outside of GW. :rolleyes:
 
Yeah I see your point crystal but their model quality has been going down hill for a while now, not in the sculpting area because they come out with some super sweet toys but their quality sucks when it comes to plastic used and fine cast in general. They have changed their plastic suppliers a ton and the plastic used is either forces through or thier process is faulty. Their plastic doesn't get hot enough before the inject it into the molds. And fine cast is still new so the need to get use to it.

DD: I agree man, I think GW went crazy money hungry when fine cast came out. They replaces pewter with resin and started charging more?? That's nuts. Also when it c omes to T&T, how many do they expect to sell?? Each gaming group needs 1. I mean I have a buddy who got it and I play with him all the time (in allsorts of ways!) So I can just use his book when we play.
 
I finally broke down and picked up the book this weekend.

I played a 3 player game with some friends and had a blast.

I like the tokens because of the transparency they add to victory points while playing the game.
It makes it easy to see who is in a lead so that you can gauge who you should be fighting.
Although I wish they were plastic for the 85 dollar price tag. They have a nice look and feel but are cardboard in the end

Rule set seemed pretty balanced and easy to play. The scenarios seemed really awesome although I wish
there were more than 3. The one we played was sort of like watchtower without the tower and you earned points immediately at the end of every turn for being nearest to the center of the map

The card system is awesome for stopping people from just ganging up and fighting the obvious player to attack. They have some funny effects for blocking magic and shooting and turning the tables of combats.

The mercenaries are kind of cool. I like take fluffy mercenaries that fit with army lore as well so I enjoyed them. Although I can see it being used to take some ridiculous combos for armies that you normally would not have access to. Add some cannons to a Beastmen army or a High Elf Wizard to your army but being able to pay them off so they don't do anything or running the risk of them breaking and joining your opponent gives them some balance.

In the end some people from my gaming group said they would chip in some cash to help cover my expense for buying the rule book for the group (even though I didn't expect them too). So despite the steep price tag; $20 a person is not so bad for a rule set that we can use over and over again.

We have made house rule games in the past to incorporate more players and some have worked well and other games not so much. So it is nice to have something official that everyone can agree on.

I feel like I had enough fun with the rules and will use them enough that it was worth my hard earned money even though it would have been nice if they made it cheaper. It is a nice set of rules if you are looking to get more than 2 people involved in a game in a fair manner instead of having house rules that are less tested.
 
It's probably not a bad set of rules at all! I just really don't want to spend that kind of money on something like this.

Now if GW was smart and ya know .. not so "Family Firendly" then I would pay good money for legit beer-hammer rules!
 
Corien Sumatris said:
It's probably not a bad set of rules at all! I just really don't want to spend that kind of money on something like this.

Now if GW was smart and ya know .. not so "Family Firendly" then I would pay good money for legit beer-hammer rules!

I think the other thing is the size of this supplement. It's something like 94 pages. By contrast, your average White Dwarf is about 150 pages.

Even if I had the disposable income to buy something like this, I'd be funneling those funds into more models or the start of a new army.
 
Another thing that I have yet to hear anything about is the fact that the rules are easy enough to convert & use for 40K too.

I've only quickly read through the book and had one opportunity to get a game in with the experience, albeit limited; I've had so far it wouldn't be a stretch to use it for both systems.
 
I had the joy of playing this last night and had a blast. You must take the competitive nature out of it and play it for what it is...Warhammer/Munchkin/ something else. You can't count on getting turns when you want and you can get backstabbed with cards. It's great fun and a refreshing take on the game.
 
bigbadbat said:
I had the joy of playing this last night and had a blast. You must take the competitive nature out of it and play it for what it is...Warhammer/Munchkin/ something else. You can't count on getting turns when you want and you can get backstabbed with cards. It's great fun and a refreshing take on the game.

I hear alot of people say the game was good but do you think its good enough for price?
 
bigbadbat said:
Without a doubt. This particular package will play endlessly, even when new editions of WHFB have come and gone.

Seriously? That much money for a supplement you could easily have house-ruled? I mean, it would have been cool as an add-on in broader campaign book, but that much money for such a lite product is mind boggling. That's the kind of content I would expect for free in a White Dwarf, not for a higher price than an entire years worth of White Dwarf mags.
 
I have yet to encounter house rules of any kind that come close to these. The addition of the cards and victory point conditions with regards to coinage really lends itself to a gaming experience not yet encountered from GW. dare i say these are the most thought out rules GW has put out in some time?
Also, since it is a multiplayer game, and I do have the benefit of playing in a tightly knit gaming group, it makes perfect sense to split the cost!
 
bigbadbat said:
I have yet to encounter house rules of any kind that come close to these. The addition of the cards and victory point conditions with regards to coinage really lends itself to a gaming experience not yet encountered from GW. dare i say these are the most thought out rules GW has put out in some time?
Also, since it is a multiplayer game, and I do have the benefit of playing in a tightly knit gaming group, it makes perfect sense to split the cost!

I'm going to back BigBadBat on his stance 100%. Another thing that people may not realize is that while the books fluff doesn't lend itself to 40K, the rules are quite easily transferable. So if you have armies for both systems you could potentially get twice as much use out of it.
 
bigbadbat said:
I have yet to encounter house rules of any kind that come close to these. The addition of the cards and victory point conditions with regards to coinage really lends itself to a gaming experience not yet encountered from GW. dare i say these are the most thought out rules GW has put out in some time?
Also, since it is a multiplayer game, and I do have the benefit of playing in a tightly knit gaming group, it makes perfect sense to split the cost!

I feel the same way about this expansion. It seems pricey but splitting the cost between a few friends makes it completely worth it. It is very fun and well thought out. We have tried house rules many a time and the games never went anywhere near as smoothly as using this rule set.
 
I just played my first game of this over this past weekend. I have to say I haven't had this much fun playing warhammer in a loonngggg time!!! Completely takes the competitive nature out of the game and is just pure fun! Love this supplement! As everyone else has already stated the cost is on the high end but it is something to go in on if you have a regular gaming group. Worth every penny IMO.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu