Wraiths - still a viable rare choice?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Actually, with Forbidden Lore on 2 casters, you can quite easily get 2 Doom and Darkness spells going at the same time.
 
Zanthor said:
Actually, with Forbidden Lore on 2 casters, you can quite easily get 2 Doom and Darkness spells going at the same time.

correct!

for the 50 points a model id much rather spend the extra 5 points for a blood knight. Wraiths and the banshee especially are way to situational and i've had mine disappear in the first turn of the game to a standard fireball. Blood knights will always do good, I take a minimum of 8 tho.
 
You can never have 2 doom and darkness spells EVER. Read the rules on spell selection.

Wraiths rule. No one is taking magic missile lores not making wraiths even better.
 
Banshee are not worth it.

2d6 +2 - LD is not as impressive in 8th. Why?

Less or no cav
Not as many small sized units
Most units are way bigger so a few kills from a banshee are not a big deal.


I'd rather have the 3 S5 As for less points.
 
Poxous said:
You can never have 2 doom and darkness spells EVER. Read the rules on spell selection.

Read the second exception to that rule. Pretty sure it says unless your character pays for the spell. Forbidden lore costs 35 points and gives you all the spells in the lore of choice. Seems to me, that I am paying for the spells.
 
belgarath97 said:
Poxous said:
You can never have 2 doom and darkness spells EVER. Read the rules on spell selection.

Read the second exception to that rule. Pretty sure it says unless your character pays for the spell. Forbidden lore costs 35 points and gives you all the spells in the lore of choice. Seems to me, that I am paying for the spells.

That is correct. Forbidden Lore is not Loremaster. We can have 10 Vampires with it and all know the same spells.
 
Wraiths w/ banshee can be very useful in a number of situations.The scream can kill an isolated hydra or stegadon or many other monsters/war machines.Since they are ethereal they can tarpit most non-magical units w/ impunity.Immunity to non magical missile fire is very useful.I like'em b/c they give my opponent something else to worry about,increasing the likelyhood that he'll do something stupid :D
TERROR...can be very theatening on the flanks.
Wraiths and banshees limit your opponents options by forcing them to keep their troops under their genny's skirts.They can prevent you from being encircled.
 
You guys are incorrect on doubling a spell. Exceptions are as follows:

1) A model has no choice over its spells. Like a treeman having treesinging or a necro buying VDM. Forbidden Lore is not an ability that buys that vampire a specific spell. Yes it gets all the spells but that is not what the rule refers too. BUYING A SPELL <-- that can be doubled

2) The races rules allow it. VCs rules do not allow them to double death spells.

Having a forbidden lore means you can not use that lore anymore. As you did not buy a specific spell. Now say you had a forbidden lore guy running VC magic you can have a necro with raise dead, VDM, ect because he bought that spell.

So you are incorrect in your reading of the rules. The rules refer to being able to buy a spell(s) not knowing a lore. Necro is a prefect example of this rule working.
 
Poxous said:
You guys are incorrect on doubling a spell. Exceptions are as follows:

1) A model has no choice over its spells. Like a treeman having treesinging or a necro buying VDM. Forbidden Lore is not an ability that buys that vampire a specific spell. Yes it gets all the spells but that is not what the rule refers too. BUYING A SPELL <-- that can be doubled

2) The races rules allow it. VCs rules do not allow them to double death spells.

Having a forbidden lore means you can not use that lore anymore. As you did not buy a specific spell. Now say you had a forbidden lore guy running VC magic you can have a necro with raise dead, VDM, ect because he bought that spell.

So you are incorrect in your reading of the rules. The rules refer to being able to buy a spell(s) not knowing a lore. Necro is a prefect example of this rule working.

"The only exceptions are where a spell is not generated randomly, such as:"

"Otherwise, IF you ROLL a spell twice you must normally replace the duplicated, etc"

I'm not rolling, case closed.
 
Just quickly skimmed this so if I echo what's been said already, sorry.

Wraiths are good, but def. Go with the bansee, I took down an altar of the gods stegadon with a single scream. Its true that they can be zapped by magic, but that's why you use them like old school fell bats, have them tucked in a flanked ready to pop out to receive a charge from non magical blocks or cav. Stand and shoot (I think you can still do it). And the fact you can potentially float right thru a nice bit of hard terrain and pop up next to a unit hiding behind it is awesome. also take a large unit, so the wounds can keep the banshee alive, she's the best unit, beast killer your gonna get its no longer affected by the immune to psychology rule so shout at everything (shame you can only upgrade 1 per unit)
 
I've been taking 2 units of 3 Wraiths purely for the Ethereal Rule they let you easily tie up things like Steam Tanks etc. They're that little bit faster than your normal guys as well so they can add a bit of punch as a flank charge.

They're hard to deal with so your opponent can waste their magic phase trying to deal with them or let them go and they can mess around going after War Machines.

Some armies like Daemons basically ignore the Ethereal Part of the rules. So chill with them on your flanks moving for Flank Charges etc. If you go with out the Howl then you're getting 9 S5 attacks a turn from 3 of them which is not insignificant.

Aramoro
 
I never tailor an Army to an opponent so that is not an option.

If you do surely it's just Light all the way in return?

Aramoro
 
I never tailor an Army to an opponent so that is not an option.

If you do surely it's just Light all the way in return?

These are contradictory statements. How do you not tailor if you are picking lores before the game?

Given the armies I've seen under the new rules, wraiths are very vulnerable. Lots of magic, and a plethora of magic weapons.
 
bored1 said:
I never tailor an Army to an opponent so that is not an option.

If you do surely it's just Light all the way in return?

These are contradictory statements. How do you not tailor if you are picking lores before the game?

Given the armies I've seen under the new rules, wraiths are very vulnerable. Lots of magic, and a plethora of magic weapons.

You misunderstand. I do not build a list to beat a specific opponent. If i'm playing against Undead I dont make an anti-undead list. I make a list at a points value.

Wraiths are every vurnerable, to specific things but thats rather the point. They have to use those limited resources to deal with them. They have to burn power dice trying to kill three annoying guys rather than dealing with the rest of my army.

Aramoro
 
You misunderstand. I do not build a list to beat a specific opponent. If i'm playing against Undead I dont make an anti-undead list. I make a list at a points value.

I got the pre-defined list part. I was commenting on your response of bringing all light against daemons. That is what I was saying is tailoring. I'm not trying to offend you, I just run into people that seem to want to pick their lore once my army comes out of the bag.

Wraiths are every vurnerable, to specific things but thats rather the point. They have to use those limited resources to deal with them. They have to burn power dice trying to kill three annoying guys rather than dealing with the rest of my army.

Unfortunately, that logic, while very efficient in 6th and 7th, is less so under the new rules I'm finding. A basic wraith unit 150 pts. It can die to a plethora of spells or items. Losing the unit means that you now have to score an extra 51 pts to prevent a loss. With the rules being what they are, this can be difficult. 8th edition doesn't really do well with "throwaway" units. The ones that do function well (suicide death vamp, for example) do so because of the mass of damage they can consistently dish out when being sacrificed.
 
A basic wraith unit 150 pts. It can die to a plethora of spells or items.
How is that different to before? I'm finding they do just about the same as in 7th.

Losing the unit means that you now have to score an extra 51 pts to prevent a loss.
How is this a problem unique to Wraiths? Same can be said of Vargs, Blood Knights or indeed any unit. Depending on what you're facing, 3 wraiths can be harder to kill than a block of GG in the right situation.

The ones that do function well (suicide death vamp, for example) do so because of the mass of damage they can consistently dish out when being sacrificed.
He is only good when he has good targets. If he can't bag some war machines or a big monster he is less useful than the wraiths as he scores precisely nothing if he doesn't wipe units out completely and usually dies to boot. A Purple Sun suicide vamp is utter rubbish vs Elves for example, so he's not actually consistent at all.
 
Johnny B said:
He is only good when he has good targets. If he can't bag some war machines or a big monster he is less useful than the wraiths as he scores precisely nothing if he doesn't wipe units out completely and usually dies to boot. A Purple Sun suicide vamp is utter rubbish vs Elves for example, so he's not actually consistent at all.

Actually against Elves the Death Sun Vamp casts IF powered up Soul Blight. Still needs 6 dice to get of effectively (18+ to cast) so no dice wasted.

Str 2 and T 2 Elves over the next two combat phases (especially on a race which already has low str and T) can just as brutal as Purple Sun. If you are using Ghouls and/or GG as you combat units (most people do) then str 2 versus T 4 is almost an auto win. Don't matter how many attacks you have if you need 6s to wound, you just can't generate enough kills.
 
bored1 said:
You misunderstand. I do not build a list to beat a specific opponent. If i'm playing against Undead I dont make an anti-undead list. I make a list at a points value.

I got the pre-defined list part. I was commenting on your response of bringing all light against daemons. That is what I was saying is tailoring. I'm not trying to offend you, I just run into people that seem to want to pick their lore once my army comes out of the bag.

Wraiths are every vurnerable, to specific things but thats rather the point. They have to use those limited resources to deal with them. They have to burn power dice trying to kill three annoying guys rather than dealing with the rest of my army.

Unfortunately, that logic, while very efficient in 6th and 7th, is less so under the new rules I'm finding. A basic wraith unit 150 pts. It can die to a plethora of spells or items. Losing the unit means that you now have to score an extra 51 pts to prevent a loss. With the rules being what they are, this can be difficult. 8th edition doesn't really do well with "throwaway" units. The ones that do function well (suicide death vamp, for example) do so because of the mass of damage they can consistently dish out when being sacrificed.

That was a comment to the poster before me. I choose my Lores with my Army list. The person before me was suggesting never taking Wraiths against daemons which is not an option. If you do then it suggests you're tailoring your lists to your opponent, which means he will do the same and explode you with light.

There are loads of ways to kill Wraiths that's true. But look at an average army list and pick them all out and you'll see they do not come without cost. Does the Skaven player warp lighting to try and kill some wraiths before they tie up his Hellpit abomination for the rest of the game or does he go for the 13th on one of your other units.

Games are only 6 turns long, 6 Magic phases to kill them in. For some armies it will be trivial to kill them. but for others it's a nightmare to deal with them. I tend to think they're worth the risk. Against those magically very strong armies just have them chilling hanging out with your units in a support role.

Aramoro
 
I would at least say that they are great in tournaments... but if your enemy knows he is playing ONLY vampires, perhaps not that great... but I want to believe they can still be very good.
 
Ohris said:
I would at least say that they are great in tournaments... but if your enemy knows he is playing ONLY vampires, perhaps not that great... but I want to believe they can still be very good.

I find the Banshee overpriced now. She basically costs 75 points (since the Wraith looses almost all combat ability). With the infantry based nature of 8th the causalities the screams cause is a lot less. People say you can Doom and Darkness a target for better screaming but for those power dice I'd probably go for casting Timewarp on the Wraiths giving them ASF, double movement and +1 attack. Furthermore the 175 minimum sized Wraith unit with the Banshee seems like such a waste. Since the unit can barely fight your paying 175 points for a Banshee.

As for the Wraiths themselves I think they have actually improved someone. Reasons why:

1) Everyone talks about magic missiles and such but lets look at the most popular lores:

IMHO it would be-

1) Life
2) Death
3) Shadow
4) Light
5) Beasts
6)(long space then the rest)

Of those top 5 the only one with a real good magic missile is Light (3D6 str 4 hits hurts). The rest are not really that good. When you consider that the only army that can stacking multiple Banishment castings is VC it's not so bad.

2) Heroes with magic weapons. People also talk about the nasty hero who zips around pwning vulnerable targets (like Warmachines, lone wizards, etc) but you only have to look as for as the extinction of the Lycni vampire to see how come lone heroes are nowadays. Almost all heroes nowadays are hiding in blocks of infantry trying to avoid the lazer guided cannonballs.

So what do we do about the heroes and champs with magic weapons hiding in the blocks of infantry? We Spirit Leech them of course. Isn't it convenient that VC have the best Death Lore casters in the game? If you see a big block of non magical Dwarven infantry but they have a annoying little Champ/hero with a rune weapon, zap the character and then send in your Wraiths.

3) Daemons, Skaven and Dwarves. Probably the 3 most common nemesis armies of Wraiths. Daemons are as good as they were against Wraiths as they were in 7th, yet people still took Wraiths in 7th. Throw in the fact that Daemons took quite a hit from 8th and are far less common, that's a win. Skaven shooting has actually been really hurt by 8th. Ratling guns have disappeared (the main bane of Wraiths-this happened before 8th), Jezzails are rarer but have have almost no chance of hitting (4+ to hit -1 for long range -1 skirmishers = 6 to hit base) with the new cover rules (an addition -1 or 2 from screening the wraiths). Dwarves are the same as they were in 7th except their artillery is more accurate. But artillery was never really that efficient for targeting wraiths anyway and will almost certainly be shot at the large blocks of infantry.

4) The game is much faster. With the variable charge ranges many of the slower units or average speed units tend to move much faster. Wraiths are the most vulnerable outside of combat, in combat they are safe from magic missiles and direct damage. With a Timewarp and VHD you can make 1st turn charges while easily:

24.1" away (deployment)
8" VHD
12" move (doubled from Timewarp)
2D6 charge (need a 5 more to complete charge)

When in thrown in the fact that a charge or flanking gives you +1 CR no outnumbering you only need to kill 4 models to win the combat (against +4 CR). Even a draw won't hurt if the BSB is nearby.

With all this in mine I have been experimenting with 5 strong Wraith units with no Banshee. At 250 points they are only 50 points more then a Coach, yet unlike a coach they can beat full infantry units solo, don't steal powerdice and don't fear Cannons. With just Timewarp alone they have 20 str 5 attacks, ASF and 12" movement.

It's not a bad deal.
 
Sadly TimeWarp will only cancel out their ASL rule from their Great Weapons so you're falling back on their awesome Initiative of 2. Not like matters as most units in the game cannot hurt them.

Aramoro
 
Aramoro said:
Sadly TimeWarp will only cancel out their ASL rule from their Great Weapons so you're falling back on their awesome Initiative of 2. Not like matters as most units in the game cannot hurt them.

Aramoro

Indeed. The ASL is simply a side benefit. Mainly interested in the 12" move and the +1 Attack.
 
It truly is a crying shame they couldn't just make the Howling thing like a 25 point add on rather than a separate weaker stat line. My final glorious use of the Banshee was in the last Vampire Counts book where she nailed some flying Bretonnian Hero who intend on killing blow my General. And even then she was there because there was a spare 90 points and I didn't feel like ranking up spare models.

In 7th Edition my Wraiths were in the armies over the 2k mark. They lurked right behind ranked units. Then using skirmisher rules would slip forward between units (or around the side).

Then they'd tag or support charge nonmagical units.

As with Lord Fear and Poxous posts against multiple ranked formations (normally in the side). Or as with Aramoro would-be scary targets, he talks of Steam Tanks mine was often cavalry. Regardless they were there to tag and get a few kills in.

With 8th I think the balance of a Wraith unit or another multiple ranked Grave Guard unit is going to be harder. Grave Guard are soooooooooo good (Great Weapons optional) and giving that up would mean the Wraiths had better be part of a tight plan.

Although I have modeled an ethereal Vampire Lord and Army Standard Bearer. Used them once as part of a theme army with a large unit of Wraiths. The other guy was goofing too, it was nutty and fun.

Kind of shame now that every army can pay ten points to get flaming magical attacks with a unit. We are less special now.
 
Bob the Liche said:
Kind of shame now that every army can pay ten points to get flaming magical attacks with a unit. We are less special now.

If you are preferring to the "Banner of eternal flame", it does NOT give magical attacks, just flaming. Our flaming banner however does give magical flaming attacks ;-) .
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu