VC Core and Horde Formation

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Corpse_Master

Skeleton
Jan 31, 2012
84
Zombies
75
Hello all,

I am a very new VC player and new to warhammer fantasy in general. Just curious, I have a small VC collection including 40 skeleton warriors and 60 zombies. If I were to field either of these two choices to fill out my core requirements would you recommend horde formation?

I heard zombies are better for tar-pitting and thus you would want no more than a 5 "man" front to minimize the number of potential casualties. But what about the Hw/S skellies?

Thanks
 
Do not form the zombies in hoard, the more models that the enemy can come into to contact with the more they will kill. I go 5or6 wide on skeletons
 
I was thinking of running a 40 man unit skellies with spears 10x4. But There are a few things that made me change my mind about running horde for VC's:

1) you would have less ranks deep making it more difficult to ignore stead fast units as chances are they would have more ranks than you.

2) Most people play 5-6 across so you would only be getting 7-8extra attacks at str 3. Maybe with re rolls on hits and wounds it could be ok but even then.

3) you lose parry but that isn't so bad if you have a Mortis engine or two. (ignore this eample when referring to hand weapon and shield.

4) it is more difficult to maneuver.

So I don't know I think Skellies are also a tar pit unit. Not going to kill much with them. the wraith and or vampire in the unit will. Or the vargeists or wraiths or whatever else hit with the unit will rack up the combat res you are looking for.
 
Personally I like to avoid having a unit being deeper than it is wide- they are supposed to be in battle formation, not in a marching column! So that usually makes me widen my units as they get bigger.
 
Yeah, they're supposed to be a battle formation, but remember that your units will be marching up next to each other, and the battle line itself will be wider than it is deep.

As for deploying skeletons and zombies - go deep with both of them. The only time I would run skeletons in horde formation is if I were fearbombing with them against enemies vulnerable to that tactic, and even then only if they were going to be engaging something with lowish toughness and not much armor. And even then, only if they were equipped with spears and under the influence of a nearby mortis engine.

That's a very specific situation, granted. Normally, I just wouldn't horde skeletons.
 
After trying out both Column and Horde formations with our previous book, I ended preferring Column for Skeletons, Zombies and Grave Guard (with sword and shield) and Horde for Ghouls and Grave Guard (with great weapons). I don't see that changing much with the new book - perhaps, with the limited marching with movement now heavily centred on our general, Columns might even have the edge because of space.

For me the Columns are all about static combat res. (standards and ranks) and breaking steadfast; the damage comes from hard hitting characters such as Vampire, Wight Kings and Wraiths.

With Ghouls they're a little less manoeuvrable anyway, lacking a musician, so squaring off against your opponent and going straight forwards, at their line, seems a viable tactic. That many poisoned attacks is quite intimidating for any foe and their extra cost includes good resilience with their higher toughness.

With the Grave Guard I personally prefer sword and shield, using them as an anvil, so making them a Column suits how I play, but if armed with great weapons going in Horde formation makes sense for a similar reason to Ghouls - that many high strength attacks are intimidating.

Probably the most important thing for us to remember is that our formations are flexible, especially with musicians with quick reforms, so you can adapt to what's best to break or counter your foe.
 
Column vs. horde depends a lot on how folks play around here. Sometimes there are lots of hordes, sometimes lots of buses. You'll have to chose accordingly. Even a zombie horde can be nasty w/the right spells on it!

Also, this thread certainly highlights the problem with "steadfast" in this edition!
 
Sanai said:
nd the battle line itself will be wider than it is deep.

You put 5 5x10 columns next to each other andd it forms a 25x50 battleline. 50 is deeper than 25 is wide.

That would add to a 25(+4inches)x10 or am I missing something?

Anyways, I agree that too deep units look´s a bit unrealistic!
 
If each enemy model is individually stronger than the model from my unit i go deep, otherwise i go horde. ie. I go deep vs chaos warriors, but horde vs skaven hordes. (depending on their ranks ofcourse)
 
Like fjhamming say I deployed based on what my opponents has. We gain no benefit from having more ranks than our opponent, you have to have at least the same number. The only thing which assists you from crumbling is killing more dudes. I often deploy 7 wide if I have to fight another bus as it means I just get more attacks than them.
 
I believe the OP was looking for effectiveness not visual effects lol. But either way 5 5x10 columns is 25 across but is not 50 deep. It is still only 10 deep. I am unsure of what you were trying to get at with that equation.
 
Aramoro said:
Like fjhamming say I deployed based on what my opponents has. We gain no benefit from having more ranks than our opponent, you have to have at least the same number. The only thing which assists you from crumbling is killing more dudes. I often deploy 7 wide if I have to fight another bus as it means I just get more attacks than them.

That´s true, but also factor in the risk of losing rank's faster. 4 or 6 extra skeleton attacks is nice but for the cost of -1 or more rankbonus it can be a bad deal vs some units.

EDIT: in hindsight, not my brightest comment :p
 
But either way 5 5x10 columns is 25 across but is not 50 deep

My bad, teaches me to do math and drink at the same time.

The battleline might look okay at deployment, but once you start the battle, units will move off on their own, and some may even win combats and pursue/wheel etc, at which point they will be fairly odd looking :p

Also, I don't see the value of discussing french napoleonic war formations in a army that completely lacks muskets and a setting which is rooted in medieval tactics despite the prescense of firearms. (In a realistic setting, the empire handgun would have replaced spears and swords completely at the empires level of technology, with the entire empire armies infantry being made up of handgunners with bayonets)
 
Sanai said:
Also, I don't see the value of discussing french napoleonic war formations in a army that completely lacks muskets and a setting which is rooted in medieval tactics despite the prescense of firearms. (In a realistic setting, the empire handgun would have replaced spears and swords completely at the empires level of technology, with the entire empire armies infantry being made up of handgunners with bayonets)

The column formation is a defence against muskets which is handy, also it has been used to break lines using shear weight of numbers. For an army which doesn't' care about it's soldiers it's a perfectly valid line breaking formation.
 
We gain no benefit by being deeper in ranks than our opponent? Does that not stop them from getting stead fast and becoming stubborn? Is that alone not enough reason to play deeper ranks with out cheep infantry?
 
Kuwanger23 said:
We gain no benefit by being deeper in ranks than our opponent? Does that not stop them from getting stead fast and becoming stubborn? Is that alone not enough reason to play deeper ranks with out cheep infantry?

Which is exactly what I said. It doesn't matter if we have the same number of ranks or 20 more ranks than our opponent.
 
The column formation is a defence against muskets which is handy, also it has been used to break lines using shear weight of numbers. For an army which doesn't' care about it's soldiers it's a perfectly valid line breaking formation.

The column formation also has the disadvantage of being narrow- in real pre- musket warfare, the larger army would often seek to widen its battleline wider than the enemies so its forces could lap around and partially encircle the enemy. Unfortanatly, lapping around disappeared from warhammer when we lost chaos dwarves and their hobgoblins.
 
Aramoro said:
Kuwanger23 said:
We gain no benefit by being deeper in ranks than our opponent? Does that not stop them from getting stead fast and becoming stubborn? Is that alone not enough reason to play deeper ranks with out cheep infantry?

Which is exactly what I said. It doesn't matter if we have the same number of ranks or 20 more ranks than our opponent.

Yes but what I am trying to say is you need to make sure you show up with equal to or more ranks. I'm not saying have 8+ ranks. But 5 is no good. Against many armies that have at least 5 ranks you are chancing it. And many armies play deeper. It depends on your meta but you need to make sure you show up with more. We have the advantage of raising back. But if we start in hordes formation chances are we are not going 6 ranks deep and that is a problem against most armies.
 
Sanai said:
In a realistic setting, the empire handgun would have replaced spears and swords completely at the empires level of technology, with the entire empire armies infantry being made up of handgunners with bayonets

Not necessarily. They still have to contend with enemies who field heavy cavalry and gigantic monsters, so the tactical advantage of using long polearms would still be very real.

Also in reality polearms were used up until the late 18th century, where as the Empire seems to be stuck in the 16th century in terms of military technology and thinking.

The column formation also has the disadvantage of being narrow- in real pre- musket warfare, the larger army would often seek to widen its battleline wider than the enemies so its forces could lap around and partially encircle the enemy. Unfortanatly, lapping around disappeared from warhammer when we lost chaos dwarves and their hobgoblins.

Infantry units in medieval warfare were typically deployed in square formation, so that they had depth and so that they could easily change direction without having to reform or maneuver (each man could simply turn to face the new direction).
 
I've ran both Zombos and Skellies as both hordes and deep formations since our 8th book, if you have strong magic and can get off that ASF+reroll hit+reroll wound combo fairly regularly with even just a single IoN each turn the horde formation is absolutely vile even on zombies. If I remember the math-hammer I did about a week ago right zombies have a like 45% wound ratio vs most elite infantry.

Last game I played my 50 zombie unit ate a 30 orc elite unit(don't know orcs but think he said Black axe or something) and 2 55 gobbie units thanks to getting both vigors(CC one & spell) and Vanhels with the book half my turns. My ~400 points(incl a lvl 4 Master necro) took out like 900 points. :devil2:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu