Anyone else having still having severe problems with war machines post 8th?

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!
No, I do not have problems vs warmachines. I have dogs, bats, batswarms, vampire bats, and spirit hosts to kill them with, not to mention numerous magic items and spells we have that can easily knock one out. Again I say, Iron curse Icon. Look it up.

Further more, if you are having serious troubles vs warmachines, what can ya do....
 
drmooreflava said:
No, I do not have problems vs warmachines. I have dogs, bats, batswarms, vampire bats, and spirit hosts to kill them with, not to mention numerous magic items and spells we have that can easily knock one out. Again I say, Iron curse Icon. Look it up.

Further more, if you are having serious troubles vs warmachines, what can ya do....

Please read the posts that were already there before you chime in. This was talked about way on the first page. Your post is not helping.

@everyone else: The OP already stated that he was having problems getting magic off, and hoping to get a comet on a IF is not a sound strategy.

1st, to get good odds of a commet you will need both a level 4 and a level 2 caster. Both of which will need to be vampires and both will need Forbidden lore. That means the majority of your magic is tied up in non-vamperic casters, which is not a good idea.

2nd, off the top of my head, chances of a miscast on 6 dice are around 27%.

3rd, Comet is a spell I have used many times on war machines, and rarly does it kill one much less a group. If you cast it, it will have a 50% chance to come down next turn at S5, meaning you will do on average of 8 hits and need 6's to wound (all war machines are T7), thus on average do a little more than 1 wound each. I will say that if it doesn't go off and goes off on your next turn, it will be S6, needing 5's to wound and will do on average 3 wounds each.

Most of us have seen the players that try to win the game by casting dwellers or purple sun or other spells every turn, and they rarly win. I do not suggest anyone expect a simple fix. Yes it may work, but it rarly will.

I would like to remind everyone that we do not play an army with a I-WIN button, we play an army that requires tactics to win. Take pride in that and don't resort to long shots or cheezy tactics. The High Elves are for that.
 
Cobra7 said:
@everyone else: The OP already stated that he was having problems getting magic off, and hoping to get a comet on a IF is not a sound strategy.

1st, to get good odds of a commet you will need both a level 4 and a level 2 caster. Both of which will need to be vampires and both will need Forbidden lore. That means the majority of your magic is tied up in non-vamperic casters, which is not a good idea.

2nd, off the top of my head, chances of a miscast on 6 dice are around 27%.

3rd, Comet is a spell I have used many times on war machines, and rarly does it kill one much less a group. If you cast it, it will have a 50% chance to come down next turn at S5, meaning you will do on average of 8 hits and need 6's to wound (all war machines are T7), thus on average do a little more than 1 wound each. I will say that if it doesn't go off and goes off on your next turn, it will be S6, needing 5's to wound and will do on average 3 wounds each.

But after all I think you are right, it isn’t a very reliable tactic, but given the circumstances I'm not sure what else could be done.

Most of us have seen the players that try to win the game by casting dwellers or purple sun or other spells every turn, and they rarly win. I do not suggest anyone expect a simple fix. Yes it may work, but it rarly will.

I would like to remind everyone that we do not play an army with a I-WIN button, we play an army that requires tactics to win. Take pride in that and don't resort to long shots or cheezy tactics. The High Elves are for that.

True. I had forgotten about the hitting the warmachine rule, thought it would wound on the crew instead. Though it would probably kill the Master engineer if nothing else, he is only T4. And you could always try casting it on the higher difficulty to make it stronger, but then you'd need a Mortis Engine to have a good chance of casting it successfully. The dispelling problem still occurs but a good roll on the winds (any double really) should let at least one spell go through.

But after all I think you are right. It isn't a very reliable tactic but given the circumstances I don't really know what else could be done.

EDIT: Another benefit of this tactic is that you can deploy most of your army in the corner on the opposite side of his corner, unalienable his warmachines to shoot. The comet has unlimited range so you could still kill him with a bit of luck but he can't kill you. Incredibly boring game but that is his fault.
 
Mad said:
EDIT: Another benefit of this tactic is that you can deploy most of your army in the corner on the opposite side of his corner, unalienable his warmachines to shoot. The comet has unlimited range so you could still kill him with a bit of luck but he can't kill you. Incredibly boring game but that is his fault.

I once played a Dwarf Player with gunline in a tournament with my Skaven. Just my luck we pulled a Battle for the Pass scenario. Naturally he set his gunline on his table edge. His goal was to make me traverse four feet of table before I could meet his hard infantry blocks in melee. That is, with what would be left of my army. I tried to play for the draw. I hid the bulk of my army behind thase large rocky formations on the table (They were about 8 inches tall). I did cheesy things like point my Aboms at the table edge so they would be off the table every other turn for his shooting phase. With all that, he killed a single warpfire team and won the game. Not by much but he won. Playing for the draw is rarely fun and hardly ever works as intended. :thumbsdown:

[Edit: In a tournament I would recommend instead that you play out one turn, let the gunline git have his glee, smile, shake his hand and conceed the game with some dignity. In a campaign setting at a hobby center I would just refuse to play said opponent.]
 
Spoke to him, two other players, and the TO tonight about the tactics he's using... turns out he has a modified bore sight laser with a snake tip because 'so many people have challenged him on LOS' and 'he thought I was a better player than to challenge him on this.' Also discovered his canons are angled to put the muzzle over the height of the dwarves on flat terrain. Oh, and concerning "screening" it doesn't work unless your running a HUGE model in front of a smaller one as he can shoot 'between' rank and file models, arms, legs, and any other tiny gap of air that allows the smallest 'true line of sight' he can claim. AKA stick a 20mm behind the coach, and you MIGHT not be able to shoot the 20mm.

At this point the BS has piled high enough that my brother and I might just drop from the campaign. Be real interesting when we've dropped from 8 players in the beginning to 4 at the end of only the first season. :slapface:
 
Vortaine said:
baynexilos said:
I play against dwarves with 8 warmachines at ard' boys alot and ive won quite a few games. I would take small units of wolves and fel bats. Blood knights with banner can help (they will still usually die but it takes alot to kill them. Of course run your general in large unit of skellies or zombies or gg and take the iron curse icon to help minimize casualties a little. Black coaches are also pretty solid as they have a 4 up ward and enough wounds to usually last through a hit. With enough tough units around he will have to pick some targets and once you can get up there and start killing his stone throwers he cant do as much damage to your block units. Also remember that you can AOE van hels to get basically another entire movement phase, and invocation of nek as often as you can to revive what you have lost so far.

Also review your war machine rules as their are few tricks that can help. With cannons you can screen your vargeists and vargulf with blocks of infantry, because if they cannot see the point on the ground they are shooting at they have to choose the actual model and if will most likely overshoot(this doesnt work very well with terrorgeists because they are so huge). Also dont place your screening infantry so that shooting at the front of them is the optimal distance to the vargulf (6 or 7 inches i think).

These games still come down to luck alot of the time. With that many warmachines hes bound to misfire occasionally (even with rerolls). So get into combat as fast as possible so they cant shoot at you, have alot of tough targets that forces tehm to choose, make ward saves (joke), and make sure when you charge warmachines to wheel so you can overrun into more of them or other units as you dont have to close the door or anything against them just align however you want (with 1 wheel). This helps you stay in combat during his shooting phase.

I think i would take(knowing i was fighting dwarves) black coach, 5 or 10 blood knights with banner(DO NOT let them get shot through the flank, cannons can only hit one rank if they are in your front arc as per their rules) a large block of HW shield GG (t4 and 4+ will make them survive a little better...just a little though, also try to get hellish vigour for when this unit hit their core) 3 units of 3 felbats(they are cheaper now :D ) 6 vargesits screened with infantry near general so they dont frenzy (maybe two groups of 3 if you just want to warmachine hunt as that makes them not as deep for cannons. huge blocks of skellies at least 5x8 if not 5x10. id take maybe 2 or 3 units of 5 wolves(unlikely that he will waste cannons to kill 1 and stone throwers will usually want to target your gg, though organ guns might eat them). Id have one combaty vampire lord with iron curse in the gg with my bsb (wight king is efficient, or vampire if you want other combat tricks). Get a master necro as hes cheap casting and toss him in the back. Mortis engine screened by infantry and parked kinda sideways to the cannons is nice and would force him to use flaming cannons to get rid of regen and give him another thing hes has t worry about shooting (as they usualy dont have that on stone throwers much).

Other things that can help is to know EXACTLY (which if you play ard boys you do) what warmachines have what runes, note that he CANNOT use the same combination of runes on different warmachines (if their are 3 cannons usually 1 isnt flaming and so on).

This is what ive used against them so far after weeks and weeks of play testing just against dwarf lists like this (of course the new units are more speculative since i mostly played against them last book and i have not gotten in over 5 games with dwarves since then). If possible ask to see his army book and list and just to see whats possible and how it works, ive always found that it helps me better understand and defeat other armies. Last thing i have no idea what points you are playing at or what he takes besdies warmachines so its hard to be super specific with what builds i would take.


EDIT: took me a long while to write that, i should also mention that you have to plce warmachines ALL at the same time in one deployment so you just place some fell bats, wolves and maybe skelly bunkers till you know his deployment then deploy knights and gg and such to take advantage of it.


EDIT: EDIT: make you have more ranks then his hordes to deny steadfast, then with good killing by your lord 8 or so wounds on average) and the gg (with hit banner, hopefully rerolls from hellish) you should be able to win combat and make him flee. Make sure your not spending too much on characters, i would have only 3 in my list. BSB, lord and master necro.


How does the infantry blocking work? I'm not seeing any rules where it says that the cannon has to see what it is shooting at or else it has to target it directly. That would mean you could effectively screen vargulfs and single rank MI because the base isn't long enough or wide enough to be hit by the minimum 2" scatter.

Also, about Hexwraiths, you guys are using them wrong. They are fast cavalry, and their special rule allows them to pass through unengaged models. They do not have to pass through the entire length and width of the unit, for if that were the case, denying them of their special rule would be easy.

Move onto the unit, reform, move out, reform. As long as you end up 1" away, you are good.

Hi i just bought some hex wraiths and am new to VC could you explain what you just said about them in a bit more detail I'm a bit slow lol. How do you mean move on to the unit reform move out? can I do all that in one turn? sorry if this is a stupid question i'm new to warhammer
 
maxtoreador said:
Spoke to him, two other players, and the TO tonight about the tactics he's using... turns out he has a modified bore sight laser with a snake tip because 'so many people have challenged him on LOS' and 'he thought I was a better player than to challenge him on this.' Also discovered his canons are angled to put the muzzle over the height of the dwarves on flat terrain. Oh, and concerning "screening" it doesn't work unless your running a HUGE model in front of a smaller one as he can shoot 'between' rank and file models, arms, legs, and any other tiny gap of air that allows the smallest 'true line of sight' he can claim. AKA stick a 20mm behind the coach, and you MIGHT not be able to shoot the 20mm.
I can see that the debate with the player in question is done, but just tossing out some quick facts for further refrence.

So it sounds like he modified his cannons to get better LoS? If so this is called Modeling to Advantage and is a strick no-no. Most places will not allow such models. If someone wants to modify a model to make it look cooler thats fine, but refrence points need to be the same as an unmodified model. One joke some friends and I were makeing once is a dragon with a flexible and extendable neck and able to use it's breath weapon from 2 feet away. It's just silly.

As far as screaning, he can see past 1 rank, but would have problems with 2 or more ranks of normal models, again, use a laser pointer to check LoS. The smallest red dot means he has LoS, but it needs to be measured from the same place every time.
 
It sounds like the problem isn't war machines. It's the dwarf general.

There is at least a small amount of common sense, decency and sportsmanship that should be involved. I understand TLoS but sometimes enough is enough.

This hobby is too expensive to piss off people who might just end up as your friends otherwise.

Me... "Congratulations, you have beaten me for the last time."

Him... "You think you can beat my super moded war machines and janky tactics?" (sarcasticly)

Me... "No, I don't."

Me... "Does anyone else want to play warhammer?"
 
Shadowfax said:
None of those options are all that convincing. Statistically, using magic is probably the best bet. You just need to use as many advantages as you can to keep from getting dispelled; extra casting value from a Mortis Engine, extra dice from Periapt (Dwarfs ALWAYS leave you two extra dispel dice in their magic phase), Dark Acolyte, intelligent sequencing of your spells to get him to dispel the less important ones, etc.

I wouldn't want to change your army or playstyle too much, but a super fast moving army or one loaded out super magicky are probably the best options. IMO.
 
saitou187 said:
Vortaine said:
baynexilos said:
I play against dwarves with 8 warmachines at ard' boys alot and ive won quite a few games. I would take small units of wolves and fel bats. Blood knights with banner can help (they will still usually die but it takes alot to kill them. Of course run your general in large unit of skellies or zombies or gg and take the iron curse icon to help minimize casualties a little. Black coaches are also pretty solid as they have a 4 up ward and enough wounds to usually last through a hit. With enough tough units around he will have to pick some targets and once you can get up there and start killing his stone throwers he cant do as much damage to your block units. Also remember that you can AOE van hels to get basically another entire movement phase, and invocation of nek as often as you can to revive what you have lost so far.

Also review your war machine rules as their are few tricks that can help. With cannons you can screen your vargeists and vargulf with blocks of infantry, because if they cannot see the point on the ground they are shooting at they have to choose the actual model and if will most likely overshoot(this doesnt work very well with terrorgeists because they are so huge). Also dont place your screening infantry so that shooting at the front of them is the optimal distance to the vargulf (6 or 7 inches i think).

These games still come down to luck alot of the time. With that many warmachines hes bound to misfire occasionally (even with rerolls). So get into combat as fast as possible so they cant shoot at you, have alot of tough targets that forces tehm to choose, make ward saves (joke), and make sure when you charge warmachines to wheel so you can overrun into more of them or other units as you dont have to close the door or anything against them just align however you want (with 1 wheel). This helps you stay in combat during his shooting phase.

I think i would take(knowing i was fighting dwarves) black coach, 5 or 10 blood knights with banner(DO NOT let them get shot through the flank, cannons can only hit one rank if they are in your front arc as per their rules) a large block of HW shield GG (t4 and 4+ will make them survive a little better...just a little though, also try to get hellish vigour for when this unit hit their core) 3 units of 3 felbats(they are cheaper now :D ) 6 vargesits screened with infantry near general so they dont frenzy (maybe two groups of 3 if you just want to warmachine hunt as that makes them not as deep for cannons. huge blocks of skellies at least 5x8 if not 5x10. id take maybe 2 or 3 units of 5 wolves(unlikely that he will waste cannons to kill 1 and stone throwers will usually want to target your gg, though organ guns might eat them). Id have one combaty vampire lord with iron curse in the gg with my bsb (wight king is efficient, or vampire if you want other combat tricks). Get a master necro as hes cheap casting and toss him in the back. Mortis engine screened by infantry and parked kinda sideways to the cannons is nice and would force him to use flaming cannons to get rid of regen and give him another thing hes has t worry about shooting (as they usualy dont have that on stone throwers much).

Other things that can help is to know EXACTLY (which if you play ard boys you do) what warmachines have what runes, note that he CANNOT use the same combination of runes on different warmachines (if their are 3 cannons usually 1 isnt flaming and so on).

This is what ive used against them so far after weeks and weeks of play testing just against dwarf lists like this (of course the new units are more speculative since i mostly played against them last book and i have not gotten in over 5 games with dwarves since then). If possible ask to see his army book and list and just to see whats possible and how it works, ive always found that it helps me better understand and defeat other armies. Last thing i have no idea what points you are playing at or what he takes besdies warmachines so its hard to be super specific with what builds i would take.


EDIT: took me a long while to write that, i should also mention that you have to plce warmachines ALL at the same time in one deployment so you just place some fell bats, wolves and maybe skelly bunkers till you know his deployment then deploy knights and gg and such to take advantage of it.


EDIT: EDIT: make you have more ranks then his hordes to deny steadfast, then with good killing by your lord 8 or so wounds on average) and the gg (with hit banner, hopefully rerolls from hellish) you should be able to win combat and make him flee. Make sure your not spending too much on characters, i would have only 3 in my list. BSB, lord and master necro.


How does the infantry blocking work? I'm not seeing any rules where it says that the cannon has to see what it is shooting at or else it has to target it directly. That would mean you could effectively screen vargulfs and single rank MI because the base isn't long enough or wide enough to be hit by the minimum 2" scatter.

Also, about Hexwraiths, you guys are using them wrong. They are fast cavalry, and their special rule allows them to pass through unengaged models. They do not have to pass through the entire length and width of the unit, for if that were the case, denying them of their special rule would be easy.

Move onto the unit, reform, move out, reform. As long as you end up 1" away, you are good.

Hi i just bought some hex wraiths and am new to VC could you explain what you just said about them in a bit more detail I'm a bit slow lol. How do you mean move on to the unit reform move out? can I do all that in one turn? sorry if this is a stupid question i'm new to warhammer

Fast Cavalry can make unlimited reforms in their movement. Hexwraiths are fast cavalry. Their rule states that in the movement subphase, you can move through units and inflict hits upon them as you do.

Most people have assumed this meant that they must move through the entire unit in order to cause hits, and that they must both start and end their move one inch away (rules that all units follow). This is impractical. The base of a hexwraith is too long to ever move through all by the smallest units (like, 5x2 units).

However, refer back to their rules on being fast cavalry and their rule that allows them to move through units. Given that their are no restrictions on its special move (and yes, i know that omissions are necessarily permissions for these games), the only way I can think to play them and can see them of being any use is for them to function as ghostly fast cavalry, which means you use your move to constantly reform through, on, and over a unit.

Like I said before, you start 1-4" away, move in, turn around, walk out, turn around so they or anyone else doesn't get your flank/rear/whatever. You have now moved all 5 models through their unit and ended the move at least one inch away from another unit.
 
Why play against this person if he does the same thing everytime? Just set up everything and when he sets up in the far corner like that, reach across the table and shake his hand. "Good Game bro, you really got me again". And walk away.
 
This guy is a tool, hes using janky tactics and has converted his models to give him a advantage, which isnt even allowed. How about you convert a TG with a 30inch long neck and scream his cannons to death turn 1, if he argurs be like 'look bro, my TG is part girafe, you got a problem? Btw, nice cannon conversion'.

On a serious note, have you tried taking like 5 zombie screens all 30inch long and 1 deep? He wont be able to shoot your guys behind the screen and if you take like 5 he wont get past them, not with IoN, a upgraded CC and a necro spamming vanhells. Maybe even put 5 wraiths in the first screen unit. Sorry if all this has bern mentioned before, not read all the pages.
 
I might just go massive combat blocks.

One huge block of skeletons or zombies with 5 wraiths in the front.

One huge block of ghouls.

One huge block of graveguards.

Backed up with enough casting to raise anything back from the dead.

Warmachines will do a lot of damage, but if everything you have on the table is massive (truely massive, like 60+ models), with raising you should be able to easily reach his lines. Then it is just a matter of matching the right combat blocks against each other.

Ghouls against regular Dwarves (that have S5 with great weapons and only heavy armor)

Wraith unit against the unit without magic weapons (generally dwarves will have them)

Grave Guard against his toughest unit (Hammerers usually).

If he is putting so much into his war machines, he shouldn't have fighty characters and the size of his blocks won't be above 40 (or 30 for the hammerers). Crush him with weight of numbers.

The only issue will be deploying your units properly across from the right units. For this, you can take a lot of chaff in small units, like single bases of spirit hosts or small units of wolves, or fell bats. Drop all of those on the table first, then you can place your combat blocks.

Leave your Mortis Engine, Coach, Terrorgheist, Corpse Cart, Varghulf, Vargheist, and anything else that is easilly killed by warmachiens at home.
 
We've discussed how much the Dwarf general from the OP is a tool. But I played yesterday against a nice guy using a fairly typical Skaven list. His artillery was one WLC, 2 plague mortars and 2 warpfire throwers. Not a whole heck of a lot, right? To counter that I had a unit of 5 direwolves, a bat swarm of 2 models, a single model spirit host and a unit of 4 Vargheist.

All of my units of artillery hunters got cut off by foot troops or his HPA. My Vargheist did manage to take out a warfire thrower. But the second one reduced them to one model. At that point I made a desperate attempt to assassinate his Greyseer who was in a unit on the side facing me. Almost got the sucker too with my last surviving Vargheist before he crumbled.

I had terrible luck never rolling above a 6 for my winds of magic. I got one single IoN off in the first turn of the game and one Vanhels later on (mainly because he kept his dice for my IoN attempts). The Greyseer dispelled everything else.

I just think that our army is terribly vulnerable to artillery. Those plague mortars and the WLC wrecked havoc on my blocks. Especially the blocks that were fighting his slaves.
 
As a general rule, any horde style strategy should fear the skaven because of the simple fact that they have ludicrous numbers of templates. I totally agree with datalink7 on his anti-dwarf artillery strategy because dwarfs like cannons and organ guns. Yes grudge throwers are a shame but he can have three of them tops. When it comes to skaven however, I would suggest going very differently. You'll want to bring all of the big stuff: mortis engines, vargulf, vargheists, terrorgheists (probably not all in the same army) because they shrug off the mortars, warpfire throwers and plagueclaw catapults that just love to get their teeth into big units. The best shooting they have to deal with monsters is the warp lightning cannon, which has as much of a chance of wounding a terrorgheist on 6s as on 2s, then you've got regen too-you shouldn't be massively worried.
I Haven't played against such an army, but I am a skaven player and have used armies loaded with artillery before and have seen the devastating effects it has on ranked up infantry. Especially chaos warriors. Man you've got to feel sorry for chaos warriors:(

Oh and also, don't bother taking expensive ethereal units against skaven, they have magical attacks coming out of their ears.
 
Honestly this thread is disheartening in the extreme, a Campaign should be something fun for all to pull this crap makes me think you should get a few allies of like minded people (who also think the guy is being a rat bastard) and take him to the proverbial parking lot and kick the **** outta him, everyone gang up on him and reduce his armies to mush for a season and see if he gets the hint...
 
Be careful taking big high toughness things against skaven.

They have scouts that skirmish and have poison slings. Ususally they are 2 or 3 units of 5 to 7.
 
If you're talking about gutter runners (which you must be) then if someone is taking three units of 5-7 then I wouldn't be worried. Then are essentially paying almost 400 pts on units that can easily be held up by a couple of spirit hosts or a decent zombie unit. Poisoned attacks aren't a huge threat when they are coming from such tiny units, all three of them firing on a single monster should only cause about seven wounds which can then be regenerated and partially healed by magic. How many points are you talking about here because I wouldn't even contemplate putting poisoned attacks on gutter runners for 5 pts per model below 2500-3000 pts. For the same price you can have a hell pit abomination and a doomwheel!
 
OP: Its just not worth your time playing this guy. This is a game that, outside of strict competitive events, you play *with* people. He isn't even slightly concerned about playing a game of warhammer with you, at least not in any sense that you value. Don't be rude, just politely explain that his and your goals in the hobby aren't the same, and that you won't be playing any more games.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu