crumble fails..... again

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Skittelz1981

Varghulf
Apr 28, 2013
707
AMS
Zombies
623
How crumble due to slain general ruins a very good game.

Turn 3; my opponent starts turn 3, casts arnzipals black horror which moves over my ghoul horde, destroys 11 of them then moves over my zombie lordbunker, kills another 14 zombos en my lord.
Crumble then took care of a spirit host, a cairn wraith a TG, another 7 ghouls, 4 GG, knocked another TG 4 wounds off and knocked 2 wounds off of my Mortis Engine that was already in a precarious battle.
That was instantly game over. a whole flank got ripped open and basically had no more fighting power left. my GG horde that was relying on marching to close the gap and get into flanks got stuck with 4" move and wouldve been redirected etc so wont see combat anymore for that reason.
Totally ruined a very fun game that was at that point balanced out and couldve gone both ways.

I truly despise the OP magic spells like this and i truly despise our slain general rule even more. even though i like VC as an army to play with, this really would be reason enough to sell it all and get something like ogre kingdoms or any other army that doesnt have retardedly unbalanced and gameruining rulings like the VC 'slain general'

truly an anticlimax and insanely punishing. just no fun at all. unddrstandable from a fluff perspective (although arguable) totally not fair from a game/balancing perspective.
 
I agree about the magic thing. I think on balance of like 100 games played in a row, it would still be a rare thing, but yeah spells like dreaded thirteenth and pit of shades have left my brother's dwarf army ruined and not much to do about it.

Same with the General slain thing. Again, in the course of 100 battles you'd expect it not to happen very often, but man...After setting up for ages, getting it already, playing three turns then that happens and not even due to tactical errors, just some crazy spell, it makes one wonder.

Still, everyone I play against says VC are OP due to all the synergy we can create, so I wouldn't say it's balanced, I'd just say it's a world of imbalances.

With the dwarf's new book having a greatly lowered ability to dispel magic, I wouldn't be surprised if in 9th magic is toned down a little though.
 
Well magic should be toned down cuz its ridiculous.
as for the synergy, it barely ever happens to me. vamplore is a soso lore that is not offensive at all. any decent player will know when to dispel vanhels and when to dispel IoN which are basically the 2 real spells we have that actually matter. Without IoN and VHDM our units are 9/10 helpless, sucking at initiative, sucking at weaponskill and sucking at strength and toughness.
the most magicdependant armies (VC and TK) actually get one of the weakest spellcasting synergy. compared to all the elves, daemons of chaos, lizardmen, heck even O&G actually have better chances at casting spellsbsuccesfully without having them dispelled.
Ive noticed that most my wins are simply based on having luck with magic, rolling well enough for the winds and having luck on getting VHDM though when in combat.

Last 3 battles my general died everytime. twice while in a bunker and twice by spells, the third time was in a combat in which he got pummeled by a dreadlord with chillblade sitting on a pegasus that challenged and i had to accept. Every time it was instantly game over due to the crumble that followed. without this stoopid rule my army would still have been fine, couldve managed to draw or win or loose minimally but crumble just goes for instant massacre with no way to recover. it just bashes the game. sad to see.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Well magic should be toned down cuz its ridiculous.

Magic is the only thing keeping the ridiculous deathstar units under control. If people didn't have to fear spells like that, the already painful deathstars we see would be far worse.
 
Skittelz1981 said:
Turn 3; my opponent starts turn 3, casts arnzipals black horror which moves over my ghoul horde, destroys 11 of them then moves over my zombie lordbunker, kills another 14 zombos en my lord.

Couldn't you have done a look out sir and have your lord avoid getting hit by the template on a 2+ ?

I am fairly new so I'm just asking for my own information.
 
I rolled 1 :vampire3:


But the issue is not so much the spell. You have quite an amount of possibilities to escape it with a character. (even though i still think that slain outright with no saves of any kind is a bit overdone, this spell allowed a wardsave which i failed as well after failing my strengthtest)
Its more about the crumble from slain general. Which is just way too punishing for an army. It cripples so bad that it removes nearly any opportunity to get back from it. A punishment so hard for an army that cant even protect its lord better than other armies.
If the punishment is so hard then killing them should be harder than for any other army too. Yet that is absolutely not the case
 
Magic is always going to be unballenced and VC will always be an army that uses magic like a crutch just to stay alive but you have to work around this.
Personally my main complaint with crumble is it kills our vampires which makes no sense in the rule or lore but yet it does.

Best thing you can do I reduce the chance of taking an such tests by always having units supported by other units or magic such as rerolls to mitigate this as much as possible.
No its not an ideal solution but I'm afraid its the best we've got. :(
 
I have to disagree over the crumbling from a slain general. We are Vampire Counts, the key element is that it is about Vampires controlling and driving forth a summoned army of the dead, slaved to his (or her :perv:) will. It makes perfect sense to me that if that control is removed, then many of the dead, especially the lesser dead, simply crumble.

However one things that always irritated me was vampires themselves suffering from crumble. I can kind of understand the reason for the RnF, but just because a bunch of Skellies bite the dust, the vampire goes poof?! I think crumble should remove the unit, and then if a vampire (or perhaps other characters who don't suffer from crumbling) are left, then a break test should be taken with a modifier of the remaining wounds.

Example:

4 Skellies plus vamp
Combat lost by 8
4 Skellies crumble
Vamp takes break test at -4

Would need some good clear wording about how the Vamp can flee under these conditions, but I think would work so much better.
 
Example:

4 Skellies plus vamp
Combat lost by 8
4 Skellies crumble
Vamp takes break test at -4

Would need some good clear wording about how the Vamp can flee under these conditions, but I think would work so much better.

I agree with that logic. After all, vampires (and necromancers) are the only ones that would actually fear for their lives and well-being. The mindless dead care not, but vampires are notoriously interested in themselves. "Death?! Why should I have to die? I am too awesome to die!" So, naturally, they would seek to prolong their own afterlife. Even if Slain General still applied for Fleeing General (because he is not concentrating enough to hold the army together) could even keep it balanced for other armies to accept.
 
I agree with that logic. After all, vampires (and necromancers) are the only ones that would actually fear for their lives and well-being. The mindless dead care not, but vampires are notoriously interested in themselves. "Death?! Why should I have to die? I am too awesome to die!" So, naturally, they would seek to prolong their own afterlife. Even if Slain General still applied for Fleeing General (because he is not concentrating enough to hold the army together) could even keep it balanced for other armies to accept.


I completely agree with this and have argued it for a long time but this used to be the rule but they changed it to simplify it, personally I feel it was simple enough but now it just makes no sense.

In 7th edition I remember having a long vampire against a Minotaur, I got charged in the flank by 2 ungor, a champion and a banner.
I was challenged so had to accept if I wanted to fight.

Killed him outright, vampire was a caster build so caused 2 wounds out of the 3 attacks we got back then.
However I had been charged, flanked and banner so I lost combat by 2 and crumbled to dust because of the one remaining ungor banner bearer.
Stupid rules. (Even if I did get my vengeance in the form of a black coach charging out of the mists)
 
I disagree that magic is that over powered. Out of all previous editions, its actually the most balanced its been. I'd say magic needs just a few tweaks:

1) Tone down nuke spells. Allow look out sir and ward saves.
2) Seperate irresitable force from miscast and allow miscast to trump IF
3) Change shadow lore spells to be more shadowy.
4) change death lore attribute to be less OP.
5) adjust miscast table to wound/effect based on number of power dice used.

As for our army general. The vampire count special rules are good. I like the risk and danger of playing vampires. I think if there are any changes, necromancers should be able to march and maybe make undead immune to poison again.
 
Killing blow makes sense. Cut the zombies head off. Stake the vampire. Etc. Poison affecting war machines makes sense, as the have living crew. Daemons and undead being poisoned, little weird. But meh, doesn't matter to me. Rather have necros marching.
 
Necros marching? But they're very old and poorly men! Now if we could get them those little scooters.....xD

They used to be very old and poorly men... now they are undead, which sucks for purposes of slain general...

Side note, have you seen the trailer for Dracula Untold? The mysterious figure that creates Dracula suspiciously reminds me of Nagash.
 
Killing blow makes sense. Cut the zombies head off. Stake the vampire. Etc. Poison affecting war machines makes sense, as the have living crew. Daemons and undead being poisoned, little weird. But meh, doesn't matter to me. Rather have necros marching.

They are not easy to kill though, some characters are immune as they are said to be tough, you can hack a zombie to pieces and it will still crawl towards you, remove a skeletons limb, nothing.
If mortals who die when they are in 7 pieces or more are immune why do the things that are harder to kill go down easier is what i am saying?

That Vampire in Dracula Untold has nothing on Nagash, maybe Ushoran as he tended to wear his nature more on the outside than others but Nagash is more like a force than a being, he is so far removed from humanity its had to give him justice when describing him.
 
That Vampire in Dracula Untold has nothing on Nagash, maybe Ushoran as he tended to wear his nature more on the outside than others but Nagash is more like a force than a being, he is so far removed from humanity its had to give him justice when describing him.

I mean the part when (soon-to-be) Dracula is climbing up the tower in the mountain where he meets a really old (like hundreds of years) Tywin Lannister (how cool would it be if we could combine the two realms!), who turns him into the powerful vampire. Dracula is thought to be one of the first vampires, although in VC history, Lahmia is the first. Nagash was still alive for another 400 (or so) years after the first vampire, so he could still have been very well alive at the time of Dracula. I also loved the imagery of the Bat Swarm.
 
Nefrata is the first in VC lore which is a desert realm much like Egypt which could be argued as a correlation between GW lore and Anne Rice with the Vampire Lestat.
Nagash is alive even now and never truely died. Also we have a VC Dracula, He is called Vashanesh/ Prince Vladimir/ Vlad Von Carstein.
 
Nefrata is the first in VC lore which is a desert realm much like Egypt which could be argued as a correlation between GW lore and Anne Rice with the Vampire Lestat.
Nagash is alive even now and never truely died. Also we have a VC Dracula, He is called Vashanesh/ Prince Vladimir/ Vlad Von Carstein.

My mistake. Nefarata was the queen of Lahmia. Also, I know that Nagash is "still alive" but I meant still in bodily form (which he may very well still be). Because Dracula becomes a vampire in the same that way Nefarata does (drinking elixir rather than receiving the Blood Kiss) in Dracula Untold, I am saying that the timelines run concurrent. I know that nobody knows when Vlad received the Blood Kiss, so it's entirely possible that he didn't, but I don't see him as being the same as Dracula (at least not in this movie).
 
"Because Dracula becomes a vampire in the same that way Nefarata does (drinking elixir rather than receiving the Blood Kiss)"
I think you have that mixed up, Its Vlad, Not Dracula which does it this way.

In the lore of Dracula and not the movie he never receives any blood kiss but is made thus his power.
Either way I am not going to dig out the book at this time of night but the Libre Necris gives the exact date he was turned and explains it was because Nefrata loved him the moment she saw him, but to annoyance of Abhorash.
 
"Because Dracula becomes a vampire in the same that way Nefarata does (drinking elixir rather than receiving the Blood Kiss)"
I think you have that mixed up, Its Vlad, Not Dracula which does it this way.

In the lore of Dracula and not the movie he never receives any blood kiss but is made thus his power.
Either way I am not going to dig out the book at this time of night but the Libre Necris gives the exact date he was turned and explains it was because Nefrata loved him the moment she saw him, but to annoyance of Abhorash.
I only have the VC rulebooks and only 8th edition presently at my disposal.
 
Yeh, there is allot you are missing in the lore books.
If you get a change get hold of all the rule books, the undead rule books as well for when they also had tomb kings, Libre Necris, Nights Dark Masters, Dwarf Grudge Lore (We are in this allot as well), and any and all campaign books like Circle of Blood, Sigmars Blood, Storm of Chaos (Some you can see how we treat Crom and Everchosen ;) ) plus novels of course like Vampire Wars, Time of Legends books which cover us and Nagash, Genevieve, Gotrek and Felix.
All these cover allot of our lore and character background, there is a fair few more I have not mentioned but this should be a really good start for you.
 
as for the synergy, it barely ever happens to me. vamplore is a soso lore that is not offensive at all. any decent player will know when to dispel vanhels and when to dispel IoN which are basically the 2 real spells we have that actually matter.

Funny you say this, as I find that Raise Dead is the spell that hands-down wins me more games than anything else in the book. Curse of Years is amazing as well for whittling down units and screwing with my opponents' magic phase. Don't want me to get Vanhels off? Better hope you roll a big magic phase next turn then or waste it all getting rid of CoY.
 
I make sure I have 3 casters with IoN in all my lists, thus making it far more likely that my units will heal. Raise Dead is quite nice, I agree and can be a gamewinner for sure.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu