I think this belongs into the Dying to Help section. Anyway, here are my thoughts on the topic.
Depending on your army theme you could easily take anything for your second Varghulf.
If your army is a bit chaosy, try a spawn, like sanai suggested.
I got an OOP Wolfen from Rackham's Confrontation system. He looks very suitable, too.
For a more Vampiric (bat-like) look you could also try to give a chaos spawn or a troll wings and sculpt him some fur as well as a new face.
The possibilities are endless. Just browse the forums and the popular alternative manufacturers (which can be found in a sticky in the Dark Arts forum).
Hope that helps,
Dogmar