United Bloodlines...who could they defeat?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Seneschal

Liche
True Blood
May 15, 2008
5,683
Zombies
2,245
So I have been wondering, what if the five major bloodline leaders; Mannfred, Neferata, Ushoran, Melkhior and Abhorash, united all the vampires of The Olde World?
Who could they best? I want to look at proposed battles and campaigns as one time only events (unless you feel that after eliminating one race, and another and another, that they could actually conquer the entire world), not a long term one where other races would ally to fight the undead once they saw the devastation they caused. Hopefully that wasn't too confusing.

For example, would their might be enough to wipe out all the dark elves? Would they be strong enough to eliminate The Empire once and for all? And the million dollar (I should probably say "yen" at this point) question; could the vampires destroy the warriors of chaos living in the northern wastes?

I feel that a united vampire army could defeat any one race with the possible exception of daemons.
The Empire would need Sigmar to save them and that wouldn't be happening anytime soon so I think the vamps would prevail there, especially since von Carstein forces alone had almost beaten them before.
The High Elves would need Teclis and several other archmages of incredible power to win so its not a guaranteed victory for the undead but if the Lahmians were able to work their way into High Elf society first and find a way to sneak the Necrachs into hidden locations where they could counter the Asur's magic, I think the vampires would prove victorious.

I am looking at in pure "fluff" terms, no game mechanics or statlines as we all know how inconsistent those things are.
 
A brief aside, Zacharias the Everliving tabled Melkhior at their last meeting.

I think they'd have it rough if all the Tomb Kings got their crap together long enough to put up a fight there. So, if it were (all of) Khemri vs VC, I think the Liches have it.
 
Do the other 'races' get to unify to fight us? That is, would we be fighting a unified Empire, or each Count and Province?

The reason I ask is because there's not a damned thing in creation that could stop them if all the Greenskins came together and fought on the same side.

I agree with Adam that a unified Khemri would beat a unified Vampire alliance. Vampires rely on harvesting the dead to refresh their armies after each battle. fighting the Tomb Kings, you can't do that. Khemri can replace its losses in that war and we cannot.

Same deal with Daemons - plus there are an infinite number of them. The only way to defeat Daemons is to kill every living thing (it's been tried).
 
Minty said:
I agree with Adam that a unified Khemri would beat a unified Vampire alliance. Vampires rely on harvesting the dead to refresh their armies after each battle. fighting the Tomb Kings, you can't do that. Khemri can replace its losses in that war and we cannot.

But wouldn't the Vampires be able to steal the Tomb King soldiers, at least the mindless ones? And they wouldn't give them time to build more Sphinxes. Also the Vampires could just go back to a land of the living and get more bodies. Where would Tomb Kings get reinforcements from?

And, isn't Vlad the leader of the von Carsteins?

Finally, wouldn't the elves detect the Necromancy around the Lahmians, and how does something looking like a 4,000 year old corpse hide in Ulthuan, the land of glory and beauty?
 
@Vashra The Cult of Excess alludes the high elves all the time so if chaos can elude the inquisitors, I can imagine ancient vamps would have a way to do it as well.

@Minty Yes, each race's members would be unified under one banner.

@Adam Zach beat Melkior? Do you know where I can find that story?
 
I believe that all Vampire Bloodlines would be able to take down Tomb Kings. Mainly due to the fact that it would be very hard to control a fight against thousands of Vampires. Its not just one Vampire Lord throwing units into a fight. You would have many Blood Dragons and Strigoi doing the fighting, Carsteins and Lahmians doing the leading and the Necrarches staying toe to toe with all of the Liches. It would be a good fight but I think the presence of so many Vampires would turn the tables.

As for that, the Armies I think we could table if completely united: Tomb Kings, Wood Elves, Beastmen, Brettonia, Ogres.

Could go either way (would be a very hard battle): Completely united Skaven, Dwarfs, Warriors, Dark Elves, Empire.

Armies that would most likely defeat us: Completely united Daemons, High Elves, Lizardmen, Orcs.

Instead of typing my reasoning in about 7-9 paragraphs just ask why I think it if you see one that you disagree with. I'm in class and it ends in 6 minutes :thumbsup:
 
Seneschal said:
@Adam Zach beat Melkior? Do you know where I can find that story?

This is also found in our current army book, although just a tiny blurb about it. It's on page 23 in the the lineage of blood, last column. 2506-2518.
 
Ushoran is also dead. There is no "leader" for the strigoi. Interesting stuff though I look forward to the discussions
 
Abhorash. said:
As for that, the Armies I think we could table if completely united: Tomb Kings, Wood Elves, Beastmen, Brettonia, Ogres.

Could go either way (would be a very hard battle): Completely united Skaven, Dwarfs, Warriors, Dark Elves, Empire.

Armies that would most likely defeat us: Completely united Daemons, High Elves, Lizardmen, Orcs.

Instead of typing my reasoning in about 7-9 paragraphs just ask why I think it if you see one that you disagree with. I'm in class and it ends in 6 minutes :thumbsup:

I am curios as to your reasoning on the Dwarves. Given there state of perpetual warfare against the Orcs and Goblins, and Skaven, I would think that they would be unable to meet the Vampire threat without completly abandoning there fight against those old enemies. So they would end up being overrun. First by the undead hordes, then by the hordes of orcs and skaven as the dwarves abondoned defensive positions to meet the vampire threat. Caught between all those forces, I dont think Dwarves would have a real chance. Not to mention that they are so spread out aomgnst there mountain strongholds that they may not have a chance to unite against us at all. We would be fighting them piecmeal.

However, I think the Tomb Kings would be one of those armies where it relly could go either way. Nagash himself was unable to subdue and conquer the United forces of the Tomb Kings. WOuld a united Vampire Force fare better? Tough to tell.
 
@crafty0ne - I was thinking about it under the assumption that all Dwarf Strongholds would unit to face all the Vampire Legions. If you take into account other armies interfering than yea Dwarfs would be fighting a very somber battle against us, Orcs, and Skaven. However I still stand by all of the Dwarf legions teamed up they would put up a very tough fight against us.

If we take into account armies going 1v1 while having to defend against rivals than High Elves would have to deal with us and the legions of the Dark Elves, Empire would have to deal with us and Warriors of Chaos, Orcs, and Daemons etc.

I think for the sake of this thread its more about comparing army power levels in fluff completely united, not which armies would crumble first against all of their rivals.
 
Abhorash. said:
@crafty0ne - I was thinking about it under the assumption that all Dwarf Strongholds would unit to face all the Vampire Legions. If you take into account other armies interfering than yea Dwarfs would be fighting a very somber battle against us, Orcs, and Skaven. However I still stand by all of the Dwarf legions teamed up they would put up a very tough fight against us.

Ahh, I see your point. Throwing out the other variables for comparison sake, Then yes I think a completly united dwarf force would be a tough match up.

I think for the sake of this thread its more about comparing army power levels in fluff completely united, not which armies would crumble first against all of their rivals.

This also raises another interesting question though. Given the threat of a completely united vampire force, what other races would realistically have the ability, will, or capacity to unite against the threat? Could orcs and goblins set aside there squabling and infighting? Could dwarves abandon there centuries long fights with orcs and skaven to meet us head on? I'd say doubtful in both cases. Lizardmen might have the greatest ability to unite and combat us and could ultimately prove to be our greatest adversary.
 
craftyOne, the idea behind this thread assumes that each race is united under one leader so no squabbling would occur. Disregard old grudges between orc clans and similar problems.
 
This is how I see it:

Daemons-literally infinite, until no more lving races to worship them, so would win unless the mortals all died.
Orcs: Reproduce through injury, hordes to begin with, flip side giving endless resurrection potential, and blood (assuming Orc blood is okay), so close
Dwarfs: Strong, tough, blood that knocks Vampires out for a few hours. Limited numbers if spit, however. Close.
Empire: Beaten except for plot armour last few times. Probably be beaten.
Asur: Dying race VS endless horde. Do the math.
Druchii: Stronger, more vicious Asur. Still possible easy fight.
Asrai: Limited numbers, trees go to slep in winter. Walkover in winter (arrow storm doesn't work when there's no blood to bleed in the rankers), close in summer.
LIzardmen: Power of Old Ones. Tight battle.
Warriors: Close combat elite VS close combat horde. Probably lose.
Bretonia: Knights charge would be absorbed by hordes, give extra Black Knights. WIzards could use Blessings of the Lady for interesting tricks. Easy win? Maybe.
Tomb Kings: Beat us last two times. no way of replenishing complete casualties though. Long term campaign of attrition required for victory.
 
Your faith in the Asur is disturbing. All the legions of Ulthuan united under the command of Tyrion and Teclis... Just can't see vamps winning this one. And Dark Elves are equal and possibly weaker than High Elves. I think we could take Dark Elves but a completely united Ulthuan would be hard to topple.
 
Skaven or greenskins are pretty much undefeatable. Assuming now that the entire races are unifying. Only daemons outnumber them. Seriously, there are so many rats down there.
 
As I read about greenskins and skaven, they are always said to be able to wipe out remaining races in a straight combat, but they are too busy offing themselves in minor and major squabbles. The underempire spans under whole world and the greenskins are also spanning large territories.
Demons would be similiarly problematic, but as far as i remember, they need a magic source from the chaos gates - near the pole they would smash everything - somewhere else it would easier...

Also I agree with Abhorash - HE might be a dying race, but seeing how they are portrayed as the best-of-everything and having the best heroes I don't see them beaten easily ;)

As for the topic - I think that vampires would fare well in a prolonged combat - the more losses are there, the more troops are there to use, the trick would be to actually manage to prolong the combat enough for that to happen. And not having your necromancers and gereals offed by assassins and scouts ;)

And as a side note - isn't orcs breeding by releasing spores through injury only a WH40K thing?
 
now i have a question is this going to be a straight 1 on 1 or are we going to think vampires have some vampires who have personally studied war and not just personal combat for a few centries i think that is part of a decider against the ones we will have trouble or lose against
 
There are not many if any who would be able to defeat the vampires in such a case.

Lahmians have their claws so deep in the Empire that they could tear it down alone already or at least cause considerably damage. It would of course take a small bit of time but the VC's would likely take over the Empire first, slaughter everyone, make their armies bigger and just continue on like that. Divide and conquer, followed by a fully overwhelming zerg of the dead that are backed up by incredibly powerful bloodsuckers.

But of course it would never happen as we know. Lahmians have no interest in taking over the world in such a manner not to mention they are backstabby as all hell, Blood Dragons are too focused on their little quest and personal glory most of the time, Strigoi are too insane, Necrach are too much loners and Carstain are too ambitious.
 
Shareya, what I proposed was a scenario where all the bloodlines came together with the purpose of pwning all the other races so personal agendas would be out of the way.
 
Why my first sentence stated that there was not much out there that could stop them.
 
The Vampires would have to be careful about how many of the Empire and Bretonnia they slaughter.

Chaos-touched blood is sickening to the Vampires, as well as some other nasty effects of drinking other races blood. Pretty much has to be human. If they are all dead to fuel the Undead hordes of their Rainbow Coalition of Bloodsuckers, then the VC are going to starve.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu