advice needed for end times game

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
I guess the argument is they lose steadfast, which they rely on a lot. One of our demons players plays nurgle, and maybe it's just me, but I demolish his troops with my witch elves regularly. I can see it only getting worse for him with regular instability.

Conversely the other demons player we have runs slaanesh/tzeentch and he relies on steadfast all the time to hold things in place while his chariots and other sources of counter damage get into place.

Personally I agree with you, i Think regular instability takes the dice out of the equation, and ultimately, whenever you pick up the dice, you have to be prepared for boxcars, and the results that follow.
 
First off, will you play the chaos ascension rules? If so then plaguebearers lose instability and are just left with unbreakable IIRC.
 
But it would be nice to mathhammer a bit though, don't have the time for it right now though. When you write "regular instability" do you mean Unstable? Just to be perfectly clear :D


Sorry yes, I mean Unstable, Unbreakable, etc.

The same as what Undead currently have.

If you have time later I'd be willing to work with you to mathhammer it out, see how it plays out. I am keen to have something to back up my opinions in my discussions with my friends.
 
First off, will you play the chaos ascension rules? If so then plaguebearers lose instability and are just left with unbreakable IIRC.
Chaos ascendant is essentially scenario based optional rules. They won't be used. Ironic that GW did that with summoning in this book considering how not that everything in Nagash book is.
 
Chaos ascendant is essentially scenario based optional rules. They won't be used. Ironic that GW did that with summoning in this book considering how not that everything in Nagash book is.

The concept of summoning an army of monsters strikes me as a much more necromancy type thing than a demonology type thing. So to me it makes more sense to have a whole lore dedicated to raising undead troops over summoning demons from the realm of chaos.

strictly from a fluff perspective of course.
 
I mean that they made chaos ascendant rules optional and way over the top. Surprised they did that. I was looking forward to daemon summoning. Instead we get optional rules for summoning and unbreakable daemons that most players treat as needing opponent's consent.

What they should have done. Made ascendant something built in and toned down. Choose ascendant god, those units suffer 1 less from unstable. Ascendant daemons can be summoned. The summoning spell acts like a signature spell for any lore a chaos sorcerer takes. Something like that would be easy and allow the whole package in.
 
I had not read this post for a while, and caught up just now.

Here's why I think your opponent will bring an Infantry Chaos Legions lists:

- Chariots, Cavalry and Monsters can't garrison inside the Watchtower. So he needs Infantry or M. Infantry to do so.
- Out of M.I. and regular Infantry, only Blightkings hold any sort of advantage while garrisoned, followed closely by Khorne Warriors (too many attacks for up to 10 models). Actually, since Blightkings are much harder to kill, I'd expect them be the ones garrisoned there!

That is why Curse of Years is much more important than while in regular games, where everyone takes only chariots.


Now, the Watchtower must be deployed in the centre of the table, doesn't it? That means, there is some partial LoS cover for Nagash (and if the player you speak of is really that good, he'll consider bringing at least 2 Khorne Cannons, since the bane of WoC were Terrorgheists, and he is mainly a Warriors player, isn't he?). So have some strategy to stop that in advance!

Vargheists suffer a bit to kill the Skullcanons, but only if you take the minimum size unit. Have 5+ and focus only on them.

Also, Chariots is a no no against Nagash, who can charge them turn 1 and then just be safe from canonballs.

Hmmm another cheesy thing he could bring is a Doombull kited to wreck anything that dares enter his Watchtower (with the... goathelm, don't recall it's english name, but the one giving him an auto-attack on an armor save). he's cheap (for what he does) and can get the job done against Undead.

Also, you don't really need both Casket and Hierotitan for a 2000pts game. Nagash is wizard enough to cast well on his own, and I'd give priority to the Casket over the Hierotitan, because a lousy snake-eyes magic phase becomes a total dominance with it, plus it's bound spell really hurts Chaos.

Finally, if you don't favor Spirit leech (it's great against, say... Chariots!) then yep, go undeath - Vampires.

Another thing you can do, is go Undeath - Light and abuse Shem's and Banishment if you can manage it, plus Pha's on Nagash is really helpful!
 
I think he's going plaguebearers actually. I expect WOC daemon princes. Hellcannon is likely. Skull cannons too. I'm doing the 2000 point list and summoning my army in using tactics discussed above. Honestly, if he brings chariots I just focus on tower and gaze/ruby ring. If he brings infantry we go curse, screams, ruby ring. Once zombies in tower it's nearly over.

Game time in an hour! I'll post an update let you guys know how it goes. Thanks for all the advice everyone!
 
Take no prisoners!
Victory! Woot!

Game went nothing like expected. Totally fought tooth and nail for the win. He's a great opponent.

He brought a 10 pink horror unit, nurgle WoC DP, tzeentch chaos Lord on dragon with hellfire sword, 20 nurgle chaos warriors, 2 beasts, 5 flamers, slug tongue special character.

I got the tower and deployed nothing in it. He took first turn and hopped his DP to block my zombies. He then moved his chaos warriors to the tower which they take on his turn 2. I summoned 6 morghast archai and 11 crypt horrors. Casket fizzled and got killed by flamers. DP got bogged down whole game by Zeds. Crypt horrors were slaughtered in once and a half round of combat by his lord. My archai held out. Turn after turn off sniper spells, T debuff, pink fire etc, wittled away my control. I used VHDM, HV and CoY to retain control. Nagash killed the chaos dragon and broke the lord, but didn't pursue to maintain position. Finally the morghasts finished off the CW in tower after five turns. We moved in, he pushed on our position. Went two more rounds and game ended. I had killed everything but his DP, last of his horrors, flamers. and beastman SC. I only had Nagash, 15 zombies, 3 morghasts and control of the MFing tower! Brutal!
 
I'm overall a fan of Nagash and the Morghasts. This was the first time I really relied on Archai, using Harbringers before. The Archai held their ground well, their anti-crumble aura helped a lot (as did Nagash's), their S6 attacks punched through the chaos warrior's armor well. They operated away from the general's march radius with their 10" hover. Morghasts are a solid, reliable, road block type of unit that hold up well.

Nagash has served me well. I've won about 70% of my games I have used him in so far. I'm getting a good handle on playing keep away and knowing when I should charge in with him to keep him safe. He is tricky to use since he has no mobility (i.e. fly or high move score). You need to be careful what to expose him to or he can get swarmed and pinned down. Nagash does well in combat against other large enemy with his S8 attacks, T7 and W7, plus 4++.

What is surprising me is how limited Lore of Undeath is proving to be for me. I find that most of the game I cast Vampire lore, that most of my summonings are things like Crypt Horrors and Morghasts and then the rest of the time Lore of Undeath is the inferior choice to what I can cast. Nagash also can't dump an unwanted spell for the signature spell, so he can get stuck with Hand of Dust for example. I usually take 4-5 Undeath spells and then end up wishing I took more Vampire, or instead to some Death, Light or Nehekara.

What do you guys find with Lore of Undeath? Does the other spells serve you as well or better than Lore of Vampires? How do you feel it stacks up?
 
I haven't played Nagash or the Mortarch yet. I wanted to try LoU but everytimes I pondered how, I came to the conclusion that LoV is clearly Superior. The summoning spell's limited range is the deal breaker for me.

Now with Nagash, Arkhan or Mannfred you get better range. I could see them being usefull but then again, I would probably only take Ryze and draw the rest of my spells from LoV. I think that, unless you really want a specific LoU spell, 3 pick on in that lore is enough.
 
First, nicely done! That is a lot of character nastiness to deal with. I am quite surprised no hell cannon or skill cannon.

I have not played much with lore of undeath, as my games to this point have been 500ish point games (with one exception messing around with Nagash) but I think you have to have the right units to summon. Morghasts, Crypt Horrors, Grave Guard and the Terrorgheist seem to me to be the best options for summoning. When comparing Harbingers and Archai, Archai take up valuable rare points that would otherwise be spent on Terrorgheists, Mortis Engines, Hierotitans, and the casket. So they are prime targets for summoning in. I think I prefer the 3 attacks str 6 4+ vs. 4 attacks str 5 5+ but but have their uses.

With Nagash summoning I think your best target for Ryze is elite infantry, I think you can squeeze in 25 Grave Guard and full command plus banner of the barrows (if your meta allows it) inside his base 450 points of summoning. That's a great road blocker for just about anything and with it costing you 0 vps can be sacrificed IMO even to a nurgle demon prince. (Str 6 +1 to hit can even do a number on him)

You have to take what your opponent will give you though, so if he focused on dispelling the infantry summoner that must have left you room for other things.

Incidentally, what was your final spell load out? Did you try to summon in any other casters (for free channeling, spell versatility, etc.)
 
First, nicely done! That is a lot of character nastiness to deal with. I am quite surprised no hell cannon or skill cannon.
Thanks! Yes he said he considered cannons. The low points made it difficult and he opted for the lords instead since they could block units and grind. His core was spent on pink horrors and chaos warriors. He was hoping the horrors could do some of the work of the cannons and come out of core points. He said not bringing cannons was a mistake.

Incidentally, what was your final spell load out? Did you try to summon in any other casters (for free channeling, spell versatility, etc.)
Nagash had Ryze, of course, then abyssal, harbringer, hand of dust, breath, VHDM, HV, curse of years, IoN. Necro had Gaze of Nagash and IoN. I used ryze, VHDM, CoY the most. IoN, HV, GoN all got used once. Light of death and Spirit Leech both got used but failed to do anything.
 
I think there's a couple of considerations for Lore of Undeath. First, the summoning spells simply aren't that flash. Second, what you can summon is strictly limited to what models you have.

Now, taking Nagash mitigates the first problem. Summoning triple the points value at triple the range is hands down game-winning. Turn 1 and you've got Nine Vargheists summoned in your rear arc? Yes please. And you can only mitigate the second problem through your own model collection because, after all, you need those nine Vargheists to start with. And the problem then becomes in later turns, what do you have left to summon? There's nothing stopping you from summoning a Terrorgheist, 8 Blood Knights, a Vampire Hero, nine Vargheists and 5 Spirit Hosts every turn! except that I simply don't have 6 Tbats, 48 blood knights, 30 spirit hosts and 54 Vargs. If you don't have enough models to really make use of the Lore of Undeath then naturally it will be of limited use.

If you're not taking Nagash, I would rate Lore of the Vampires as a much better lore. If you're taking Nagash, lore of Undeath is amazing. Hell, you want more LoV? Just summon your own Master Necromancer! With Nagash I take all 7 Lore of Undeath spells. I know this means I'm stuck with a couple of crappy ones, but IMO the benefit of being certain to have all the summoning spells is worth it. When he's not casting Lore of Undeath summoning spells, then Nagash is just a regular wizard. He needs to be casting those spells to get the most bang for his buck. I then take two Lore of Vampire spells on top of my lore of Undeath, purely so I can make use of the lore attribute to heal some wounds on Nagash if he got unlucky. The ability to summon those powerful 450+ point units anywhere within 36", and the fact that even if the enemy destroys those units they are worth ZERO victory points, is immensely powerful.
 
You raise a good point. Just summon vampire lore casters. In theory, Nagash can take all 7 spells, two vampire spells for back up and then just summon his army into play as you say. In practice I find he is limited by the winds of magic and any miscasts or fail spells that occur. Even if I do take 7 undeath, then use harbringer to summon a lord with vampire lore, I only get 195 points to do that. This restricts the power of that master necromancer unless you have tokens.

The other option is to rely on vampire and death magic and let ryze do your summoning every turn. Between Varghiests, crypt horrors and morghasts, most of the tools needed are covered. Though summoned Tbats are awesome, they also take casting on a 24.

Nagash with a full load of vampire and death spells is snipping and purple sunning easily, then using the vampire lore to manipulate everything he summons and what's already in his army.

I'll have to experiment with both approaches. If you do to, I like to compare what we find out.
 
Sure, although to be honest I don't like taking Nagash without warning people first. Last game I played I destroyed my opponents 2,500 Ogre army for the loss of 30 Dire Wolves. It can be a bit one-sided if people aren't expecting him.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu