As my first serious post on this site, I must say I'm very impressed with the community and look forward to contributing more to the dark cause.
Secondly, apologies in advance for what I know is going to be a huge rant about how Lizardmen are OP.
Intro:
My friend recently started playing Lizardmen, and we'd had a couple of games before today. The first game (1500pts) was a very close draw, with nearly everyone dead. In the second game (2000pt), I was annihilated by his Slann using Bane Head + Rule of Burning Iron combo on my lord and Spirit of the Forge on his unit of Black Knights (with Hatred and Regen banners).
The whole time I was struggling just to keep my Lord and unit alive and couldn't use my PD to bolster my small core units as I had intended. I was using Mannfred as my lord, and thus had a magic heavy list (or what I thought was magic heavy). I manged to kill 1 unit of Saurus before I conceded (my general and uber-unit dead, the rest crumbling fast, and my opponent still going strong).
That was a couple of weeks ago, so I had time to ponder what I could possibly do against a Slann using Lore of Metal, surrounded by a rock hard army of spear wielding Saurus.
The Predicament:
I needed to shut down his Slann somehow, and there was no point in trying to compete magically, so I went defence heavy, dropped Mannfred in favour of a combat Lord and stacked up on Dispell scrolls. My list was as follows:
Vampire Lord:
Red Fury, Dread Knight, Infinite Hatred, Blood Drinker, 2x Dispel Scrolls
Vampire:
Dark Acolyte, Lord of the Dead, Flayed Hauberk, Dispel Scroll
Vampire:
Dark Acolyte, Lord of the Dead, 2x Dispel Scroll
Vampire:
Dread Knight, LotD, Sword of Battle, Dispel Scroll
11x Skeletons:
Full Command, Vamp Thrall
11x Skeletons:
Full Command, Vamp Thrall
6x Black Knights:
Standard of Strigos, Hellknight (fighting Vampire Thrall went here)
Varghulf
6x Blood Knights:
Kastellan, Banner of Dead Legion, (Lord went here)
The Plan:
Simply, I wanted to charge his Slann unit with my Blood Knights, and slaughter the lot of them. Since I knew he'd only have 10x TG bodyguards, I was pretty confident of doing so if I made it into combat. I knew I'd be facing the old Lore of Metal trick, so I had the Black Knights as a backup unit in case one got nuked with SotF.
My entire plan hinged on him not rolling Irresistable Force for SotF... not much of a plan.
Also, I knew my friend had bought 2x Stegadons and would probably be using them, but I didn't know what configuration he'd be using. I was dreading 2x EotGs, but other than that, I felt my heavy cavalry would be able to deal with them.
Battle, the First:
I was in for a surprise, as I found out my opponent was fielding 2x EotGs. His list (roughly):
Slann:
Focus Mystery, Becalming Cogitation, The Focused Rumination
Skink Priest:
Plaque of Extra Spellening, Ancient Steg w/ EotG
Skink Priest:
Ancient Steg w/ Eotg
18x Saurus:
Spears, Shields, Banner, Musician
18x Saurus:
Spears, Shields, Banner, Musician
10x Skinks:
Blowpipes
10x Temple Guard:
As I wanted to charge his Slann unit, I wanted to deploy my Blood Knights smack in front of them, but for some reason I put my skeleton units in the centre of my line (old habit), after which Mr. Slann deployed in front of them. Deployment ended up as follows:
................................................EotG.................................
............EotG...Saurus....Slann....Saurus.....Skinks....................
............BloodKs....Skellies...Skellies.....BlackKs.....Varghulf......
Skinks and Black Knights were both on hills, my left flank was anchored by a forest, while his right had a hill.
Turn 1:
VC:
My entire army surged forward, eager to get to grips with the enemy. This is uncharacteristic of me, since I usually hang back while I bolster my skeletons, however I knew I had to kill his Slann before he got too many SotF and RoBIs off.
My Varghulf lands in position to charge the skinks in case they cause trouble for my Black Knights, who wheel to face the right hand Saurus block.
My Blood Knights stop in front of the left flank EotG and Saurus block. I make sure not to move them too close to the Saurus.
The magic phase is a complete whiff. I manage to raise 5 skeletons on my right-hand unit.
Lizards:
Turns out I placed my Blood Knights far enough from the Saurus, but not the EotG... which promptly charges me.
His other EotG wheels slightly to face the threat on his left flank, while the skinks move off the hill to the right of my Black Ks in the hope of drawing them away from his centre.
Skinks shoot at the Varghulf causing 3 wounds...
In the magic phase, Burning Alignment kills 5 Blood Knights... RoBI kills the remaining Blood Knight, but I manage to scroll SotF.
Two wounds are done to my Lord from impact hits. I manage to wound the Skink priest 3 times, but he makes all his saves. My Lord dies from crumbling...
Turn 2:
VC:
Varghulf charges the skinks, who have to reform enough so my Black Knights can charge the Saurus block.
My skeleton blocks wheel left and form a battle line against the EotG and Saurus on my left.
In combat, my Varghulf kills three skinks. He manages to cause 1 wound... I fail my regen save and there is much rejoicing in a little skink village somewhere.
My Black Knights do much better, slaughtering the Saurus, causing them to flee despite the nearby Slann. I chase them down and overrun into the flank of the other EotG.
Lizards:
On the left flank, his EotG manages to charge the flank of my skeleton line (he reformed after massacring my lords unit).
In magic, his left hand EotG fries 5 our of 11 skeletons, while the right hand one kills 4 Black Knights. Spirit of the Forge is then cast against them with Irresistable Force, finishing off the Knights.
In combat, impact hits kill and combat kill 5 more skeletons, my Vamp and skellies do nothing in return, and crumble to dust. The EotG overruns into the other skeleton block.
At this point I concede the game....
Since I didn't get to stick to my plan due to a botched deployment, we decide to have another game. I really want to know if my VC should be shelved until I can get a new army or not.
Battle, the Second:
We used the same lists and terrain setup, except I placed my lord in the Black Knights, and the fighty Vamp in the Blood Knights..
Deployment:
.........Skinks.......Saurus..EotG.Slann.EotG..........Saurus..........
......VG...............Skellies......BloodKs.Skellies....BlackKs...........
His skinks were on a hill, while the right-flank Saurus were next to one. My Black Knights were on top of a hill directly in front of the Saurus.
Turn 1:
VC:
My skeletons march forward 8". Having learnt my lesson from last game, my Blood Knights only march about 11", wheeling slightly in the hope of not having to charge the Stegs flanking his Slann unit. It looks like I'll clip the left hand one at this stage, since they're so close together.
My Black Knights stop in front of the Saurus, readying for a charge next turn, while the Varghulf move forward to threaten the flank of the Saurus block.
My magic is completely shut down by the Lizards.
Lizards:
Both EotG march forward 12", the right hand one wheeling toward the Black Kngihts slightly. I suddenly have a very bad feeling...
The right hand Saurus block marches forward and wheels slightly, so that my Knights will pursue off into the corner. The left hand block moves up to support the EotG.
The skinks move up and pepper the Varghulf with poisoned darts, which miraculously can hurt an dead creature somehow (why can't they be immune like Mordheim dammit!) and do 2 wounds.
In the magic phase, Burning Alignment (I know this is gonna hurt, since an average roll for range will cover my whole army) wipes out the Blood Knights, a Black Knight and five skeletons... I break down in tears and fling my models out the window. j/k. I am very annoyed at this point. I manage to scroll his Lore of Metal spells for this round.
Turn 2:
VC:
I figure I'm going to lose at this point anyway, so everyone charges. My skeleton blocks charge an EotG each, my Vargh charges the flank of the Saurus block, Black Knights charge the other Saurus.
In magic, I regen 1 wound on the Vargh.
My Knights smash into the Saurus block, break them, and run them down. I decided to pursue, since I only killed 7 of 18, and I knew they'd regroup next turn (Ld8, Cold blooded).
My right hand skeleton block manages to kill the Skink priest in a challenge with my Vamp. I win the combat and the Steg flees! My luck runs out, because I don't pursue far enough.
The other skeleton unit isn't so lucky. I do no damage and suffer a 2 wounds in return from damage/crumbling.
The Vargh kills 3 Saurus but loses by 1 due to combat rez and loses a wound.
Lizards:
The Steg regoups and turns to face the pursuing skeletons.
Skinks charge the Varghulf in the rear, Slann block moves up to threaten the flank of the skeletons pursuing the decomissioned EotGs.
In magic, the remain EotG uses Burning Alignment, does a wound on the Vargh and kills a couple of skeletons in combat with it.
Luckily, the Slann has no LOS to my Knights, but kills a couple of skellies with Lore of Metal spells.
In combat, the skinks and Saurus combined do no damage, while I kill some skinks. I lose combat from static rez, but make my regen saves.
Turn 3:
VC:
Skeletons charge the Steg. Knights wheel around to face the rear of the Steg.
My meagre magic is shut down easily.
In combat, my Vargh kills 5 skinks, takes no damage. The Saurus flee and end up on the other side of the remaining EotG.
My vamp does a wound to the remaining Skink Priest for no damage in return, but the combat is tied due to outnumber.
The other skeleton/steg combat is a draw.
Lizards:
I can't remember what happens here, except the remaining skeletons in my right hand unit are killed. I'm referring to pictures as a write this, but I must've missed taking one for this turn.
Turn 4:
VC:
Knights charge Steg in the rear.
Vargh finishes skinks and reforms to face the EotG. Vamp Thrall manages to kill the remaining Skink Priest, but dies herself from crumbling. At this point I rejoice at shutting down the EotGs. However it's taken nearly my whole army to do so.
Steg is killed, one skink crew is left and flees toward Saurus block.
Lizards:
Saurus regroup. Steg manouvres to the right on the Saurus who are facing my Knights. Slann unit backs up toward the Saurus.
It takes my remaining 3 scrolls and all my dispel dice to stop the torrent of Metal spells directed at my Knights. I still have a hope of winning...
Turn 5:
VC:
A hill now separates my Black Knights from the Slann and his unit of Temple Guard. I know they're out of range, so I simple march my full distance and end up on the far edge of the hill about 6" away from the Lizards...
My lone Vamp Thrall on foot and the Thrall in the unit of Knights both have Vanhels dance, and I have 5 PD... I my lone Thrall throws 3 dice at it (the max he can)... and doesn't cast it. I needed a 7. But wait, I still have 2 dice left!!!! Still doesn't cast...
At this point, I'm about ready to shoot myself.
Lizards:
Nothing moves. My opponent is confident that the Black Knights will cease to exist after the magic phase.
In a sarcastic show of optimism, I say that I still have 4 dispel dice.
So the magic phase rolls around and Spirit of the Forge is cast on the Black Knights with Irresistable Force, causing 11 wounds and leaving a large steaming puddle of metal.
I concede, my lone Vampire raising his finger in defiance as he flees. The scaly ones blink a few times without comprehending the meaning of the gesture.
The Rant:
I'm really tired at this point, which is lucky for you guys, because it means my rant won't be as long.
How am I supposed to beat 2x EotG and a Slann with Lore of Metal? Burning Alignment is soooo powerrful, it's crazy. S5 against undead and no save? And Lore of Metal. Seriously, wtf? What are Bretonnians supposed to do? IMO, it should work like a bound spell, so there's a chance of dispelling, either that or allow armour saves.
Also Bane Head is ridiculous. It just works with no possibility of dispelling.
The way I see it, the only way I can win is to kill his Slann quickly, and the only way I can do that is to use cavalry, which instantly get nuked by EotG and Lores of Metal.
I've thought about ethereals, but LM have a TONNE of magic so I doubt they'd last any longer that my heavy cav.
I've read all the threads about dealing with Lizardmen, and I have a few ideas, however I'm not really prepared to fork out for new models. Please comment on where I went wrong, and what I could possible do to counter the scaled menace. Here are my available models:
60x skeletons
30x zombies
20x grave guard
6x Black Knights
6x Blood Knights
2x Mounted Vamps
3x Vamps on Foot
1x Wight King
10x Dire Wolves
1x Varghulf
2x Corpse Carts
Comments and criticism please!
Secondly, apologies in advance for what I know is going to be a huge rant about how Lizardmen are OP.
Intro:
My friend recently started playing Lizardmen, and we'd had a couple of games before today. The first game (1500pts) was a very close draw, with nearly everyone dead. In the second game (2000pt), I was annihilated by his Slann using Bane Head + Rule of Burning Iron combo on my lord and Spirit of the Forge on his unit of Black Knights (with Hatred and Regen banners).
The whole time I was struggling just to keep my Lord and unit alive and couldn't use my PD to bolster my small core units as I had intended. I was using Mannfred as my lord, and thus had a magic heavy list (or what I thought was magic heavy). I manged to kill 1 unit of Saurus before I conceded (my general and uber-unit dead, the rest crumbling fast, and my opponent still going strong).
That was a couple of weeks ago, so I had time to ponder what I could possibly do against a Slann using Lore of Metal, surrounded by a rock hard army of spear wielding Saurus.
The Predicament:
I needed to shut down his Slann somehow, and there was no point in trying to compete magically, so I went defence heavy, dropped Mannfred in favour of a combat Lord and stacked up on Dispell scrolls. My list was as follows:
Vampire Lord:
Red Fury, Dread Knight, Infinite Hatred, Blood Drinker, 2x Dispel Scrolls
Vampire:
Dark Acolyte, Lord of the Dead, Flayed Hauberk, Dispel Scroll
Vampire:
Dark Acolyte, Lord of the Dead, 2x Dispel Scroll
Vampire:
Dread Knight, LotD, Sword of Battle, Dispel Scroll
11x Skeletons:
Full Command, Vamp Thrall
11x Skeletons:
Full Command, Vamp Thrall
6x Black Knights:
Standard of Strigos, Hellknight (fighting Vampire Thrall went here)
Varghulf
6x Blood Knights:
Kastellan, Banner of Dead Legion, (Lord went here)
The Plan:
Simply, I wanted to charge his Slann unit with my Blood Knights, and slaughter the lot of them. Since I knew he'd only have 10x TG bodyguards, I was pretty confident of doing so if I made it into combat. I knew I'd be facing the old Lore of Metal trick, so I had the Black Knights as a backup unit in case one got nuked with SotF.
My entire plan hinged on him not rolling Irresistable Force for SotF... not much of a plan.
Also, I knew my friend had bought 2x Stegadons and would probably be using them, but I didn't know what configuration he'd be using. I was dreading 2x EotGs, but other than that, I felt my heavy cavalry would be able to deal with them.
Battle, the First:
I was in for a surprise, as I found out my opponent was fielding 2x EotGs. His list (roughly):
Slann:
Focus Mystery, Becalming Cogitation, The Focused Rumination
Skink Priest:
Plaque of Extra Spellening, Ancient Steg w/ EotG
Skink Priest:
Ancient Steg w/ Eotg
18x Saurus:
Spears, Shields, Banner, Musician
18x Saurus:
Spears, Shields, Banner, Musician
10x Skinks:
Blowpipes
10x Temple Guard:
As I wanted to charge his Slann unit, I wanted to deploy my Blood Knights smack in front of them, but for some reason I put my skeleton units in the centre of my line (old habit), after which Mr. Slann deployed in front of them. Deployment ended up as follows:
................................................EotG.................................
............EotG...Saurus....Slann....Saurus.....Skinks....................
............BloodKs....Skellies...Skellies.....BlackKs.....Varghulf......
Skinks and Black Knights were both on hills, my left flank was anchored by a forest, while his right had a hill.
Turn 1:
VC:
My entire army surged forward, eager to get to grips with the enemy. This is uncharacteristic of me, since I usually hang back while I bolster my skeletons, however I knew I had to kill his Slann before he got too many SotF and RoBIs off.
My Varghulf lands in position to charge the skinks in case they cause trouble for my Black Knights, who wheel to face the right hand Saurus block.
My Blood Knights stop in front of the left flank EotG and Saurus block. I make sure not to move them too close to the Saurus.
The magic phase is a complete whiff. I manage to raise 5 skeletons on my right-hand unit.
Lizards:
Turns out I placed my Blood Knights far enough from the Saurus, but not the EotG... which promptly charges me.
His other EotG wheels slightly to face the threat on his left flank, while the skinks move off the hill to the right of my Black Ks in the hope of drawing them away from his centre.
Skinks shoot at the Varghulf causing 3 wounds...
In the magic phase, Burning Alignment kills 5 Blood Knights... RoBI kills the remaining Blood Knight, but I manage to scroll SotF.
Two wounds are done to my Lord from impact hits. I manage to wound the Skink priest 3 times, but he makes all his saves. My Lord dies from crumbling...
Turn 2:
VC:
Varghulf charges the skinks, who have to reform enough so my Black Knights can charge the Saurus block.
My skeleton blocks wheel left and form a battle line against the EotG and Saurus on my left.
In combat, my Varghulf kills three skinks. He manages to cause 1 wound... I fail my regen save and there is much rejoicing in a little skink village somewhere.
My Black Knights do much better, slaughtering the Saurus, causing them to flee despite the nearby Slann. I chase them down and overrun into the flank of the other EotG.
Lizards:
On the left flank, his EotG manages to charge the flank of my skeleton line (he reformed after massacring my lords unit).
In magic, his left hand EotG fries 5 our of 11 skeletons, while the right hand one kills 4 Black Knights. Spirit of the Forge is then cast against them with Irresistable Force, finishing off the Knights.
In combat, impact hits kill and combat kill 5 more skeletons, my Vamp and skellies do nothing in return, and crumble to dust. The EotG overruns into the other skeleton block.
At this point I concede the game....
Since I didn't get to stick to my plan due to a botched deployment, we decide to have another game. I really want to know if my VC should be shelved until I can get a new army or not.
Battle, the Second:
We used the same lists and terrain setup, except I placed my lord in the Black Knights, and the fighty Vamp in the Blood Knights..
Deployment:
.........Skinks.......Saurus..EotG.Slann.EotG..........Saurus..........
......VG...............Skellies......BloodKs.Skellies....BlackKs...........
His skinks were on a hill, while the right-flank Saurus were next to one. My Black Knights were on top of a hill directly in front of the Saurus.
Turn 1:
VC:
My skeletons march forward 8". Having learnt my lesson from last game, my Blood Knights only march about 11", wheeling slightly in the hope of not having to charge the Stegs flanking his Slann unit. It looks like I'll clip the left hand one at this stage, since they're so close together.
My Black Knights stop in front of the Saurus, readying for a charge next turn, while the Varghulf move forward to threaten the flank of the Saurus block.
My magic is completely shut down by the Lizards.
Lizards:
Both EotG march forward 12", the right hand one wheeling toward the Black Kngihts slightly. I suddenly have a very bad feeling...
The right hand Saurus block marches forward and wheels slightly, so that my Knights will pursue off into the corner. The left hand block moves up to support the EotG.
The skinks move up and pepper the Varghulf with poisoned darts, which miraculously can hurt an dead creature somehow (why can't they be immune like Mordheim dammit!) and do 2 wounds.
In the magic phase, Burning Alignment (I know this is gonna hurt, since an average roll for range will cover my whole army) wipes out the Blood Knights, a Black Knight and five skeletons... I break down in tears and fling my models out the window. j/k. I am very annoyed at this point. I manage to scroll his Lore of Metal spells for this round.
Turn 2:
VC:
I figure I'm going to lose at this point anyway, so everyone charges. My skeleton blocks charge an EotG each, my Vargh charges the flank of the Saurus block, Black Knights charge the other Saurus.
In magic, I regen 1 wound on the Vargh.
My Knights smash into the Saurus block, break them, and run them down. I decided to pursue, since I only killed 7 of 18, and I knew they'd regroup next turn (Ld8, Cold blooded).
My right hand skeleton block manages to kill the Skink priest in a challenge with my Vamp. I win the combat and the Steg flees! My luck runs out, because I don't pursue far enough.
The other skeleton unit isn't so lucky. I do no damage and suffer a 2 wounds in return from damage/crumbling.
The Vargh kills 3 Saurus but loses by 1 due to combat rez and loses a wound.
Lizards:
The Steg regoups and turns to face the pursuing skeletons.
Skinks charge the Varghulf in the rear, Slann block moves up to threaten the flank of the skeletons pursuing the decomissioned EotGs.
In magic, the remain EotG uses Burning Alignment, does a wound on the Vargh and kills a couple of skeletons in combat with it.
Luckily, the Slann has no LOS to my Knights, but kills a couple of skellies with Lore of Metal spells.
In combat, the skinks and Saurus combined do no damage, while I kill some skinks. I lose combat from static rez, but make my regen saves.
Turn 3:
VC:
Skeletons charge the Steg. Knights wheel around to face the rear of the Steg.
My meagre magic is shut down easily.
In combat, my Vargh kills 5 skinks, takes no damage. The Saurus flee and end up on the other side of the remaining EotG.
My vamp does a wound to the remaining Skink Priest for no damage in return, but the combat is tied due to outnumber.
The other skeleton/steg combat is a draw.
Lizards:
I can't remember what happens here, except the remaining skeletons in my right hand unit are killed. I'm referring to pictures as a write this, but I must've missed taking one for this turn.
Turn 4:
VC:
Knights charge Steg in the rear.
Vargh finishes skinks and reforms to face the EotG. Vamp Thrall manages to kill the remaining Skink Priest, but dies herself from crumbling. At this point I rejoice at shutting down the EotGs. However it's taken nearly my whole army to do so.
Steg is killed, one skink crew is left and flees toward Saurus block.
Lizards:
Saurus regroup. Steg manouvres to the right on the Saurus who are facing my Knights. Slann unit backs up toward the Saurus.
It takes my remaining 3 scrolls and all my dispel dice to stop the torrent of Metal spells directed at my Knights. I still have a hope of winning...
Turn 5:
VC:
A hill now separates my Black Knights from the Slann and his unit of Temple Guard. I know they're out of range, so I simple march my full distance and end up on the far edge of the hill about 6" away from the Lizards...
My lone Vamp Thrall on foot and the Thrall in the unit of Knights both have Vanhels dance, and I have 5 PD... I my lone Thrall throws 3 dice at it (the max he can)... and doesn't cast it. I needed a 7. But wait, I still have 2 dice left!!!! Still doesn't cast...
At this point, I'm about ready to shoot myself.
Lizards:
Nothing moves. My opponent is confident that the Black Knights will cease to exist after the magic phase.
In a sarcastic show of optimism, I say that I still have 4 dispel dice.
So the magic phase rolls around and Spirit of the Forge is cast on the Black Knights with Irresistable Force, causing 11 wounds and leaving a large steaming puddle of metal.
I concede, my lone Vampire raising his finger in defiance as he flees. The scaly ones blink a few times without comprehending the meaning of the gesture.
The Rant:
I'm really tired at this point, which is lucky for you guys, because it means my rant won't be as long.
How am I supposed to beat 2x EotG and a Slann with Lore of Metal? Burning Alignment is soooo powerrful, it's crazy. S5 against undead and no save? And Lore of Metal. Seriously, wtf? What are Bretonnians supposed to do? IMO, it should work like a bound spell, so there's a chance of dispelling, either that or allow armour saves.
Also Bane Head is ridiculous. It just works with no possibility of dispelling.
The way I see it, the only way I can win is to kill his Slann quickly, and the only way I can do that is to use cavalry, which instantly get nuked by EotG and Lores of Metal.
I've thought about ethereals, but LM have a TONNE of magic so I doubt they'd last any longer that my heavy cav.
I've read all the threads about dealing with Lizardmen, and I have a few ideas, however I'm not really prepared to fork out for new models. Please comment on where I went wrong, and what I could possible do to counter the scaled menace. Here are my available models:
60x skeletons
30x zombies
20x grave guard
6x Black Knights
6x Blood Knights
2x Mounted Vamps
3x Vamps on Foot
1x Wight King
10x Dire Wolves
1x Varghulf
2x Corpse Carts
Comments and criticism please!