So many to think about.
In plastic I really like the Skaven Doom Wheel with grey seer on the bell. The corpse cart is pretty good too.
In metal I have always liked the shaggoth. The Slann is very atmospheric too. From the olden days, the metal wights from the early 1990's I loved for such a long time - and the original set of metal Empire wizards wowed me in their day. Non-GW I really like the Gamezone mournful knights and their dire wolves.
These days I think GW has fallen behind a little, other companies sculpts seem far better than GW's offerings, which can be very hit and miss at the moment. For example, Enigma Miniatures Dark Vlad and Winged Vampire are probably the two vamps that I will recruit for my army at some stage. Meanwhile, I don't really like any of the GW metal vampires, Konrad is passable, Mannfredd on his steed too, the rest are pretty poor IMO.