two simple questions

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Apr 25, 2013
6
Zombies
14
cheers!

i've played my first game since 4th edition 2 weeks ago and i got two simple questions for which i couldn't find any answers so far. maybe silly ones.. :zombie:

1.) unit size. our army book on page84 tells us it's 'the smallest number of models needed to form that unit' - does that include any chars inside that unit, eg is a unit with 19 zombies and a necromancer legal?

2.) the rulebook tells nothing (as far as i see) about handling information during a battle. in my first fight against woc we told each other before beginning which magic items each char carried etc, which left no surprises but felt a bit lousy too. i remember that we used in 4th to reveal this infos when the chars where encountered in battle, not before. is there any 'official' guideline how this is done?
 
Characters and units are purchased separately, minimum unit size must be observed when purchasing models for a particular unit,unit upgrades such as command count as models ofcourse.
All you usually have to tell your opponent are your models basic rules..any upgrades or items purchased are revealed as they are made use of in game.
Players usually show lists afterwards though.
Some comps are open list and you must give your opponent a copy of your list.
 
Count Lasombra is correct on both points.

To expand upon the second, you are not required to reveal magic items before play.

Magic items, weapons, banners and so on are all considered hidden until used, or until some other thing reveals them. There are spells and magic items which force the enemy to reveal some or all of his items.

You are required to tell your opponent what you are deploying and what mundane weapons and upgrades they have and so on.

E.G. "This is a unit of Skeletons, full command. This is a Level One Necromancer, Lore of Vampires, he knows Invocation of Nehek."

You do not have to reveal what (if any) magic items you have. If your Skeletons have a banner, you don't have to tell the other player if it is magical or not until you use its power (if any).


I have a profound, soul-deep hatred of secrecy and closed lists, but the rules permit you to keep those things to yourself until used in-play.

You also need not reveal any... For want of a better word, 'suprise' models like Night Goblin Fanatics.
 
Count Lasombra and Minty got it right. I would like to add though that in the 8th game system there are no actual guide lines on how much to reveal. The BRB never mentions anything about having secret item or such. The odd thing is that some spells and items from armybooks (even new one like Ogres) have effects that forces the opponent to reveal any hidden thing such as magic items and fanatics. To me it is pretty clear that the GW writers themselves are used to the closed lists of the old days, though they forgot to cover it with actual rules (and IIRC it was the same story in 7th). So it is basically up to the players or tournament organizers to determine if magic items should be hidden, just go for whatever you think is most fun. I like things hidden, as it brings an element of surprise to the game.

In Sweden we use an unofficial FaQ document for many tournament, and in it there are rules to cover what is hidden and what is not. Just follow this link and scroll to "3. Open/Semi-open army lists".
 
Count Lasombra said:
Characters and units are purchased separately, minimum unit size must be observed when purchasing models for a particular unit,unit upgrades such as command count as models ofcourse.

I just want to clarify this sentence, because it seems a little ambiguous to me: He's saying that models upgraded to command still count towards the unit size, rather than being like actual character models which don't count towards the size.

You still are getting only as many as you pay for, you just may choose to "Alter" up to 3 models to their respective roles (Banner, Music, Champ.).

Maybe I am the only one who thought that was a bit confusing :ghost:
 
Tawg said:
Maybe I am the only one who thought that was a bit confusing :ghost:

Well, be assured that with your post now i'm with you on this (or at least similar) level of confusion.. :devil2:

But i think i know what Count Lasombra's point was here - during the process of army building one has to fulfill the requirements for list seperately (which makes total sense): core units - chars - etc. before melting them together.
Afterwards it was somehow clearer too when i read the rules-section where it says that for battle deployment characters are deployed last - setting up a unit of just 19 zombies (no matter the command options) before would habe been obviously illegal.

But thanks again for all your qualified replies - one feels warm and safe as a zombie when you know the brains is stored in a secured place like this..
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu