WHFB - 7th Unlimited Raising of Models

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Skorne

Wight King
Jul 11, 2008
466
Zombies
165
Maybe not a rules question per se, but do you allow this in your games?

I played a game at the local GW recently where my opponent was another VC player. We played a 1000 point game and his rather unimaginative list consisted of :

3 vampires with dark acolyte and lord of the dead
3 units of skeletons.

In the course of the game it came upon a situation where he was using dice to represent skeletons. He would put a dice with the 5 showing behind his unit to represent another rank, so that long after he had run out of models, he had 3 or 4 dice behind a unit to represent 15 or 20 extra skeletons.

Is this allowed in the rules? I suppose it is since people have used things such as lemons as a proxy for a bloodthirster and a cellphone for a stegadon. This would seem to allow for unlimited raising of troops (The guy had 20-30 dice, which I thought was odd). This was only my 5th game and I had not encountered this before. I did win by killing his general, but had the game gone on to 7 turns he would have won, with 1 40ish unit of skeletons left and a vampire.

Your thoughts? Is this common? I personally had thought that if you raised troops that you did not have models for, you lost those extra troops.
 
Personally I wouldn't have allowed it, you normally proxy either because of an army theme, i.e , these spider models represent dire wolves because spiders fit my theme better, that would be fine.

I don't know who you play with but I definatley would not accept a lemon as BT or a mobile phone.

So summary - if a person wants to raise troops, he should have the models to represent them.
 
There are some items in the Chaos AB that turns models into spawns... The rules say: "If you do not have a spare chaos spawn model the model is slain..." I think you should use the same kind of rules here (if you don't have skellies, you can't raise more...).
 
The Dark Sheep said:
There are some items in the Chaos AB that turns models into spawns... The rules say: "If you do not have a spare chaos spawn model the model is slain..." I think you should use the same kind of rules here (if you don't have skellies, you can't raise more...).

And in a tournament I am sure that is exactly how it would be played. However, in friendly games where people are just getting started or are trying out new lists I think it's a question of etiquette. If it is truly that important to stick to all the rules as close as possible, then by all means. I usually err on the side of courtesy for friendly games as I still get the benefit of learning how to deal with new or different situations as they come up. Now, since he knew he'd be raising potentially more models than he had, he should have told you that ahead of time and made sure you were cool with it, as most things related to models not being "wysiwyg".

I guess that since I get to play less than I would want too I am more forgiving of things that allow me to get games in when I can. If that meant playing somebody's list that was mostly proxy, so long as the sizes of things were accurate and it was easy to understand what was going on, I'd be fine with it.
 
I think it's really important to be a generous gamer, but I reckon that use of dice in place of models rather destroys the point of playing in the first place. The models are a vital part of the hobby. And IoN and Raise Dead are hugely open to abuse if we don't insist on use of models.
 
I agree with it being an issue of etiquette. In tournament play, no. In a friendly game, maybe. Depends how much I like the person. If its a poor 12 year old, I'd be fine with, but if its someone who has other models, but made his army into a summoning horde, I would not be ok. I'd ask why he didn't build his army around the models he had.

The models are a huge part of the experience for me. You could play with just bases, or pieces of paper representing your models, on a flat surface with terrain marked with markers. But that is not the game I want to play.
 
Absolutely. I just can't see the point in pieces of paper. For me, a large part of the fun lies in the models - I love looking at a battlefield, especially from a "model's eye" viewpoint.
 
You need models in order to raise them, which is one reason a lot of Vampire players make loads of skeletons/zombies out of "spare parts" such as a head and one arm and tombstones.

As for dice, depending on the situation I will use dice to represent models in the rear ranks for one simple purpose: Time Saving. If we are low on time and I raise 10, 15, 30 zombies to a unit I don't want to put each model on my tray when they are gunna get rapped later in the game.

I will start putting the models on the tray while my opponent starts his turn if necessary, however. And do not raise more skeletons/zombies than I have models for. This is why I now have 4 goblins and two 40mm bases and 3 dwarves to represent my spirit hosts if I get wind of undeath off again :D

As for "Lemons" and "Cell Phones" counting as...no, just no. Worst case is the proper base and something on it to represent the model to me. Unassembled is OK as long as you work towards building it as I know how hard it can be to put together metal models (I don't even want to assemble the treeman I bought, holy hell I hate how this model goes together).
 
Interesting points. The person I played had a full 2k vc army, with bk and such, just did not have enough skeletons for his master plan of raising a horde I suppose. It was the first time playing him, and being new to the shop I was eager to find opponents. I prefer the notion of only raising what you have models for, any model on a small base would have been fine with me.
I had first turn, and since i only had 20 skeleton models (still building my 1k force) i did not raise any, using my dice for other spells. Then his turn came, and there was 12 'counts as skeletons' dice in his ranks. I walked away with a victory but it just seemed to be lacking something.
Do all VC vs. VC games usually end up in one big combat in the middle of the table? That was what the people in the shop were saying, and that undead vs. undead in general is not a good match up.

Anyways, thanks for your input. I will be going back with a new opinion on proxies, and what I will and will not accept in general (Somehow, out of his 3 vampires, all 3 of them had danse, with no forbidden lore or book.. he claims he rolled them but I never saw it).
 
Having 3 vamps roll Van Hel's sounds pretty iffy to me. Even with 3 lvl 2 vamps your odds are only 1 in 125 (unless my math is completely out) of pulling that off.

I would watch them pretty closely if I was to play them a second time.
 
Ultimately, we play games which rely upon trust - for me it's rare to know my opponent's army inside out, so I have to believe him (or her) if he tells me that something is true. But also, questioning every move or spell or whatever sucks all the fun out of playing. That said, if someone cheats then I don't play them again. Getting 3 vampires with Danse seems unlikely, but it is possible - gaming etiquette, though, demands that you roll your spells in full view of the other player. If someone doesn't do that, I'd be very suspicious. I'd be wary of playing that opponent again, Skorne.
 
This game is way too expencive as it is for me to stop my opponent from raising model beyond what he's got. Same goes for spawns and horrors etc.

As for claiming he got so many vanhels "in secret", no, I would never let that fly. Dice rolls have to be 100% in the open. All the time.

Danceman.
 
I agree with Danceman. In order to have what one needs to play an army that raises hordes of models mid game (models of types you may or may not have) is much to time and resource consuming. We can never be prepared for the irrisistable 'Summon Undead Horde' that raises 25 Zombies past the 65 we already have scattered about the board. Or a chaos player that rolls too many sixes on 'Gift of Chaos.' While I believe we should endvour to have extra models for raising, even if we don't plan to use them, I don't think people should be forced to have a model for every single raise!
And if your opponent gets too anal about it, get BfSP Goblins.
 
I must admit I don't like the idea of dice as raised models but I have no problem with it if there are sufficient mitigating circumstances. Still I am guilty of having done it when I started out or on occasions where I was feeling ridiculously lazy!
 
I think the game should be played with the models. If you don't have the right models or a halfway suitable proxy, then you shouldn't be able to raise them. To be honest, if you're raising that many troops in the first place, it's probably because you're a cheesemonger who's brought 3 level 2 Vamps to a 1000 point game or Morghur and a spawn factory, in which case you really do deserve no sympathy. I don't have a vast amount of spare models, and if I run out then I'm just happy to have raised so many in the first place!

After all, if you're proxying dice and skeletons when raising them, why not just go the whole hog? It's an expensive hobby, so why not just use square bits of card to begin with...

As for rolling VHD in secret, three times: bullsheeeit! What a shocker, the guy who brings the lame one-trick pony is also a cheater. Reminds me of a guy from a local GW whose VC army consists of Mannfred von Carstein (As played by a Dragon Prince), a few Ghoul models, then every model on a 20mm base he has, Bretonnian horses as Black Knights and empty 40mm bases as Fell Bats and raised Spirit Hosts. Exactly the kind of guy who should be representing VC players, eh?
 
Proxying models against friends, if you've asked their permission before the game is one thing (or if you know they won't mind). This is common if you want to test out new builds, units or even armies, and I wouldn't care in that circumstance.

Just using dice to represent models in normal games (without asking)... not so much. It is a miniatures game, troops are represented by miniatures. There is no difference between using dice to represent raised units and using empty bases to represent starting troops.
 
Just get somekind of models. Now I use a very ghoulbased army (still have 10 to assemble!) and usually run out of ghouls models when I raise (4-5 dice in a 1k game). But still I have tons of other undead models to represent them until I get the proper models, skellies and zombies mostly. That I think is ok in friendly games, but in tourny play I agree with all the others. But dices, cellphones etc - No. In that case I would say "take what you got and we´ll play a game of that size" :).
 
I would say that if you don't have the models for it, then you are playing the wrong army :mrgreen:
 
I played a couple of magic-heavy armies recently for a change, ran out of Zombie models, but my opponent proxied half his army so had no problem with my using Skeletons as Zombies. As all my actual Skeletons had been blown away by his RBT, there was no issue of confusion ;)
 
I had a question that's somewhat related to this:

Is there a limit to how many models you can raise in a certain unit? I'm thinking specifically about Fell Bats, with a unit size of 3-10. Is 10 a hard limit, or is it just a limit on the starting size?
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu