Vampire General with Lore of Heavens?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Smogg

Grave Guard
Jan 27, 2012
260
Zombies
206
So I was thinking about the FAQ dealing with the Wizards Hat. A way to have a general with another Lore than Lore of Vampires.

Then I recalled people having dismissed the idea of using Forbidden Lore to do the same trick, because it reads "The Vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook except Lore of Life". Since it reads "Can" then your general would still be able to choose Lore of Vampires, and so he would be forced to do so.

Now taking a look at the Wizards Hat. That also reads "can":
"...being a Level 2 Wizard who can use a randomly chosen spell lore."
But wait, that's not optional even though it reads "can".

So it would seem that when the Wizards Hat or the Forbidden Lore impose a rule where the wizard "Can use this or that", then that replaces their normal ability to choose between Lore of Vampires, Shadow or death.

Basically, if we read the meaning of the word "can" the same way in Forbidden Lore, as it's ruled in Wizards Hat, then yes, you could have a vampire general. Give him forbidden lore. Now he no longer is able to choose lore of vampires, so you can pick any of the standard lores except lore of life.
 
No 'can' implies that he has the option to, so it just is added to his list of lores he is able to use, if anything this FAQ shows that Wizard Hat can be controlled.
 
yeah but then if I give my Vampire Lord a wizards hat, according to that logic, then he has the option to choose a random lore instead of Lore of Vampires.

But that is not consistent with the FAQ:
Q: If a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to choose the Lore of the
Vampires as their spell lore (due to the Wizarding Hat for example)
but is still the Wizard with the highest Leadership in the army, must
he still be the army’s General? (p26)
A: Yes.

According to the FAQ, the wizards hat does not let him choose either a randomly chosen lore OR Lore of vampires. The FAQ uses the wizards hat as an example where is is unable to choose lore of vampires even though the item say. "can choose a randomly chosen spell lore"

Following the same logic Forbidden lore will not allow him to choose either one of the 7 warhammer lores OR Lore of vampires.


In short: You would think "can" implies that he has the option to but when reading Wizards Hat and the FAQ, "Can" does in fact imply that his new options replace his initial option of choice.
 
That point does make sense, however I'd like to think that if GW meant for us to have a different Lore in our generals via Forbidden Lore, that would be the example they'd use in the FAQ.

However, not addressing this exact topic in the FAQ by saying "Forbiden Lore is useless in your General since..." is just as confusing.
 
The weird thing is that the FaQ slightly contradicts the book. I don't have the book in front of me but I'm pretty sure is say something like this:
If he can choose a spell lore, then he must use the Lore of Vampires.

So no matter what lore options he has he must use the Lore of Vampire if he can choose which lore he has. The wizarding hat doesn’t let you choose a lore and thus you may use any lore it randomly selects for you, and you can still be the general.

But then tha FaQ comes in and fucks it all up. It says that "if a Vampire or Vampire Lord is unable to choose the Lore of the
Vampires as their spell lore...". This means it is now important if he can actually choose the Lore of Vampire, which is it wasn't before. So now the entire question lies within the Forbidden Lore. Dose it replace or add to the vampire lore selection? I honestly don't know what do believe, but I like Smogg's reasoning.
 
Nah. I think the difference is that the Wizarding Hat only lets you choose a BRB lore. Forbidden Lore just opens up more choices.
 
Right, the wizard hat lets you roll for a random lore from the BrB. Forbidden lore lets you choose which lore you want from the BrB.
 
With the wizards hat you can choose a randomly chosen spell lore

With Forbidden Lore you can generate spells from any one of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook except Lore of Life

Now please explain to me why Lore of Vampires should be possible with Forbidden Lore but not with Wizards Hat.
 
Because Forbidden Lore does not negate choosing Lore of Vampires, the lore already open to you.

Forbidden Lore: "The Vampire can generate his spells from any one of the lores in the Warhammer rulebook, except the Lore of Life."

Wizarding Hat: "The wearer is treated as being a Level 2 Wizard who can use a randomly chosen spell lore."

Wizarding Hat forces you to roll randomly. Forbidden Lore lets you choose. And, as a Vamp General, if you can choose, you MUST choose Lore of Vampires.
 
But the word can is featured both places so while wearing the wizarding hat you're not forced to choose the lores in the brb, you can opt to choose what ever lore available to you or roll randomly for a lore from the brb..

The wording is the same but I still wont play it so that forbidden lore gives us the possebility to use any lore.. Although I would love having a level 4 casting Metal against my WoC opponents :)

The FAQ is confusing at best, but if they wanted us to use forbidden lore on our generals they would've used that as example as demian said too!
 
Bullhax said:
But the word can is featured both places so while wearing the wizarding hat you're not forced to choose the lores in the brb, you can opt to choose what ever lore available to you or roll randomly for a lore from the brb..

Would you really go with this as an argument? Really? So your going to pay 100 points (YOUR ENTIRE POINT ALLOWANCE) for an item that you say "Well I may use it or may not use it, but it gives me an option to roll for a random lore....should I want to."

Sorry. To me that makes absolutely 0 sense...:slapface:

The item makes you a L2 wizard with a random lore from the BrB. That's it. Sorry I don't mean to be rude or anything but it really gets my goat when some people take apart GW writing on an item, which we all know is terrible sometimes,and try and make an item into something that it isn't, or could be, or might be. When using a little common sense and the item works just fine.
 
Of course wizard's hat force you to choose a random spell lore from the BRB. This is spelled out in the FAQ.

My point is just that Forbidden Lore use the same wording as the Wizards hat, thus I would think Forbidden Lore also force you to choose from one of the 7 lores in the BRB.

Second, since the FAQ mention the wizards hat as an example, I would think more cases apply. The only other possible case is Forbidden Lore. True GW could have used forbidden lore as an example instead, but then people would wonder why they did not mention the wizards hat. Forbidden Lore in my opinion should also be seen in the light that GW prolly did not intend it to be next to useless, but rather to scale it down compared to the previous edition where you got loremaster.

Now the wizards hat has been up before the FAQ in quite a few discussions. It was speculated that if you could bypass your mandatory lore of vampires by getting wizards hat, then you could buy Forbidden Lore on top of this and override the random lore by the selection of the 7 lores of magic. Since you as the owner gets to choose. Now the counter argument back then was that you could not buy the wizards hat for your general since you had to make him capable of picking lore of vampires. With the FAQ out, this turned out to be wrong. You can indeed buy wizards hat. So just another funny side point is that it seems you can get wizards hat, forbidden lore and then have a lvl 2 vampire with a lore of your choice that is then stupid. At for "only" 125 points extra. An even more theoretical discussion of course, as it would put you on a serious disadvantage right off the bat. But hey, it's nice to be amongst friendly dark souls that wont flame you for putting out some weird readings.

For my personal experience I have never considered alternative lores for my Vampire Lord as more than a distant dream to chock a friend one in a while. Lore of Vampires is simply too good in my opinion, and having your general know IoN and usually being in the center of everything makes a huge difference in my battles.
 
midean said:
Bullhax said:
But the word can is featured both places so while wearing the wizarding hat you're not forced to choose the lores in the brb, you can opt to choose what ever lore available to you or roll randomly for a lore from the brb..

Would you really go with this as an argument? Really? So your going to pay 100 points (YOUR ENTIRE POINT ALLOWANCE) for an item that you say "Well I may use it or may not use it, but it gives me an option to roll for a random lore....should I want to."

Sorry. To me that makes absolutely 0 sense...:slapface:

The item makes you a L2 wizard with a random lore from the BrB. That's it. Sorry I don't mean to be rude or anything but it really gets my goat when some people take apart GW writing on an item, which we all know is terrible sometimes,and try and make an item into something that it isn't, or could be, or might be. When using a little common sense and the item works just fine.

Yes I would use that as an argument rather than that the item is expensive thus it MUST at least be somewhat beneficial, who in their right mind would ever buy the wizarding hat on a character who is a wizard already.. My point was simply that the wording is the SAME, why shouldn't they then do the same.. The VC general is a special situation and before the FAQ, with the way that the Wizarding Hats text is written I wouldn't allow him to use another lore than the vamp. one, the can wasn't strong enough on it's own to me at least to equal "has to" or "is forced to", can is very often used as may, that is how I've read the word for the Forbidden Lore too and my reason for not being allowed to used it to get another lore than vamp. on my general.

I'm mostly playing devils advocate here since I sincerly don't think GW wants us to use forbidden lore that way.

The item is clearly not made with Vampire lords in mind as the primary buyer, but makes perfect sense (still wouldn't buy it) when given to a Lord that doesn't have a wizard level.

I'm sorry I got your goat ;) but this is a thread about this very specific wording, GW has a poor trackrecord of horrible writing and IMO this part of the FAQ should've been left out. I did just apply my common sense (pre FAQ that is) and made it so that the hat couldn't be used to change my generals lore.. To me this isn't really that outrageous since the wording is the same.. All this is to me is a stupid FAQ.. Life goes on and I wont play the game any differently before they FAQ it to be for forbidden lore too.
 
The difference is the wizarding hat does not open up new lores. It makes you a wizard who chooses lores randomly from the book. This overrides everything. Essentially you turn yourself into a lvl2 empire wizard. The use of can is say you are allowed now to do something in conjunction with the rest of the sentence. ie. here is some cake you can now eat cake. So before you didn't have any now you have some oh and btw that's what you can do with it. The vampire special rule you can buy gives to the ability to eat that cake and that other cake but you already have some cake to eat. You have to eat what's on your plate first which is the lore of vamps.

Essentially the wizarding hat makes you someone who is a wizard that chooses those lores. The magic item taking precedence rule you have to use it. Same as magic weapons if you buy a magic sword and a great weapon would you argue you can choose to use the greatweapon?. You don't therefore have the option of not using it. It tells you what you can do now you have chosen it.

Damn deconstruction of sentences. People need to stop fixating on certain words. English as a language has many nuances and the same word when combined with a different bunch can mean something slightly different. Can has more than one meaning.

All you need to do is read the start of the magic items section In the rulebook. Oh look I have to use it if I bought it. Oh no I only have the option of core spell lores ergo I can't be general.
Vampire special rule oh look I get more options. Damnit I still have lore of vamps as part of that option. I'll have to be general then.

Simple I now need cake after that rant

*runs off to find cake*
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu