Forge said:
no, the problem is people try to run them liek they did in 7th, small one rank units of cavalry. they are far to expensive to do this way and way more vulnerable due to LoS rules, destructive magic, no more guess ranges with artillery and lack the ability to break ranks (and steadfast, which did not exist in the last edition) unless they are ran at least 10 strong with characters and a protective banner.
True, it is a risk to run them in a smaller unit. I have had almost the same discussion with other WoC players about wether to run 2x5 (or 6) Chaos Knights or 1x10 with char support. Many are afraid to run them too small due to warmachines and/or magic and I can understand their position. A large, char supported, unit of Hv Cav is most certainly a magnet for enemy fire but does a small unit really draw that much attention?
I've found that half of my opponents don't even bother shooting/casting at small units of Hv Cav anymore because there are much better targets on the table and Hv Cav is just too hard to kill. Plus there is always the risk of shooting at a unit with a good defensive banner in it. Sometimes the ability to take a good banner is just as good as the banner itself

It's like sending 2 units at an Abom or a Hydra. Which one has the 10pt Flame banner? Shoot both and you might not kill either. Kill one and the other has the banner= bye,bye Hydra.
Against the other half of my opponents I do lose a unit (especialy if they go 1st) before I hit their lines. I can influence their choice of targets a bit by placement, terrain, screening, buffs ect but something will get shot at. If it's "only" a small unit then it's less of a loss and allows my other units to get into position untouched.
What I don't like about a big Hv Cav unit is the reduction in units. 2 units cover double the territory, threaten twice as many units, are half as valuable thus twice as expendable. I find that having multiple units threatening a large amount of potential targets forces my opponents to make choices and therefore mistakes opening holes in his/her battle line. Im not saying go back to MSU style like in 7th. This doesn't apply to infantry and not even "normal" Cavalry, only to elite Hv Cav and monsterous inf/cav. Things that remain a threat even in small numbers.
Breaking Ranks: Ok you have a point there, but if your super unit get reduced to 9 models they won't be breaking ranks either. I've given up trying to break ranks with such expensive models so I don't bother. I guess that's why people perfer Black Knights as they do a better job of it. I like to let my Hv Cav do what they do best, kill stuff. Against smaller units they just kill them all. Against bigger units they shread until the unit is small enough to break with whatever I can get in the front. Or I don't even bother attacking the bigger units, that's what Elite Inf is for. Most of the time I just clean up the support units. Hv Cav might seem like overkill but it assures me of being able to break through, reform and on to the next target.
So to sum up:
Forge you are right, most people will be better off with a large well supported and well protected unit of Blood Knights. But for those who want to take a bit more risk and have more points for other rares (which
VC have a lot of good choices of) I think a small unit is certainly viable, maybe not ideal but viable.
Stonewyrm
P.S. It would be interessting to hear from the more expierienced Vampire commanders about the possible synergy between Blood Knights and other
VC units, especialy the rares.