Van hels 8" move

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

eggsPR

Vampire Count
True Blood
Aug 28, 2011
1,136
Dublin
Zombies
878
Scenario.

My hexwraiths are 1" away from the front of an enemy unit.

I vanhels my hexwraiths.

The hexwraiths don't have enough of 8" movement to go through to the backside or flank of the enemy unit.

Could I move them all forward, say 3", then back 3" so they are in the exact position of where they started, yet get the effects of the drive-by?

I guess my rule question is can the van hels march be forward/backward/sideways, so long as it doesn't exceed 8"? I move wherever with vanhels'ed fliers as they can move easily, but I never chose them to reverse direction like I'm trying with the hexwraiths.
 
Don't see why not. Seeing as they are fast cav and can reform as many times as they like, yes, you can ride in and out as long as you can end up 1" away from said enemy unit at the end of your movement.
 
You can even reform to put a hit on a unit then move away. Just treat it as a tiny little movement phase out of sequence. You can move into their unit reform turn and wander out of whichever side you wish. Just remember you only have 8" of movement to do it in.

A
 
This is similar to one scenario I posted in the teachings forum under a Hexwraith discussion I'm trying to start. Nice to see this is possible.

And Happy New Year !
 
The rule specifically states "during the remaining move sub-phase". I read it as that is only possible in that phase only and not during the magic phase, or even in the charge phase. This is what the Soulstrider rule declares.

The Spectral hunter rules also declares specifically that units passed during the Remaining Moves Sub-phase will get hit.
 
Sudor said:
The rule specifically states "during the remaining move sub-phase". I read it as that is only possible in that phase only and not during the magic phase, or even in the charge phase. This is what the Soulstrider rule declares.

The Spectral hunter rules also declares specifically that units passed during the Remaining Moves Sub-phase will get hit.

This is wrong and was FAQ'ed in the latest errata..! It does work in the magic phase with Vanhel's..!

Exact wording:

Q: Do Hexwraiths that move through an enemy unit in the Magic phase due to Vanhel’s Danse Macabre cause hits with their Spectral Hunters rule like they would in the Movement phase? (p47) A: Yes.
 
Yeah but u can can hels them and use the drive by bc the spell states "... Up to 8" in the same way as a normal move made in the Remaining Moves sub-phase."
 
eggspr said:
Yeah but u can can hels them and use the drive by bc the spell states "... Up to 8" in the same way as a normal move made in the Remaining Moves sub-phase."

Well with that sorted out I guess it comes down to how you define the word -through-. Moving in and out the way you suggest is possible for a fast cavalry, but to me that sounds like bending the rules to your own advantage.
I would not allow it.
 
From what I gather its the same way terradons use their drop rocks move. As long as the model can move over (or through in the hexes case) and finish their movement 1" away, you gain the effects of the maneuver.

So a terradon can fly over you, then land right in front if you and drop rocks. Hexes should be able to do the same :)
 
Essentially you measure to where they are in the unit. Then get your opponent to mark and move his unit. Now move out of the way and put the unit back. Or instead of all that pfaffing just declare it measure to see if it's possible and only move what's is needed to get you into the end position. It's perfectly legal so not allowing it is house ruling and getting rid of rules you don't like. Perfectly acceptable if you agree before the game but as its legal you will have to drop one of your armies special rules to compensate for their handicap.

A
 
I dont consider that houseruling something out. The word through, to me, means that the unit enters on one side an exits on another.

Guess we have to agree to disagree on this one.
 
through
[throo] Show IPA
preposition
1.
in at one end, side, or surface and out at the other: to pass through a tunnel; We drove through Denver without stopping. Sun came through the window.

4.
over the surface of, by way of, or within the limits or medium of: to travel through a country; to fly through the air.

I guess like most things in this game there is an interpretative impasse. Above as defined in the points of view is the two definitions above. I guess if you use 4. the move is legal.

If you use 1. then i guess you will have to enter the front and out the flank. This decreases the distance you have to move and meets the literal definition.
 
It's fair enough.

The way I see it you pick your unit up and move it 8" it's starting point is only used for the movement calculation. If you end up in the same place you end up in the same place. So that's move forward 2-3"reform to turn round move 5-6" then reform again. Fast cav gives you unlimited reforms the fact you are now in exactly the same position is immaterial. Ideally as I said mark out their unit do your move calculating what you have moved over then put their unit back. Yes it is cheesy and a little WAAC but if I was in a tournie I'd do it.

A
 
Interesting discussion of what "move through" means.

I'll just like to mention that if "move through" is limited to entering on one end and exiting on the other, it would result in a whole range of new freedom for charges and moves in general.

Imagine my block of 40 zombies wheeling through the front of a unit swordsmen during a charge, not actually "moving through" them as they did not exit on the other side of the unit!

No, I guess I just wanted to point out that when it comes to movement in general I think everyone has a good understanding of what moving through means. Then just take that meaning and apply it to hexwraiths as well.
 
Smogg said:
Interesting discussion of what "move through" means.

I'll just like to mention that if "move through" is limited to entering on one end and exiting on the other, it would result in a whole range of new freedom for charges and moves in general.

Imagine my block of 40 zombies wheeling through the front of a unit swordsmen during a charge, not actually "moving through" them as they did not exit on the other side of the unit!

No, I guess I just wanted to point out that when it comes to movement in general I think everyone has a good understanding of what moving through means. Then just take that meaning and apply it to hexwraiths as well.

Thank you! :)
 
Smogg said:
Interesting discussion of what "move through" means.

I'll just like to mention that if "move through" is limited to entering on one end and exiting on the other, it would result in a whole range of new freedom for charges and moves in general.

Imagine my block of 40 zombies wheeling through the front of a unit swordsmen during a charge, not actually "moving through" them as they did not exit on the other side of the unit!

No, I guess I just wanted to point out that when it comes to movement in general I think everyone has a good understanding of what moving through means. Then just take that meaning and apply it to hexwraiths as well.

Interesting and reasonable thought, but you know if GW ever FAQ's it they will muck it up in the opposite of your reasoning and all sorts of chaos will pursue. :rolleyes:
 
So you could move through a unit in the movement phase, do hits to it, and then Vanhels the hexwraiths through the same or another unit in the magic phase and do hits again?
 
Noobafrass said:
So you could move through a unit in the movement phase, do hits to it, and then Vanhels the hexwraiths through the same or another unit in the magic phase and do hits again?

I would say that is correct considering the FAQ clarification! :thumbsup:
 
eggspr said:
From what I gather its the same way terradons use their drop rocks move. As long as the model can move over (or through in the hexes case) and finish their movement 1" away, you gain the effects of the maneuver.

So a terradon can fly over you, then land right in front if you and drop rocks. Hexes should be able to do the same :)

This.

It's exactly the same IMO. Terradons are allowed to fly, pause mid-air as long as they barely clip your unit, drop their rocks, and make a complete about face, again all *mid-move* and it is legal. Hexwraiths can do the same as Fast Cav.

I still don't like them much though. :zombie:

- Larry
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu