Zombie horde fights the trees (2k)

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Grassman

Skeleton
Aug 23, 2007
70
Zombies
43
A few weeks ago I had a battle with my zombie army against my main opponent which is WE, somewhat of a bad match up.
I tweaked my list a bit since the previous one I posted in the Armylist section, so here is the list I played with

Vamp lord
+lvl
MotBA, forbidden lore (Lore of Death)
Skull staff, helm of commandment

Vamp
MotBA
Sceptre the Noirot

Vamp
MotBA
Scroll

Vamp
MotBA
Book of Arkhan

1x 30 zombies (mus, standard)
4x 20 zombies (mus, standard)
1x 10 ghouls (the ghoul bunker)

6 Black Knights (full command + Banner of the barrows)
6 Black Knights (full command + Royal banner of Strigos)

His list
2x 8 dryads
2x 10 glade guards
6 waywatchrs
2x 7 wardancers 1 met champ en mus andere enkel met mus
2x 5 wild riders en FC
branchwraith lvl1 + cluster of radiance (went in a dryad unit)
branchwraith lvl1 + annoyance of netlings (went in the other dryad unit)
spellweaver lvl 4 + wand of witch elm, DS en steed
noble on eagle: shield, light armor, spear, pageant of shrikes, "pick out bow"

Alter on an eagle (did nothing the whole game so he won’t be mentioned)

There were 3 forests (including his own), 1 hill and 1 impassable terrain. While setting up the terrain randomly everything except 1 forest was on 1 side of the table, lol. He took that side.

From left to right he deployed: wild riders (WR), dryads, dryads, wardancers, spellweaver, wild riders, 2x 10 glade guards (10 on the hill and 10 in front of it), wardancers and some waywatchers in the middle of the table :s
I had from left to right: 1 straight zombie line :D, behind de line some black knights and the ghoulbunker and further to my right in the forest my other black knights (so he couldn’t deploy his waywatchers there).

I took first turn
The zombies and ghoulbunker went a bit forward and the knights behind the line ran a bit further to the left. The knights in the wood stayed there. My magic phase went really smooth compared to our previous game. I raised a ton of zombies in to the existing units and a new unit in front of the waywatchers whom I then Vanhelsed into them. The WE player did nothing to stop the book :s. He elected to flee but watchers were somewhat short-legged, ran 6” and were caught by the zombies who drew first blood :p. I was astonished!!

WE turn 1
Too be brief, he moved his whole army closer towards mine in his movement phase. His magic phase wasn’t pretty good, none of his spells came through. Every glade guard focused his arrows on the zombie unit who had run down the watchers, and killed some. No combat in this turn.

VC turn 2
Zombies stumble forward but not to much, I wanted to delay combat as long as possible. The knights in the wood enjoyed it and stayed there. The other BK unit angled so they where now faced to the enemy. Magic saw the zombie units grow further. I tried to scare him a bit and launched wind of death to his dryads who lost 6 of their fellows.
Still no combat.

WE turn 2
His army moved forward. Finally some of his treesinging got through and he killed 2 knights who were still camping in the woods. Shooting saw some of my zombies die. There was some combat now as his wild riders and dryads had charged the lone zombie unit who had heroically killed the watchers previous turn. Ofcourse they were whipped out but riders didn’t managed to get to my zombie line yet (2” away of the zombies now).

VC turn 3
My whole line shuffled 1” forward. The line was further reinforced thanks to winds of magic. Knights angled some more so he had to charge the zombie line head-on. The trap was set none of his units could now escape the giant tarpit.

WE turn 3
All of his units now charged my zombie line. From left to right this were the combats: wild riders vs zombies, no combat for this unit (his dryad + branchwraith stayed an inch away from them), wardancers vs zombies, dryads vs zombies, wild riders vs zombies. 1 unit of wardancers stayed behind to charge my knights should they charge the far right wild riders.
Shooting did nothing. In combat he won all the combats but the zombie units stayed big enough.

VC turn 4
I charge in my BK with the hatred banner into the far right wild riders. Magic saw a lot of zombies come back, but more important I got drain life off :p (irresistible). Weakening all of his fighting units but they still were able to dish out a lot of hurt to the zombies. But we had a little rule discussion: the drain life killed 2 wild riders so he took one away which was in combat with my BK and he said they weren’t in combat anymore so they couldn’t attack :s (this cost me a lot of points and maybe the game). Lost a lot of zombies again, but I won some combats by 1 now (thank you helm) but his units stayed put.

WE turn 4
Charged his wardancers into my hatred knights and shot the other knight unit to death with his shooting. He killed some more zombies but now lost a combat with his left wardancers but lost none to the zombies arms who tried to pull them down ( I had something like 20 S2 attacks and no wounds :o). The most right dryad unit lost combat too but no kills here either.

VC turn 5
Charged with some zombies into his 2 dryads who were standing just in front of them laughing. Dryads lost and were killed ( with 18 S2 attacks I rolled 5 kills now :s). Second zombie unit from the right charged the rights wild riders. And here we had the same argue as drain life got off again (irresistible again :p) so he took away the model so my zombies were out of combat. In the magic phase I raised more zombies but I couldn’t keep up the numbers anymore, I knew I had lost.

WE turn 5
His 2 fleeing units rallied. His frontline units were whiping the floor with my zombies, although he lost a combat but they hold again.

VC turn 6
I charge the zombies into the wild riders again (bad mistake). Raised some more zombies, no drain life now. Won combat against 3 wardancers but againg they hold.

WE turn 6
It was over, he finally kills 3 zombie units.

In the end all I had left was 2 units of zombies full numbers, the goulbunker with the vamps. He had only lost his waywatchers, 1 dryad unit, half a unit of wardancers and wild riders.

Solid victory for the tree huggers.

Conclusion
The battle was even: I had more luck in the magic phase, while had more luck during combat.
Although on crucial moments the raise spell abandoned me as I tried 4 times in one turn (2 times with 2 dices and 2 times with 1) to raise some zombies behind the tarpitted units but all I got was a miscast which luckily didn’t damage me.
Zombies are now way better then they were before I think the D6+4 is really helpful, even wardancers with their +1A dance have troubles getting through them.
I think I will be switching the barrows knights for some fell bats and/or bat swarms to make sure I have units behind his line to catch fleeing units and charge them from behind (it would have helped a lot). Another option is to disband both knight units and put my lord on a zombie dragon and at some fell bats, because I really need a unit who is able to dish out a lot of attacks in 1 combat. Knights can do it but they don’t always get behind the lines which will cost me games.

One question remains: If you have this situation AAAAAE
Assume E has charged, drain life kills some models of the A-unit. Can you take away the far right A model so E is out of combat? What to do when there is only the command group left?
I think the rulebook says you have to take away the A-models not in combat with E but I need 100% certainty.


Thanks for reading. I hope you enjoyed the report any comments are welcome as this is my first report ever.
 
I'm pretty sure that you would move the units up as you would from model's killed in combat, once units are engaged they remain in BSB contact until on flees or is destroyed.
 
Disciple is correct. By your opponants logic, the spell would put the units out of combat, which is not the case. Magic and combat are different phases, the kills in one have no bearing on the other. If that were true then the staff of damnation would actually hurt a vampire player, because if a unit killed the whole front rank of an opponant's block in the magic phase then they coudn't attack, if we were playing by your opponants rules.

In this case he simply loses a model, he can pick the model, but it doesn't take you out of base of base. Units that are in combat and hit by that spell also don't have to take panic checks for 25% casualties, because they are in combat.
 
Hi all (my first post yay), I'm grassman's opponent from the other day. My interpretation of the rules may be off as we always encounter 1 or more problems everytime we play and try to find somthing or some answer angainst it. :rolleyes:

The problem itself was the fact that my Wild Riders where in CC in front with the zombies and in the flank with the BK, as magic phase comes first I took casualties from them before the actual CC phase. I had FC so I removed the 2 other plain models, leaving the BK out of combat because I didn't move the FC-models. The question I think is: should I have had to move my 3 remaining models back to the BK or is this really a case of "fighting yourself out of combat"? Anyway it isn't the first time we met such "wierd stuff" in our battle I mean who hasn't :grin:.

here is how it was:

problemWRVC.jpg


the red are BK the green is my command group, blue one plain models, the big unit are the zombies and the big "thing" is the rest of the battle. We also pushed the BK forward to let them reach the WR but the met the zombies, not beeing able to join the WR that we hadn't moved, if he hadn't charged this way either, his champ wouldn't have been in B2B when charging my WR. Hope you guys can help clear things out. :rolleyes:

To continue the battle report itself, the only problem he had was that his hammer units where killed to soon for him to use them, and if that wouldn't have happened it would have been a pain for me :) (here comes that rule issue)
I was also really surprised of the speed the zombied came back and especially their poursue move, with his 8+ ranks sometimes it did hurt. Against armies with not as much ItP troops as WE it would surely work.

@ grassman it was a noble on eagle, an alter on eagle is not possible

PS: sorry for the long post I got carried away :redface:



cheers

peterhof
 
basically peterhof and grassman, regarding any combat you must move and remove models in such a way that the most models possible are in base-base contact, i.e. you should have removed models from the far right. sounds like it was an interesting game still, I've not seen such a zombie heavy army in VC actually do any damage before, regardless of the loss, i'm impressed.
 
But isn't the owner of the unit allowed to choose which members of the unit he takes away as casualty? Only if the wounds aren't relocated to specific mini's of course.
 
He is allowed to choose yes 'providing' the maximum number models are kept in close combat, the above case you would have had to remove two troops and the remaining three would have to be positioned far left to still be in contact with Black Knights
 
yeah thx for clearing things up
so let's call the battle a draw then as my knights would have annihilated your whole line :grin:

I hope I have inspired some people with this report and shown that zombies aren't that crappy

Give me a "Z", give me a "O", give me "M", give me a "B", give me a "I", give me an "E", give me a "S" .... GO ZOMBIES!! :P
 
I think you actually played the casualty removal correctly- the only guidance the book gives on casualties is that they should come from the rear rank, and if in one rank, then both ends equally. Though this allows for some very "gamey" tactics (especially concerning chariots hitting flanks) and most will play it the sensible way of retaining maximal contact where possible. However, just because the Knights were removed from base contact with the Zombies, didn't mean the combat had ended! The combat continues, resolution counted (So probably not a good thing for the Knights) and then you redress ranks at the end, to bring the Zombies back into combat. So yeah, probably safest to call it a draw and have a rematch :D
 
That is just one of those bothersome multiple unit combat that the BrB doesn't explain very well, to not say at al o_o

@ nicodemus I would suggest you take a lot of zombies and be verry carrefull when choosing your hammer unit, because if they die your done most of the time as zombies crumble like hell (no pun intended)

@Evc are you refering to the black knights or the Wild riders?
 
The Wild Riders being removed to avoid contact with the Black Knights, I mean. The Black Knights would still have counted as being in combat with the Wild Riders, you'd just have to redress the ranks at the end of the combat phase, to bring the Wild Riders back into combat with them.
 
I think some people on here are making up rules. Peterhof lost 2 models from a single rank unit and according to the rules for removing models from a single rank unit he must remove them equally from the ends. In the instance above the BKs would then have to slide in to maintain contact ... but ... they are unable to due to the zombie unit beng in the way. Now, if the wounds were caused in close combat then I believe the oppising unit would have to slide into the BKs to maintain contact ... but since the damage was caused by a spell then it appears IMHO that it was played correctly.
 
If the BKs are not in BTB in the CC phase, then how are they in combat?

Yes, you would remove the models from the ends, but then to fulfill the maximizing models in base contact, you would slide the remaining wild riders over to be in base contact with the black knights since they cannot move closer to the wild riders because the zombies are in the way.

Maximizing models is a pretty core aspect of the game, so much so that the rule book gives you examples where charges and even defenders will slide to maximize, even if it puts them into a position that they normally wouldn't have been, or even have been able to do with normal movement. The casualties happened in the magic phase, at the end you would then maximize for the next phase.

Let me give you another example:

What if the charge was to the rear of a block, so zombies to the front of a block, black knights to the rear.
In the magic phase, 5 models from the block are killed, which are removed from the rear as normal. This puts the black knights out of btb with the rear of the unit. Are you telling me that in the close combat phase my knights won't be attacking but would still suffer crumble? That's just silly. At the end of the magic phase, the knights move up to be in the rear, and the combat is fought as normal.

Better yet, what if it was simply a rear charge by the knights. Lose 5 models from magic in the previous so the knights aren't in BTB, then close combat phase... nothing happens? I used staff of damnation on my knights in the magic phase, they killed the 5 in front of them (while in the rear), so you are saying they don't slide up and attack in the close combat phase? I think that once you break it down to similiar situations that are simplier it is easy to see what the solution is.
 
No, but they are being taken out of context. You only maximise when you charge.

Going by a diagram inthe rulebook about incomplete ranks and fighting, I would say that for Reincus' examples, if an entire rear rank or flank file was wiped out, then your models would still count as being in contact for the fighting. Hence why it's probably easiest to just remove enemy models that aren't in contact in the first place, really, just as most people do play :)
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu