8th Edition Blood Knights - More Viable?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
to keep my blood knights alive its the banner o blood keep and a thrall with magic res 2. so thats a 4+ ward vs cannon AND a 2+ ward vs magic that allows some sort of a save. it allows them to get to where they need to be ie combat. i run a unit of 6 or 7. they evaporate units.
 
I think blood knights have become somewhat less viable (until higher point values), the ability to control frenzy is good, but we used to be able to do that last edition with screening them with wolves, now the dogs arnt needed and a leadership will suffice. but now because you cant screen your blood knights to not get shot or avoid frenzy and artillery has become MUCH more deadly as you dont have to guess anymore i think running them in small numbers is asking for them to get crushed, they are AMAZING in larger numbers at least 7-8 strong at LEAST with banner of blood keep.
 
Forge said:
I think blood knights have become somewhat less viable (until higher point values), the ability to control frenzy is good, but we used to be able to do that last edition with screening them with wolves, now the dogs arnt needed and a leadership will suffice. but now because you cant screen your blood knights to not get shot or avoid frenzy and artillery has become MUCH more deadly as you dont have to guess anymore i think running them in small numbers is asking for them to get crushed, they are AMAZING in larger numbers at least 7-8 strong at LEAST with banner of blood keep.

actually you dont need the banner o bloodkeep. vs non arty you can place a unit of say 6 dogs in front to give hard cover. -2 to hit is a god send. now you charge with dogs at one target and BKs at a different. true LOS means the vamps can still see their target. but i prefer the bloodkeep banner myself.
 
u need or blood keep or u need drakenhoff
that unit is attracting bullets/arrows/ other projectiles i dont want to think about/ flaming stuff (unusual but could still happen)
and yes
Blood knights are not good in smaller armies
blood knights are the center of your army ramming straight through the enemy before you can say peanut butter
 
Vampire BK, i have trouble reading your posts due to the lack of any decipherable Gramar... Mind editing to make that a bit clearer? Please!

Blood knights are fun... But im not sure id run them often.
 
Greetings and Salutations

Being my first post, I must make aware that I am building a Vampire army and have not yet the oppertunity to field them in battle. I am intrigued by this discussion about Blood Knights as they were one of the big reasons why I started collecting Vampires. I field both WoC and Bretonnian armies so I feel confident that I have learned a couple of tricks about how to use Heavy Cavalry.

Is it really nessesary to add a character or an expensive banner to an already expensive unit? Of course it makes the unit better but they can be run without can't they?
Why is Int 4 "horrible"? Seems pretty average to me or even slightly above average. And even if they attack 2nd they are Hv Cav with a 2+ AS.
Why would you put a fast unit like Blood Knights in the centre of your Army limiting their mobility and leaving them vunerable to being surrounded?

Due to my expirience with Chaos Knights, Grail Knights and Dragon Princes I would have to agree with Gladius Rex and Ferrum. Use Blood Knights and their speed to flank enemies that are in CC with your infantry or go in alone (from the flank) to hold an enemy unit until you can charge/Vanhels something in the front. Or use them to run over small to middle sized units on the flanks. Or even use them to take out enemy warmachines before circling back to hit the main battle line from the rear.

It would seem to me that like other Hv Cav, Blood Knights have a new role in 8th. They are no longer able to just charge anything from the front and break them. They need to be used in a flank/support role where their weak SCR is less relavent and their pure killing power is best put to use.
 
i find you just need to pick your battles. a wight bsb with the hatred banner and the Bloods with regen or blood keep have a great SCR. +1 charge...+1 bsb...+1 std. plus a bajillion attacks str7 or 5 and 4.

as a surprise the hand of death or book or arkhan is great on a vamp in there. asf and reroll misses is just too good.
 
Stonewyrm,

The problem that some people have is adapting from what Blood Knights WERE in 7th ed (pure death on hoofs) to what they are now, which is more a strategic part of the battle plan. Before you just needed some fodder to shield you until you were ready to charge... now you need an infantry unit to hold your target in place to the Knights can smash into them.

Honestly I was doing the same thing in 7th ed, tar pitting with infantry and breaking units with flank charges, but now that 5 wide horses dont cause Disruption, people turn their noses at them like they are useless, and frankly I dont get it.

But to each their own.
 
@ Gladius

The best part about those nose turners is that they underestimate the unit, so when it comes time for blood to be spilledthe knights are often allowed to run free :suck:

This is from my limited experience of course but Stormwyrm really got it, they can kill just about anything they touch even without buffs like VHD or a lord, and just to comment on your question about if they need a character or banners etc... I don't think they need them persay, it's just that there are many things that can tip the balance against units like Chaos Warriors who'd strike first, I usually give a thrall in there terror and blood drinker as well as the dragon helm this gives the unit a chance to scare away things that they'd normally have more trouble
facing, and since they're on the flanks they should be out of the general's LD bubble. However I
also keep a necro with book of Arkhan handy just in case :)

*EDITED* (thrall load out)
 
Gladius Rex said:
Stonewyrm,

The problem that some people have is adapting from what Blood Knights WERE in 7th ed (pure death on hoofs) to what they are now, which is more a strategic part of the battle plan. Before you just needed some fodder to shield you until you were ready to charge... now you need an infantry unit to hold your target in place to the Knights can smash into them.

Honestly I was doing the same thing in 7th ed, tar pitting with infantry and breaking units with flank charges, but now that 5 wide horses dont cause Disruption, people turn their noses at them like they are useless, and frankly I dont get it.

But to each their own.

no, the problem is people try to run them liek they did in 7th, small one rank units of cavalry. they are far to expensive to do this way and way more vulnerable due to LoS rules, destructive magic, no more guess ranges with artillery and lack the ability to break ranks (and steadfast, which did not exist in the last edition) unless they are ran at least 10 strong with characters and a protective banner.
 
Forge said:
no, the problem is people try to run them liek they did in 7th, small one rank units of cavalry. they are far to expensive to do this way and way more vulnerable due to LoS rules, destructive magic, no more guess ranges with artillery and lack the ability to break ranks (and steadfast, which did not exist in the last edition) unless they are ran at least 10 strong with characters and a protective banner.

True, it is a risk to run them in a smaller unit. I have had almost the same discussion with other WoC players about wether to run 2x5 (or 6) Chaos Knights or 1x10 with char support. Many are afraid to run them too small due to warmachines and/or magic and I can understand their position. A large, char supported, unit of Hv Cav is most certainly a magnet for enemy fire but does a small unit really draw that much attention?

I've found that half of my opponents don't even bother shooting/casting at small units of Hv Cav anymore because there are much better targets on the table and Hv Cav is just too hard to kill. Plus there is always the risk of shooting at a unit with a good defensive banner in it. Sometimes the ability to take a good banner is just as good as the banner itself ;) It's like sending 2 units at an Abom or a Hydra. Which one has the 10pt Flame banner? Shoot both and you might not kill either. Kill one and the other has the banner= bye,bye Hydra.

Against the other half of my opponents I do lose a unit (especialy if they go 1st) before I hit their lines. I can influence their choice of targets a bit by placement, terrain, screening, buffs ect but something will get shot at. If it's "only" a small unit then it's less of a loss and allows my other units to get into position untouched.

What I don't like about a big Hv Cav unit is the reduction in units. 2 units cover double the territory, threaten twice as many units, are half as valuable thus twice as expendable. I find that having multiple units threatening a large amount of potential targets forces my opponents to make choices and therefore mistakes opening holes in his/her battle line. Im not saying go back to MSU style like in 7th. This doesn't apply to infantry and not even "normal" Cavalry, only to elite Hv Cav and monsterous inf/cav. Things that remain a threat even in small numbers.

Breaking Ranks: Ok you have a point there, but if your super unit get reduced to 9 models they won't be breaking ranks either. I've given up trying to break ranks with such expensive models so I don't bother. I guess that's why people perfer Black Knights as they do a better job of it. I like to let my Hv Cav do what they do best, kill stuff. Against smaller units they just kill them all. Against bigger units they shread until the unit is small enough to break with whatever I can get in the front. Or I don't even bother attacking the bigger units, that's what Elite Inf is for. Most of the time I just clean up the support units. Hv Cav might seem like overkill but it assures me of being able to break through, reform and on to the next target.

So to sum up: Forge you are right, most people will be better off with a large well supported and well protected unit of Blood Knights. But for those who want to take a bit more risk and have more points for other rares (which VC have a lot of good choices of) I think a small unit is certainly viable, maybe not ideal but viable.

Stonewyrm

P.S. It would be interessting to hear from the more expierienced Vampire commanders about the possible synergy between Blood Knights and other VC units, especialy the rares.
 
@ Stonewyrm.

We had a thread about such a thing, it got locked down a few weeks back. Sorry about your luck.

There are sort of two camps on the topic, those who have no problem with 5 blood knights/ w banner and a Combat Thrall (typically with Blood Drinker) and use them to flank charge.

Then there are those that feel they need 10 so they can cause Disruption. I dont know why disruption is so important to them, it has nothing to do with Steadfast (which in my opinion is the real objective to win).

so for me, I bring large blocks of infantry, 5 or 6 wide and typically 5 ranks deep, and I hit units with them to break steadfast. Our core typically wont kill alot of things, so breaking stedfast doesnt mean much if you dont win, so I tend to hit a flank with a heavy hitting unit. I dont need them to cause disruption, i just need them to dish out 5-8 wounds. That typically reduces their leadership down (now that stedfast is gone) to the point that they have a pretty low chance of succeeding their break test. To get those 5-8 wounds, i can lose a Blood Knight and still get it done, since my Thrall often regens them via Blood Drinker or IoN.

Of course I dont need Blood Knights for that, I can get the same effect from Black Knights with KB Lances, or even another unit of infantry if one is nearby.

I guess for me, the formula for winning in 8th ed is really a quite simple one.

1. Break Steadfast (this means out rank them)
2. Deliver hard hitting unit to a flank
3. Overrun

If you wipe two units of your enemy in this fashion, you typically are in pretty good shape for the rest of the fight being as noone regrows troops like we do, once the battle tips in our favor, it typically wont tip back the other way unless your luck just goes sour.

I guess the real question is... why worry so much about Disruption? You are at best only gaining +3 CR, if you hit them hard enough, you can reduce them to a LD of 2 or 3 for most armies, maybe a 5 if its Elves or Dwarves.

Losing ranks in 7th ed was a much bigger deal because for VC, static combat res was one of our biggest assets, but now it really isnt. We still have some capability, but lets be fair, that isnt how we are winning battles these days. Thus why i state that the problem isnt how people are fielding them, its the mentality of what objectives need to be accomplished and asking the wrong kind of units to do the wrong sort of jobs.
 
Gladius Rex said:
There are sort of two camps on the topic, those who have no problem with 5 blood knights/ w banner and a Combat Thrall....Then there are those that feel they need 10 so they can cause Disruption.

I guess the real question is... why worry so much about Disruption?

Very True. But I will give the other camp credit, +3 CR is nothing to sneeze at. They can certainly hit targets that I might avoid because of the static CR. I guess it also comes down to what do you want to achive with your Blood Knights? Clean up small and medium sized support units/Warmachines? Hunt Monsters? Take down big blocks of infantry? The role dictates the size, I guess some just use their BK differently.

I posted in a thread on another forum called "Can Cav heavy VC work?". I gave my opinions on how to use Hv Cav in general (not VC specific), maybe they can be helpful for someone.

"Using Hv Cav in 8th seems to require: (For me at least)

1) Patience. Wait for the right charge, always flank if possible. Unless your opponent has lots of warmachines don't get sucked in to early.
2) Cunning. Attacking unexpectedly can throw an opponent off balance. Just because unit "X" is on the outer flank doesn't mean that you have to attack unit "X". Sometimes an unexpected attack on unit "Y" (just inside of "X") will be more effective because either: a) "Y" is weaker, b) it will create a big whole in the battleline and/or c) it opens up overruns on juicy targets. VC seem to have tons of options when it comes to increasing movement or ignoring terrain. Banners of Swiftness, Rampager's, Ranger's, Hellish Vigour. Ethereal, Flying, Talisman of Lycni, Hunter in the Dark and Vanhel's!!
3) Protection. Any kind of protection is important, Ward vs. shooting, Ironcurse, MR, whatever.
4) Support. Get some inf unit into the combat or at least threaten (be within 8"-10"). Either they won't be able to reform or they will be afraid to due to the chance of a countercharge by your inf unit into their front (now flank). I don't have enough experience with VC but maybe even a raised Zombie unit in the rear could work.
5) Balls! It take courage to use Hv Cav in units of less than 10. A unit of 10 might last longer but 2x5 (or 2x6) will cover a lot more ground and threaten a bigger area. Risk vs. Reward, your choice. Using re-raise (or Lore of Life for other armies) can midigate the risk of running small units and won't hurt big units either. :wink: "
 
The big problem with running blood knights in 10 is that the ones in the second row only get one attack... so you're paying 55 points for one str 5-7 attack (in reality you'd be paying 275 points for 5 str 5-7 attacks)... quite a rip off if you ask me :D especially when for 120 points you can get just as many str 4-6 attacks with KB from black knights. And of course, if your unit drops to 9 by the end of CC, then you don't disrupt. So really I would say it's pretty much the best way to run these guys. And I can see this working if you have enough siege targets on the table.

I would say that running blood knights in a smaller group is more ideal (unless you have points burning a hole in your pocket) since multiple rows really makes you miss out on the benefits of blood knights. If you're looking for a bigger block of cavalry to disrupt, well that's what black knights are for imo :D. Disrupting ranks is a pretty useful function of these guys since it'll almost guarantee a win from combat.
 
its not about the static combat resolution...... not really at all. its the fact that unless you have 2 ranks you cant break ranks to break stead fast, you can kill 15 guys with your blood knights, if the enemy still has 2 ranks in the end he tests at unmodified leadership with the generals leadership most likely and a BSB reroll, then you die because your stuck in combat. you also have to run them big so they can survive to get into combat, if you run them small they are either going to charge right in flank or not really doesnt matter since you dont break ranks and then fall into the situation above that i mentioned, or you wait 3 or so turns till your fat infantry block that breaks steadfast makes it into combat, over the course of those 3 or so turns your opponent if hes smart will realize that your incredibly small 5 man unit of blood knights with banner of blood keep is worth 370 points or 500 something with a thrall in there(who will no benefit from Look out Sir after the first knight diee) and shoot it with everything hes got, if he doesnt kill it before it gets to hand to hand he probably will have killed 3 or so and then your blood knights will get killed later in the battle. any of my opponents who does not realize the frailty of a small blood knight unit and realize that its worth a ton of points and dont dump everything they got into it, id throw zombies at them and win because that opponent is a little slow.

If i was my opponent and saw either a huge block of blood knights or a tiny block of blood knights id dump everything I had into it till it dies, or I kill the vampire/lord with blood drinker and the unit is slightly down sized, the big unit is either all he has in substitute of a grave guard block or free points if its a small unit.

your better off spending 375 points of a giant unit of grave guard its 400 million times better not even an exageration, it will live to see an IoN, has enough wounds to survive a bad round of combat, has static combat resolution, can break stead fast, has killing blow and in comparison to the amount of attacks your throwing out there really is LITTLE difference 14 attacks from the grave guard(7 wide, 21 attacks horded, although will cost a tad more points then the 5 blood knights with banner) 15 attacks from the blood knights. Sure the mobility is cool on the knights, but it only works in your favor if you can survive to be fighting strength when you get into combat (with your infantry block) or can support its self on its own (which is really only viable in a 2 rank unit of blood knights) the goal with the knights on their own is to break your opponent in the first round of combat where you have their steadfast broken from the flank charge and have them testing on snake eyes, youll overrun probably in an unsuitable place get charged in the flank and have to have the ability to suck it up (numbers and vampire lord with blood drinker) if you dont break them in the first round they will reform on you and youll be face to face and youll be strength 5 again which is still good, but the combat result is likely to be about the same or you get beaten, you will be losing blood knights in combat and in combat resolution, and if you lose in combat resolution its all over your done you dont have enough models to soak up the unstable wounds.

Danseman had what I was saying down from the start,

you need to look at Survivability(end game)/combat effectiveness(after 2-3 rounds shooting/magic) to point cost, blood knights are just not there unless ran at least 10 strong including characters with banner of blood keep or drakkenhoff (example: Vamp Lord, wight BSB, 8 blood knights)

when you run it this way they will do the support role the right way, but honestly from what ive found they can charge a unit head on and clobber it up, its ok being stuck in combat for multiple rounds because you have the extra attacks and the durability to withstand it most likely even win combat.

also when you run it this way in games 3k or less you will not be able to fit both grave guard and the blood knights effectively together.
 
often grave guard appear to be more survivable, and in many ways they are. but the true chioice for unit selection is your style.

But if you run 7 blood knights (5 to match infantry columns+2 ) then they will have (if they go first or at the same time) 21 attacks + hatred banner. that is 15 str7 wounds without a character.

grave guard with std, muso, banner of the barrows and great weapons can get 27 dudes for that price.

vs ws3 or more and in horde formation
18 str6 wounds if they all may hit. so similar to the blood knights.

6 wide = 12 attacks = 8 str 6 wounds. but ASL.

so if you want to charge and fight in your turn blood knights are best as they have swift stride and move 7 so have a beter chance of making combat on the charge.

however if you want the enemy to charge you to allow you to heal in the following magic phase, then horde GG may be better. it also allows you to recharge the fleeing survivors if they break in their turn.
 
Forge said:
...or you wait 3 or so turns till your fat infantry block that breaks steadfast makes it into combat

Your right Forge. Your completly right. If you want to use your Blood Knights to attack the main Battle line then they need to be bigger in order to survive either a solo charge or until the infantry gets there. No arguement there.

What some of us like to do is use small(er) units of Heavy Cav to deal with those units that infantry can't. Stuff like: Warmachines, Salamanders, Fast cav, Missile units(<20), Chariots and other Hv Cav. If you really have balls you can also hunt Monsters, Stegadons and Hellcannons.

So the idea is not to wait around but still get into CC as fast as possible. After they have done their job and have run over the support troops then the infantry should have reached the enemy. Then it's safe to throw the Hv Cav into a rear/flank.
 
The difference in what Forge is saying and what the rest of us say is that Forge has this idea that the role of a Blood Knight is to hit foes head on, do 10 wounds, break steadfast, and overrun all by their lonesome.

The very quote that Stonewyrm has reposted is evidence of that.


I would just about never run ANY Hv Cav unit into the front battle line. Not if I can at all keep from it. Sure, sometimes, luck just goes the wrong way, but i guess maybe I'm the oddball, but I dont see Heavy Cav in 8th ed as "hit them square away and win". I feel like that was a 7th ed mentality.

In 7th ed, you could charge any unit with Hv Cav on their own (especially Blood Knights) and they would wipe the floor with the enemy, because there was no Stedfast Rule, there was no supporting attacks and no Horde formation.

in 8th ed, if you are not running your Hv Cav into a flank, you truely are going to waste points on Blood Knights or Black Knights.

So if I am looking to hit a flank, i dont need more than 5 or 6 models (including characters). I sure as heck dont need supporting attacks for 55 pts per, and i wouldnt even say I need supporting attacks for 28pts per for Black Knights barded, but since the Black Knights have no other protection from shooting except numbers and a 2+ AS, i accept that i will have to field a second rank just to survive to get there, but the Banner of Blood Keep does just fine in protecting my expensive cav from shooting and magic and the loses they take on their way to the flank of the enemy unit, gets regenerated quickly by a thrall with blood drinker or a IoN.

I have never fought an opponent with enough shooting (that starts in range of my blood knights) to kill them all in one round, and typically by round 2, (3 at the latest) they are in combat and protected from most things that would do them real harm.

It is true that at 2K or less, you probably are not going to fit blood knights and graveguard in the same list, so at 1.5K games, you are either going to need alot of Ghouls or Skellies to Anvil with while your Blood Knights are Hammers, or you are going to have Graveguard be your anvil and perhaps Black Knights be your hammer or a Varghulf or Black Coach hit the flanks.

Ive done both ways at 2K and less with no real issues other than horrid dice.
 
im feeling like i want to give my bloodknights a go :) especcially the 4-5 bk with a vampire thrall and blooddrinker seems pretty interesting, i know they are vunerable but if deployed and manouvered well i think they might have a good chance at earning their points back.

even though some units/models are allways superior to others when u look at stats alone, it doesnt mean that they cant fill a role in ur army.

the bloodknights definatelly have weakpoints wich we can improve alittle making them less of a glasscannon...wolfs or bats providing hardcover for shooting, terrain, deployment, and gear.

my gaming group is prolly the hardest to try these with...HE with asf and shooting, skaven with shooting and magic, orcs with warmachines, brets with warmachines and shooting.

im guessing i will bring forbidden lore light with the BK. phas protection and asf+extra attacks seems a pretty good pair with the knights, even without the knights its still my 3rd favourite lore (after vamps and shadow)

big unit of GG on the midfield and BK looking for a flank charge is no joke.
and chargin into that mage bunker or warmachines aint a bad idea either, i tend to see those pretty often (like teclis for example)

and since im allmost finished building and painting my mournfull knights i definatelly need to give them a try atleast :konrad:
 
I think i'm going to try this as well. I spent so much time painting and assembling them I wanna give them a shot.

I can see throwing a Lord up there in big points games, but with my local crew we're now a fielding 2 - 2.5k armies. In that realm, I just can't afford a lord who isn't my general. That leaves me with putting a thrall in there. So at these points I'm thinking: 4 BKs (one kastellan), and the vamp. I think the Book of Arkhan is a better fit than Blooddrinker for mobility & ASF. The unit will probably be too far away from my caster-lord to rely on lore of light buffs, I suspect.

Do people who try this generally take Dread Lord on their thrall, or pay for the mount and armor separately? I was thinking Dread Lord & Supernatural Horror for his 50 vamp-points.

-aki
 
imagine this combo...6 bloodknights AND timewarp spell. ASF 24 str 7 attacks plus ASF 18 str4 attacks!! :Vampire1: charge range is 14+ 3d6 pick the highest!

that could break a unit from the front esp with the hatred banner.
 
@ Akiro 27

I use those two gifts on my bk thrall, that way if I wish I can fit a nasty weapon and even some armor. With dread knight and Dragonhelm he gets a 1+ save and can also take the bloodsucker if you're so inclined, although it might be better to try and give then some magic resistance instead of the helm and sword.

I find that dread knight is just so worth the points it costs, because the mount is barded which you can't normally get and he get *free* armor and a lance, I personally don't want to pay for a lance unless it's the flaming one, and even then I'd rather take the bloodrinker.
 
Ferrum, thanks for the info.

I asked this in the rules section, but wanted to confirm since it's on-topic: Is it true that i'm bound to use the lance from Dreadknight on the charge, or do I have the choice to say use a Blooddrinker? My understanding is that i can only choose additional weapons on the non-charge round of combat, which limits the effectiveness of a nasty-weapon purchase.

-aki
 
Gladius Rex said:
The difference in what Forge is saying and what the rest of us say is that Forge has this idea that the role of a Blood Knight is to hit foes head on, do 10 wounds, break steadfast, and overrun all by their lonesome.

The very quote that Stonewyrm has reposted is evidence of that.


I would just about never run ANY Hv Cav unit into the front battle line. Not if I can at all keep from it. Sure, sometimes, luck just goes the wrong way, but i guess maybe I'm the oddball, but I dont see Heavy Cav in 8th ed as "hit them square away and win". I feel like that was a 7th ed mentality.

In 7th ed, you could charge any unit with Hv Cav on their own (especially Blood Knights) and they would wipe the floor with the enemy, because there was no Stedfast Rule, there was no supporting attacks and no Horde formation.

in 8th ed, if you are not running your Hv Cav into a flank, you truely are going to waste points on Blood Knights or Black Knights.

So if I am looking to hit a flank, i dont need more than 5 or 6 models (including characters). I sure as heck dont need supporting attacks for 55 pts per, and i wouldnt even say I need supporting attacks for 28pts per for Black Knights barded, but since the Black Knights have no other protection from shooting except numbers and a 2+ AS, i accept that i will have to field a second rank just to survive to get there, but the Banner of Blood Keep does just fine in protecting my expensive cav from shooting and magic and the loses they take on their way to the flank of the enemy unit, gets regenerated quickly by a thrall with blood drinker or a IoN.

I have never fought an opponent with enough shooting (that starts in range of my blood knights) to kill them all in one round, and typically by round 2, (3 at the latest) they are in combat and protected from most things that would do them real harm.

It is true that at 2K or less, you probably are not going to fit blood knights and graveguard in the same list, so at 1.5K games, you are either going to need alot of Ghouls or Skellies to Anvil with while your Blood Knights are Hammers, or you are going to have Graveguard be your anvil and perhaps Black Knights be your hammer or a Varghulf or Black Coach hit the flanks.

Ive done both ways at 2K and less with no real issues other than horrid dice.

No, your blind to EVERYTHING im saying.

You act like all 5 of your blood knights are going to see combat!, you act like those 5 blood knights will still be alive to support your slow infantry! you act like those 5 blood knights will survive the entire game!

as far as the warmachine hunters and monster hunters ordeal, you c an only fight with 2 cav models against a war machine, your better off buying 2 varghulfs for the price of that squishy blood knight unit, or running 5 black knights if you insist on the cavalry.

to everyone here

THE 5 BLOOD KNIGHTS YOU BOUGHT WILL NOT BE 5 MODELS STRONG WHEN YOU REACH COMBAT!

you'll be lucky if theres any left, definitely lucky if you have any of them at the end of the game.

im not saying to build them to run at the front of a unit, im saying they need to be built to get the job done (a flank charge) you need to run alot of them so that you have enough models to reach combat with and protect your lord who is in turn protecting your blood knight investment, the amount of models you need to do that will mean you have enough for 2 ranks, or are 1-2 shy of it so it is worth the investment to add in 1 or 2 more blood knights. if you dont break steadfast you will get stuck in hand to hand and lose your strength bonus get reformed on, lose a model or 2 a turn from combat, if you lose combat you lose more models, even losing by one is bad. if you get stuck in combat you probably will get flank charged and F***ed (we are talking a solo charge into the flank no support) now if you wait around 3 or so turns for your infantry to be there for you to support with your blood knights they are either going to be dead, or down to 1-2 models, YAY so productive.

with the amount of models you need to bring to make them survive the battle and to do their flank support decently they end up being strong enough just to clash in head first, which is probably the better idea since when you overrun (since you have to) your flank isn't exposed rather then overrunning from a flank charge and getting boned.

at the points they cost you have to protect your investment, simple as that.
 
Actually akiro, you're not allowed to use the lance as long as you have blood drinker...peroid! See p. 501 under I'm using this one.


"as far as the warmachine hunters and monster hunters ordeal, you c an only fight with 2 cav models against a war machine, your better off..." This is incorrect. You select up to six models in a unit attacking a warmachine and those 6 are considered to be in base contact with the warmachine. Only one varghulf can attack at a time as opposed (and they also wouldn't get thunderstomp IIRC) to 6 blood knights so actually they are MUCH better at wiping out a warmachine... assuming you'd need that many attacks for whatever reason. See warmachine entry for details. I think a unit of blood knights is FAR too expensive to deal with something like siege but to be fair, they can do it if needs be.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu