Why do we not have Skeleton Archers???

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Count Lasombra said:
...We would have an absurd advantage in a shooting war as well...as our casualties get up.I think this is why they don't let us shoot.

and yet, no one complains that tomb king archers do just that! they shoot, a bunch get shot back, the skellies get back up...
the key to it all working is to simply prevent the unit from going beyond it's starting unit size.

for us to have shooting and keep it balanced, it simply needs to follow along the lines of the tomb kings; basic missile weapons, (bow/long bow, maybe a higher pts cost crossbow at most), a set to-hit score that takes into account that the troops aren't that good at shooting, and finally a rule to stop the VC player from summoning a huge hoard of shooty death!


as for the question about zombies & skellies being poop right now. well, they are!
zombies are the worst troops in the game, and they were pointed for 7th ed when fear was over-powered. in 8th ed, they should cost maybe 1pt/model at the moment! it's quite easy to see the fightier unit in the game, (anything with 2 or more attacks & S4+), kill off 30-40 zombies easily through combat + crumbling damage...
zombies don't even tarpit anymore because you need stupidly high numbers of them. they also can't be used to support an on-going combat because your opponent will simply shift focus to them and then all your units will take the crumbling damage!:'(

skellies i've found are only usable as a bunker for a caster vampire/general, and to provide an additional banner or two for certain senarios.
now, i've also found that if you take light magic, skellies become better than most other core in the game! light magic nullifies the 2 biggest problems the skeletons suffer from; piss-poor WS & I. when your magic works, you can suddenly be faced with WS10/I10 & ASF skellies! now your unit will fight in a similar fasion to elf spear hoards... (lots of diddly all adding up)
light magic synergises well with the lore of metal, beasts and our own VC lore too. still, it doesn't make skellies miles above ghouls, since magic is unreliable and random. if your spells don't take effect, those skellies are gonna die quite quickly!

cheers!
 
I think it makes sense for TK because they are supposed to be defensive dead.Athough,giving them units of chariots is a strong incentive to charge.They are good damage interdiction as well,which conspires w/ the ballistics.
I'm looking forward to the new TK book,it may give us some insight into where we may be headed as well.
 
I really do not see the lack of ogre-sized units or shooting as a hole in the army.

and yet, no one complains that tomb king archers do just that! they shoot, a bunch get shot back, the skellies get back up...
the key to it all working is to simply prevent the unit from going beyond it's starting unit size.

for us to have shooting and keep it balanced, it simply needs to follow along the lines of the tomb kings; basic missile weapons, (bow/long bow, maybe a higher pts cost crossbow at most), a set to-hit score that takes into account that the troops aren't that good at shooting, and finally a rule to stop the VC player from summoning a huge hoard of shooty death!

Have you read the Tomb King book? Their skeletons cost more, their TG don't have access to GWs(but might get those in the new one), the only thing remotely like an offencive hammer unit are their chariots and those doesn't exactly fare well in the 8th. Their rare consist of a stone thrower and an expencive giant type. They do have an ogre-sized unit but it is quite costly and unstable/enemy ranks/supporting attacks hurts in unit a lot. Their hierophant who keeps their entire army up and going has T3 with 3 wounds at best and the only characters that can heal the army cannot march and have access to very little in the way of protection and are always T3.

So yeah, arguing that because TK can heal their units VC should get shooting too is not even close to a compelling argument to my ears. Why should VC get something for free and why should VC suddenly get a special rule unique to TK?

I think it is inevitable that VC are getting a monster unit though, seems to be all the rage and every army book MUST have at least one.
 
i'm not trying to deny that the tomb king book is utter poop! we all know that TK's suck in 8th and have litterly nothing going for them...
still, while expensive, ushabtii do start to really pay for themselves at higher pts levels where you can bring a unit of 6-8 into the fight!

anyways, my argument is that GW has about-faced in terms of one of their 'army design rules'. namely that certain armies were always denied abilities like shooting. (chaos warriors, daemons & beastmen alongside us VC's being the main ones)
however, GW has shifted their stance and given some light shooting to those other armies. it's not terribly effective true, but it's there and adds another layer of tactical depth to those armies. (complain all you want that ungor shooting sucks, small units of bow-totting skirmishers are still bloody annoying to deal with and are great for hunting other small units!)
my complaint is that it's completely unfair if GW denies us the same oppertunities! if friggin chaos warriors get access to the game's best stone thrower, then why can't VC's have some basic S3/4 shooting as well?

sure our army is ment to be offensive, but it's fun to able to build a challenging and highly themed army as well!
plus, there's alot of times that a bit of light shooting would really help too... enemy gunlines, craptastic magic phases and/or massive hoards are all a huge problem for non-ghoul spam + gravestar VC's to face. why the hell should i be forced into the same old boring build just so i can compete?!
at least with some shooting ability, and to an extent a monstrous unit which gains more supporting attacks, i can open up alot of new possible play styles! (and really, the push-push-charge is getting beyond silly now...)

there is a damn good reason that all VC armies look almost identicle in terms of unit selection. perhaps if we were to eventually gain the range of choice that tomb kings will soon be blessed with, everyone else might also stop complaining that VC's are just a cheesey 'i win' button too!

cheers!
 
I wouldn't bitch about a little shooting being added to the list.But,if it was made clear to me that the shooting would mean a reduction of magical or combat ability..I'd vote against it.
 
i'm not trying to deny that the tomb king book is utter poop! we all know that TK's suck in 8th and have litterly nothing going for them...
still, while expensive, ushabtii do start to really pay for themselves at higher pts levels where you can bring a unit of 6-8 into the fight!

That is 390-520 points. It is a rare day when they earn their points.

there is a damn good reason that all VC armies look almost identicle in terms of unit selection. perhaps if we were to eventually gain the range of choice that tomb kings will soon be blessed with, everyone else might also stop complaining that VC's are just a cheesey 'i win' button too!

Judging from the limited rumours we have there doesn't seem to much changing for TK other than the extra big monster and a war machine. Well, the magic phase looks to see a complete overhaul but holefully will retain some level of the old nehekharan flavour. The streamlining of army lists seem to be a fairly universal development, ie, load up on 2-3 core infantry + 1-2 special elite blocks(unless this is already possible in core) and the rest goes into magic/shooting depending on army.
 
Personally I am not bothered about skellie archers. I might be tempted more by crossbows, but even then with their WS it is just not going to be cost effective.

Skellies / Zombies are crap, but sticking a bow on their arm is not going top fix that. To be fixed the three main core (ghouls / skellies / zombies) need to be clearly put in their own category, to make each viable. For example:

Ghouls: lower T to 3. leave rest as is. They are our offensive core.
Skellies: Free command, extra weapons options. These are the cheap anvils, bunkers etc.
Zombies: Increase T to 3 or even 4. Their role will be pure cheap tarpitting.

Pointed rightly wound make things a lot better than giving us shooting.

The only thing I might be interested in is maybe a warmachine of some kind...but then to be honest I would just prefer to have my Vampire Lord back with four wounds.
 
for our main core, i'd personally like to see the following styles;
- ghouls; go back to a skirmisher unit. bump their movement up slightly to M5 so they can reliably work their way around the enemy's flanks.
it would also fit their imagry a bit better since they're supposed to be rather cowardly little gits, skulking about in the shadows and preying upon the helpless!

- skeletons; add in options for additional hand weapons or maybe halberds? give 'em the option for heavy armour since we already have the damn models anyways!

- zombies; at least T3, 4 isn't a huge stretch since we know that currently those ghouls die pretty damn fast anyways!
keep 'em at S2 and they'll be fine, along the same lines as skaven slaves or gobbos as a reliable, cheap tarpit.

shooting would be nice too!:redface:
 
How about a large corporal catapult throwing zombies in enemy regiments :lol:


Anubis said:
for our main core, i'd personally like to see the following styles;
- ghouls; go back to a skirmisher unit. bump their movement up slightly to M5 so they can reliably work their way around the enemy's flanks.
it would also fit their imagry a bit better since they're supposed to be rather cowardly little gits, skulking about in the shadows and preying upon the helpless!

I agree with this, I also see them as those little critters that hide in the shaddows and attack the flanks.

I also think DoN made some good points (wich I´m to lazy to quote).
 
well, the other point of making ghouls back into skirmishers is it adds some much needed flexibility to our movement phase, plus it opens the door for GW to create a new special unit of lightly armoured charnel guard/strigany.

i think one of the biggest reasons why i really want us to gain some shooting is because alot of the local players here take huge advantage of VC's right now... (we have ALOT! of WAAC types in my area now that our local GW is closed.:'()
basically, a little bit of shooting would help us deal with tactics like skaven armies using 4-5+ 30 strong slaves units to tarpit & shoot down our best units.

the fact that we have pretty much no way of dealing with multiple, cheap tarpit units before they get to us is a huge disadvantage... magic is too unreliable, and we have better uses for it than blasting a 100pts tarpit out of the way!
a bit of shooting though, and we'd at least get a way to knock off a rank or two, or perhaps force a panic test...

cheers!
 
I think the question you have to ask yourselves here is, "What would we shoot with?" Would our Skeleton warriors have the option to take bows? Our BS2 Skeletons? I think not. Tomb King arrows are all blessed by their Asp Goddess, so they always hit on 5+. This, along with the ability to double-tap in the magic phase, is one of the reasons their shooting is so powerful. But could the Vampire Counts ever come close to this? Where's our goddess' blessing? Moreover, where's our goddess? VC Skeleton archers would be really laughable, and they would probably hit most things on a 6 or 7+.

The one bit of VC shooting that I could imagine is a zombie-chucking contraption, a kind of necromantic construction like the Corpse Cart. It would probably be similar to the TK's Screaming Skull Catapault, except with a lower strength, no flaming attacks, and maybe some other goodies like poison.
 
i would instead suggest the zombies to be the guys to carry our missile weapons. (if we get any). it helps to further define them from skeletons too, since right now they're almost identical in terms of being banner-toting tarpits...

as to the crappy BS, well, it's not to hard to imagine the willpower of the vampire 'guiding' the undead to aim properly. or perhaps instead of 'blessings', our missile weapons are cursed to seek-out the blood of the living?!
either way, i think if we had a strait 6+ to-hit roll, it wouldn't be so bad. as for shooting in the magic phase? we don't need to get an option for it, but it could provide the basis for a new necromancy spell... (and would also provide a buff in general since i'd bet we'll lose the staff of damnation as an actual magic item if the trend continues!)

mind you, a zombie catapult would be quite humoruos as well! i'd just like to see us get some kind of semi-decent option for the shooting phase to really help combat enemies who abuse multiple cheap tarpits and/or massive gunlines.

cheers!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu