Wraith Scythes: why farm implements?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
What if you greenstuffed some ghostly remnants to the blade? Kinda like the remnants of the target's soul were being "reaped" from the body?
 
Well 2 whole years later and the New wraiths have scythes. You've got to admit Grish that the new sculpts are beautiful and probably wouldn't have the same kind of impact without those beautiful big farming tools of theirs.:)
 
Also, weight is not an issue, neither is the origin of the weapon (I have already pointed out that hammers, axes, picks, spears, knives, bows, javelins, etc all originate from tools or hunting implements)

All that matters when you are ethereal is maximum amount of bladed surface to swing around to hit as many targets as possible. Hence, the scythe.
 
Reading over the whole thread again it becomes apparent from everyone's posts that the scythe is purely there for impact, lets face it the wraiths themselves do not need a weapon as is evident with the chill grasp attack. If there has ever been a weapon that has stopped a man in his tracks based purely on menacing presence it's the scythe.:zombie:
 
I haven't read through this whole thing, so I don't know if this point has been raised already, but surely it's a psychological thing. The scythe being a tool for harvesting wheat(or similar), effortlessly cutting it down in swathes. When used as a weapon by a terrifying figure (such as myself) the beholder associates it with a harvesting of life, rather than a battle or a fight. As such it becomes very scary, due to the removal of possible resistance (could best him in battle) which one might feel if the reaper wielded a conventional weapon, such as a sword.

The reason GW gave it to the wraiths was probably just because death carries them, thus making them cool. I doubt they put this kind of thought into it:D

Edit: Have now read most of the thread and have realized that this has very much already been said. Oh well, it was nice to rant a little
 
Does anybody know where the image of the Reaper with a Scythe originally comes from? Why we all accept it as the weapon of Death itself?

I think if we all agree the Grim Reaper uses a scythe then there's no real argument for Wraiths not using them.
 
From what little research I have just done, it appears to me that it is to do with the mass destructive nature of the black plague. Around this time, Death was portrayed as a skeletal figure with a large scythe, mowing down crowds of people 'as if they were grain'. I'd say that's a pretty good reason to use a scythe.
 
People don't seem to notice that a sword is just a gloryfied stick. all melee weapons(by my possibly faulty logic) originated from the stick.
Sword= sharpened stick
Hammer= rock on the top of a stick
Axe= sharpened rock on the top of a stick
Scythe= a looong sharpened rock on the end of a stick

So, basically, all primitive weapons conatain a stick and may have a rock.
 
Wraiths get +2 S from using a great weapon, so if weight is not an issue what is granting the additional S?

Armour also blocks the Scythe from a wraith, so again, it interacts physically with it's environment, so it must have physical properties.

With a Great Weapon, you have ASL, so it does slow them down.

Wraiths in Warhammer are not a concept, they are actual beings, and their weapons have actual combat effects for them. You can't kill the Grim Reaper; it's an idea. Wraiths are actually fielded on a battle with an objective at stake, and can be killed. If you are a Wraith and you have any self-preservation, these would be considerations (and you have Wraith Characters, so I'm making the assumption self-preservation is a concept).

What I take from this: Weapon of choice matters. They're on a field of combat where they can, and often do, get killed.

Certain great swords have a longer surface.

It's my belief in combat that very small changes in a fight can matter a great deal. You can argue that all bullets shoot guns, thus they're all effective, but in reality, they are not. Bullet size matters. Muzzle length matters. Weight matters. Cost matters. Reliability matters. Same with weapons. Not all weapons are equal, and I have not read anything other than peasants using Scythes (and modified scythes; not scythes in base form. I have yet to see examples of people actually using an unmodified Scythe, like our Wraits are modelled with, in combat). This leads me to believe that soldiers had good reasons not to use them. I don't see anything different in Warhammer that would suggest otherwise.

Game wise, it's just another great weapon. But I really dislike the look. Technically, you could model anything largish and say it's a great weapon. A club, a treebanch, a giant balloon, whatever. But I would say a giant balloon would suck too.

I'll be happy modelling mine with real weapons and leave the grass cutting wraiths to others.
 
It's psychological to invoke the image of the reaper though. Causing terror and all that, scaring foes off can be a very viable tactic for the wraiths.
 
It is probably done by GW because it is a pop culture image most, if not all westerners recognize. So yes it is psychological, to other players (oh gosh thats a whole bunch of 'deaths' marching at me), to the buyers (hey thats cool looking!).

being a super duper noob to the game, i am wholly and completely unqualified to comment on the mechanics aspect of the wraith wielding scythe.
 
It has physical properties yes, but the entire "its cumbersome" argument is mitigated largely by the ethereal properties of a wraith. Its all about fighting style- the wraith fighting style is to reap through infantry in the exact same manner a farmer reaps through corn. I personally like the aesthetic of a scythe. A scythe also gives greater reach than a greatsword (being essentially a polearm) and more blade than a regular polearm.

If its just aesthetics you disapprove of... that's not really an arguable point, that's just your personal preference. So model your wraiths with something else.

and modified scythes; not scythes in base form. I have yet to see examples of people actually using an unmodified Scythe, like our Wraits are modelled with, in combat). This leads me to believe that soldiers had good reasons not to use them. I don't see anything different in Warhammer that would suggest otherwise.

I have yet to see examples of people riding giant reptiles into battle or wearing robes and phasing through walls in battle or touching people and having them die from being touched in battle... want me to continue?


Also, wraiths are not actually "fighting a battle" from their point of view. They are just harvesting. People are the wraith equivalent of wheat- just a crop to be harvested. The wraith also has little choice in weapons- its a spirit, more or less a lesser elemental of the wind of death formed from the soul of a dead sorcerer. The scythe is as much a part of it as the robes and the skullface. It doesn't think "hmm maybe I should use a different weapon" or about how much the weapon costs or how efficient it is. It just kills because thats what it does.
 
I fail to see how a scythe could not be absolutely devastating in a battle.

3 attacks surely represents the swing of a scythe, the extra strength is representation of the extra reach and momentum of the scythe as it hits.

Now if I had a scythe and was battling someone with any hand weapon like a dagger, broadsword, axe, it would be purely down to speed and agility that my opponent does or does not die (ASL). I take my swing, they get inside my swing ( bearing in mind the length of my shaft :O and the length of the blade on it) they've got to cover at least have of that distance before just getting knocked off there feet from the momentum. If they've managed to do that then I've probably got a blade through my sternum.

But I am not Ethereal. If they manage to do that to a Wraith, they go through him, out the other side and die on the back swing.

A simple understanding of Physics would tell you that a Scythe would be more potent than a Great sword. A Scythe is a Great sword tied to a stick at a 90 degree angle. If you get caught on the end of that swing even Heavy armour isn't going to help as the tip will punch right through it, your ribs, internal organs and come out the other side. If the blade edge hits you it will crush your armour much like a Great sword but with at least double the momentum and quadruple the force and rupture your insides.

If it's just aesthetics that's understandable but as a realistic weapon it is definitely the thing Wraiths should be walking around with.
 
There rare usage is probably due to the fact that if the first attack failed the weight of the scythe would leave you unable to defend the opponents counter. A great sword generally has balncing to if all else fails at least use the hilt to defend.
however this could be solve with some rocks and some ducktapexD...
 
Count Darvaleth said:
Does anybody know where the image of the Reaper with a Scythe originally comes from? Why we all accept it as the weapon of Death itself?

I think if we all agree the Grim Reaper uses a scythe then there's no real argument for Wraiths not using them.

the image originally comes from Europe in the middle ages, At the time most of Europe was rural and agricultural based, therefore just about EVERYONE knew what a scythe looked like and what it could do to grass and crops. Death was then depicted with it as the reaper of life as people were dying in large numbers at the same time; hence he's called The Grim Reaper and not Bob.

G.W Wraiths are a personification of Death in the Middle Ages/renaissance fantasy setting the G.W chose for WFB, plus they look cool.. A ghost with a honking great farm implament!! what's not to love!
 
Yes, a scythe is a farm weapon, sure. But one could say the very same for axes (lumberjack), warhammers (yes! the name of the whole game) (smith) and knives (cook - and not only the halfling-ones).

The game is set in an era were anything could be made a weapon. Have a look at the beginning of "Braveheart". Mr. Wallace senior comes to a house with a lot of dead men. The first thing he does is to grab an axe from a chopping block. Maybe this could work today... But remember Mr. Sean Connery in "The Untouchables": "...must be a [fill in any nation]. Comes with a knife to a shootout...".

So to answer the question - yes, farm tools are o.k. for the time the game is set in. A scythe is a bladed weapon, that is ready available.
 
While both the flaws and benefits of the scythe as a combat weapon have been said, Wraiths are immortal and would have plenty of time to practise using them and thus minmising negatives of the weapon (slow recovery time after attack) and maximise the posistives(large swing arch). So sure in the hands of a farmer the unmodified scythe may be a minor weapon, In the hands of an immortal warrior with to much time on his hands it is an ultimate vanguisher of enemys on the battle'field'.
 
Thorin Hubertson said:
Yes, a scythe is a farm weapon, sure. But one could say the very same for axes (lumberjack), warhammers (yes! the name of the whole game) (smith) and knives (cook - and not only the halfling-ones).

The game is set in an era were anything could be made a weapon. Have a look at the beginning of "Braveheart". Mr. Wallace senior comes to a house with a lot of dead men. The first thing he does is to grab an axe from a chopping block. Maybe this could work today... But remember Mr. Sean Connery in "The Untouchables": "...must be a [fill in any nation]. Comes with a knife to a shootout...".

So to answer the question - yes, farm tools are o.k. for the time the game is set in. A scythe is a bladed weapon, that is ready available.

the clue is in the name Grim reaper, it's not jsut that it's a bladed weapon it's one to harvest souls just like harvesting hay you use a scythe it's hard to reap corn with a warhammer, plus it's not an implament usually found on a farm, a mallet yes, but not a warhammer, and if you've ever tried to cut a field of corn with a knife you're masochistic in the extreme. they're supposed to be a physical personification of death, i.e the grim reaper, hence the scythe. not the grim lumberjack (although with the shirt and all that would be cool!!)
 
I have been reading about the weapons of peasant soldiers during the Medieval Age and I remembered this topic and reread the posts. I thought everyone would appreciate this additional information about scythes as war weapons:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_scythe

adaten.digitale_sammlungen.de__db_bsb00006570_images_bsb00006570_00411.webp


Paulus Hector Mair scythes

Keep turning the page there are 9 pages.

Medieval scythe combat video

I have only posted pertinent links not the constant random route I take across the internet (and human history the past 2,891 years). :vampire3:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu