What's with High Elves?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

PureSphinx

Ghoul
Jul 16, 2014
178
Zombies
153
I don't know if it's just me or if high elves are stupid good. I mean, a core unit that gets 4 ranks of Melee attacks (5 in horde) AND 3 ranks of better shooting than a lot of armies' specials? Or a 10 woman unit of sisters reforming, marching through a forest and then shooting through cover out of said forest and still hitting on 2s? Wounding on 2s? Turning my 1+ cold one Knights to 5+?

Their bolt throwers can shoot directly at characters in units, their special units can beat a ten man unit of Blood Knights after the Knights got the charge, and those magic items!!! I have a dispel scroll for 25 points and oh yeah, it decimates your wizard. Banner of the Win Dragon makes this unit invincible, and they are also unbreakable ASF great weapon users with two attacks apiece.

Did I mention that Dragon Prince horses beat Nagash to death? HORSES, people! Why are they so strong? Please tell me that my opponent is misunderstanding his rules. If not... How do I beat them? As it stands I surrender every game against HE before it even starts, because I can't even bring the game to a draw with any of my four armies. Help would be appreciated
 
Those Great Weapons cancel ASF and make them strike at Initiative order, for one. Also, T3 across the board is squishy. Run up and bash on them. Sister are Quick to Fire only with a Handmaiden in the unit, and if she has the magic S5 (I think?) bow, only her arrows get the S buff.
 
I tried running up to bash but the spearmen that also have bows just stand and shoot to decimate half the unit and then ASF 30 attacks with rerolls decimate the other half. I've never used artillery and I haven't used much shooting, but his bolt throwers don't have Sniper he just draws a straight line with his tape hitting my character and all the guys behind him and saying "this is where I'm shooting." And yeah I'm pretty sure he thinks all the sisters get S5 AP shots and that they ignore shooting through cover with quick to fire. I don't have a HE codex handy else I'd read it all myself.
 
Yeah he's power gamer to the point of "I don't care how cool the thing is or how friendly the game is, I play to win and if you don't like it I'm just gonna insult your skills and say that's why you want to play a friendly game because you can't handle losing."

Not to make him sound like an ass because we are actually good friends, he's just really competitive and stuff.
 
Have you heard of dark elfs? These guys do have that fucking banner though. It's the only item in warhammer I flat out don't think should exist.
 
Sounds like your friend isn't playing by the rules. He's playing to fast and loose. My advice, slow down, play lower point values and learn the rules fully before increasing the points.

Elves are beatable. Another thing, if you are new to the game (assuming this since you both seem to be learning the game) undead armies have a high learning curve. You will continue to lose until you have a solid grasp on not only the basic rules, but fear, magic, moving characters, crumble, fighting outclassed match ups and knowing how to maximize reforms and redirectors. Once you've got a handle on that stuff, undead become an amazing and very rewarding army.
 
Last edited:
Yeah he's power gamer to the point of "I don't care how cool the thing is or how friendly the game is, I play to win and if you don't like it I'm just gonna insult your skills and say that's why you want to play a friendly game because you can't handle losing."

Not to make him sound like an ass because we are actually good friends, he's just really competitive and stuff.


He's also a cheater as Ballistic Skill shooting (which bolt throwers are) cannot target points. They shoot at the unit and you take rank and file off first until you are down to less than 5 rank and file in which case you allocate one hit per model until every model has one before you allocate the second hit. I think both of you should read the 'shooting' section of the basic rule book again before you play your next battle. :redface: You are mixing up cannons and bolt throwers and even cannons allow a "look out sir" roll.
 
Have you heard of dark elfs? These guys do have that fucking banner though. It's the only item in warhammer I flat out don't think should exist.
I play Dark Elves actually. I admit they are also a pain in the ass to play against, but I think he's just misinterpreting rules, like @Yorga said. I won't lie - I didn't bother with the shooting section in my reading of the rulebook, and I'm sure you can guess why :)

@najo I am definitely still learning the game, but this guy's been playing for 7(?) years, while I've only just started in late 8th edition (a year ago at most). Of my four armies, I actually do best with Beastmen because they are simple and straightforward in their playstyle. I can theoryhammer undead for days, but when I get to the table it's just practice because I can't seem to carry my theoryhammering into the game.
 
Have you heard of dark elfs? These guys do have that fucking banner though. It's the only item in warhammer I flat out don't think should exist.

The World Dragon Banner can be dealt with, just feed it a zombie unit and keep it replenished during the game. If you are still having issues, don't give your VL a magic weapon and send his unit at the appropriate group of elves.
 
I'm going to second what @Seneschal is saying about BotWD and go one further. First, build a vampire lord blender and give him additional hand weapon. The elves are dead.

Second, BotWD is not broken. It gives high elves an anvil unit against daemons and allows them to curb enemy magic and tooled up characters. That banner is easily dealt with by flanking tactics, redirection, hexes, tarpitting etc. Plus elves are soft. Honestly, that banner was potentially bold game design on the edge of OP, but bold none the less.

@PureSphinx Read your rulebook in bits and pieces each game. Reread and really learn rules on reforming, charging, moving and panic. That is the heart of the game. Then learn shooting and in this case bolt throwers. What point size are you two playing BTW?
 
What point size are you two playing BTW?
Our group plays anywhere from 500 - 3000 depending on the day, but on average its around 1500 - 2400. Smaller if we are just starting an army, like the last game against him I played with my new Daemons, which we played at 1300 points. BTW, he didn't take BotWD against me that game, it's just something to complain about :)
 
Our group plays anywhere from 500 - 3000 depending on the day, but on average its around 1500 - 2400. Smaller if we are just starting an army, like the last game against him I played with my new Daemons, which we played at 1300 points. BTW, he didn't take BotWD against me that game, it's just something to complain about :)
Sounds like your friend needs to slow down and really learn the game. My advice is everyone play a bunch of 1000pt games focusing on rules.

As for the banner, easy way to deal with it is blight kings. Pure daemon way, run either nurgle, death, shadow or Slaanesh magic. Then hex it and flank the unit. It should die.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu