what does everyone think of 8th edition?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Alucard

Ghoul
Jun 9, 2008
161
TEXAS
Zombies
68
ok lords and ladies of darkness, i have not played a game of whfb since it's fifth or sixth incarnation, although i have kept up with my army books. what does everyone think of the new rules vs. our beloved vampire counts? i know we were nerfed a bit, but whats the real impact from guys who actually play (vs. guys like me who just buy models, complain about painting them, and make army lists.). thanks all!
 
fast, easy, relatively argument free in many of the ways that previous editions were not.

highly powered magic, way too many reform options, and some units becoming extremely cost effective.
 
I dont like 8th edition but im stuck playing it because my group of friends all play armies that were positively effected by the rule changes.

I personally dont like it because I find that certain armies have a huge advantage, and I find there are more and more games were I march across the battlefield getting shotup and by the time I get in combat the games already over.

Rules I HATE in 8th Edition:
Steadfast -> Retarded, makes Cavalry ineffective, Not enough ways to remove, Makes ITP not so good, Makes many units obsolete as even if you win your opponent likely wont break.

Charging/Init -> Im a firm believer that if you charge you should get to go first regardless of Init. The charge should give you the jump to actually get to attack back instead of getting killed off before you get a chance to attack back. This really effects cavalry in negative way as your relying on your +2 STR lances to win you the combat. So not only do you likely go 2nd but they will be steadfast against you too.

ASF = Re-Rolls -> Lets be honest here this rule was specifically put in 8th edition to make HE's a top army instead of a Strong Army. This change has 100% to do with selling models, which is what GW is about and always will be about which is making money. In 7th edition having hatred ect. would be a big thing but now its over-shadowed by ASF which basically auto-wins any combat. He who strikes first almost always wins EVERY combat.

Super Spells -> These spells just ruin the game. WH is suposed to be about tactics and strategy. However all people talk about now is there tooled up Suicide Character thats tactic is to run into the enemy and miscast purple suns or whatever lameo spell you decide to use. The only thing more annoying that being shot to death as you move across the battlefield is a Super Spell single handedly winning a game.

However my friends seem to really like the new rules because they really benefited from it. Im really getting sick and tired of fighting Steam Tanks and Plague Furnaces or Retarded Shooting armies every game. I feel like VC struggle to compete against the best armies and I find myself taking more and more time in-between games. Im not mad at the VC army im just sick of playing for 4 hours and all I got to show for it was marching across the battle and picking dead bodies off as I get shot to hell by whatever army is taking advantage of our lack of shooting.
 
While I agree with some of what Yanda said ie. cav being nerfed (god i miss my blood knights), stupid broken spells being deliberately cast with IF etc etc

I still think it has been a positve change to the game, it just means we have to be more tactical against certain armies. I've been having a streak of bad luck against a particlur empire player at the moment having lost the last 7 games I think :( however that shall not stop me from marshalling my undead troops and occaisionally throwing out the old Blood Knight deathstar army every now and then :)
 
I personally dont like it because I find that certain armies have a huge advantage, and I find there are more and more games were I march across the battlefield getting shotup and by the time I get in combat the games already over.

Um. Right. I don't think you can make this argument as a vamp player, where for the previous two editions we were s top 3 power army consistently. To the point where the only armies that you saw predominantly winning major tourneys for years were skaven/vamps/daemons/a few assorted that shifted with army books until storm of chaos came out (6th) and vamps/daemons/dark elves (7th). Literally years. And really, though I wasn't much of a tourney player at the time, undead/vamps were fairly nuts in 5th edition from what I recall.

As for the rest...2 points:

-Did you play 5th edition?

-Cav got watered down. Again, you had what? 11 years of cav dominance in the game? 6th came out in 99? or was it later than that?

-
 
Alright guys, DoN's already pointed to an existing thread where you can let fly your opinions about the general gameplay of the 8th edition. Looking at Alucard's opening post, this thread ought to be about the changes that are affecting the Vampire Counts army, and how things have panned out from there.
 
Looking at Alucard's opening post, this thread ought to be about the changes that are affecting the Vampire Counts army, and how things have panned out from there.

Well from that perspective, I think that our options got more limited in some ways. However, this is consistent across the game:

-Combat characters are not what they were. Personally, I think a combat oriented VC list will run into problems against strong opponents. You give up a lot of things that make your crappy core (which you must now bring 25% of) better. One can argue the strength of ghouls, which are very strong, but they lack banners.

-You have to wipe out units completely to win. Which initially seems great, but crumble/unstable, and the sheer choppiness of 8th makes it difficult. Combined with the changes to fear, this makes combat a bit of an uphill battle.

-Magic is stronger. And how many spells you know actually matters more than your level. Forbidden Lore is now amazing.

-Our choppy infantry (Grave Guard) stand up well to almost any other choppy unit in the game. Our problem is they are not core. Which means that while we give saurus and chaos warriors a run for their money, we can't spam the way khornate warriors are.
 
I think VC became more limited in what works but what works is really good.

8th Vc are great and the fact the most of the other armies are better to it kind of calms the 'VC are broken' crying on the interweb
 
I find 8th plays a lot faster so I like it a lot more. (not to mention i have won every 8th battle i have played so far... I Love the Black Coach!)
 
I personally like 8th, there's a couple of things I'd change but you can't have everything. I have to say ghouls are they way forward this edition in my opinion (especially with ghoulkin :) ), and this comes from a player who was set on skellys last edition, grave guard are gold as well.

Your army lists will need a rethink in most cases, I don't think many 7th edition lists will transfer over without any changes.

As for vamps being nurfed, i'm 13 - 1 up on the win to loss, bloody dark elf hydra at 750 points, it just ate my entire army after it had finished burning a large amount of it.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu