Yep, the magic being listed on the scroll could mean only when using said scroll you are allowed to summon stuff. Could be wrong.
From what I understand you can choose to include WarScrolls or not. I played it as though you needed to field the unit to get the Summon Spell my first game, but I could see reasonably just saying that you are going to include the WarScroll as part of the army with no models on the board. If you play a game where WarScrolls are limited (By player agreement or otherwise) then this would make a lot of sense, since it's like putting units in reserves almost.
May you please share your insights into the tactical play in this game? I played a game and everything just got into some big blobs and we threw some dice some things died and tactics seemed to be a foreign concept. I hope I don't sound cruel I'm not trying to be I just don't get where your getting the complexity in this game from.
While I'm not as overly exuberant as Najo about how thrillingly great the new system is, I am also not in the same camp as you.
I believe that much of people's experiences with this new version of the game are going to be heavily tinted by their initial knee-jerk reactions, and people (On either side) are not really thinking too hard about it.
I played a few games yesterday, although I probably won't get anymore in for a while (Maybe one of these weekdays I'll try again, but certainly not today). But from what I played, the whole game is grossly simplified. I played the game as written with no restriction on shooting into/out of combat, and that changes the valuation of some units a bit, as their ranged attacks essentially become additional hits, but only on their turn. It doesn't seem to be too big of a boon, but I haven't played against a variety of forces yet to see a ranged unit that is
too strong with this interpretation of the rules. But you can easily just agree not to with friends, but I guess strangers may be a bit different depending on their disposition and desires.
As for movement specifically? It's not that bad. Movement ranges vary by units, with the "mounted" ones moving a fairly uniform 10" or so, most humans at 5" and "Slow" being 4" and "Fast" being 6". Pretty standard stuff, and at this point I feel I could guess the speed of any model I already own on that basic knowledge, which is cool.
With the movement though there are some rules intricacies I can see coming from this. For starters running. Either you choose to get the +d6" movement (Larger bonus for some armies, depending on speed) and you forgo Shooting/Charging, or you take your normal movement and accept it there. Personally I have been allowing people to move, take measurements and then decide if they want to run following. It's a hold over from
40k running being in the shooting phase, so I'm just use to it being a different interaction. But it allows people to see if their guns are in range/if they want to run or how far from a charge they are beforehand.
So running is kind of cool, it's a bit of a risk-reward thing, just far simpler and fairly easy to control. The biggest "tactical" choice with running I've come into is that, if you are on the "bottom" of the turn, right before Initiative, rolling for that run can put you right where you need to to really get a good turn off if you take the initiative. But on the other hand you may be setting yourself up to be charged by our opponent. It's a little dicey (No pun), and FAR more random of an interaction that in previous editions where the game was much more about planning and executing a sound strategy, but it does offer the chance for risk-reward play, and a bit of "Ohhhhh GOT YOU!" type moments.
The 3" charge range also means that charges of snake-eyes always fail, something I did not consider before it happened to me. That in itself is interesting, because without explicitly having to state that 2" always fails, they worked it into the rules, which is.. almost clever. Almost. Some units Special rules for charging will also come out as we move forwards, and things like Skeleton's WarScroll which grant a minimum charge of 6" is pretty great, giving you full control over knowing if you'll be in at a certain range. There are also units with bonuses (I haven't looked at Brits, but I'm sure they still get charge bonuses of some sort).
Along with this, the " 3" buffer " around units now does provide some things. I don't know big of a deal it was to Najo's games (Apparently fairly great, since he likes to mention it), but I can see that enabling you to "Force" opponents around units or creating road blocks in tight areas of the board such that you can control the flow of battle.
The 1/2" charge range also means that once units are into each other for combat and "Spread out" by their pile-in moves, that you won't really be able to charge in second units unless you have moved around or there is open space on the frontage of the unit. Not exactly what I'd call depth, but an interesting point to consider as armies "Smash together into blobs."
It's not exactly what I'd call depth, but it has a lot more going for it than you might be looking for. Especially if you're already trying to take out the trash, and you are glazing over everything with a disdainful attitude before you start. Not that I'm saying you are for sure doing so, but I feel that many players may do well to take at least one introspective look at the whole deal.
For me personally? I agree with a lot of what Eyeless stated as pros/cons. Except that I don't think summoning is restricted the way he said, and the magic phase is a little lack-luster with almost no models, but I could see it getting interesting with larger forces.
The biggest thing they have robbed me of is customization/list building. The level of detail/choices I had previous was much greater, and it was one of the biggest things in the game for me. Building list was important, it was what
was fun for me. Although there are a few rules tweaks for what would have been different gear options previously, so there is still a bit of customization reflected by the rules, but damn do I miss my blood-lines.
However, considering the different effects of items or units, even before these rules, I was working on modeling units that had nothing to do with what GW said for me to play with. For instance I was working on a "Coiling Death Wurm" that was burrowing/breaking ground over the course of 6x40mm bases, that I planned to use as Crypt Horrors. I just thought it was cool (And had terrorgheist parts left over that inspired me). There is nothing stopping me from doing so now as well. I also had a multitude of vampires with "Various" interpretations of rules reflected in their modeling, like a Female Vampire born into the air in a swarm of crows that I was going to simply count as a Nightmare in game, despite it's obvious lack of being an actual Nightmare.
I mean, even before
AoS I was using my imagination in the game, flavoring things how I liked, playing the way I wanted.
And if you think about it, do I really have to be missing them entirely? I mean I very well could come up with formations/ideas to reflect the effects I loved in game, with opponents permission, and heaven forbid, GW might do the same with forthcoming expansions/rules sets.
That is one of the biggest things I am grasping at for this game. If GW comes out with permissions sets for scenarios that give objective play like in
40k currently (I don't know if you're familiar, but it's random VPs based on objectives generated in game), I would honestly throw all doubts away and jump whole-heartedly into
AoS. And that's for the permission of objectives. I don't even need them to tell me I can for me to do it, and I'm sure soon enough I'll be coming up with a mock-deck of objectives just like from
40k, because I think it'll be fun. And if GW comes out with campaign books, detailing "Epic historic fights" and "Worlds conqoured" and all the special rules you can shake a stick at to go with them (New terrain rules, mission rules, maybe even rules for extended multi-mission play), then this game will be rolling, in my opinion.
And I feel like most people are really not looking at what they are being given, they are only looking at what was taken away.
Sure I feel robbed on a few aspects of the game, but in the end, they don't define my enjoyment - of the hobby or the game that is played with my models.
But if you played for the game, then I can't help you. I am a hobbyist, and I play a game with the works of my hobby. I never picked up Warhammer because it was the greatest game to play, I picked it up because the models and story were great, it inspired stories for me, and my friends and I can sit back and have something to burn time on together. And if those things are destroyed for you than I am sorry, but this is not the end of the world.
Not the real world anyways - in game, the world is pretty much shot.