Vamps Vs Lizards 2000pnts

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Strahd

Black Knight
Aug 29, 2008
316
Zombies
191
Well I was looking to get a game in with my new uber 2250 unbeatable vampire army of doom for adepticon when my friend called me and told me that the point limit for the tourny was 2000 this year :mad2: So after trimming the fat off the list I called my friend Matt up and we scheduled a game against his Lizards. My list consisted of:

Vamp Lord w/ MotBA, LoD, forbidden lore, cadaverous curiass, crown of the damned, sword of might, cursed book and black periapt

vamp BSB dark acolyte, LoD, Drakkenhoff banner

Mannfred the Acolyte skull staff

10 skeleys FC

10 skeleys FC

20 zombies

2 CC w/balefire

19 GG FC Banner of Hellfire

5 wraiths

I didnt get a copy of Matts list but from memory:

Slann BSB

Scar vet on CO w/flaming sword thing, and maiming shield

Scar vet on CO w/parana blade

Skink priest on steg w/EotG

10 Saurus w/spears standard musician

20 skinks w/krox

20 skinks w,krox

10 TG musician standard

5 saurus CO riders

2x salamander packs

I rolled for spells and got raise dead and wind of undeath for BSB and chose lore of metal for my lord. He took lore of light for slann and got portent of far for skink. Set up for him.... He had a hill center of his deployment zone where he place his TG with slann and flanked them with his saurus spearmen, also on the hill. On his other flank he had steg with a single salamander in front of it with the other saly on the spearmens flank. He then placed his skink units one on either side of his farthest flanks one of which had his scar vet with parana blade in it. His saurus cav was next to his Steg. I deployed a little shy of my deployment zone GG central flanked by CC and the CC were flanked by skeley units. The skelly unit to my right had Manny in it and the other 2 vamps went in GG. Zombies were on my far left flank and Wraiths sat behind a hill flanking my right unit of skeleys within 6" of manny. We rolled for first turn and he won the roll off and opted to go first.

Turn 1 He rolled stupid for his scar vet in the skink unit so they stumbled forward, and his only other movement was to move his salys up. No magic due to me being out of range and no shooting.

My turn I Move everything up max and wraiths hid in a woods in front of the hill. Magic starts off with BSB fluffing 2 attemtps at Invo needing only 3's I roll 2 2's. Manny casts Gaze at the salys but it is dispelled. Lord attempts to cast rule of burning iron on Scar vet but dispelled. He gets some invo's off raising 5 skeletons in mannys unit and casts SotF but it gets scrolled.

Turn 2 The skinks with Scar vet move up, everything else stays put. Magic the only spell slann gets off is burning gaze on skeleton unit on my left and he crisps 4. Skink priests casts portent on saly. Saly flames my depleated skeley unit and brings it down to 1 model!!

My turn 2 Manny joins GG unit and everything else moves up, wraiths move a little further in the woods but still out of sight. Magic Manny Gazes the saly on my right, wounds it and kills a skink. BSB again fails both his invo attemps :rolleyes: Manny casts Vanhels on GG to bring them in line with the rest of my units and the lord boosts depleted skeley unit 13 more models. CC get miasmas off.

Turn 3 The salamander on my left charges zombie unit while the skink/krox unit charges my left side skeley unit. The other salamander charges my skeley unit to my right. Magic he Burning gazes my CC for no wounds and miscasts on Dazzling brightness ending magic phase and dispelling my miasmas :mad2: Combat, saly crew do 5 wounds to zombies but im within 12" of bsb so no extra wounds, saly number 2 kills 1 skeley and I kill 2 skinks, they break and I pursue. Now his salamander is blocking his CO riders so I dont have to worry about a flank charge on my gg :mrgreen:
Skink/Krox unit dust 3 skeletons and I lose 3 more from combat rez.

In my turn the GG charge his TG and my CC move up trying to keep as many units within 6" as I can. Wraiths are kinda stuck because he has his scar vet sitting outside the wood waiting for them to poke there heads out so they remain in woods. Magic phase my trusty BSB again fails both invo attemtps :'( Lord boosts skeley unit fighting the skinks up 2 models, manny casts vanhels but is scrolled, Lord casts lead on the TG. CC get miasmas off. Zombies beat the saly and it runs. My zombies do there 2d6 extra attacks and kill the remaining crew. The running saly fails the monster ld check and rolls a 6 for reaction getting hatred and frenzy. I lose the skely skink battle by 1 but BSB keeps me from losing another skeleton. My super killy GG unit of doom with there 4 str 6, 6 str 5 and 3 str 4 attacks manage to kill a measily 5 TG!!!!

Turn 4 Saurus spears flank my GG and his steg charges my skely unit on my right. The lone saly rallys but the one to my right doesnt and runs off the table. Magic phase starts with Slann miscasting AGAIN ending the magic phase and my always strikes first miasma :wow2: but also does a wound to the slann. Combat skink/krox do some wounds but its another wash. Steg kills some skeletons but I now have him tied up in combat. GG combat I issue a challenge with my champ and his vet accepts. I think this was a bit of a mistake by me because I probably should have issued with my lord. He was immune to KB had a 4 up ward save and cursed book plus regen but im very gun shy about getting him in combat with anything remotely powerful for obviouse reasons but still.... Anyway I was hoping for KB against him but it was not to be and he killed my champ. His saurus kill I think 1 more and I kill some more TG but there is one remaining so he doesnt run again due to stubborn....

My turn My zombie unit flank charges his skink/krox unit that is in combat with my skeletons and I move my wraiths outside of his skink/krox units LOS. CC sit preparing for miasma to go off again. Magic starts and I had quite a lot of things to ponder.... I needed to cast raise to block his saurus cavalry from getting into my gg's other flank and had to invo my skeleton units back up to sustain their combats enough until I killed his slann and had the upper hand in magic. My BSB of course fluffed his rolls for the 4th time so I decided I would try to cast Law of Gold on his scar vet with the magic sword so my wraiths would be safe and I miscast.... to make matters worse I roll the dreaded dbl 1's for my result and my lord is now doing the 2 step with some crazy daemon in another dimension, great...... I think I get an invo off and raise some more skeletons and cc goes off but thats it. Combat starts with the GG. Vet kills 2 gg and I lose another from the saurus, I kill the remaining TG and do a wound on the slann. Skink/Krox lose combat but dont break, and skeleton and steg are a wash. For my crumble test I lose a wraith 2 wounds to a cc a cpl skeletons and half of my remaining zombie unit.

Turn 5 His cavalry wasnt able to charge so he reformed them for a turn 6 charge, he moved his other skink unit with vet to try to pin my wraiths and his frenzy saly moved up to flank my zombies next turn if they were still around.... His magic phase nothing happened and no shooting. Combat skinks/krox kill some more zombies skeletons but again wash, steg and skeletons I lost some more but without my lord these units werent going to stick around much longer.... GG got to strike first his vet issued challenge but I declined so he sent bsb to the back. GG did another wound on slann and killed a cpl saurus and he did some wounds back. I lost but didnt lose anymore gg.

My turn I started my crumble test..... I lost a cc some skeletons in combat with steg were brought to 4 models and I lost some zombies, not to shabby. I moved my wraiths again out of sight of his vet and repositioned my lone cc. Magic I tried to raise what I could which wasnt much and miasma was dispeled... Skink/krox combat I lost my remaining skeletons but I still had a single zombie vainly holding my left flank Lol... My other unit of skeletons got dusted as well. My GG however finally came through..... His vet issued another challenge which again I declined, manny went to the back this time. He fluffed his vets attacks at my GG and in turn I KBed him and my remaining troops and bsb killed his Slann!!!! His saurus broke and I pursued and caught them.

Turn 6 He charged his steg into my CC. His lone salamander charged into my lone zombie due to frenzy. He reformed his CO riders to face my wraiths as my GG was now out of range of them. He again reposition his skinks to face my wraiths.... Magic nothing and no shooting. His steg took out my CC and my zombie dies....

My turn I lose 2 more wraiths crumble but lose no GG. I charge gg into his skink/krox unit and wraiths charge cavalry. Magic I am able to bring back 2 wraiths. Combat I kill 3 saurus CO's and the rest flee... My GG take out the other skink/krox unit and that was that.....

A very bloody game, I had a little over half of my GG left with 2 vamps and 3 wraiths left and he had his steg 1 salamander a scar vet and his skink/krox unit. After tallying up the score I had a minor win. If my lord hadnt died It would have been a massacre I think as he would have been able to keep the units alive until the slann was dead and with magic superiority and vanhels I would have owned after that but it was not to be. A very enjoyable game with a good player. We also got in a 1999 pnt game the following day and he got his revenge trouncing my poor vamps!!!!
Till next time.....
 
Great report! A Vamp win against Lizards, hurrah!

Your magic ability in this game reminds me of my own. Even with tonnes of casting dice, I tend to fluff at least half of my invo rolls.

This game also shows that even against a balanced Lizards list, VC have a tough time.

Coupla questions:
Do you often take Forbidden Lore/Metal?

Regarding the use of Burning Iron/Spirit of the Forge on Lizards, since they have a Scaly Skin save and not an Armour Save, does the Scaly Save count towards the strength of said spells? I'm guessing it wouldn't, since the spell is supposed to work by heating up metal armour. This would make Lore of Metal a lot less effective against Lizards in general (esp. Stegs) methinks.
 
Well it wasn't a struggle really until my lord died but yeah lizards are a tough match up for vamps. To answer your question yes RoI and SotF work on scaly skin, the spells are based off the targets AS whatever it is. I was tempted to take lore of shadow as pit of shades is great against lizards low intiative but I went metal and it still wasn't bad. I am new to the forbidden lore this being my first game with it but I think tacticaly speaking it's invaluable, I don't know why it's taken me this long to use it.
 
Hmm, guess I'm just playing the devil's advocate here, but I think if I played Lizards I would argue that Saurus have a Scaly Skin save which acts like armour, but isn't. If it was meant to be exactly like armour, why doesn't it just say 'Saurus have a 5+ armour save', or 'Scaly skin works just like heavy armour'?. Rule of Iron etc says that it uses armour save to calculate strength, and since Saurus have a mix of Scaly Skin and shields/armour, the strength would be less.

The argument is that Scaly Skin is a special kind of save that happens to work just like regular armour (ie, can be combined with other armour), and just like other special saves (ward, regen) is unaffected by Lore of Metal.

I say again, devil's advocate:tongue:, but if I can argue it like this, there's no reason my Scaly opponent can't, and I'm afraid I'd have to agree with him (it just makes sense imo). Don't get me wrong, I'd love to use Spirit of the Forge on 3+ AS Temple Guard, I just think there's a valid argument here.

I'm hoping it's been FAQ'ed somewhere.
 
The only reason they dont say its like heavy armour is because of saurus characters being able to wear light armour over the top
 
Lol if I had a dollar for everything that didn't make sense in warhammer....you have to read the spell. It specifically states the str of attack vs AS. Doesn't matter how they get the AS or what kind it is they just want the total value of the models AS. My friend argued this at adepticon last year and the judge ruled that a dragons scaly skin was still armour due to it giving the model an AS so the spell worked against it. It doesn't really make sense that undead are affected by poison either but we are....you have to use the rules as written instead of common sense.
 
I thought undead were affected by poison because your oppenent knows they're facing undead and use holy water on their weapons instead? That I can understand, but a spell that heats up metal armour working on a creatures skin? RAW is one thing, but ignoring the fluff written right above the spell describing exactly how it works is really something else. I think this case is beyond just not using common sense, it's downright ridiculous.

I think your friend was right to argue that, and I still think it's a very valid argument. Rules as intended comes into it. Plus Lore of Metal is already ridiculous in my opinion.

Anyway, if that's how they run it at Adepticon, I'll just have to refer my opponent to your post if the question comes up. I'm gonna have fun using Lore of Metal on my friends 3+/2+ save Stegadons/Priest that aren't actually wearing a scrap of armour. He's gonna loooove that :rolleyes:
 
theres many possible things.
Eg the howdah heats up and catches a flame frying the priest and crew
Scales are an insulating layer and could quite easy become blistered
 
You need to hurry up and get a game in Tybalt, I want to see how your new list does against your lizard man arch nemesis..... Also again fluff doesnt pertain to RAW. Look at the burning alignment from EotG. It says burning but its not a flaming attack. You could make a new post for things that dont make sense it WFB and it would be pages and pages long Lol.
 
allabang: If the spell simply heated things up, then yes. However the spell works on metal only. It's from the Lore of Metal for crying out loud! If it just set thing on fire it'd be in the Lore of Fire. I'm gonna stop now before I get carried away, but this has to be the stupidest thing I've come across in WHFB, in terms of how it actually affects the game. BA not being a Flaming attack is relatively minor, but this is game changing.

Amen on the 'things that don't make sense' thread, maybe I'll make one just for fun. Perhaps the rules designers at GW will stumble upon in one day.

I'm trying to organise another game for this weekend. I want to see how my list does too:tongue:
 
The howdah has many metal bits on ;)
If they heat up then the wood will eventually catch fire.
lizardmen addorn themselves with gold and bronze etc, even a ring around the ankle could be enough if it heated to a point where it disabled said warrior.
 
Yeah I agree with Allabangs rational. There is metal all over the lizzy army, plenty enough for spells to make sense.
 
isnt there a spell that makes the targets armor rust to nothing? or did i just make that up? i assume that wouldnt work on lizards.

i think scaly skin does count as an armor save in the lore of metal stength issue, just as it does for armor save modifiers, i think it would be a bit broken to give a whole army immunity from such effects.
 
Good report I enjoyed reading this.

I do not have my Lizzie book with me but I am sure that is says somewhere in there that scaly skin gives BLANK armor save. If you look at the stat line the armor save is there. No matter what you wear it contributes to your stat line of armor save. This is a ridicluous arguement. I have never heard anyone argue this and it does not fly at any tournaments I have ever been to in the States. Scaly skin is an armor save. The fluff of the spell does not matter it is how it works that matters. The same way heavy armor can be defined as any bits/combination of armor that constitues heavy armor. This could easily be bits and pieces of armor to make up heavy or even light armor. Scaly Skin is an armor save get over it. Metal works just fine on them always has.
 
RoBI and SotF don't talk about types of armor that you're wearing, just what save you've got. If an opponent tried that on me they'd be wolf/skelechamp conga'd into oblivion and/or would not get to use their scaly skin armor save at all (which is ridiculous; the LM rulebook says it stacks with other armor). Long story short, the spell doesn't care what kind of armor you're wearing, and if you argue otherwise, go look up the melting point of chitin; it's pretty huge (1500 C+), but i'm sure at some point the proteins would denature.
Cheers,
ED
 
To everyone out there: I know it doesn't care what type of armour it is. I know it 'just works', since after all, the spell says it's based on armour save. I know that 'fluff counts for nothing'. Since when in the history of GW were those things not the case? Geez guys, read back over the bit where I said 'I'm playing the devils advocate here' and lighten up. I don't need to be told to 'get over it' since I was never 'on it' to begin with. I don't even PLAY Lizardmen, for crying out loud.

I'm just saying that's it's incredibly stupid for a spell that works on METAL to work on non-metals. It's a question of fluff and rules revision, but above all it's an opinion. I'm pretty sure 'type' of armour never comes into WHFB at all, but this is one situation where I think it should. (We've already been over the 'not everything has to make sense in WHFB', so no need to mention that again.)

Ether Dude: not sure what your point is about the melting point of chitin. Everything burns/decomposes eventually on increasing temperature, and as said before, it's lore of METAL not lore of Fire, Heating, Burninating etc. Once again I reiterate, LORE OF METAL. I'm pretty sure it being from the Lore of METAL means it only works on METAL things. I think it RoBI and SotF would work somewhat like induction cooktops, in that only ferrous METAL objects will be heated.

Pretty sure the wizards down at the gold community college didn't get around to thinking 'Gee, we better modify out STRICTLY METAL spells to work on heating chitin up to 1500C so it works on Lizardmen whom I've never even seen and in fact I'm pretty sure don't even exist'.

If you think lore of metal can just heat anything up until it burns, no matter the temperature required, doesn't the Lore of Fire become redundant? (speaking in fluff terms, obviously). Why are only mummies and treefolk vulnerable to fire when we can all just bust out our ultimate Lore of METAL and heat that gold filling your general has up to a million degrees?

I don't think it makes sense at all that an army covered in 'bits of metal' will be affected in the same way as an army with head-to-toe armour plating, breast plates, solid metal cannons etc. expecially when the spells in question have a strength based on the armour save (ie. the weight of METAL) on the taget unit.

I'm gonna leave it at that, since I didn't mean to hijack Strahd's thread, and I believe everything has been said and makes sense (although feel free to PM, in fact please do). It's all a matter of interpretation now.

My apologies to Strahd:redface:, and I assure everyone that everything said by me in this post is in good humour:clown:
 
Remember to keep it civil, guys. GW has indeed decided to leave armour saves in a single category which is why the Lore of Metal make no distinction between the sources of armour save, even though it probably should. My favourite case in point when it comes to Warhammer weirdness however is the High Elves' Dragon Armour which will nullify everything that has to do with flaming attacks, even if it is a cannon ball merely wreathed in flame. The iron globe simply disappeares once it makes contact with the armour? Really?

...Cool. :vampire2:

Anyway, thanks for writing up the report, Strahd. It is indeed good to see the Lizardmen getting their scaly butts slapped around. :)
 
tldr version


To sum up this post in one line: "GW makes silly rules sometimes". Who woulda thunk it? ;)
 
Lol, yeah I guess. However, I can one up you.

Most of YOUR posts can be summed up in one emoticon: ';)'

Also, hope everyone had a Merry Christmas!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu