8th Edition Blood Knights - More Viable?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
Dklyn said:
Actually akiro, you're not allowed to use the lance as long as you have blood drinker...peroid! See p. 501 under I'm using this one.


"as far as the warmachine hunters and monster hunters ordeal, you c an only fight with 2 cav models against a war machine, your better off..." This is incorrect. You select up to six models in a unit attacking a warmachine and those 6 are considered to be in base contact with the warmachine. Only one varghulf can attack at a time as opposed (and they also wouldn't get thunderstomp IIRC) to 6 blood knights so actually they are MUCH better at wiping out a warmachine... assuming you'd need that many attacks for whatever reason. See warmachine entry for details. I think a unit of blood knights is FAR too expensive to deal with something like siege but to be fair, they can do it if needs be.

mis read the types that count as 3 models. still doesnt damper my arguement, like you said, blood knights are a silly choice to buy to kill war machines.
 
Forge said:
No, your blind to EVERYTHING im saying.

You act like all 5 of your blood knights are going to see combat!, you act like those 5 blood knights will still be alive to support your slow infantry! you act like those 5 blood knights will survive the entire game!

as far as the warmachine hunters and monster hunters ordeal, you c an only fight with 2 cav models against a war machine, your better off buying 2 varghulfs for the price of that squishy blood knight unit, or running 5 black knights if you insist on the cavalry.

to everyone here

THE 5 BLOOD KNIGHTS YOU BOUGHT WILL NOT BE 5 MODELS STRONG WHEN YOU REACH COMBAT!

you'll be lucky if theres any left, definitely lucky if you have any of them at the end of the game.

im not saying to build them to run at the front of a unit, im saying they need to be built to get the job done (a flank charge) you need to run alot of them so that you have enough models to reach combat with and protect your lord who is in turn protecting your blood knight investment, the amount of models you need to do that will mean you have enough for 2 ranks, or are 1-2 shy of it so it is worth the investment to add in 1 or 2 more blood knights. if you dont break steadfast you will get stuck in hand to hand and lose your strength bonus get reformed on, lose a model or 2 a turn from combat, if you lose combat you lose more models, even losing by one is bad. if you get stuck in combat you probably will get flank charged and F***ed (we are talking a solo charge into the flank no support) now if you wait around 3 or so turns for your infantry to be there for you to support with your blood knights they are either going to be dead, or down to 1-2 models, YAY so productive.

with the amount of models you need to bring to make them survive the battle and to do their flank support decently they end up being strong enough just to clash in head first, which is probably the better idea since when you overrun (since you have to) your flank isn't exposed rather then overrunning from a flank charge and getting boned.

at the points they cost you have to protect your investment, simple as that.

There are lots of things I love about this post of yours. I am not good at cutting multiple quotes or HTML but I will just rereference things as need.

First - I am not blind to what you are saying. IF you take Blood Knights, they are obviously going to be a focal point of your army list for that particular game. no questions about it. You obviously have to protect it, no questions about it.

You go on to say that blood knights should not hunt war machines.... on this, i totally agree, we have other units much better priced and capable of doing that job ( see fel bats or hellsteed thrall hunter)

THEN, you go to say this: "im not saying to build them to run at the front of a unit, im saying they need to be built to get the job done (a flank charge)"

Ok... so you want to build them to do a flank charge, I was wrong... or was I? Because then you go on to say this: "with the amount of models you need to bring to make them survive the battle and to do their flank support decently they end up being strong enough just to clash in head first, which is probably the better idea"

So if in your mind, Blood Knights have to come in groups large enough to survive (that number i guess being 10 to 15?) that you might as well just hit head first instead of a flank charge just again reinforces what I said prior.

That is a very 7th ed way to look at it. The more Blood Knights you field, the more expensive the unit is and thus the more you are going to have to ask that unit to do in order to earn back its points. At 400 points, I can field 5, full command and banner, hit the flank of a unit and still have blood knights left. will they all survive? NO, of course not. I never once stated that. Casualties happen. But if you got a Thrall with Blood Drinker with them or IoN support, if even one survives, you can keep them up and going. it really isnt THAT hard. If I run 5 Knights and a Thrall, I may have 3 or 4 Knights and a Thrall left when I hit a flank. That is probably the most common situation i have. Then my Thrall often goes first with blood Drinker and with 3 attacks (assuming no red fury here) he wil score 2 wounds most of the time. That puts me back to full.

I mean... is your metagame so shooting heavy that nothing short of infantry stands a chance to see round 2? Because if so, Id love to know how your poor varghulf makes it, let alone two of them. You talk about a rare choice that never sees combat, for me, its the poor Varghulf. He eats one single bolt from a HE bolt thrower, fails that 50/50 regen save and it explodes into D3 and he is just about all but done.

I also dont find our infantry to be that slow. Our M value is a 4 across the board. Thats really pretty standard. We also get VdM, Ghoulkin, to help move our Infantry up early on and get it into position. I fail to understand how the movement of infantry is what is holding Blood Knights back.

I think the idea of Phas Protection is another great example, along with screening units (note that the very Fel Bats we just suggested to go after shooting warmachines) also grant you cover bonus, so its not like you gotta make a unit JUST to cover, it can cover while going to do its job as well.

the very basis of your argument is typically that they dont work in games with 2K points or less. But really, noone here is talking 2K or less necessarily. At less points, it is harder to make them work, but not impossible.

I fully encourage people to try them. What is the worse that can happen? You give them a shot and they dont work out that game? You can evaluate why or how they didnt work out and adapt and try them again, find better ways to get them to work if you want to, or scrap the idea all together. I personally use them all the time with no problem. I have the notion that most other players who field them will probably have mixed results at first and get better with them over time and trial and error.
 
Gladius Rex said:
Forge said:
No, your blind to EVERYTHING im saying.

You act like all 5 of your blood knights are going to see combat!, you act like those 5 blood knights will still be alive to support your slow infantry! you act like those 5 blood knights will survive the entire game!

as far as the warmachine hunters and monster hunters ordeal, you c an only fight with 2 cav models against a war machine, your better off buying 2 varghulfs for the price of that squishy blood knight unit, or running 5 black knights if you insist on the cavalry.

to everyone here

THE 5 BLOOD KNIGHTS YOU BOUGHT WILL NOT BE 5 MODELS STRONG WHEN YOU REACH COMBAT!

you'll be lucky if theres any left, definitely lucky if you have any of them at the end of the game.

im not saying to build them to run at the front of a unit, im saying they need to be built to get the job done (a flank charge) you need to run alot of them so that you have enough models to reach combat with and protect your lord who is in turn protecting your blood knight investment, the amount of models you need to do that will mean you have enough for 2 ranks, or are 1-2 shy of it so it is worth the investment to add in 1 or 2 more blood knights. if you dont break steadfast you will get stuck in hand to hand and lose your strength bonus get reformed on, lose a model or 2 a turn from combat, if you lose combat you lose more models, even losing by one is bad. if you get stuck in combat you probably will get flank charged and F***ed (we are talking a solo charge into the flank no support) now if you wait around 3 or so turns for your infantry to be there for you to support with your blood knights they are either going to be dead, or down to 1-2 models, YAY so productive.

with the amount of models you need to bring to make them survive the battle and to do their flank support decently they end up being strong enough just to clash in head first, which is probably the better idea since when you overrun (since you have to) your flank isn't exposed rather then overrunning from a flank charge and getting boned.

at the points they cost you have to protect your investment, simple as that.

That is a very 7th ed way to look at it. The more Blood Knights you field, the more expensive the unit is and thus the more you are going to have to ask that unit to do in order to earn back its points. At 400 points, I can field 5, full command and banner, hit the flank of a unit and still have blood knights left. will they all survive? NO, of course not. I never once stated that. Casualties happen. But if you got a Thrall with Blood Drinker with them or IoN support, if even one survives, you can keep them up and going. it really isnt THAT hard. If I run 5 Knights and a Thrall, I may have 3 or 4 Knights and a Thrall left when I hit a flank. That is probably the most common situation i have. Then my Thrall often goes first with blood Drinker and with 3 attacks (assuming no red fury here) he wil score 2 wounds most of the time. That puts me back to full.


this is why you are horribly blind, your thrall will not see combat with only 5 blood knights on the table, you'd be lucky if he did. he takes a cannonball to the face with no Look out Sir then your riding on a 50/50 ward save and he goes "poof" bye 200 something points. any magic missile at the unit after that point or even hand gunners and the unit is likely to lose a couple more models,

YOU WILL BE SHOT AT (magic and shooting) FOR 3 TURNS OR SO, you can maybe get a charge in second turn, I highly doubt it, but if you did they would be going in unsupported and then die, and then your digging your self out of a 600 point hole.

you can play how ever you want, but stop giving people shi**y advice based on absolutely nothing.

as far as our "I dont find our infantry to be that slow actually) is just another reason to take grave guard instead. id rather have 400 points of ghouls then 400 points of blood knights.

You saying my idea is a very 7th edition way of looking at things is ignorant, considering heavy cavalry were normally used in a single rank wide line to clash into flanks to deny static combat resolution, now heavy cavalry are simply to expensive and vulnerable compared to infantry and dont get the job done right anymore. I said the amount of models you need to dump into them for them to survive the battle and do their job your going to have enough models to make 2 ranks, our blood knights have frenzy meaning they must overrun, if you it something in the flank and break them your going to overrun with your flank wide open to your enemy and your unit will crumple to unstable. NOW if you take a smaller unit they wont break the unit they charged and get charged in the flank anyways and get screwed. your frenzied unit must be able to withstand a flank charge because it is very likely to happen, your better off running your unit that is built for a flank charge straight at your enemy to avoid getting flank charged.
 
Forge... Im sure you do very well and all that... But his advice isnt wrong.

While i agree you need more then 5 RnF, just as a matter of principle if a character is in there, You often dont need more then that to hit someone.

2+, 4+ shrugs off bow fire, and its a 3+ 4+ or a 4+ 4+. a 4+ 4+ is a 75 percent chance to stop a round... And thats REALLLY heavy shooting.

If your getting shot at by a bow/xbow unit, you will only loose one or two, tops, even with 36 shots or more coming at you.

Against NON elite troops, four or five knights will kill that unit, eventually... As they are far to potent. You WILL have four knights when you hit combat though. Even on a Pitched battle deployment, you are 24 inches apart from your enemy, usually. 14 forwards first turn, then your in charge range... Or you can stretch it out even further going around a flank. Used in such a manner, they will be shot at by EVERYTHING that the enemy your playing has, as that unit NEEDS to die, or it will either win against, or badly cripple, nearly anything it touches. Given that, having one or two full turns of shooting focused on ONE unit, which admittedly is a large point investment, can be a major advantage. If your enemy is still in a battle line when you hit them, then a small unit of blood knights stuck in the front of an enemy unit will not likely get a flank charge without being opened up to a flank charge of your own.

You are entirely correct in that a single, entirely unsupported small unit of blood knights will die if it gets stuck into what it cant handle. That is why you charge something nice and squishy, like crossbow men, if your forced to make that unsupported charge. The static combat res from 15 strength five attacks, plus 5 strength four attacks, is easier to maintain if forced into that environment. You do HORRIFIC damage with blood knights, they should hold on for the one turn needed to get yourself into position with the rest of your force
 
Mortus946736 said:
Forge... Im sure you do very well and all that... But his advice isnt wrong.

While i agree you need more then 5 RnF, just as a matter of principle if a character is in there, You often dont need more then that to hit someone.

2+, 4+ shrugs off bow fire, and its a 3+ 4+ or a 4+ 4+. a 4+ 4+ is a 75 percent chance to stop a round... And thats REALLLY heavy shooting.

If your getting shot at by a bow/xbow unit, you will only loose one or two, tops, even with 36 shots or more coming at you.

Against NON elite troops, four or five knights will kill that unit, eventually... As they are far to potent. You WILL have four knights when you hit combat though. Even on a Pitched battle deployment, you are 24 inches apart from your enemy, usually. 14 forwards first turn, then your in charge range... Or you can stretch it out even further going around a flank. Used in such a manner, they will be shot at by EVERYTHING that the enemy your playing has, as that unit NEEDS to die, or it will either win against, or badly cripple, nearly anything it touches. Given that, having one or two full turns of shooting focused on ONE unit, which admittedly is a large point investment, can be a major advantage. If your enemy is still in a battle line when you hit them, then a small unit of blood knights stuck in the front of an enemy unit will not likely get a flank charge without being opened up to a flank charge of your own.

You are entirely correct in that a single, entirely unsupported small unit of blood knights will die if it gets stuck into what it cant handle. That is why you charge something nice and squishy, like crossbow men, if your forced to make that unsupported charge. The static combat res from 15 strength five attacks, plus 5 strength four attacks, is easier to maintain if forced into that environment. You do HORRIFIC damage with blood knights, they should hold on for the one turn needed to get yourself into position with the rest of your force

You and Gladius are back tracking on your selves at this point, your saying to straight up charge second turn unsupported, that still brings you back to the fact your going to get killed the next turn because you didnt break the unit you charged.

using 400+ points of blood knights to kill crossbowmen? thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. 4 blood knights will not likely get into hand to hand, ive lost 7 black knights in one turn so like 3-4 if I had banner of blood keep. most people will run 2 cannons which which have basically a 50/50 chance of killing 2 blood knights, thats without the magic phase being taken into account or the other shooting.

your treating the unit as a throw away unit, if you enjoy losing then by all means do it, 400+ points in a large hole to dig your self out of especially since that unit will disappear pretty quick. your going to have to kill about 2 entire units or more to make up for those points, its a dumb idea.
 
Forge said:
Mortus946736 said:
Forge... Im sure you do very well and all that... But his advice isnt wrong.

While i agree you need more then 5 RnF, just as a matter of principle if a character is in there, You often dont need more then that to hit someone.

2+, 4+ shrugs off bow fire, and its a 3+ 4+ or a 4+ 4+. a 4+ 4+ is a 75 percent chance to stop a round... And thats REALLLY heavy shooting.

If your getting shot at by a bow/xbow unit, you will only loose one or two, tops, even with 36 shots or more coming at you.

Against NON elite troops, four or five knights will kill that unit, eventually... As they are far to potent. You WILL have four knights when you hit combat though. Even on a Pitched battle deployment, you are 24 inches apart from your enemy, usually. 14 forwards first turn, then your in charge range... Or you can stretch it out even further going around a flank. Used in such a manner, they will be shot at by EVERYTHING that the enemy your playing has, as that unit NEEDS to die, or it will either win against, or badly cripple, nearly anything it touches. Given that, having one or two full turns of shooting focused on ONE unit, which admittedly is a large point investment, can be a major advantage. If your enemy is still in a battle line when you hit them, then a small unit of blood knights stuck in the front of an enemy unit will not likely get a flank charge without being opened up to a flank charge of your own.

You are entirely correct in that a single, entirely unsupported small unit of blood knights will die if it gets stuck into what it cant handle. That is why you charge something nice and squishy, like crossbow men, if your forced to make that unsupported charge. The static combat res from 15 strength five attacks, plus 5 strength four attacks, is easier to maintain if forced into that environment. You do HORRIFIC damage with blood knights, they should hold on for the one turn needed to get yourself into position with the rest of your force

You and Gladius are back tracking on your selves at this point, your saying to straight up charge second turn unsupported, that still brings you back to the fact your going to get killed the next turn because you didnt break the unit you charged.

using 400+ points of blood knights to kill crossbowmen? thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. 4 blood knights will not likely get into hand to hand, ive lost 7 black knights in one turn so like 3-4 if I had banner of blood keep. most people will run 2 cannons which which have basically a 50/50 chance of killing 2 blood knights, thats without the magic phase being taken into account or the other shooting.

your treating the unit as a throw away unit, if you enjoy losing then by all means do it, 400+ points in a large hole to dig your self out of especially since that unit will disappear pretty quick. your going to have to kill about 2 entire units or more to make up for those points, its a dumb idea.


Im curious on how 'most people' run cannons when only three races can... Skaven, Dwarves, Empire...

And heavy war machines are the ONLY thing that will kill that unit before it hits combat, or heavy magic... Neither work particularly well on Black knights... Dwellers? Pit of shades? Not working on blood knights....

Exaggerating to make a point doesn't really support your point.

Now... When a blood knight unit hits the front of something squishy...

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
cccccc
cccccc

If they can even charge that blood knight unit, they are exposing a far more lethal counter charge for yourself, as you will be only one turn behind.

Now... Wouldnt you agree that soaking up EVERY SINGLE WARMACHINE shot for the first, at least, 2-3 turns, isnt worth points? Your correct in that they probably wont, by themselves, make back the points spent. But, as i have started to notice, even with gunlines, is that not having the rest of your army chewed up by those war machines is infinitely better then the alternative.

If at all possible, you want to hit a flank with that Blood Knight unit, but if they hit from the front, they WILL last a turn or more due to their inherent killing power.

A flank charge is plus 2 combat res.. Blood knights are still blood knights, so assuming strength five, weapon skill 4, reasonable no?

4 bases from 20 Mm
3 Bases for 25 Mm

that means anywhere from 3-8 attacks new into the equation from that counter charge.

4s to hit, 3s to wound: 50% Chance to hit, 66.66 percent chance to wound out of that 50%

each attack has a 33.33% chance to wound, thus: 1.98 Wounds, out of 6 attacks

2 Wounds. 2+ goes to 4+, thus on average, 1 wound taken from that flank charge.

From the front, assuming you charged something squishy: 8 attacks, weapon skill 3, strength three...

4s to hit, 5s to wound. 16% chance per attack to cause a wound, with a 16.66% Chance for the armor to fail and let the wound in, making it: 2% Percent chance per attack to cause a wound from the front.

In converse: Hitting forwards from your knights: Lets say 4 knights and thrall, assuming you got one or two back from a blood drinker:

Knights:
4x3 attacks is= 12 attacks
Hitting on threes, wounding on 2s.
Each attack has a 55% Chance of causing a wound, roughly.
12 attacks= 6.6 Wounds, with them getting no saves.

Horses:
4s to hit, 3s to wound: 4 horses.
each attack has a 33% chance to cause a wound, adding in 1 kill, roughly.

7 Kills for your side, at least: They have 2 kills, on average, with me being generous. +2 for flank and charge, then +3 for ranks, max.
They dont win combat, or if they do, not by much.

Each other knight added adds in one more kill, and .33 of a kill for a horse, on average

Starting slightly larger then 5 Knights, and a thrall, the survivability only goes up.

Show me where that is wrong, in detail please. If a big block hits them from the side, you should still win combat, or only loose by 1 or 2, tops, setting yourself up for a wonderful flank charge of your own.
 
Wouldn't blood knights actually have strength 7 on the charge seeing as how they have lances? I just noticed that you said they'd have strength 5 on the charge and was wondering why you said that.

Besides that I agree with most things that EVERYONE has said here. Forge, Mortius, and Gladius, you all have good points, they are different yes, but all valid to a point.
You ALL just need to calm down and try to work out the 'best strategy' without ripping throats out.

Thank you all for grinding this out by the way, even though there is some rage here it's very insightful! :)


*edit*

I just saw that you included the S7 into your calculations, I was just confused by the line saying "assuming strength five", I take it you meant they were unaugmented?
 
I meant on Forge's supposedly lethal counter charge he feels is inevitable...

On the charge, there is no doubt that you will win combat... Ever...
 
Mortus946736 said:
I said a bunch of stuff

I may have paraphrased some of your post...

Even though it was directed at forge, I hope you don't mind my answering some of your points. I overall share the forge's view, although perhaps not quite to his extreme... but I think you are overestimating blood knights a bit.

My first and probably biggest point: why are you spending so many points to deal with a squishy unit? I would much rather send in core with a combat thrall to deal with that unit. Not only will they be able to deal with such a weak unit well enough, but can do so in a shorter time (due to steadfast being harder to reach) and with less risk (not as vulnerable to wounds, losing combat won't destroy the troops etc) and hey, you need core anyways right? You can even tack on some extra CR on the standard if you'd like, instead of spending 75+ points to give the unit some basic survivability.
True, they won't have a million high str awesome attacks, but you don't need all that to deal with the most vanilla troops in the game (WS 3 Str 3 no saves at all??). Heck, I wouldn't even bother sending blk knights into this guy's flank :D. So the question I ask when designing all my units, and would ask for the blood knights, is what problem is this unit solving? If it's solving a problem my core/heroes have already taken care of, then why the redundancy?

2nd point: While cannons may not be a common site, the center of the stonethrower's hole also negates armor and hits at str 9 (so pretty much a cannon) in addition to hitting a few other guys. While not necessarily high str hits (with the exception of a runed grudge thrower or a trebuchet), you will feel being unlucky with just one of those extra hits.

3rd: A cavalry's flank base is much longer than its front, so actually there would very likely be more then 3 guys in base contact with your knights. I would say plan on 5 at least granting 10 attacks. If those are at str 5, you are in more trouble than you guessed (somewhere around 1-2 wounds given). Also, your ideal situation you described puts CR right about even. If one attacks did not go in your favor, you can easily lose combat which is bad for blood knights as they lose their frenzy in addition to losing more knights! That could mean your down 3 knights quickly which is tough to recover from and with a little bad luck, your unit is completely wiped out.
"you should still win combat, or only loose by 1 or 2, tops" that's not good! Losing by 2 with bld knights means that losing the unit is very likely. You quoted a unit having 4 knights, well if you lose CR by two, then you probably lose 2 knights during combat (which isn't far fetched at all) and now you lose the other two. Since blood drinker is applied during the thralls init, which is likely before taking any casualties, that thrall won't do you any good this combat.
All of this assuming your attacking one of the easiest to kill units in the game. If they even have a 6+ parry save, then you lose a wound in there and CR starts to tip towards the foe.
The point I'm making here is even under the best of reasonable circumstances, it still doesn't bode too well for our mounted friends. As things move away from the ideal, entire demise rapidly becomes the more likely scenario. That's not good news to hear from your 400-500 point investment.

4) "Now... Wouldnt you agree that soaking up EVERY SINGLE WARMACHINE shot for the first, at least, 2-3 turns, isnt worth points?"
Absolutely not. Blood knights are 55 points a piece whereas skeletons (my usual cannon fodder) are 8. Even GG are worth 13. They only have 1 extra toughness and extra armor (somethings that won't help much, if at all, against war machines) Depending on your foe, it would be unlikely for the small bld knight unit to absorb all the siege fire for 3 rounds, but then again I play against dwarfs, brets, and skaven who all have some nasty war machines, so maybe the people you play don't have the powerful machines I get to deal with :D.

I could go on, but I think I've made the big points pretty clear, plus I'm sure forge has some thoughts to add.
 
Im waiting patiently for the ridicule.

My point was, its possible to get blood knights into combat on the second turn, and have them survive to get support in there...
 
sure it's possible, but my point is that it's not necessarily likely :D. It's possible to have an army entirely of zombies and be able to destroy an entire army (just roll a lot of 6's) but that doesn't make zombies any more useful.
What you presented was as close to ideal as realistically possible (incredibly weak unit in the front of the bld knights with only a str 5 1atk unit no special rules as a hammer no heroes/lords...and of course only one unit charged ). Even then, it's pretty iffy if the knights will hold. I don't see a bld knight unit commonly being able to hold off after being flanked is all. You said "Show me where that is wrong," and so in short, the situation described isn't that realistic (erring in bld knight favor), the # of soldiers attacking from the flank was underestimated, and the result mentioned still isn't looking good for the mounted vampire warriors.
Just things for people to keep in mind while deciding how (and if) to use bld knights.
 
Some interesting points, however I can see things in this thread are getting a little heated.

Please remember the forum rules about posting, I don't want to start coming down with my modhammer (or should that be adminhammer?)......:smash:
 
I dont feel like I am backpeddling at all.

I also don't run then into just squishy things, i run them into just about whatever I feel like and it typically comes up roses.

I think the difference in what I am saying and what i see other saying is that I dont use them ALONE. I use them in conjunction with other units to achieve my goals. I use terrain, my own units, and magic to help support Blood Knights when i decide to use them. As I stated before, if you make that selection, it is now the focus of your army list because they are expensive.

So maybe to better explain why I can make my Blood Knights succeed, I need to explain what else I use in conjunction with them. Now granted (as I have agreed with Forge on) the fewer the points, the harder it is to do this, but I typically play at 2.5K, occasionally popping up to 3, sometimes dropping down to 2K depending on where my opponent is comfortable playing with his army.

To properly support Blood Knights:

Core:

I typically run ghouls. They are T4, alot of attacks (which is sort of the theme of the entire list really)

In a 2.5K game, I will take 2 units of 30+ ghouls, or one unit of 30+ ghouls and one unit of Skellies at 35ish models. I go with ghouls because I know i need them to blitz up the field to engage units so my Blood Knights can charge, so a sizable unit of ghouls is necessary in most cases unless you wish to use VdM, then you can run Skellies, but I like to use my VdM on the Blood Knights themselves, so I find Ghoulkin does the trick nicely.

Specials
Now you have options, but you have one specific goal. You need to get something in the face of your opponents shooting. If nothing else, this special unit is going to provide some screening, and also give your opponent a good reason to shoot at it instead of your expensive blood knights.

So you have either fel bats or black knights for this job. I dont add any extras, no extra barding, as i want the black Knights to be fast, and I only field 5-6 of them. With Fel Bats, i field maybe 4 of them. This gives you a pretty cheap unit. Fel Bats will probably be the cheaper and achieve the goal more effectively, but just pointing out that black knights can do the job.


So now on to Rares.

We are selecting Blood Knights. I typically give them all the fixins. Blood Keep Banner, Full Command. The only thing I typically dont spend on is a weapon for the Kastellen. Ive toyed with different options for him, but basically i find he does just fine with his lance. This unit is 400 points on the nose as I field 5 in most cases (knowing well a 6th rider will be joining soon)

Typically, I also toss in a Varghulf here. Unless you are at 2K, you can still fit him in, depending on choices elsewehre.

Heroes!
I need a WK for my BSB. he is going to accompany one of the ghoul units. And by that i mean he is going to accompany the ghoul unit closest to my Blood Knights. The Ghoul unit that he joins shall become my anvil, as I plan on tossing the ole Hoff banner on this guy in most cases.

I also need a Mounted Thrall with Blood Drinker. I find Dread Knight + Blood Drinker to work pretty well. This guy typically also takes Ghoulkin for the important aspect of moving up my anvil prior to the game starting. Goes without saying that this guy is going to ride with the blood knights.

Typically at this point, I have all the heroes I need unless I am at larger point games. depending on what I do with my Lord next (as i have tried a couple different things) I may have enough room for one more hero. Sometimes its just a bare bones WK to go in the other ghoul unit, sometimes it may be another thrall with Forbidden Lore (LIght or Shadows in my opinion)

LORD

So with the Lord, I have tried a couple things. First is to go with a pure caster Lord. This works out alright if your second core choice was the Skellies instead of the second unit of ghouls. You can Writsbands him up and MotBA him up and let him do his job from the back of the battlefield. This works ok for me in this list concept, but honestly, more times than not, I put my Lord on an abyssal terror. Still has the Wristbands and Dread Knights himself, but this allows him to be more mobile and utilize his more hybrid state of caster/combat. Just like the Blood Knights, I am not running him into a combat alone, he will typically aid the other ghoul unit in movement and cast spells. He sometimes will attract a little shooting, but again, if they want to shoot at him, they are not shooting at my Blood Knights now are they? The actual combination of powers. magic sort of vary depending on what army I am facing.

So in summary, the list will look sort of like this.

2 units ghouls, one or both with WKs, one WK is the HOFF BSB (ghouls typically 6 wide)

1 unit Fel Bats

Varghulf

Blood Knights/w Thrall Blood Drinker

Hybrid Lord on abyssal terror


So as we all know, making a list is only half the battle. Now you have to create a simple battle strategy. The idea in this list is to blitzkrieg your enemy. Highly mobile army here, very fast overall, and thus will cut down rounds until CC. Once it is in CC, you are dealing with alot of attacks both from the core ghouls, the blood knights, and even your Lord on his Abyssal Terror generates a fair number of high strength attacks.

SO how do we utilize the units to aid our biggest hammer unit? Well this all starts prior to setting our army on the table.

Terrain Deployment. It is the first thing you do in a Warhammer game is roll for terrain and then place it on the board. This is not a time to just want to get on with the game and haphazardly toss terrain "whereever". You have a strategy in mind, and it all starts here. In the games i play in, terrain is done per the BRB. That means 4+1d6 pieces of terrain. Id say in most games I have played, this is 8 pieces of terrain. Terrain does alot of good stuff for you. It also tells you alot about your opponents battle strategy. If I am up against a shooting styled army, my foe is going to want his hills. I would say 99% of the time, my opponents first selection is a hill. 95% of those instances, that hill goes dead center of his own deployment zone. I know now where his deadliest shooting units are probably going to go. So for me, buildings, impassible terrain, and forest are simply devices for cover. That means they need to go directly between where my Blood Knights are going to start and where that hill is positioned. I know my Blood Knights will march 14 inches. So no suprise, my second terrain piece will go about 14 inches in a diagonal pattern so that it will be about where I need it to be to shield my Blood Knights from flank charges and shooting after its first round of movement. the key with this placement is to not block up where you intend for your Anvil to meet its foe. After that, if I have more terrain to utilize, I will put something on the other side of the battlefield, just to cut down the arc of clear fire my opponent has from that hill. Sometimes my foe is clever and will put a building in his deployment zone (like i dont know what that is going to be used for) so if you see that, keep it in mind as well when deploying defensive terrain strategy. If you do well in terrain placement (keeping in mind things like terrain that might grant flamming attacks (get that thing to a table edge asap), you should be able to put a hurting to his possible shooting game and optimize the cover bonuses you can gain from terrain.

DEPLOYMENT PHASE: A savy player might swap ends of the table with you if he realizes what is coming. But in doing so, he just gave up the hill and possibly a building that his shooting would greatly benefit from. Since you didnt put anything useful in your own deployment zone, i have found that 99% of games I play in, that my opponent will stick to his own side of the table. Either way, it works to your favor a bit if he has shooting at all.

So on to actual deployment - I tend to never roll good, so i never seem to deploy first. If I do, I plop down my extra core unit first, typically the opposite side of the board of where I think my Blood Knights are going to go. If this extra unit of ghouls is in clear LOS to that hill, probably the better, it will give him something to shoot out without cover and he will probably take it. If your opponent is worth a damn, he is probably going to toss out some crap units first. No worries, our battle strategy is set at this point. At some point, he is going to put down his shooting. This may be archers, it may be warmachines. Regardless it is going to go on the hill or in the building. Either way, our Blood Knights need to deploy after their shooting and they need to be positioned with terrain in the way of the deadliest shooting, again 99% of the time, its that hill, so they telegraphed where we need our cover. The other key ingredient to the deploy phase, is that unit of Fel Bats. Fel Bats I tend to use to bridge any gap I see where there is LoS to where I intend to put my Blood Knights. This will help create cover as well and also give my Fel Bats clear LoS to the shooting, which just begs the opponent to do something about this swift moving unit that is pretty much guaranteed to come for their hill or building and tie them up. Will the Fel Bats probably destory the shooting with only 4 models? maybe not, but it will certainly tie them up, which is what is needed most.

So we got our units in place. We are staring down our foe. Our foe is going to have come units intended for CC in MOST lists. A Dwarf Gunline is probably the worst case scenario for us. But most lists will have some units begging for close combat. So lets intice them further. its time for ghoulkin movement!!!! THis gives us 8 inches of movement, including some slight wheeling for BOTH our ghoul units. This also moves up our WK BSB. it is pretty likely that after this movement, that both ghoul units will be in LoS of the Hill and the shooting. No problem, that is sort of the point.

After Ghoulkin, you should now be set up with the front of your ghoul anvil unit slightly angled and up the field slightly from your Blood Knights. Your opponent if he moves first, is going to advance with his CC unit. I cant say short of the Dwarf Gunline (again worst case scenario) where the opponent simply sits back and doesnt advance.

The goal is to have your anvil hit the unit desired, exposing the flank to the Blood Knights. If your opponent charges you (which is often the case for me it seems) you have set your anvil where you want it, and it should be about 8 to 9 inches away from the shielding terrain you set to protect your blood Knights. this will give the blood knights a pretty good chance of still being in the flank of the unit and getting its charge off.

Your Fell Bats have to make a bee line (or bat line i guess lol) at the shooting. Your other ghoul unit should be in position to intercept any other infantry blocks that are moving upwards. Your Varghulf is probably going to assist that other ghoul unit in moving as it has no thrall in it (at best a bare bones wk) so the varghulf becomes a weaker hammer to your weaker core anvil. Your Lord has options. He can either assist the Varghulf and the other Ghoul unit being a second hammer to the weaker ghoul core, charging in unicen with the Varghulf once the ghouls have encountered the enemy, or it can make its way over to assist with the BSB anvil and Blood Knight encounter. You just have to be cautious of the shooting. You are a large target, so you can't claim cover, so you want to get into combat, but make sure you are not too far to help throw an IoN at the Knights or ghouls. If you get SUH, even better. the list is not incredibly strong in the magic phase, but you are using magic primarilly to just protect your investment and regrow troops, be it ghouls or Blood Knights.

Carrying out the Strategy:

Your Anvil unit with Hoff Banner is pretty formidable. you are still T4 (just like a GG) only you are not getting the armour save. the AS is pretty negligable at only 5+. Any bonus S score beyond 3 and its basically not there, so at T4 and regen, you are just as defensive as the GG are, you just don't have the same killing prowess, but you are not too far off. You get twice the attacks and poison ones at that and with a WK leading the charge, you have a sturdy hero with KB. Since your Lord is going to probably get into combat, you may or may not have the Helm in this list, but its ok, your Lord should probably take Summon Ghouls and just regrow the losses as best he can along with the Thrall who accompanies the Blood Knights. If you did a fine job of shielding your Blood Knights, letting the bannner of blood keep soak up what shots can be made at you by their shooting, you really should have all 5 of your knights and your thrall intact. At worse case, you may have lost one and be 5 strong as a unit. Once that unit has the ghoul anvil in place (typically round 2) you may now flank charge it. Enjoy, you worked hard to get to this point.

So that combat you should win. You got defended ghouls and a huge hammer. If you lost any units to shooting, the blood drinker is going to bring em back at this point. If your ghouls are breaking Steadfast (which they should be at 5 ranks deep) you are now going to overrun. Obviously the Knights are better at this than ghouls.

So now we get to what Forge is talking about? You won, you overran, you more than catch your enemy and destory the unit. So far strategy is working as intended, but now what do you do?

Well odds are at this point, you are facing that blasted Hill. Typically back there may even be a bunker unit with a caster in it. Alot of possibilities. There is another unit enganged with your ghouls/Varghulf/Lord. If that combat is going on you might be a simple wheel from getting into combat there depending on how far you overran. So now you have this one opprotunity where shooting again becomes an issue. This is why you splurged on a Blood Keep Banner, because you knew this moment would come. its 4+ ward vs ranged attacks will keep you from losing the entire unit in most cases. If your Fel bats did their job, they are tieing up some of the shooting. Since you hit a unit and overran it in one turn, it is probably unlikely that your opponent intended on his CC unit losing and set up a counter charge. it is probably more likely that your opponent is looking to win the other side of the table vs your lesser anvil, varghulf and Lord.

FINISH THEM!

Now what happens with that other unit of ghouls and the Varghulf is perhaps an uncertainty, You will want to keep your Varghulf further upfield than your Lord, because he will protect from any flank charges our counter charges since he has no Flank. Depending on your foe this combat is winnable. If nothing else, this side of the table goes into more points denial. Key thing is to not lose your Lord. So if the unit advancing up the field is more than you think your ghouls/varghulf/lord can handle, then dont throw your Lord in there, let him go do other things. If for some reason your Lord loses his Abyssal terror to shooting, he may have to try to join the ghoul unit or get into the BSB unit after that combat is won.

So to finish up the game, find a second charge with your Blood Knights. At this point, you just want to get every last point out of their killing prowess you can. If its an artillery unit, a bunker, whatever, just go anhillate something, they already helped destory and overrun one unit, so finding a weaker target for the twilight of the battel that they can hit and win is probalby not too hard to do at this point. You may even have panicing units out there from when you broke the other unit to hit as they try to flee the board. Your anvil unit is probably going to reform after winning combat and either turn to help the other ghoul unit, or countercharge a unit that is countercharging that ghoul unit. Either way, the quick destruction of the right side of the table (via knights and ghouls) typically has left you in control of the match. Terrain placement suggests that there is probably not alot left to the right side of the table since you put alot of pesky terrain over there.

So in summary:

Blood Knights are the focal point of your list when you take them. You have to build according to how you plan to use them. Victory happens via all phases of the game (terrain - deployment - movement - magic - combat) and of course... with a little luck.

Is this 100% going to give you a win 100% of the time. No, of course not. The strategy may have to be tweaked depending on the foe. Is this a tournament list? Probably not (though I did win a recent tourney at my game shop with such a list at 2.4K, though granted, it was a small turnout for the tourney, only played 3 games and none were against heavy shooting armies. Unfortuately I dont get any cool certificates for winning, so I cant post it in my sig, but I got some store credit for my troubles and now im off to buy something fun with it.

Sorry this is so long, but i hope it helps give you an idea of how i use them, how i build my list around them and how i use them in conjunction with other units to help create an environment where Blood Knights can flourish.

Is simply plopping down Graveguard EASIER! Sure, but i like the challenge.

Gladius Rex
 
you keep saying you use them in conjunction with stuff, which mean what infantry? the things that take 3-4 turns to get into combat? the blood knights with either be dead, or almost dead at that point, then you have to dig your self out of the grave you dug yourself. thats what im saying. 5 blood knights is essentially free points to your opponent as long as they make the wise decision to shoot at them and weaken em up.
 
It does not take that long to get infantry into combat. I just typed an epic long post detailing how i get my infantry into combat earlier than round 3. Typically i see combat in round 2 with my infantry.

SO yes, i use them in conjunction with infantry, typically ghouls because via ghoulkin and VdM I can get my ghoulies into combat that early, giving the faster moving blood knights no problems finding a flank in round 2. In one round of shooting (perhaps 2 if I got second) I typically have not lost all my Blood Knights and the Blood Drinker on the thrall typically remedies what few loses I do take. I have never lost my Thrall prior to engaging in combat. I have lost him sometimes to units like White Lions. those are a tricky unit to run Hv Cav into, you gotta nerf em down somehow, typically shadows to keep them from killing your Blood Knights before they ever get to strike. so you do have to watch for ASF and high strength, but aside from that, i have no real issues.

ghoulkin + ghouls + hoff banner + Blood Knights + Blood Drinker + flank chage ussually will = win.
 
That is an oddly specific scenario you spent so long to describe. Do you use that list often? Has it worked out as you described (more or less) every time?
You also made some assumptions that I feel aren't always the case: "you just don't have the same killing prowess, but you are not too far off. You get twice the attacks ... [referring to ghouls vs GG]" Your front line gets twice as many attacks, but the unit does not. A unit of ghouls gets 16 attacks whereas GG get 11 (including champs). Also str 3 vs str 6 is pretty far off in killing prowess. That's the difference b/t your opponent having a 4+ AS vs none, in addition to nearly always having a 2+ to wound vs 4-5+. While ghouls do have poison, GG have KB and often getting +1 to hit as well so... In any case this is a thread about bld knights not ghouls so I'll stop on that, but since it was mentioned I felt I should present the opposing viewpoint so to speak :D

"This unit is 400 points on the nose as I field 5 in most cases " Yup, but the true cost of the unit is to include the thrall (who lacks Lo,S) which is likely around 200 points. That makes about 30% of your points tied up in just 7 wounds

"Your opponent if he moves first, is going to advance with his CC unit. ." This isn't true for my opponents. No matter who I play, it's very typical I find for them to not advance at all until they feel they can get a charge off. It's not usually in the opponent's best interest to expedite CC for me, unless there is some special scenario going on.

"If you lost any units to shooting, the blood drinker is going to bring em back at this point" This isn't necessarily true either, unless you only lose one. You always have a 1/3 chance of missing. If you're against particularly defensive foes, then you'd be lucky to get just one wound with str 5. It's hard to discuss the exact statistics since it'll vary from foe to foe, but against weak foes you have ~50% chance to kill (making more than one a little lucky), and against a T4 4+ armor/parry save (saurus warriors for example) it'll drop off to 30%, making one wound a little lucky but pretty expected, more than one out of the question. I would plan on having the opponent handing me an anvil instead of a hammer, so 30% seems far more realistic estimate to me. Of course, there are lists that won't have too many defensive type troops making it possible to score more wounds, in these cases though there is a trade off of having more devastation fly at you so your worries change a bit. Like I said, hard to discuss in detail, but hopefully you understand my skepticism of relying on bringing back all bld knights lost earlier (and I personally would count on losing more than one to ranged attacks due to the opponents I face). I understand a little luck is always needed, but this involves quite a bit to get happening and seems like a critical part in getting this to work. Every deficit wound hurts killing power.

Just some thoughts. I don't mean to say bld knights can't work, just that they are overpriced for not doing anything so special. Their specialty is lots of of high str attacks, which isn't all that impressive really especially next to GG. Now if you use bld knights for the challenge of being at a disadvantage, then that's one thing, and it would be helpful to make it clear that's how you intend to use bld knights. However, sometimes it seems that you're implying that they generally are an equal (or even superior) to GG as far as their killing ability/ point cost which is what I disagree with, even after reading your detailed strategies.

Anyways, happy hunting!
 
Dklyn has it on the nose.

7 wounds is nothing big to rely on, for the amount of points your spending you can have a nice grave guard unit and a black coach or whatever, everything is better protected and can survive a bad set of rolls, believe it or not you can fail 2+ saves, Ive had skeletons kill 3 knights in one turn 5 wide. You are trying to play math hammer but your throwing in WAY to many variables, "my opponent deploys here, i get this spell off, my opponent moves here, I make all 50% of my ward saves or more, my opponent misses my thrall with a cannon ball." statistics are supposed to be as variable free as possible. spells are the BIGGEST variable in the game, starts with random power dice, whether your opponent is level 4 or not, if you roll decent, if your opponent rolls bad, simple simple simple, the only thing I really factor into math hammer is helm of commandment, only because it cant be stopped and your usually following around your main target unit with the bunker anyways, theres few situations where im out of range of my grave guard with HoC or tied up in combat.

Frankly its not hard to hit things with a cannon anymore statistically if you put your initial shot 8 inches before the model you want to tag your likely to hit it, and it goes up even higher if they have a engineer.

You need to have EVERYTHING go your way with that unit for it to do notable damage to your opponent (remember for every knight you lose you lose out on 3 attacks from the knight and 1 from the horse, this is not the case with supporting attacks), your likely to get 2-3 blood knights in combat against a majority of armies out there, and a fairly high chance of losing your thrall (compared to most characters, also remember shooting hits are distributed evenly amongst all models in the unit in the case of bows, ect.)

the chances of that blood knight unit staying alive the ENTIRE game is very very very low, then you have to compensate by killing 600 points worth of your opponents stuff. those blood knights will not earn their keep nor make up for what you lost, period, they simply will not be fighting strength by the time they get to combat unless your very lucky.
 
First and foremost, im pretty sure i said in the last line of my long strategy that it is NOT in fact EASIER to use blood knights than Graveguard. I said that. I have never said it is EASIER, i said it is POSSIBLE.

Now I also realise that ghouls do not have as much killing prowess as graveguard do, I am pretty sure i mentioned that in my battle strat as well, i looked at ghouls more from the defensive standpoint because im using them as an anvil, which means i need them to not lose more than they kill and against alot of enemies, ghouls and graveguard are defensively equals since 5+ AS is not much. So long as you bring the same HOff Banner, you can make the T4 last in either situation.

As we say here in the midwest "If "ifs" and "buts" were candy and nuts, it'd be Christmas everyday" So sure we can get into the heavily situational stuff and bring up 10000000 variances that will make any particular battle strategy more likely or less likely to succeed.

I have used this list probably 10 times. Most my games are against OnG, WoC, HE, and DE. So when it comes to shooting, i see a ton more ballistas than i ever see cannons. I have played Dwarves and even Chaos Dwarves and my WoC friend does bring a Hellcannon (which is more a stone thrower really than a cannon), but even when I played Dwarfs a couple times, their cannons really didnt hurt me much. We joked about him having "aluminum cannonballs" in his cannons.

As for archers, i really don't see alot of archers. My HE friend says his are overpriced garbage (like 12 pts a model or something silly he says) and my OnG friend who takes more shooting tends to say his Balllistic skill sucks so bad on his archers that he rarely hits enough with them to make them worthwhile. My WoC friend says the best shooting he can do is his Hellcannon and it seems to have a hard time keeping that template over the knights, which when 6 wide is not a very big unit and easy for a template to drift off of or do minimal hits, by which then we get a 50% shot at saving.

So that leaves me with really with Skaven and DE shooting. My Skaven friend says he doesn't care that much for their shooting. I dont know why that is, I have heard it is really good, but i see alot of plaguemonks and clanrats, and the big hellpit abomination, and a doomwheel and stuff like that, but the "cannon" thing... i guess I may have only seen it once and that particular game I didnt have Blood Knights fielded, so it didnt particularly impress me.

So what shooting do i see that i have seen work? Bolt Throwers!!!!

my HE friend while he despises his archers, LOVES the bolt thrower. he will take 3 or 4 in some lists and focus fire my graveguard units if I dont protect them. Volleys of 6 thats 24 shots and it seems they are quite good at wounding me, even with my regen banner. For some reason though, when he shoots at my Blood Knights, he tries to single bolt them in the flank, so I have found that if I keep my flank from being exposed, that he will shoot at my infantry before he shoots at my hv cav. My DE friend on the other hand, will take crossbowmen. He also takes some item that lets him shoot twice. He too tends to target my larger blocks of infantry with it. So the blood knights get spared.

We have one guy who plays empire but is rarely there and we have another guy who plays Brittonia, but he fears my VC so badly that he wont hardly play me.

So i guess really, our games are more dominated by magic and close combat. I think the shooting that is fielding against me is viewed as a way to whittle my infantry blocks down before hitting them in CC, which would make my enemies want to shoot me and charge me in the same round before i get a chance to regrow any, so perhaps that helps explain why i see combat in round 2 alot and not round 3 or 4.

I use ghoulkin because after a ghoulkin movement, I am pretty close to being in charge range really. if we start out at the edge of our deployment zone, which i do with my ghouls and my enemies seem to have one unit that does that, then i move up 8 and now we are at 16 inches apart. So if you are looking at DE or HE with 5 move scores naturally, they are looking at a 7 to 17 inch range, so while they do not often close the gap alot in round 1, if I do not charge them in round 2 or if they go first, we both have typically moved into CC or made it so they can charge me. They know my VCs are going to win via attrition if they wait and let me res up troops, and they feel (rightfully or wrongfully) that beating my infantry is the key to victory, so they shoot me, then they charge to try and finish me off. If they don't give themselves that advantage, then they know its going to be a long day. If they shot at my blood knights, they know that my infantry is still not going anywhere and theirs likely is going to, so i guess for them historically, it has worked out best for them to do as they have done to me.

i guess in short, my battle strategies work in the local shops where i play. I can't boast a 90% win percentage, but that is also because I will use some theme lists for fun, or do other quirky things like deploy scouts or make a list centered around the idea of as many flying units as possible "which i dub Vlad's Flying Circus". Those lists sometimes fall flat on their face, other times they work out fine.

However, i have found that Blood Knights will do their job just fine if you create a setting where they can be the hammers we want them to be.

and again, is winning with blood knights EASIER than with Graveguard, no. Is it possible to win with Blood Knights... of course it is, you just have to go about things differently, they are still the best Hv Cav in the game (for what that is worth to you) and if we cant field them, then every other for sure can't field theirs.

Gladius Rex
 
There's a lot to comment on so I hope you don't mind my not including everything, just the parts that I feel are worthwhile mentioning.
I've noticed you say using GG is easier a coupld of times... easier isn't always better of course and so I just assumed you meant like simpler (as in an easier strategy to use, but will work just as well) which makes sense because GG are pretty straightforward, charge into combat keep rolling dice until there are no more models and then move on. Now that I read: "is winning with blood knights EASIER than with Graveguard, no." and so perhaps when you said GG were easier, you meant easier to win with, or to put in another way, bld knights are, generally speaking, not as useful as GG even when supported. If that is what you mean, then we are all in agreement. I hope you can understand my confusion on this.

Anyways... "Now I also realise that ghouls do not have as much killing prowess as graveguard do, I am pretty sure i mentioned that in my battle strat as well," I know what you said in your post as I quoted it in mine :D. I pointed out what I disagreed with (that ghouls were not far off from GG and get twice the attacks) and that was that. I'm also not convinced their defensive (or staying power as some call it) is as good as GG either, but that's a topic for another thread.

"So what shooting do i see that i have seen work? Bolt Throwers!!!!" Count yourself lucky... siege such as stonethrowers and cannons have a lot more potential for harm as they can target the thrall right out of the unit and with a small bit of luck, negate his AS leaving him with a 4+ ward save to protect him. Magic is really the bigger threat overall anyways since there's no cover for that!.

"They know my VCs are going to win via attrition if they wait and let me res up troops, and they feel (rightfully or wrongfully) that beating my infantry is the key to victory, so they shoot me, then they charge to try and finish me off. If they don't give themselves that advantage" One mistake is to fire on your infantry while you have some bld knights and whatnot on the table... they should have something in their arsenal to match/beat down the ghouls so there's little need to pelt magic missiles at them when there are other options. If you're talking about the weak shooting attacks (str 3 long bow or something) then sure whatever they aren't going to do much no matter who they target... but the actually worth while attacks (cannons, bolt throwers, spells etc.) belong on the small groups of elite troops (like bld knights). I don't really see what advantage they are giving themselves...
Also, how on earth to they shoot you and charge you in the same round?

"i guess in short, my battle strategies work in the local shops where i play. I can't boast a 90% win percentage, but that is also because I will use some theme lists for fun, or do other quirky things like deploy scouts or make a list centered around the idea of as many flying units as possible "which i dub Vlad's Flying Circus". Those lists sometimes fall flat on their face, other times they work out fine." That's ok, I can boast a 150% win percentage and that's against foes who use twice the army size I have. Does this make me very attractive to women? Absolutely, and all these claims can be made because it's the internet...
 
Gladius Rex said:
First and foremost, im pretty sure i said in the last line of my long strategy that it is NOT in fact EASIER to use blood knights than Graveguard. I said that. I have never said it is EASIER, i said it is POSSIBLE.

Now I also realise that ghouls do not have as much killing prowess as graveguard do, I am pretty sure i mentioned that in my battle strat as well, i looked at ghouls more from the defensive standpoint because im using them as an anvil, which means i need them to not lose more than they kill and against alot of enemies, ghouls and graveguard are defensively equals since 5+ AS is not much. So long as you bring the same HOff Banner, you can make the T4 last in either situation.

As we say here in the midwest "If "ifs" and "buts" were candy and nuts, it'd be Christmas everyday" So sure we can get into the heavily situational stuff and bring up 10000000 variances that will make any particular battle strategy more likely or less likely to succeed.

I have used this list probably 10 times. Most my games are against OnG, WoC, HE, and DE. So when it comes to shooting, i see a ton more ballistas than i ever see cannons. I have played Dwarves and even Chaos Dwarves and my WoC friend does bring a Hellcannon (which is more a stone thrower really than a cannon), but even when I played Dwarfs a couple times, their cannons really didnt hurt me much. We joked about him having "aluminum cannonballs" in his cannons.

As for archers, i really don't see alot of archers. My HE friend says his are overpriced garbage (like 12 pts a model or something silly he says) and my OnG friend who takes more shooting tends to say his Balllistic skill sucks so bad on his archers that he rarely hits enough with them to make them worthwhile. My WoC friend says the best shooting he can do is his Hellcannon and it seems to have a hard time keeping that template over the knights, which when 6 wide is not a very big unit and easy for a template to drift off of or do minimal hits, by which then we get a 50% shot at saving.

So that leaves me with really with Skaven and DE shooting. My Skaven friend says he doesn't care that much for their shooting. I dont know why that is, I have heard it is really good, but i see alot of plaguemonks and clanrats, and the big hellpit abomination, and a doomwheel and stuff like that, but the "cannon" thing... i guess I may have only seen it once and that particular game I didnt have Blood Knights fielded, so it didnt particularly impress me.

So what shooting do i see that i have seen work? Bolt Throwers!!!!

my HE friend while he despises his archers, LOVES the bolt thrower. he will take 3 or 4 in some lists and focus fire my graveguard units if I dont protect them. Volleys of 6 thats 24 shots and it seems they are quite good at wounding me, even with my regen banner. For some reason though, when he shoots at my Blood Knights, he tries to single bolt them in the flank, so I have found that if I keep my flank from being exposed, that he will shoot at my infantry before he shoots at my hv cav. My DE friend on the other hand, will take crossbowmen. He also takes some item that lets him shoot twice. He too tends to target my larger blocks of infantry with it. So the blood knights get spared.

We have one guy who plays empire but is rarely there and we have another guy who plays Brittonia, but he fears my VC so badly that he wont hardly play me.

So i guess really, our games are more dominated by magic and close combat. I think the shooting that is fielding against me is viewed as a way to whittle my infantry blocks down before hitting them in CC, which would make my enemies want to shoot me and charge me in the same round before i get a chance to regrow any, so perhaps that helps explain why i see combat in round 2 alot and not round 3 or 4.

I use ghoulkin because after a ghoulkin movement, I am pretty close to being in charge range really. if we start out at the edge of our deployment zone, which i do with my ghouls and my enemies seem to have one unit that does that, then i move up 8 and now we are at 16 inches apart. So if you are looking at DE or HE with 5 move scores naturally, they are looking at a 7 to 17 inch range, so while they do not often close the gap alot in round 1, if I do not charge them in round 2 or if they go first, we both have typically moved into CC or made it so they can charge me. They know my VCs are going to win via attrition if they wait and let me res up troops, and they feel (rightfully or wrongfully) that beating my infantry is the key to victory, so they shoot me, then they charge to try and finish me off. If they don't give themselves that advantage, then they know its going to be a long day. If they shot at my blood knights, they know that my infantry is still not going anywhere and theirs likely is going to, so i guess for them historically, it has worked out best for them to do as they have done to me.

i guess in short, my battle strategies work in the local shops where i play. I can't boast a 90% win percentage, but that is also because I will use some theme lists for fun, or do other quirky things like deploy scouts or make a list centered around the idea of as many flying units as possible "which i dub Vlad's Flying Circus". Those lists sometimes fall flat on their face, other times they work out fine.

However, i have found that Blood Knights will do their job just fine if you create a setting where they can be the hammers we want them to be.

and again, is winning with blood knights EASIER than with Graveguard, no. Is it possible to win with Blood Knights... of course it is, you just have to go about things differently, they are still the best Hv Cav in the game (for what that is worth to you) and if we cant field them, then every other for sure can't field theirs.

Gladius Rex

from what I fathom from all of this is your local gaming group is not very competitive, thus weaker units are of more use and survivability.

HE seaguard (archers) are fricken AMAZING they can really put the hurt on stuff.

Skaven shooting, best shooting in the game hands down. WoC should have enough magic and or hell cannons to put the hurt on a single blood knight unit, my local WoC player does and hes in the top tier of my gaming group, but WoC have a hard time against VC it seems, I haven't lost to him in about 7 months. OnG shooting was even better then it is going to be in the new book, you can take 3 rock lobbas tons of spear chukkas and doom divers for dead cheap, yes their bows arnt very good I agree.

The thing that me and Dklyn (correct me if im wrong Dklyn) is in the broad spectrum of things if people play as competitive as their armies can play, taking into account every army in the game 5 blood knights is not good, it will die and wont contribute much to your game (infact detract).

and suggesting they are good in the broad spectrum of things is what sets me off, local meta game is cool, i mentioned it in the thread that got locked down that I dont think your gaming group represents all the armies and is not super competitive like my store, if it did you would realize 5 blood knights is a hinderance, that tactic would never fly in my store it would be gunned down, and I play against every army out there but brentonia and tomb kings, and my gaming group tends to lean towards the "this list will break faces" side, hence my stand point and the lists I post on the forums.
 
Gladius, whenever I take blood knights against bolt throwers I ensure that they have a nice juicy flank to shoot at. they will fire the bolt first, wound, then i take my save, they realise i have banner of the barrows and dont bother shooting at it with anything else. alternatively, the unit gets gorund down, in which case i feel sad and move on, using the rest of my army which is still in good knick due to everything focussing on the blood knights.

(fun story, i had a singular blood knight hold off a unit of 20 dryads for 3 turns, then chase them down and destroy them :P)


Now I think this thread has lost its spirit long ago, and there is little new being said.

On the topic of are blood knights more viable, they just like everything else are different. Comparing them to their performance in 7th ed is folly and comparing them go Grave guard is a little foolish as well. every unit in 8th has a different role now.

I am hearing a lot being said about it being a waste to send blood knights into weaker units, I dont really think this is the case. A unit of blood knights can easily go on a rampage, devouring as many smaller units that the enemy rbrings as it can, without support from spells or other units. While your blood knights are removing the enemies versatility and support, your bigger blocks of infantry bog down any unit that blood knights cant steamroller and wait until the blood knights have had their fun or just grind them in the war of attrition we do so well. This includes GG, however they being stronger with their GW can go head on with the enemies prized unit and either rip it to shreds or fight a more interesting fight.
 
Pretty much sums it up forge.

lynks said:
I am hearing a lot being said about it being a waste to send blood knights into weaker units, I dont really think this is the case. A unit of blood knights can easily go on a rampage, devouring as many smaller units that the enemy rbrings as it can, without support from spells or other units.

Weaker units do not equal smaller units (in fact usually they are big!). By weaker I mean like men-at-arms, skinks, basically anything that you can easily kill and won't really hurt you back. 4-500 points to take out something even skeletons could handle is kind of a waste :D.
 
Dklyn said:
Pretty much sums it up forge.

lynks said:
I am hearing a lot being said about it being a waste to send blood knights into weaker units, I dont really think this is the case. A unit of blood knights can easily go on a rampage, devouring as many smaller units that the enemy rbrings as it can, without support from spells or other units.

Weaker units do not equal smaller units (in fact usually they are big!). By weaker I mean like men-at-arms, skinks, basically anything that you can easily kill and won't really hurt you back. 4-500 points to take out something even skeletons could handle is kind of a waste :D.

exactly, the cheap notable support units usually come in large numbers with ranks, something the blood knights cant stand up to. you can chase away the cheap annoying units with a black coach or black knights which are half the price. even fell bats could probably do the job.
 
You seem to have this impression that the people in my store are not playing for something. We do have a league that runs in 2 month spans. Prizes are store credit. Whoever wins the most games places first. Second goes to the person who played the most games period, and third goes to the person who has played against the most number of different players.

Now when I line up on the table against a foe, I don't typically give them the same look twice. Sometimes I run the very GG heavy list that you run. Sometimes I don't. Since all our battles are scheduled ahead of time, and 80% or better are just pitched battles and a known point value, my opponent can never rely on how much shooting to bring against me. My HE friend did try some seaguard in a recent game, but it didnt do him alot of good. My OnG friend brings doom divers and spear chuckas, he just never seems to hit with them. Maybe when he gets his new book (which I hear is today) he will make me change my tune when I play him next.

I think if there is anything at my shop that causes our games to steer away from shooting, is the presence of Warhammer 40K.

Warhammer 40K (from what I see at my shop) looks like a pretty heavy shooting game. So at my shop, if you like shooting, you go play with the 40K people where shooting is king. If you like close combat, you go play Fantasy.

Not suprising, the couple of people who do both 40K and Fantasy... play Dwarves and Dark Elves.

So i wouldn't say that it is an issue of competitive, or their not caring if they win or lose, or them just not trying, I think if my local metagame differs (which we all know everyones metagame is different) it differs in that the people there use magic as their ranged far more than they use shooting. Either way, my Blood Knights come out unscathed. I am also pretty sure that my game shop is not unique. It may not even be the minority. There are 4 game shops within an hour of me that i know of, and from what I gather, none of them sound anything like what you are speaking of, Forge.

I can agree with you, that the way you talk, shooting plays a HUGE roll in your local metagame. that would make any unit susceptable to shooting seem less viable.

I guess in the end every player who reads these forums has to take into account their own local metagame. It is mentioned in EVERY single thread that goes for more than 10 posts at some point or another, that your local metagame may not allow for a certain tactic. The armies you see at your shop may alter your perception. I think these things are all givens. Anyone who is taking ANY advice on this forum as 100% guarantees for success without first taking into account their local metagame is asking for trouble. So that being said... my advice stands.

Blood Knights CAN work as a hammer unit. You just have to go about it differently than if you are going to go the easier route of using GG with GW as your hammer unit.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu