Where'd I Go Wrong?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Luthor

Zombie
Apr 9, 2009
3
Zombies
6
Today I managed to get some Warhammer in, and to sum it up I was crushed under a ton of Ogres... If anyone has any advice as to where I went wrong it would be much appreciated.

1750 pts - Ogres vs. VC + Bretts

My List:

The deploy on our side looked like this:

From left to write: Black Knights, Varghulf, Skellies, Corpse Cart w/ Vamp Behind It, and then more Skellies.

Then Men at Arms, Bowmen, Knights, and Lord.

The Ogres went: Tyrant, Bulls, Gnoblers, Bulls, Ironguts, Leadbelchers, Hunter, and then Man Eaters.

Turn 1 -
Ogres go first as Bretts opt for the Blessing of the Lady, and thus we decided I also have to wait. Ogres move up and I found that in the next two turns I would be getting crushed no matter what. The Ogre Tyrant moved behind some brush, and the Scrap Launcher Fired and smashed 3 Skeletons.

Bretts + VC
I ready myself for the charge, and flank charge my Black Knights into the Tyrants flank. Magic raises a few things here and there but is generally ineffective.

Turn 2 -
Ogres continue to move up, and a few magic spells later more skeletons are dead. The scrap launcher fires and kills 9 skeletons with a direct hit...

Bretts + VC
More magic attempts only one spell gets off because 3 of them rolled below a 3, sigh again... Black Knights move through the brush and attack the Tyrant's flank. The Tyrant challenges my Black Knight Champ and overkills him because I can't hide. 3 Black Knights crumble as a result, sigh...

Turn 3 -
Ogres hit home, Bulls flank the skeleton unit and Ironguts hit the front. Another unit of Bulls and some Gnoblers get ready to attack next turn. Scrap launcher fires at the Bretts. Ogres kill all of the skeletons. Final Black Knight dies.

VC + Bretts
Varghulf charges Ogre Bulls. Second Skeleton Unit charges the Ogres head on. Corpse Cart charges the Bulls flank, and my Vamp legs it away. I raise some Zombies to block the Ironguts from flanking the Corpse Cart. Vargulf and Skellies kill the Bulls due to some good rolls, and prepare to meet the Tyrant. Bulls wound the Cart twice.

Turn 4 -
Ironguts charge the zombies, and the Tyrant charges the Varghulf. Gnoblers throw sharp stuff to no effect. Zombies are slain easily, Corpse Cart is crushed. Varghulf almost dies due to the Tenderizer, but does two wounds to the Tyrant.

VC + Bretts
Skellies charge the Gnoblers who hold, Why!?! Vamp legs it away to not get crushed under the Ironguts. In the magic phase I heal the Varghulf to full, and in battle the Skellies cause the Gnoblers to flee, and run them down with double sixes, Irresistible Pursue! The Tenderizer is also the Tyrant's undoing as the Varghulf goes first and cuts him down.

Turn 5 -
Ogre Ironguts move forwards at the Vamp, Bulls move to attack the Varghulf.

VC + Bretts
Skellies move to get back into the combat, and the Varghulf charges the Bulls. Vamp summons Skellies to block the Ironguts so he doesn't die like usual. Varghulf does two wounds, but crumbles two in return.

Turn 6 -
Ironguts cut down the zombies, and Varghulf holds barely.

VC + Bretts
Skellies charge Bulls to no effect, and Varghulf is cut down. Vamp does an alamo charge and does one wound to the Ogre Butcher in a challenge.

The ogres managed to pull out a minor victory, I just couldn't get any rolls or any flank charges the whole game. The Bretts had it bad as well, and lost their Bowmen and Men-at-Arms due to Fear, but managed to clear their table side of Ogres with only Knights and a Lord. Granted they only fought a unit of LeadBelchers, Man Eaters, and a Hunter.
 
Well, other than the dice gods looking spitefully upon you, there were only a few spots where I saw any problems.

1)You were at a disadvantage from the start, having to wait for your bretonnian ally. Granted, going second has its advantages, in this case, seizing the initiative may have been more advantageous. Not your fault, that's something that didn't become clear until you until your skeletons were dual charged by bulls and ironguts.

2) I would never recommend putting a Corpse Cart into close combat, that thing is just too unreliable, keep it back for support.

3) In the end, instead of bonzai charging the butcher with your vamp, I would have tried to get him into a position to Spam Raise dead for table quarters.

You played a good game friend, mostly the Dice Gods just decided to mess around with you today.
 
Vargulf and BK's should combo-charge their target together.

CC in combat is a desperation move.

I'm guessing the Butcher was in a unit. Solo vamp vs unit = powdered vamp due to static rez.

It looks like you needed more magic support for your units. One caster? If you're going low magic, you have to have a very offensive build. Ghouls are more effective than skellies vs ogres because of twin poison attacks. They are also a more effective offensive unit.

It also looks like you had trouble with unit positioning (something I struggle with myself). If your units are in a wall, it is harder for your opponent to take your flanks.

You had no way to march block your opponent, aside from summoned zombies. As you are playing a low-magic list, that isn't much of an option. Some Fell Bats would have been handy.
 
Yeah, as soon as I deployed I saw a huge error, me and my Brett ally had about a 8" gap between our lines where the Ironguts deployed. I wheeled my Skeletons to take the Ironguts head on and the Bulls in the flank, instead of the other way around. Sadly, they were smashed to bits by a Rhinox.

I didn't think of trying to negate table quarters, but my Vamp was mostly hiding or running the whole game when my lines collapsed, spawning zombies as he ran (saved his life, as it held up the Ironguts).

As for the CC I have decided it is genuinely ineffective with Unholy Lodestone at such small points games, really only raising one or two skellies. The Balefire would have been much more useful to negate his casting of +1 T spells and Stubborn spells, which saved his unit of Bulls from total destruction and caused my Varghulf to die.

I'd like to think the dice weren't biased but perhaps they were, I failed 3 IoN in a row... 4 Re-rollable Varghulf attacks...my and my dice rolling record in other games is legendary. Triple 1's, and then 4 1's out of 5 right in a row...
 
My advice would be if you know you will be playing against Ogres, take Konrad. He excells against Ogres.. I managed to do 20+ wounds in one round of combat with him against some Bulls, all before the rest of his unit did their attacks. It was brilliant.
 
Also keep in mind of those nasty charges. Ogres get these Bull Charges, which act as Impact Hits IIRC. It's best to march block them and charge them first. This often means you either need a speedy army or lots of magic. He surprisingly got some magic through too, which could have been stopped.

I agree with Fodderboy. The points you pay for Skeletons having armour is nullified by half his army or at least reduced some bit (excepting those Gnoblars). Ghouls would have been a nice addition instead of Skeletons. The points you pay for Poison and 2 A's would have been well worth it (too bad they aren't Skirmishers anymore).

Also, no idea why the Brett player took Men at Arms and Bowmen. They suck so much. :wow2: He could've brought what VC lack - a Trebuchet, or some more much needed Heavy Cavalry with a 1+ AS (or 2+... whatever). This would've added more speed.
 
In a unit of 5 black knights you should always be able to move a champ to a postion where a lone tyrant on a 40mm base cannot be in contact with him.

therefore, you have somewhere for him to "hide". Never accept a challenge from an ogre tyrant if at all possible.

He also got rather lucky with scrappie shots - 2 hitting something and it not ripping itself to shreds is only a dream for most ogr players :)

As an ogre player myself (as my primary army) I must say that VC is one of the better matchups for them though - ogres causing fear and being multi-wound tend to take down lowly dead things pretty easily...
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu