So why not just go back to unit strength then?
Because there's no measure of "Unit Strength" in 8th. And counting ranks is
much quicker than counting models. ("1,2,3,4,
5 ranks," vs "7 models wide x 5 ranks deep is 35, plus the 4 stray models in the second rank is
39 Unit Strength."
Plus we're still using support attacks and the
Horde rule, so using
ranks to calculate the bonus rather than number of models creates a counter point to going 10-wide–
Horde formations will have more attacks, but fewer ranks, and so won't get the Steadfast bonus. Or, you sacrifice those attacks for the bump in the CR via Steadfast. If you're just counting models, the
Horde could get more attacks
and still have more models than a unit with more ranks.
Now, the difference is clear: Way more attacks is better than +1 CR (which is why GW probably went with making the Steadfast unit "stubborn" instead). So, maybe it should be a bigger bonus? Like + the difference in ranks? That would help counter the extra attacks.
I'm trying not to over complicate things, though.
If MoK generated dispel dice again then I'd be good with that, of course the real issue with this is that it means everyone has to max out on wizards to have a decent magic defense and offense, I could see this being far worse than in previous editions with using percentages rather than slots.
Meh. It was kind of like that in 6th Edition, and it wasn't such a big problem (although spells weren't as devastating back then, either). Remember, if they're taking tons of wizards, they're likely doing that at the expense of blender lords and such. And if they're taking a bunch of level 2s, they won't have much (or any) hope of getting off the 20+ difficulty "unit deleting" spells. Level 2 can only roll 3 dice. So they'll need a roll of 18, +2 for level to get a 20. Maybe we can drop the idea of adding a Wizard's level to the roll to make it even more difficult to get those spells.
I get what GW was going for: They didn't want the magic phase to be a phase that you can just write off. The magic phase can have a major impact on the game now, so players need to build their lists accordingly. You can't simply ignore it like you used to be able to, and if you do, you'll regret it.
My suggestion is intended to at least make the magic phase more consistent & reliable, and eliminate the extraneous, unnecessary dice rolls.
Sounds a little extreme, I think if you failed a fear test at the start of combat -1 to hit and then suffering a minus to leadership based on the outnumber ratio might be a bit better.
Part of it is to eliminate the
need to make the fear roll at the start (which is forgotten more often than not, forcing things to either be re-rolled, or played
wrong.)
Since you have the BSB re-rolls, general's bonus, etc, that test is usually passed anyway. So, again, it's a lot of extraneous dice rolling that amounts to nothing (a recurring theme in 8th edition).
And it's far less extreme than the way it worked in 6th: A fear causing unit charged you, no test was necessary. And if you lost combat by even 1 point, and the unit outnumbered you, you
broke automatically. Meaning, if you whiffed all your attacks, and they had one more rank than you and inflicted no casualties, your unit was
gone without a single model having been slain.
Now to be fair, that was the strategy for the undead with poor fighting ability: Outnumber the opponent and just
scare them off. I think this is a nice balance between the two: get rid of the unnecessary (oft-forgotten) tests, and still scare off a few models without breaking the entire unit when hardly anyone was killed.
It does kinda make me wonder how 8th ed books would function in 6th ed with a few minor tweaks to 6th.
I think the 8th books (and their points) are fine, because everyone is on the same footing. If the point costs are bad, they're bad for everyone. One reason I'm loathe to go back to a straight 6th edition is because 8th is pretty tight on the special rules, and I enjoy the things like Hordes and supporting attacks. In "Straight 6th" units like Skeletons and Zombies would be way under-pointed because of the Fear auto-break. I think part of the reason their point costs came down in 8th is because the Fear rule had its teeth pulled (no auto break, no failed charges because of fear tests, no auto flee reaction because of failed fear tests).
The main problem going forward is that there won't be any new models for the armies. And even when they put out new Undead models, unless it can be proxies for an existing
VC unit, it won't have any useable stats. (The new stuff will come with
AoS- only stats, and in order to fit in an 8th edition list, it will need to be completely house-ruled.)