Anybody use grave guard anymore?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
@eggy generally, that would be true. Magic weapons cannot be given the flaming rule because of the banner. There are some units where magical attacks happens to be one of there special rules (chaos knights, skullcrushers, Grail Knights) who can gain the benefit of the banner.
 
Ravenheart said:
@eggy generally, that would be true. Magic weapons cannot be given the flaming rule because of the banner. There are some units where magical attacks happens to be one of there special rules (chaos knights, skullcrushers, Grail Knights) who can gain the benefit of the banner.

i was only allowed to get flaming attacks for the steeds for my chaos knights in a tournament. may have been faqed
 
Yeah but skull crushers don't have a special rule built into them like 7th ed chaos knights.

Now you must pay points for ensorcelled weapons, which are magic weapons, no? It doesn't say they then have magical attacks.

Juggers on the other hand have magical attacks being Deamonic and all, so surely they'd have flaming attacks in addition magical.

I'll have to check the rule book.
 
it was this ed and i bought the ensorcelled weapons:slapface:. I really needed to play that list in public a few times before that tourney. went 3 for 5 and got runner up for paint
 
I read multiple cases of people putting ONE cairn wraith in a grave guard unit. What's the point? The VC players in my area seem to either put four or five in a unit or zero. A lone cairn wraith won't make your men invincible and it denies you a S6 killing blow attack.
 
It protects from Champ challenges. If you have already lost your unit champ in a challenge (Which is common because GG will go last) then you really don't want your VL getting sucked into one, so they challenge and you accept with the wraith. How many champions are out there that have magical attacks? 3 or 4 maybe?
 
You see alot of GWs out there... and a wraith can suck out trhe challenge by that guy. And, if it's a GW wielder on a dragon or Peg, then happy days bc the mount is useless as is his stomp.

Also, the unit causes Terror if a Terror-causing model is in the unit, which causes Fear against Fear-causing units, like Ogres :)
 
Mikael.K said:
So, I play a lot with the swedish comp system. The penalties for VC units are pretty high, and should be! GG is one of those troop types that comps really good for the ammount of points you pay for them. I´ve played around with units of 30+ or so with GW´s a long time ago, even with twin engines.

The problem is, it feels like they seem so good on paper, but in real life they get creamed into oblivion. Anybody got any good ideas revolving around units of 35-40 grave guard? :)

I feel like you really need at least 40 of them to ensure there is enough return attacks to make a dent in things. Depending on what you're facing, you could take ten or more casualties before you get to swing, so if you're only starting with 30 you might only end up with ~15 return attacks, and then you're looking at a very steep uphill battle.
 
Seneschal said:
-GG get stomped by the monstrous cav that everyone and their brother has nowadays.
-GG's KB attacks do nothing to monstrous cav and Phoenix Guard aren't really afraid with their wardsave.
-More and more armies are getting rerolls to hit (dark elves getting ASF?) making the GG worth less than they are
-Their price tag is rather steep

I think this sums it up quite well.

Thing is, I really want to like Grave Guard - they have really nice models and fluff. But, they just don't seem to be able to do much, relative to their cost.

- If I give them swords and shields, then they're somewhat resilient, but struggle to do damage back - mainly because of the stupid and completely arbitrary limitations on killing blow. In this case, unless I put a blender lord with them, they'll usually die to CR over a couple of turns. And, if I need a ~500pt blender lord with the unit, I might as well just use ghouls or skeletons.

- If I give them great weapons, I find that they tend to take too much damage before getting to strike back - and, whilst they hit back hard, it's usually not hard enough to offset their initial losses.

- Also, I'm just going to say it; Banner of the Barrows is a pain in the arse. For one, it's more than a little irritating that I have to pay a 50pt tax to make my 'elite' unit actually act as such (whoopee, WS3 - I bet those Chaos Warriors are shaking already). Second, it means that they can't have a magic banner (i.e. flaming), unless I also include a BSB in the squad.

I guess I just always end up feeling like I'm forced to spend far too much to make the unit work - especially when I compare it to other choices. It's a bit like buying a car, only to be told that the steering wheel costs extra, and the brakes will only work if you slip them a tenner before each journey.
 
I always have good luck with them, even when I get creamed my GG were always the one high point of the game. Horde em up with a BoB = 3 ranks of str 6 attacks hitting on 3s. I also keep a necro on a corpse cart with Book of Arkhan nearby, not only can he rez them, but a bubble Vanhel's at the right time means the GG get a free charge off, Always Strikes First and Reroll Hits. This charge is usually enough to demolish any unit.
 
Kindred said:
I always have good luck with them, even when I get creamed my GG were always the one high point of the game. Horde em up with a BoB = 3 ranks of str 6 attacks hitting on 3s. I also keep a necro on a corpse cart with Book of Arkhan nearby, not only can he rez them, but a bubble Vanhel's at the right time means the GG get a free charge off, Always Strikes First and Reroll Hits. This charge is usually enough to demolish any unit.

A couple of things:

- Vanhel's doesn't let you charge a unit under any circumstances. You are not permitted to move within 1" of an enemy unit.

- Bear in mind that ASF from Vanhel is counteracted by the ASL on the GG great weapons - meaning they'll strike at just I3 (you might already know this, but I thought I'd mention it just in case).
 
Vipoid said:
A couple of things:

- Vanhel's doesn't let you charge a unit under any circumstances. You are not permitted to move within 1" of an enemy unit.

- Bear in mind that ASF from Vanhel is counteracted by the ASL on the GG great weapons - meaning they'll strike at just I3 (you might already know this, but I thought I'd mention it just in case).

I was aware of the ASF/ASL canceling out (still lets you hit before an enemy unit who also has GWs tho!) But whats all this about no Vanhels charging? It's always let you charge ever since I started playing in 5th ed, which helps counter the fact that our crappy march restrictions often leave us open to outmaneuvering. Just about ALL my wins since 8th ed (out of a 4 win, 20 loss record) are thanks to maneuvering into position then getting a bubble of vanhels charges through at just the right moment, you saying they took that away from us too?
 
Kindred said:
I was aware of the ASF/ASL canceling out (still lets you hit before an enemy unit who also has GWs tho!) But whats all this about no Vanhels charging? It's always let you charge ever since I started playing in 5th ed, which helps counter the fact that our crappy march restrictions often leave us open to outmaneuvering. Just about ALL my wins since 8th ed (out of a 4 win, 20 loss record) are thanks to maneuvering into position then getting a bubble of vanhels charges through at just the right moment, you saying they took that away from us too?

Unfortunately, yes. The spell no longer mentions that you're allowed to make a charge move out of it, or even move into contact with an enemy in some other way.
 
Kindred said:
But whats all this about no Vanhels charging? It's always let you charge ever since I started playing in 5th ed, which helps counter the fact that our crappy march restrictions often leave us open to outmaneuvering. Just about ALL my wins since 8th ed (out of a 4 win, 20 loss record) are thanks to maneuvering into position then getting a bubble of vanhels charges through at just the right moment, you saying they took that away from us too?

I'm afraid that they have indeed taken that away.

Now, the extra move from Vanhel's follows all the restrictions of a move made in the 'remaining moves' phase - i.e. it can never be used to charge an enemy unit.

Sorry to burst your bubble. :(
 
Vipoid said:
Kindred said:
I always have good luck with them, even when I get creamed my GG were always the one high point of the game. Horde em up with a BoB = 3 ranks of str 6 attacks hitting on 3s. I also keep a necro on a corpse cart with Book of Arkhan nearby, not only can he rez them, but a bubble Vanhel's at the right time means the GG get a free charge off, Always Strikes First and Reroll Hits. This charge is usually enough to demolish any unit.

A couple of things:

- Vanhel's doesn't let you charge a unit under any circumstances. You are not permitted to move within 1" of an enemy unit.

- Bear in mind that ASF from Vanhel is counteracted by the ASL on the GG great weapons - meaning they'll strike at just I3 (you might already know this, but I thought I'd mention it just in case).


Vanhels doesn't provide ASF, it just provides rerolls to hit, the corpse cart that provides ASF.

As a unit they are alright but nothing special, for the points you can get far better choices, I don't see the point in hording them unless you take a unit of 40/50 (the back rank will die before it gets to attack). Ff your going sword and board you may as well use skeletons and get a much larger unit. I think the only reason they see play is rule of cool (thats why I use them).

I don't stick a blender lord with mine anymore, you end up with relying on a 900-1000pts unit to win you the game, I just stick my challenge vampire with great weapon in the unit for a little combat punch.

I think they just pay to many points for being undead, they should probably be 9/10pts a model, it's either that or they need a complete rethink on what the units role actually is.
 
logan054 said:
Vanhels doesn't provide ASF, it just provides rerolls to hit, the corpse cart that provides ASF.

You're right, of course. Bit of a brain-fail there on my part. :redface:

logan054 said:
I don't stick a blender lord with mine anymore, you end up with relying on a 900-1000pts unit to win you the game.

Likewise. Whilst it seems flavourful to stick the vampire lord (or SGK) with his elite guard, I find that it's often dubious in practice. Usually, it leaves my core units vulnerable, since they're left without a strong character to counteract the CR they inevitably bleed. Also, it's just too much of a target for any unpleasant spells my opponent has.

Now, if I use them at all, I'll usually just stick a hero-vampire or Wight king with them (the latter more for flavour than because it will do something meaningful).

logan054 said:
I think they just pay to many points for being undead, they should probably be 9/10pts a model, it's either that or they need a complete rethink on what the units role actually is.

I agree. At the moment, I think we're paying far too much for Fear and Unbreakable on quite a few of our models - particularly infantry. Fear just seems worthless in its current state - even if your enemy isn't ItP (and an awful lot are), with L9/10 IP and/or BSBs the likelihood of failing is minute. And, when the planets finally align and an enemy fails their fear test, the effect is rarely impressive anyway. maybe if the enemy struck at I1, that might give them a bit more to think about.

Unbreakable is useful, but less so in this edition when every other army has IP, BSBs, standard of discipline, crown of command and steadfast. In fact, unlike normal Ld tests, the crumble from unbreakable is incredibly hard to actually modify. The pathetic -1 from our (still full-price) BSBs is really all we get. In addition, it even limits our actions, since we're not allowed to do anything but hold when charged. Finally, it seems like our magic is more there to offset our inherent disadvantages (poor WS, units that bleed CR and effectively double their casualties after every fight etc.), rather than giving us advantages.

Basically, it just seems like the value of being undead could do with some re-evaluation.
 
Vipoid said:
You're right, of course. Bit of a brain-fail there on my part. :redface:

Easily confused considering how ASF works this edition.

Likewise. Whilst it seems flavourful to stick the vampire lord (or SGK) with his elite guard, I find that it's often dubious in practice. Usually, it leaves my core units vulnerable, since they're left without a strong character to counteract the CR they inevitably bleed. Also, it's just too much of a target for any unpleasant spells my opponent has.

Now, if I use them at all, I'll usually just stick a hero-vampire or Wight king with them (the latter more for flavour than because it will do something meaningful).

It's certainly a trap many people fall into with the vampire lord/SGK in regards to graveguard, well not just grave guard, many people fall into the trap of putting a combat lord in their most powerful unit. Its this obsession people have with death stars this edition. I do exactly the same with my Vampire lord, stick her with the Skeleton warriors and let her grind down the opponents unit while using her damage and magic to counter act the wounds caused by the opponents unit.

It would also be nice if the wight king was worth while, but then I guess that mainly because of how powerful magic is this edition. Maybe all forms of Wights really need some kind of rethink, it would actually be nice if Wight kings and grave guard had some sort of synergy outside of a 50pts banner.

I agree. At the moment, I think we're paying far too much for Fear and Unbreakable on quite a few of our models - particularly infantry. Fear just seems worthless in its current state - even if your enemy isn't ItP (and an awful lot are), with L9/10 IP and/or BSBs the likelihood of failing is minute. And, when the planets finally align and an enemy fails their fear test, the effect is rarely impressive anyway. maybe if the enemy struck at I1, that might give them a bit more to think about.

Unbreakable is useful, but less so in this edition when every other army has IP, BSBs, standard of discipline, crown of command and steadfast. In fact, unlike normal Ld tests, the crumble from unbreakable is incredibly hard to actually modify. The pathetic -1 from our (still full-price) BSBs is really all we get. In addition, it even limits our actions, since we're not allowed to do anything but hold when charged. Finally, it seems like our magic is more there to offset our inherent disadvantages (poor WS, units that bleed CR and effectively double their casualties after every fight etc.), rather than giving us advantages.

Basically, it just seems like the value of being undead could do with some re-evaluation.

Well its the whole crumble rule thats the problem, it would be nice if it worked more like daemons unstable,this would make BSB's and stubborn more useful to our army. It would also make Grave guard less of a points sink! I do wonder if the horde rule is part of the problem with units like grave guard, because they take so many more loses from the sheer volume of attacks, they lose so many more models to crumble.

At the moment aren't they same points as executioners when armed with great weapons? I which one I would rather have! They should probably have platemail as standard for the points they pay now.

I do agree that the lore does seem more like its designed to bring us on a equal footing with other armies, I think the thing that carries me through games is my Blender lord and Wraiths.
 
Vipoid said:
I'm afraid that they have indeed taken that away.

Now, the extra move from Vanhel's follows all the restrictions of a move made in the 'remaining moves' phase - i.e. it can never be used to charge an enemy unit.

Sorry to burst your bubble. :(

Sigh, every time I think "well we're pretty bad in 8th ed, but at least we still have this going for us", it turns out I'm just playing us wrong. I think our whole army is built around the idea that fear is a devastating effect and Unbreakable is amazing, both of which used to be true. Now that fear does just about nothing at all and everyone is borderline unbreakable anyway, we're just left with overpriced units that couldn't fight their way out of a paper bag.
After so many years with VC I wouldn't have the heart to sell my whole force, but I'm really gonna pare it down in light of them being awful now (from it's current 6k size to maybe 2k). Maybe I can put the money toward my project to magnetize the bases and weapons on a blood angels force to double as WoC. Keep an eye out for some truly well painted VC models hitting ebay soon!
 
logan054 said:
It would also be nice if the wight king was worth while, but then I guess that mainly because of how powerful magic is this edition. Maybe all forms of Wights really need some kind of rethink, it would actually be nice if Wight kings and grave guard had some sort of synergy outside of a 50pts banner.

Well, I think one of the issues is that most wizards are stupidly undercosted at the moment. Lv4s in particular just seem ludicrously cheap at ~200pts base for many armies. The +4 to dispel alone is probably worth a good chunk of that, then they have versatility, and the ability to affect enemy and friendly units at range. Finally, with the current #6 spells, they can basically play football with a sphere of annihilation. :slapface:

logan054 said:
Well its the whole crumble rule thats the problem, it would be nice if it worked more like daemons unstable,this would make BSB's and stubborn more useful to our army.

That would certainly be nice. Lt would also be useful if our lords didn't explode from CR (at least, not as easily as zombies).

Vampire Lord - "Well, I've cut a couple of them down like vermin, and they've yet to scratch me. Looks like I've got this one... OH DEAR GOD - RANKS! RANKS!! AND A BANNER. ARRRRAGH!" :grave:
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu