Why do we not have Skeleton Archers???

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I my self believe the vampires lack the ranged weaponry as a whole because they want their enemies to see death up close, and have total fear of what they would become should they die, as most vampires appear to me to be kind of toying with their enemies. showing them the true power of the undead the endless tide up close. perhaps a fear of some unnatural desecration which will befall all the living.

where as tk are more interested in their own lands and killing those who would disturb, or stumble upon their artefacts and try to steal them as such so killing with out the same joy. also the tomb kings are more like the wights and are ancient warriors rarely raisng new dead so would have the weapons already to hand as well, however vampires make ther armies as they go. but thats IMO
 
GW would never make an archer unit specifically for VC for a few reasons,
1, They already make archers for TK so if your'e playing a friendly game you could always use them and adapt the rules.
2, GW are a business after all and they can only make a unit mould if they think the uptake is high enough to warrant the production costs, I reckon it wouldn't be.
3, VC just aren't that sort of army both in the fluff and on the battlefield, standing and shooting just isn't their style.

On a personal note I would also add that archers are never that effective anyway and what's wrong with giving them a good old fashioned club round the head?
I think its very much a case of you want what you don't have and if you did have them you wouldn't want them.
 
True that vlad. I wish we had arches just to have them! I think they might be useful if it were an upgrade for skellies because getting to stand and shoot, however unfluffly, would be a good thing!
 
Ferrum said:
True that vlad. I wish we had arches just to have them! I think they might be useful if it were an upgrade for skellies because getting to stand and shoot, however unfluffly, would be a good thing!

You make it sound as though Vampire Counts don't have enough options already, which I find a bit odd. I think that there is already sufficient variety in the book.

I also have to disagree with your about the background. There are enough issues with players looking to break background conventions in the game these days, so let's not encourage the army book writers to start going down that route as well :).
 
Sanai said:
I think complaining about an army not having random things is silly.
Something isnt finished when theres nothing left to add, it when theres nothing left to take away, and all that is left is what it needs.
Does the army book really need archers, catapults, necromancer lords, wight lords, vampiric infantry, zombie giants, zombie ogres, zombie crossbowmen, human levies, undead fliers and zombie horsemen?

Everything but human levies and Zombie horseman, heck yes!
 
BS2 Archers, even with S&S would be 100% useless. No one would field them AND I guarantee players would whine over the unit being useless. GW would never ever hear the end of it...

Like Irisado, I hope GW never go down that road. Army design gives the army focus and flavour. Throwing in random units into army books that neither needs or deserves them is just bad design. There are always tons of various themes possible within an army book and to account for all them would make balancing the game a bigger mess than it already is.
Not that I have any illusions about fantasy becoming a balanced game but this isn't a good arguement to make it even messier.

However, GW encourages house rules and fan-made lists. It's a game and if you can convince your club to let you use TK archers or a version of your own, give it a try. Just be prepared to meet resistence and be a good sport about it.
 
The reason VC don't have archers like most people have said is to set them apart from Tomb Kings.

The in character justification as to why VC dont have archers and tomb kings do lies right at the core of each armies fluff.

Nagash mastered the art of unlife so to speak and was able to sustain it with no side effects. The mummies and skeletons of the tomb kings have been raised flawlessly so to speak so I guess they retain control over themselves.

The vampires got there immortality and power from the elixer of life that Neferata created using a book she obtained from nagash. It's like a 2nd hand or unofficial version of the magic the tomb kings use. The vampires just raise the flesh and the bones and very little else I suppose.

Thats how I understand it. It's my opinion though and it sits well with me. :P
 
That makes a lot of sense, very little of the dead warriors soul and self returns with the body. The vampire counts have no need of independent thinkers within their armies, and if they do they just use thralls and necromancers to fill the gaps!
 
Personally i surely miss legal units of skeletons armed with crossbows and scythes, like they had in really early army books. those grim reapers where awesome!

I do, however, have a unit of 10 skeleton archers that i regularly field in battle, and ive yet to have a single opponent complain, so no worries there. of course, they have only BS2 (and no TK asp arrows or anything), regular bows and cost 3 points extra per model for it. They are actually so useless they have yet to cause a single kill in ranged battle. I guess that is why noone ever complains...

But how I love to use them nonetheless. that unit always makes me laugh, trying to hit on 8+ or 9+... its fun to have a shooting phase, even if it is totally useless.

And i definitively think that bows, or maybe rather crossbows, are totally in flavour of a Sylvanian or medieval vampire army. With crossbows the occational hit could actually cause some harm too.
 
I think it would also look strange
As said before vampire counts want to toy with their opponents, amd giving them a look of what they will become (a brainless zombie)
A ranged unit would take that idea away

What I would wanna see is a flesh golem :D
But that´s not what this thread is about
 
I'd rather see a necromancer with some kind of wand which could count as a ranged weapon! :D

Pewpew laser beam!
 
see, i personally feel that the VC background as whole does support a limited amount of missile troops;
- the armies of neferata and her court very closely resemble the armies of ancient lahmia, so skeleton archers & catapults would be there for sure!
it's even rummored that the silver pinacle has a form of ushabti guardians...

- the hosts of sylvania are built around the former state army, so things like archers & zombie crossbowmen would fit. plus, vlad used all manner of war engines when he assaulted altdorf...

- the army of blood keep is the same host of men-at-arms and retainers that were killed by walach when he cursed the order with undeath. empire knights like their bretonnian counter-parts eshew missile weapons themselves, but they still retain a small cadre of lowborn servents who would wield crossbows/longbows...

- the army of the red duke. just like the forces of blood keep, an army of a former bretonnian knight turned blood dragon would likely include zombie pesants with bows.

the only VC's that don't really fit the idea of a small number of missile troops would be the necrarchs & the strigoi. the idea of giving us back skellies w/bows and/or zombies w/xbows isn't just because we want them! it's also because we're the only army without a shooting phase! hell, even all 3 chaos armies get shooting!
it doesn't have to be alot, or even that effective, but just to give those VC players who want a full game turn the chance to have one! or else to help further theme an army to your chosen idea. (ie: the army of the red duke)

tomb kings can keep their uniqueness by having a higher set to-hit roll than VC's, and then have the option to stand and shoot (ala 'war memories' rummor), while VC missile troops don't get that option... (because overall they are simply re-animated corpses)

i just feel that overall, our book lacks alot of variety & choice due to how badly 8th ed has effected us... look no further than the tournament scene, almost every VC army has the same unit structure! a sure sign that our book is seriously lacking in flexability and/or viable choices.
now we should never be able to gunline! but, for fun and added flavor it would be awsome to get the chance to rol some dice in the shooting phase and maybe inflict a kill or two over the corse of the game!

cheers!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Helman Ghorst
Would make tomb kings seem like Vampire Counts in a desert, rather than their own specific army.

But the idea of VC skeleton archers is pretty cool, I wouldn't mind having a go at converting some...
 
there is A LOT more differenting the two undead armies, adding zombie crossbowmen or armoured skeleton crossbowmen or something would hardly make the armies look as one.
 
Cuzzy said:
I think it would also look strange
As said before vampire counts want to toy with their opponents, amd giving them a look of what they will become (a brainless zombie)
A ranged unit would take that idea away

Furthermore, consider how Vampires see their enemies. Enemies are the equivalent of a milk bottle.

Now, to open a milk bottle, of course you can stand 100ft away, take your shotgun, shoot at the bottle, walk over and drink the milk. However, by then it will all have spilled.

Conversely, you can walk up close and open it. This way, you get more of the content.

See what I mean?
 
i'm confident that in 6 years we will have skeleton crossbowmen, the lore points that because they are being controlled by vampires they cant shoot blah blah blah... but more importantly skeletons are reaching the point of worthlessness, and lets face it the only core offensively worth using are ghouls. So i suppose we wait patiently and maybe almighty Mat Ward will throw us some crossbows.
 
Or the almighty Mat ward makes the skeletons somewhat more powerfull in battle, and maybe a bit cheaper. Then we suddenly will use skeletons again.
I just don´t like the idea of skeleton bowmen. I you really want them you should´ve chosen tomb kings.
 
Cuzzy said:
Or the almighty Mat ward makes the skeletons somewhat more powerfull in battle, and maybe a bit cheaper. Then we suddenly will use skeletons again.
I just don´t like the idea of skeleton bowmen. I you really want them you should´ve chosen tomb kings.

that's your opinion. and perhaps at one time it was right to say, 'suck it up, we're vampires, GW have said no shooting for us!'

but that's changed! look at the chaos armies. they also at one time belonged in the 'no shooting units allowed' category. but GW has shifted that belief because it's not fair to disallow an army an entire phase of the game!!! (the sole exception being dwarves & magic)

thus, when the VC book is redone, we should get some basic shooting based on that principle of 'fairness' and because GW want to give players the ability to play their book to fit any theme that's in the established background...

now, to keep us different from tomb kings, the idea is an easy one: instead of skeleton archers, give us zombie levies!
this solves two problems;
a) defines a proper role between skellies & zombies. zombies provide either big blocks of mindless tarpits, or carry bows/xbows.
b) GW produces new zombies w/bows/xbows and perhaps polearms?!!

it would also give us a reason to take zombies as a viable tacticle option! right now there's no reason to actually take zombies - they're too expensive for what you get & it's far cheaper to raise them!!!

cheers!
 
you do realise that zombies are not the type that can aim and shoot right?

they're more like run,kill,eat..

plus a hooting unit would make this army a bit too powerful. you start with some blocks of undead and keep raising them and raising them until God knows how many ranged models you have.
 
Dark master said:
you do realise that zombies are not the type that can aim and shoot right?

they're more like run,kill,eat..

plus a hooting unit would make this army a bit too powerful. you start with some blocks of undead and keep raising them and raising them until God knows how many ranged models you have.

the run-kill-eat steriotype is hollywood. the historical idea of living dead is more of the slow, shambling undead...

and a shooting unit would not make us OP... we would likely get a set to-hit roll similar to tomb kings. (though likely a bit worse since they are zombies afterall!)

as for the 'raising a huge swarm of shooty goodness' issue, it's simple really; no VC unit can be raised beyond their starting unit size! we handle that limitation well enough with our current book anyways.
it could also give you a reason to raise a unit of 'basic/naked' zombies, since those would be the types that could be invo'd as high you can take 'em!


the big problem with our book right now is two-fold;
a) the big holes in our list. lack of shooting & monstrous units.
b) the inflexability of our units. overall VC armies tend to have a fairly rigid structure; ghouls + grave guard + small amount of personal flavor.
but if you go to any tournament, you can bet that 95%+ of all the VC armies in attendance will be almost identicle in terms of actual unit structure! (only the characters will have a much greater deal of variety because we all have our little gems!)

cheers!
 
Anubis said:
but that's changed! look at the chaos armies. they also at one time belonged in the 'no shooting units allowed' category. but GW has shifted that belief because it's not fair to disallow an army an entire phase of the game!!! (the sole exception being dwarves & magic)

And look how that turned out. Ungors with shortbows :|:thumbsdown:
Just like zombies they are not the kind of creatures that can work up the patience to handle a ranged weapon.
 
I have only just started building my army and haven't actually used them in a battle yet however just from reading around the internet it seems to be a general consensus that skele's and zombies are basically useless in their current form.

Now being that this topic is about whether something should be added or not what is the opinion of you experienced players about the core units in VC army?

Are they useless and should something be added or do you find that you go into a game with armies like Empire and Brettonia feeling as though you can win?

Not trying to be a trouble maker just trying to get some perspective as a new player because I have had the same thoughts in that something is missing :)
 
I like the lack of shooting...it means the dead almost always attack.They are coming to get you :scared:.The inability to make the enemy cross the board makes us more monstrous somehow.Also,if we were able to sit back and shoot while ION raising our troop count;this would create a two fold problem for the enemy which would be very tough to deal with.
We would have an absurd advantage in a shooting war as well...as our casualties get up.I think this is why they don't let us shoot.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu