Hi Guys,
Thanks for all the feedback, the good and the bad!
What surprised the most me about this thread was the sheer anger at the fact that I would presume to inflict such an episode on to people, and the certainty that no-one in their right mind could possibly enjoy to listen to that type of episode. I'm not one to shy away from harsh feedback and criticism but I think some of the comments are a little OTT, especially when this format has been used for around 40 episodes.
Any how, like I said, I'm not one to let a few comments keep me down....
Corrections - Fair points on the crumbling error. Gareth asked if they all crumbled and I said no. My bad. The Ghoul King one Chris should have caught. I didn't spot it at the time. I'm always happy to bring up any errors we made in rules on the next show.
VC vs Armour - I'll back up Chris on that one. I asked my Daily Show listeners and twitter and facebook followers for questions for the review show and we had a load of questions for advice vs armour. It seems that the current meta game with an army with 8-10 units with high toughness and armour (of course backed with magic and magic attacks) is really hammering the
VC in tournament gaming. I'm talking, Warriors, Empire, Ogres, High and Dark Elves with armoured builds and mobile characters. Even Bretonnia.
The lord can only be in 1 place, the Terrorghiest is an easy to bring down target and the banshee screams are unreliable. After that the
VC have lots of low strength attacks that do not cut it. This is the experience of the Bad Dice guys facing
VC, Chris playing with them and also a number of the top players in the UK both with and against
VC. Grave Guard are not the answer to this. Far too many units in warhammer will destroy the grave guard very easily for them to be a worthy inclusion to the list as a counter to a small amount of units.
I don't want to turn this thread into a 'merits of Grave Guard' thread but am happy to debate it elsewhere. Send me an email with your counter argument and I will dedicate an episode of the daily show to it. bencurry @ baddice.co.uk (remove the spaces)
So, back to podcast formats.
I do not like to single out other peoples shows as examples but seeing as you raise Beast of War I will run with them. The episode you pointed out was part of a
VC week. That episode looked at a few units and was 25mins. There are more in the series. well over 3 hours worth (probably closer to 4, across 14ish separate sections). If you ignore the unboxings and just focus on the gaming and rules reviews it still takes around 2 hours.
This biggest feedback I can take from that is the fact that I should timestamp my show notes so you can jump to segment. I know this but I do not do it as it takes too long. no other reason. If i get enough feedback then I might consider doing it again.
Funnily enough, I know that there are a good number of people that prefer a shorter show with no filler and I cater to that audience too. You guys might prefer my Daily episodes. Its a solo show (just myself and a mic and an occasional guest) that picks one topic and talks on it for 10 - 15 mins.
I have covered
VC in the past, you might want to check out http://baddice.co.uk/daily51/ for an interview with Raf Harbinson at a UK event talking about his dire wolf list, http://baddice.co.uk/daily133/ this one is a look at filling your 600 points of core in a
VC list and most recently http://baddice.co.uk/daily220/ What Would Curry Do, Vampire Counts. This topic came about from me often getting asked 'what would you do with xxx army' so I turned it into a regular feature.
Its late here so thats all for now, thanks for sitting through the show even if you did hate it. I'm 100% certain that if i got 8 mins into a podcast episode and it was so bad I would have switched off. i know this because I do it repeatedly. (here's looking at you Xizor

Love ya Chrissy!!)
Cheers,
Ben