Your personal 'Finecast' review

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

How do you rate Citadel Finecast?

  • Finecast is brilliant quality! I like it

    Votes: 12 38.7%
  • Finecast is ok but I don't see the visual improvement

    Votes: 8 25.8%
  • Finecast is bad quality - so many miscasts!

    Votes: 7 22.6%
  • Finecast is ok, but I liked the feel of metal

    Votes: 8 25.8%

  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll votes is visible for users with special permission.
Aug 3, 2010
780
Zombies
736
Hey guys,

Seeing as finecast now hit the stores many people are curious about it and it is no longer just tossing rumours around. So the following idea jumped on me:

As the comments about finecast on the interwebs seem to be either very positive or utterly negative I'd like you to post your personal impressions of your finecast product(s), so that we can finally clear up the question of "Finecost or Failcast"?

Please only post in this thread if you own or have seen a finecast model personally, because I want objective reviews and not the usual "the friend of a friend said, that...". Tell us your opinion on finecast in terms of quality and flexibility (meaning how easy it is to work with it, not necessarily bendability) and even more important: Tell us why!

Cheers,

Dogmar
 
OOPS,I voted too soon.I haven't actually seen any of the new models but I am a BIG fan of metal models and almost always choose them in preference to plastic.The only thing I like about plastic,is the ease with which you convert it.Also,outside of the gaming world people generally associate plastic with "cheapness" and no matter how well painted it is they will be thinking in the back of their head that it's cheap plastic crap.
 
I bought a finecast Asotrath the Grim model; it was SO easy to put together. A dream to glue together AND pretty darn simple to convert. Super glue works like magic.

Undercoating it black with a brush and paint-pot was a bit of a nightmare, however... the paint just ran off and I ended up spraying it, which solved the issue. Perhaps it's just this model, though.

And earlier I did break his axe-handle, but then I did drop it on the floor. Still surprised me though, and was a pain to glue together again.


But overall, it's really, really awesome. SO much easier to build than metal, SO much more durable, and SO much easier to paint. :thumbsup:
 
Count Darvaleth said:
And earlier I did break his axe-handle, but then I did drop it on the floor. Still surprised me though, and was a pain to glue together again.

But overall, it's really, really awesome. SO much easier to build than metal, SO much more durable, and SO much easier to paint. :thumbsup:

hmm.. this is a bit confusing o_o
 
I like the additional detail on the models, however there are problems using resin for conversion work, trying to mix resin and plastic is VERY difficult as the seams tend to break, trying to do weapon swaps is in my opinion now impossible as pinning can shatter the resin (believe me I tried, wanted a custom weapon on the resin female vamp, now it's a 1 arm vamp) unless your going to do arm swaps from another resin converting will become difficult. Oh and dont forget to scrub the models with a toothbrush before trying to apply paint to remove the mold protection or you can just rub the paint off of resin!

overall im on the fence not for or against gunna adopt a wait and see approach if they can rectify the conversion problems by releasing alternatives arms weapons etc.... on forge world
 
@ Bishop: Yeah, that was a fail on my behalf. As long as you don't got chucking them on the floor repeatedly, they're a lot more durable. For instance, if I picked up a metal model by a certain part, it would break, whereas I can hold Astorath anywhere, no matter how awkward, and he's fine.

Oh, and I did manage to convert using plastic and resin. Really quite easy, actually, put a chainaxe on Astorath's bone-axe handle instead of his power axe. Super glue = sorted.


... you're supposed to wash models before painting them? :slapface: What with, soap? :clown:
 
Lightly soapy warm water and a toothbrush. It just gets the release agent off and helps the paint stick. I found my metal models chipped less easily when I started doing this but I do it for everything now.
 
My friend bought his 1st finecast. It was that Dark Angel with the cloak over his shoulder. While alot more duarable and easily built, he found it bothersome cleaning up the mould lines, and more importantly, some parts of the model seemed to have slumped. Example, the model has two skulls on/near its backpack, one was fine but the other looked as if half the skull had melted somewhat as it was droopy and very un-skull like. Same goes for another part of the backpack he found.
So initial impressions were not the best but we do suspect this was just a faulty model. Just thought I'd share. :)
 
After seeing it and testing some sprues I got hold of through dark sorceries(visiting a GW store that is) I have come to the following list.

Positive:
- light weight (finally my arthritis won't kill me whilst trying to bring my horde armies along)

- actually putting resin models together is easier than metal, it's just the cleaning up etc. that is a pain.

- resin is capable of much more detail and though it doesn't really show now as they are using the old molds, new miniatures have the potential to surprise many gamers who aren't used to resin.

Negative:
- resin takes some getting used to; IMO it's advanced stuff. As Count Darvaleth noticed resin HAS to be washed beforehand, this is due to the molding-process. You could potentially skip this with plastic and metal as it's not too much of a big deal but resin absolutely needs to be dunked in soapy water.

- the resin mix is way too soft, this is probably to prevent the chipping and shattering resin is prone to but this flexibility could break away the paint on wobbly bits like spears, banner poles, swords etc. Haven't seen a big block of resin yet so I also cannot comment on how shatter-proof it really is but resin has always been really fragile the bigger the mass is...have to wait and see.

- not the material but the way GW handled its introduction. They should have taken more time with this as it was clearly rushed seeing the ridiculous amounts of miscasts right now.
 
My mate made a good review of his finecast purchases with lots of pictures etc. Its here: http://grotorderly.blogspot.com/2011/05/not-so-fine-finecast.html

(check the follow up story when he went to exchange his models as well ha ha).

So far myself not impressed.Went with few mates when their were buying their stuff and really, far too many problems. Material actually looks good to work with (albeit I would be afraid to push the file harder on it in case i destroy it ;) but so many miscats and bubbles in product advertised as a best thing since sliced bread was invented is just a joke.
 
I bought a varghulf and i have to say that the detail is very fine indeed mostly... BUT... They didnt use enough material to mould it, so it was flat on the top where fur should have been... Made me have a chuckle with finecast being all about details, its kinda hard to see those details when a bit of the figure is missing entirely!
 
I picked up the empire captain on the day they came out, painting comp for local GW.
Easy to glue, a bit bendy and its harder to cut as with little force it does not cut but with alot you risk slicing right on through, its like trying to cut through rubber.
They do bounce, found that out when I dropped mine bit the amount of mold extras on the model, the amount of trimming and filing, personally I do not see what the fuss is about, it is cheaper to produce and easier to convert. (although some of the characters I have seen look like they have received a bath in carbonite and frozen for all eternity)

I just want to know why if it saves them money why are we paying more yet again?
Why did thy think we would be excited at having everything we have now in a different material with nothing new?
Why are there so many Miss-casts and especially on models with alot of small bits?
Are we ever going to have character stock in GW again or is it going to always look empty and take us a week to order something we used to be able to just pick up?

My Final question came about when I was painting my new figure and looking at the box.......
Me: Why does my figure have detail not shown in the image?
GW Manager: The image is of the metal one.
Me: Why is there a image of a metal model on the Fine Cast box?
GW Manager: For comparison.
*tumble weed*

Is it just me or does that just seem like they did a really half arsed job?
 
ai675.photobucket.com_albums_vv114_GordonIron_Finecost.webp
 
I can finally comment!

The way GW launched their latest material was a poor show. In fact I have to admit I thought it was a sad day for their loyal fans. However, I'm not here to say how poor the launch was as the real crux of this thread is about the product itself.

I popped into my local GW on my way home from work today to see what all the fuss was about. I was sceptical but decided to remian open-minded.
Firstly it has to be said that the detail is amazing, so much better than the metal we're used to. Some models have benefited hugely from the new material such as Abaddon and the 'Nids. As for the resin, it is much different than anything I've ever worked with. It is very soft but amazingly durable (this was demonstrated to me with a drop test off the counter), however, it is a new material and as such I think it will take the veterans amongst us some getting used to as it behaves differently to both plastic and the metal models we're used to painting. For instance, if you want to reshape a tail or a claw heat it up under hot water and simply bend it into the position you want. All in all it has my vote. As a fan of metal minis I never thought I'd say it but I personally feel it is a phenomenal canvas for both painting and modelling opportunutues with detail like never before.

Cheers,

u_m
 
How would you rate the softness of the material? I would like to see how paint behaves when you bend it (being on purpose or by accident - it WILL eventually happen). Up until now I have only seen a friends unpainted Skaven hero of some sort. I didn't have the metal one to compare but generally speaking it looked like nothing too special and bendable as hell. Good details, but I have those on my metal figures too - the only thing is maybe that the edges are a tiny bit more sharp and less round.

The reshaping thing is definitely a big plus and it seems when you don't get a miscast the stuff is nice. Still there seem to be lots of miscasts telling from the poll results.

I'll pick up Urien Rakarth or a DE Archon some time later this week, so I can finally judge the new product myself. I try to remain sceptical but open-minded. Being pre-occupied has never proved to help from my experience.
 
My guess it it would behave much my like plastic. As we all know the plastics are far less likely to chip and this is because they have some flex in and don't expand and contract due to heat. Depending on what paints you use they are generally a quite supple when they are dry taking on an almost plastic quality (not unlike PVA). I have yet to paint them but purely from my perspective as a painter rather than a gamer they're a lot nicer (and lighter too which saves hand cramp after long sessions painting!).

Cheers,

u_m
 
I do not have any finecast myself but I wanted to respond on the thing U_T said about the bending.
You said that if it was put in warm water it bended really easily, but if the mini for example stand in the sun for a while (which can get very warm, would it be possible for limbs and other outreaching parts to bend downwards?
So the question is basicly can you put a finecast mini in the sun?
 
Cuzzy said:
I do not have any finecast myself but I wanted to respond on the thing U_T said about the bending.
You said that if it was put in warm water it bended really easily, but if the mini for example stand in the sun for a while (which can get very warm, would it be possible for limbs and other outreaching parts to bend downwards?
So the question is basicly can you put a finecast mini in the sun?

That is a fair question and one I'm not sure about. To be honest I wouldn't ever recommend putting models in the sun anyway. It has the potential to bleach colour and especially with metal models, excessive heat will make the metal expand and blister the paint off anyway. Sure maybe have a game in the garden but I'd personally never leave models in direct sunlight. That's just me though.
 
I got the Empire Captain with hammer in resin today, and I have to say I prefer it a lot more than the old metal's. It's a lot easier to work with (especially mouldlines!) and though I haven't done any conversion work (I never do) it would be a lot easier to than the metals as well. Painting I [also] haven't tried because it's raining here and I can't be bothered to get soaked going out to the garage to spray, :innocent: But I'm sure it will be better painting as well!

~M
 
So it does seem there are some good points about Finecast. You know, GW could have made some really good publicity amongst the community if they hadn't been so greedy at the same time. :rolleyes:
 
So the question is basicly can you put a finecast mini in the sun?

To be frank, I can deal with any of the other reported issues with finecast, but this one terrifies me. I mean, what if you're transporting your finecast minis in your army case, in the boot of your car on a hot day? That will get plenty hot. Are they that susceptible to heat?
 
I know, Fine cast do have bonus points, I had to do a painting comp for fine cast at my local with the empire captain.
At the moment it looks like I am going to win, Wish me luck and I will link the images at comps end.
Only grudge I have is that the pic he took of the mini is in terrible light. :swear:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu