What would you change about the new book?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Time for my first real post since I got back. Interesting thread.

I'm not very pleased with the book. I hate that everything in it encourages us to stack up in a big pile in the centre of the battlefield. The most important thing to do to fix this is the vampire marching rule, the old one was better.

Corpse carts being chariots is pretty stupid, it needs to be able to keep up with the army, now it can't.

Having to take lore of vampire on the general is just sad.

For me the new book didn't change that much in terms of power, I fell we might have become a little stronger a most. But it did change a lot in eternal balance. It is great that zombies and skeletons are balanced now compared to ghouls, I feel that they are all viable now. But when it comes to characters and overall tactics I feel much more locked up that with the last book. Most sad of all I think is that to me the vampire lord seams pretty worthless now, a normal vampire brings enough hitting power, and necromancer lords are more viable for magic.

But most importantly, I would give us a freaking FaQ. Why is it taking so long?!!?!!
 
woodster17 said:
The rules are fine by me.

However, the writing (fluff wise) seems childish. The book doesn't feel as dark as VC books are meant to be and the new stuff is just plain bizarre. It feels like more energy has gone in to the book aesthetically and opposed to the content which is very disappointing.

I ignore most the fluff in the book, I don't collect Von Carsteins, I never will and frankly they don't interest me in the slightest. I think my only complaint is really how certain powers are a auto include, I mean how many vampires do you not see with ASF and/or red fury, its a rather sickening combo when combined with something like a ogre blade or sword of anti-heroes. Playing against my mates WoC it was like "charge vampire and grave guard in, remove unit", can't bring myself to use Red fury again :(
 
I think, considering we really need all the magical help we can get, I prefer the black coach as it is now. It may not power as fast, but it is tough enough to stick around for the decent ones late game
 
Honestly after playing more games with this book the only real dud in my eyes is the mortis engine. Other than that everything has fantastic synergy and plays really well.
 
More creativity would've been nice. Varghulf...vargheist...terrorgheist...why not add poltergeist to the list? Heck, go into D+D Ravenloft and grab the bussengeist and valpurgeist while you're at it...........

Why are vargheist models bigger than the varghulf? I would've just somehow combined the two units together and made the new sculpts the appropriate size.
 
I'd either weaken the 'ghulf so it would be taken in units or do away with it and have that model represent a vargheist (and thus, make the new plastic ones the same size).

CH's really should have been werewolves or flesh golems.
 
I would've liked to have kept the old bloodline theme. Why either Abhorash (like Neferatta) or Walach Harkon has never been made a special character is beyond me. In the the last book fluff, there was a character,"The Dark Master", from Marienburg, as well as a main Strigoi special character. An opportunity was missed with no follow up or development of that. Blood Knights should have plate armor with no point cost increase. I like the Coach as is in this edition. I think the reason for necromancers having "master of the dead" but vampires don't is to force you into thinking more about how your roster is constructed. Vampires do have "summon creatures" and when made a level 4 Lord, you're almost guaranteed to raise a bat swarm, 3 fell bats and 5 wolves per turn. Overall, I'm pretty happy. Cruddace did the new Empire book and it stinks...point increases everywhere with either weakened stat lines or zero change. That could've been us!
 
I would change the cover! But seriously my gripes are more with the core rules than the VC army book. The things that do not feel good to me all flow forth from the horrible new Undead/Unstable rule. I preferred the old rule.

and yes the fluff and especially the new Mannfred story is...derp.:slapface:
 
I would like all vampires to give a march bubble again. Having just the general do it limits us so much imo. Combine this with the other bubbles we now have from spells, corpse carts and mortis engine and it's very hard to deploy well and keep your army in range of all those things.

To me it feels like we are being forced to cram all out units into one small space and I really dislike that.
 
I don't bother. I see marching as more of a perk than a basic right. I just keep all of my stuff in formation and as long as your magic is good enough, you can compensate for the casualties with ION
 
Aside from a FAQ explaining the out the problems with raising..

Crypt Horrors...I mean...eh Big Ghouls? Comun. They really should have been Stiched Constructs of some counts. Like multiple corpses stiched togther into a bigger thing. Yes, I know I could just convert something like that, but I'm not a great converter....plus I'd know it was Crypt Horrors

I'd like Special Characters we can relate more to. First of all, they are all Von Carstein.... and to boot they are dead AND gone.

Where's Walach Harkon or Neferata? They exist and represent other bloodlines. While I dont often use SC's the vampire ones are particularly boring.

Oh and the whole fluff section. Basically a copy/paste from the last book. While the old stuff about Vlad and his friends needs to be there, it would be nice to advance the story a little.

Ogh I forgot the horrible dwarf/elven story...ergh. Out with that
 
Special Characters: I was soooo disappointed when the book came out and there was no Red Duke. Especially once I saw that Chaos Wight King. They can put that guy in but no Red Duke?

I would change the Fellbats - Seriously, compared to dire wolves whats the difference? Fellbats get to move ONE more inch with the fly rule but cost double?

Vargulf and Varghiests: Should have been one unit.

Its a very good book.
I also play Empire and that.... oh my. I started Vampire Counts in January. Then I got really excited to revamp my Empire and the army ends up being a bunch of overpriced troops relying on Heroes/Lords to hold the army together with the special rules. - feels alot like vampire counts - kill the priests/captains and the army crumbles. Talk about a stupid author.
 
Ok if I had to put it in a top 20 things I would change to limit it to stop me from getting into a really long rant, these are not in any order mind, just as they came to mind.

1) Bring back march bubble, large games on a table wider than a 4 by 4 don't work as the general can not cover the table.

2) Bring Back the Drakenhoff Banner.

3) Bring Back Forbidden Lore the Way it Used to Be.

4) Bring back Necromancy spells.

5) Make the Black Coach work in both magic Phases like it used to. (Yes we don't lose dice now but we could dounter that with Master of the Dark Arts +2 power dice, not now we can't)

6) Return Master of the Dark Arts to the way it was.

7) Return Mannfred to the way he was with 2 possible arcane items and his points back to what they were.

8) Reduce ghouls to 8 points each like they used to be.

9) Add some of the old characters we used to have in years gone by, Walach etc

10) Give us some range, just because we are dead does not mean we should not have catapults or bows, it mentions them in the damn books and TK's can do it without issue.

11) Make Dark Acolyte useful so it is +D3 to casting.

12) Bring Back Summon ghouls, Ghoul Kin (which should now effect Varghiests as well) and Lord of dead without it just being for 1 master Necro.

13) Make Heroic Killing Blow 1 nominated attack out of our total attacks and not have to swap everything for it.

14) Give Vlad Back the old Effects of Blood Drinker and not just this 1 off 4+ rubbish, also whilst you are at it, give him the full lore, he was a powerful spell caster, not as good as Mannfred but then again that why he was a higher magic level and has 2 lores, Mannfred as a hero had access to more spells than vlad, that just ain't right!

15) Bring back old equipment like Flayed Hauberk etc, to be honest bring it all back there, to many to go into but most were damn well useful.

16) Point cost isabella down to 120, she is not worth 175, getting +2 attacks, beguile and +1 strength is not worth + 85 points on her original cost, yes you get her new ability with vlad if you pay for a nearly 500 point lord!

17) Lower the Strigoi Ghoul kings points and give them profile optional upgrades like in the old days, Iron sinues etc so they can get built in say 3+ armour for +35 points.

18) Give the Terrorghiest and crypt horros a damn 4+ regen, stop it with this reduced regen rubbish, these are expensive points models with no other kind of save.

19) Get rid of the mortis engine only increasing you're regen up to a 4+

20) Make Coven thrones useful to characters so they get its inbuilt ward save as their own in addition to the + to their armour, you gave the screaming bell special rules like this and thats a big cart with a bell on it, this is a palanquin filled with vampires on a cloud of ghosts!
If that does not deserve a special consideration as far as rules go I don't know what the hell does.
 
DDM:

While I agree with a lot of your points, one also has to keep in mind that the 7.ed VC army-list was perhaps in need of a nerf to balance things out against other armies, and considering that the 8.ed book has more unit options (i.e a bigger toolkit) to boot, your suggestions (if all were implemented) would make things spiral out of control as far as balance goes, pretty quickly...
Not the biggest fan of the 8.ed book here mind you, but things were changed for a reason...
 
I know we needed a few things going and every army but ogres so far has been nerfed.
I just miss some of the old selection and items.
This is my wish list of what i wanted, some of it should 100% of been done, the mortis engine for instance increasing past 4+ is a no... But would I of like to of seen it like that?.... Hell yeh!


Now if i had to limit them:

1) Bring back march bubble, large games on a table wider than a 4 by 4 don't work as the general can not cover the table.

2) Bring Back the Drakenhoff Banner.

3) Bring Back Forbidden Lore the Way it Used to Be.

4) Bring back Necromancy spells. (for van halls and I wanted it to keep the charge ability)

7) Return Mannfred to the way he was with 2 possible arcane items and his points back to what they were.

8) Reduce ghouls to 8 points each like they used to be.

14) Give Vlad Back the old Effects of Blood Drinker and not just this 1 off 4+ rubbish, also whilst you are at it, give him the full lore, he was a powerful spell caster, not as good as Mannfred but then again that why he was a higher magic level and has 2 lores, Mannfred as a hero had access to more spells than vlad, that just ain't right!

15) Bring back old equipment like Flayed Hauberk etc, to be honest bring it all back there, to many to go into but most were damn well useful.

16) Point cost isabella down to 120, she is not worth 175, getting +2 attacks, beguile and +1 strength is not worth + 85 points on her original cost, yes you get her new ability with vlad if you pay for a nearly 500 point lord!

18) Give the Terrorghiest and crypt horros a damn 4+ regen, stop it with this reduced regen rubbish, these are expensive points models with no other kind of save.

21) Give Blood knights Full Plate.





Now thats the ones I would certainly like to see and are reasonable as most of them are return things to the old glory days.
Still want the black coach to work in both phases though.

Now I understand we have more choice now but not allot of it is practical in a competitive environment and to be honest the real winner of our new book was the crypt horrors.
 
I miss a lot of the old stuff as well DDM, but a lot I am happy to see go, purely for balance reasons.

1. I agree on the march bubble. In larger games, especially in games with random deployment, you might actually loose the game in the deployment phase, through no fault of your own. That's not how it's supposed to be... Also, the fact that we only have Frenzied Vampire units that can operate independently from the general annoys me. Why are Blood Knights Frenzied and carry Lances to boot? Oddest combination on knight ever...

2. Agreed, but in name only. The effect, combined with the new re-raise rules, would be too good a combination.

3. Depends. If various bloodlines were introduced, I'd give each one a separate set of spell lores to select their spells from, cost free..

4. Needless to say, the charge ability was a game changer. I'm ok with the changes though, but I haven't yet had enough games in 8.ed to really see how much it changed things on a large scale.

7. I liked the more versatile Mannfred as well. I kept some of that on him for the Legacies project (and also brought back his staff as a paired weapon with his sword as well).

8. I'd rather change the ghouls, to give them a new battlefield role, more in accordance with how they are in the fluff. We don'treally need a 3'rd unit compeeting with the skeletons and zombies for the role of the main battle'line (Strigoi army being the exception).

14. Yes. Blood Drinker (or the hunger rule in general) was a big disappointment overall. He should have had the weapon from the Steven Savile triology, the wailing one. As far as Vlad's spell casting goes, a lot of what he did was due to ancient scrolls written by Nagash, not necessarily his inate magical abilities. I think lvl 3 is fine here. It would undermine Mannfred too mucgh if he was also a lvl 4...

15. Hehe. Every army is going to have the same problem. Overall, I think the 10 items we got were well selected however. I've seen armies come out much worse.

16. Technically, those new abilities do cost 85 points, so that is hard to argue in some respects. Haven't tested her on the table though, so I can't really comment on her total cost as such.

18. At an increased cost?

21. No :tongue:

Remember that the cost of the black coach was not errataed with the introduction of the 8ed rulebook, so for a while there it was much more potent that originally designed. Still, it was nice though, although It did give me a bit of a "bat mobile" kind of a feeling once it started to juice up..

The crypt Horrors are very nice from a tactical standpoint, but I still remain unconvinced as far as their fluff/origins go.. Smacks a little too much of a low-budget Hollywood movie too me, and a slightly too convenient way just for the strigoi to up their strengths. :)
 
1) The thing that gets me about it apart from larger games is we can't count on our cav to take the flanks unless they are Blood Knights as the Black Knights, hex wraiths and terrorghiests may get stuck at a snails pace.
Well you do get Knights errant in Bretonia with very similar problems, I don't think that BK should have frenzy, the attack from it sure but why the hell does a Knight which is famed for self control have less control that a Strigoi for instance?

2) I want it back almost the same as it was, hell make it a 5+ instead of a 4+ but give it back, keep the points the same, come on, you let forge world make a banner of it a month or two before you removed it.

3) I really liked having the whole of a lore to choose from, it made us more tactically flexible in games.

4) Danse Macabre was a my fav spell, I did not say give it back ASF as well, just allow it to be a charge, hey there I can move 8 inches and you're 4 away, I must stop right in front of you and not go into combat because you might find it is unfair I got a chance to move again after using a chunk of my spell dice.

7) I like changing him, normally a +1 to cast and dispel and the earthing rod, now they have increased his points so he is no longer usable in most games.

8) With skeletons new points ghouls at 8 still would not cut it, its just more reasonable and they will see more use fighting monsters etc again, at 10 points they are 1 point less that GG with KB, 4+ armour/ 6+ Parry, Strength 4 with a option to take a GW.
That is more than a 1 or 2 point gap in ability.

14) I loved that sentient blade, I remember posner being disgusted by the Vampire Blade, Vlad himself though even when not using the scrolls blacked out the sky and caused thunder in his anger.
His tent was packed with the writings of Nagash and Mannfred barley managed top get anything from it, I was just saying vlad is better than a level 3, give him the lore itself and keep him the same level or give him back his old bound spell for the storm where he could ground all flyers.

15) I know but its not something I like, armies individuality is being leeched out of them.

16) If you go from the item cost they do but she has 2 wounds, toughness 4 and a 5 up save, sorry darling, you are fighting 1 chaos warrior..... Yeh, you are going to lose, its like having 2 GG without shields for defense, don't stop jack, she gets hit and she will die.

18) Round them up to 250 and I will call it a fair change.

21) Yes a thousand times.


So long as you survived the first cannon shots aimed at it. :innocent:

I can see strigoi doing it much like others do to humans which increase their strength but the mutations just don't make sense.
Perhaps true blood led the way for this upgrade?
 
8)Ghouls are well balanced at 10pts. Anything less just isn't feasible given their stats. Make them Toughness 3 and then you can reduce the points. But I too would like to see a better role for them on the field instead of competing against the skeletons.
(T3 and 7pts I like because then I could model peasant levies as the unit).

1)Changing the march bubble: It would work fine if the hero level vamps could make the unit their with march.
The current design wants you to put your Lord on that massive zombie dragon base which also gives 18" range. Even that doesn't really work because its still doesn't get your flanks and in that size of game he always gets decapitated by cannonballs or Batista.

15) I think everyone agrees that 10 items per army is too few, Should have been 15 per army.

21) Full plate on the Blood Knights is not for game design, its for the fluff and modeling. Blood Knight fluff is that they were an Empire Knightly Order. And Empire Knights have full plate. Also, the vampire lord should have access to full plate since the model riding the dragon clearing has it.
Otherwise they should change the fluff and release models that look Bretonnian.

4) I was never a fan of this 'charging out of phase with magic' spells that were all floating around.
 
I don't know if I have 20

1) I tend to agree with bring back the march bubble for vampire, if not that then perhaps any unit a vampire joins my march, and also perhaps make it so being on a large target increases the range.

2) Fobidden lore should certainly be how it use to be

3)Either bring back Necromancy spells or make it so every vampire has IoN as a free spell

4) Manfred needs some tweaking, I think his real issue is his lack of protection, I don't think he needs additional items, thats a out dated mechanic, some sort of wardsave would be nice or at the very least make his armoursave better than a 5+ so you are not forced into taking him on a steed.

5) Bring back the old bloodlines from 6th and have the powers available based on this but with a additional pool of generic powers (ASF not being one).

6) Ghouls need tweaking, honestly I would love to see them as a skirmished living unit again

7)Dark Acolyte certainly needs tweaking, +D3 to all casting does seem like the best option

8) I would also make Wraiths a skirmish unit, perhaps even a new type that allows them support attacks like MI (just no stomp obviously)

9) Allow Wraith characters and Banshee Characters magical items

10) I tend to agree that blood knights need a rethink, platemail, no frenzy sounds like a excellent start, how about devastating charge instead?

11) Werewolves! I mean proper werewolves, not wolf men, something very similar to skinwolves in stats.

Other than that I guess a nice expensive banner would be nice, just not a 4+ regen banner of auto-include, it was silly before.
 
The_Peacemaker said:
8)Ghouls are well balanced at 10pts. Anything less just isn't feasible given their stats. Make them Toughness 3 and then you can reduce the points. But I too would like to see a better role for them on the field instead of competing against the skeletons.
(T3 and 7pts I like because then I could model peasant levies as the unit).

1)Changing the march bubble: It would work fine if the hero level vamps could make the unit their with march.
The current design wants you to put your Lord on that massive zombie dragon base which also gives 18" range. Even that doesn't really work because its still doesn't get your flanks and in that size of game he always gets decapitated by cannonballs or Batista.

15) I think everyone agrees that 10 items per army is too few, Should have been 15 per army.

21) Full plate on the Blood Knights is not for game design, its for the fluff and modeling. Blood Knight fluff is that they were an Empire Knightly Order. And Empire Knights have full plate. Also, the vampire lord should have access to full plate since the model riding the dragon clearing has it.
Otherwise they should change the fluff and release models that look Bretonnian.

4) I was never a fan of this 'charging out of phase with magic' spells that were all floating around.



8) Their stats are not all that, they can not march like before, lost key vampire abilities that used to help them and all they have is toughness 4 and poison.
They are good against foes with no/ low armour be it troop or monster, nothing else in earnest.
You have to remember they have no saves of any kind.

1) We need some ability to march back, giving us a spell and saying here you go waist you're power dice to do something you should be able to do is not reasonable by any stretch of the word.
Yes Tomb Kings have this but they also have a huge amount of ranged troops, we have short range screaming.....
Also just to highlight, our Marching is 12 inches based of the magical effect of our general, it has nothing to do with leadership like inspiring presence though the larger base does make him a few inches wider which does help.

15) I don't want to see all armies restricted to the same gear, I like having the fluffyness of the gear we used to have, it gave us allot to work with.

21) Fluff reasons is why I argue it mate but it should be allowed as a character upgrade, you can't tell me they can find magical swords and giant flying screeching undead bats but not a suit of full plate armour which is found is every city through out the empire.

4) if you move into base contact it should count as a charge, for no reason would you stop before reaching them.





logan054 said:
I don't know if I have 20

1) I tend to agree with bring back the march bubble for vampire, if not that then perhaps any unit a vampire joins my march, and also perhaps make it so being on a large target increases the range.

2) Fobidden lore should certainly be how it use to be

3)Either bring back Necromancy spells or make it so every vampire has IoN as a free spell

4) Manfred needs some tweaking, I think his real issue is his lack of protection, I don't think he needs additional items, thats a out dated mechanic, some sort of wardsave would be nice or at the very least make his armoursave better than a 5+ so you are not forced into taking him on a steed.

5) Bring back the old bloodlines from 6th and have the powers available based on this but with a additional pool of generic powers (ASF not being one).

6) Ghouls need tweaking, honestly I would love to see them as a skirmished living unit again

7)Dark Acolyte certainly needs tweaking, +D3 to all casting does seem like the best option

8) I would also make Wraiths a skirmish unit, perhaps even a new type that allows them support attacks like MI (just no stomp obviously)

9) Allow Wraith characters and Banshee Characters magical items

10) I tend to agree that blood knights need a rethink, platemail, no frenzy sounds like a excellent start, how about devastating charge instead?

11) Werewolves! I mean proper werewolves, not wolf men, something very similar to skinwolves in stats.

Other than that I guess a nice expensive banner would be nice, just not a 4+ regen banner of auto-include, it was silly before.





1) Yes, me likey! :thumbsup:

2) Miss the old ability far to much, such potent magic armies we once had.

3) Natural affinity with the dead, certainly makes sense all them having this spell as they use to.

4) Well a 5+ ward is certainly reasonable enough in my eyes.

5) I think we older players will be trumpeting this point till we are in our graves.

6) I don't think they would work as skirmishers, not with everything now favoring the huge unit.

7) Well lets hope they do something with the damn thing.

8) Not sure on that, I am happy with them as they are, I don't think they need any such extra attacks, that would make them seem more like on foot hex wraiths.

9) They are powerful raised dead, not sure they would have any ability to have a will of their own any longer beyond what they have become, a character normally has a keen mind, also even old vamps ethereal meant you could not take magic items, thats stuff just falls straight off.

10) Just give them the Extra attack as a special rule called something fluffy Like "Immortal Blade Masters" allowing them an extra attack on their 2 on the basic stat and a 6+ parry in combat even though mounted like ogre cav.

11) Sorry, they always seem to give dark gothic vampire beasties to chaos because GW love their money maker so much....
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu