Bad Dice Podcast 103 - Vampire Counts Army Review

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

Ben Curry

Zombie
Apr 6, 2013
2
Zombies
5
Hi,

Sorry to drop in here just for some shameless self-promotion! I wouldn't normally do such a thing but I thought this would be of interest to everyone.

Bad Dice Podcast episode 103 has just been released and it is our Vampire Counts Army Review.

We have a guest on the show. Chris Legg has played Vampires since the book was released, he was the Vampire player in the 2012 ETC England Team and has consistently placed highly on the UK tournament scene with the army including a 2nd place at the UK Masters this year.

He gives us some insights into the list and talks about his experiences with different unit combos and builds.

You can get the show at baddice.co.uk/103

Subscribe for free on iTunes or by adding the RSS Feed to your prefered podcast app

For more Vampire Counts podcasts you can also check out episode 220 of the Bad Dice Daily for my thoughts on a list.

Thanks for listening!

Ben.
 
I Really had to force myself to listen through allot of it, getting side tracked by rubbish for so long.
Nearly 15 minutes on talking about Easter and crap before it even touched on the book....

Few mistakes made as well, 17:20 said the characters in the army do not crumble if the leader dies, not just vampires don't, characters don't.
Would of thought the expert would kind of leap in and put things right.
21:00, Strigoi ghoul kings can not wear magic armour, just chuck heavy armour on him...... (Thats the expert saying that)

I still listening to it though, its very lengthy.....
 
Duke Danse Macabre said:

Totally agree with Danse Macabre ... that entire podcast is like what, two and a half hours in length, and one could very well shave half of it, reducing it to essential information.
Then, there's several mistakes being made, as has been pointed out.
All in all, not very good information for potentialy new VC players, nothing new or revealing for the veterans, and most certainly 2.5 hrs. of wasted time.
 
Ok, guys, here's a suggestion - if you're going to mindlessly yammer on about nothing, do it to fill in time *after* your review.

I'm currently 8 minutes in and you've done nothing but incessantly spout absolute drivel. Were you all drunk when you recorded this, or did you genuinely think that VC players would be thrilled to hear what Easter Eggs you received this year?

Furthermore, this review is two-and-a-half hours long - that's longer than most films. Did you really look at this opening and think to yourselves "Yep, this is all vital stuff - no way we can cut any of this."?

I strongly suggest you look up the word 'concise' and apply it to future podcasts.
 
I think you all are being really harsh. 8 minutes of non-army review? Just skip it. It's not like you're sitting there taking notes. This podcast is something I have on while I'm painting or doing non-warhammer gaming. For that, I think it's just fine.

The one bone I do have to pick is the review is centered around two or three builds and units such as grave guard get totally overlooked. "How would you make grave guard work?" "I dunno...greatweapons and hope for the best? Mournfang take them off." He is dead wrong that they have no purpose. By his own admission VC are bad at armor. Enter s6 with KB. Are they idiot proof? Heck no. Are they the best choice in the book? Heck no. Am I 3 for 3 against warriors of chaos because of them? Heck yes.

This is a common problem with podcasts, here, let me rattle off the net list and say how all the components are good. As a veteran, duh. I can scrounge the internet as well as the next guy. However, if asked "How would you make grave guard work?" I promise my answer would be better than "Don't take them." The "top players" that Mr. Curry bring on are no doubt good at the game; they have the stats to back it up, but their approach rarely deviates from take the hardest thing I can find in the book and push it around cagey-like. If you're going to do an army review of a net list, please bring up why this player does well with his list. What does Chris do that lower table people don't?

Again, fine job in that this podcast doesn't really deviate from the podcast standard, but I had hoped to expect more of the Bad Dice crew.
 
I would if it was 8 minutes of none army review but if was 3 minutes here, 8 there, 15 there another 5 there.
Its got more holes filled with useless information and babble than Swiss Cheese.
It lasted far to long, the information it gave was nothing new to Vamps counts players, yes their expert has played the new book since it came out yet all our vets know more than him on vamps, he is a good gamer yes but he knows lots of armies where most of us here focus on vamps.

He did shoot himself in the foot with the amour statement, in fact i would say they are one of the best due to high strength characters, models which ignore armour through screaming/ hex wraithyness, tones of strength 5 on cav and GG.....
Poor against armour?..... What the hell is he on about?
If you take nothing but ghouls and horrors I would agree but then I'm afraid if thats your entire force with master necro, your a lemon.

All the units should of been covered in the cast, certainly even if it was half that length but the interviews knew little and the expert still made massive mistakes and point blank ignored some things.
I only listed 2 mistakes, there was a hell of allot more than that.

Going with what you are saying though Ether Dude I think the Thing that Chris knows better than us is the other armies, not vamps.
To him they are a gaming army and he is now on Chaos Warriors as a power army, we devote ourselves to one main army and spend hundred of hours playing, looking up lore and info, looking for cool converts and making our own.
I feel confident in saying 90% of those who post on this thread will run rings round him in a lore conversation.


In the future though as we are nearly all saying this, please edit the content....
Parts were just plain painful to listen too.
 
I think the thing you guys are missing is that its a bad dice podcast episode doing a review of the vampire book. The 3 guys chatting about what they've been getting upto is part of the podcasts charm, if you wanted to listen to nothing but someone going through each unit telling you what it can and cant do like a robot then the bad dice isnt for you. To be honest id be surprised if a podcast that was that dull would get very many listeners at all.

I personally feel like the bad dice guys do a great job mixing actual tactical advice with a nice relaxed feel to their episodes. Having co hosted a much smaller podcast for the last 9 months i know how easy it is to go off topic but i think if you try and stick to a very rigid structure you'd end up with a very dull episode.

I appreciate the fact that there are some mistakes in there too but lets be honest how many times do we all get the odd rule mixed up.

Like most others i listen to bad dice while painting or doing the dreaded chores and i hope they continue to produce great quality episodes long into the future.

Cheers
Xisor
 
Whoah there's a lot of negativity in this thread! Personally I'm a fan of the podcast. Sure I might not agree with everything they suggest, but it's nice to listen to them while painting or travelling and there are quite a few tactical gems in their episodes.
Also I like the odd tangents they go off on and the little talks about what they've been up to. I don't think I could listen to a podcast that was too serious. Keep up the good work guys :)
 
Shyanekh said:
Whoah there's a lot of negativity in this thread! Personally I'm a fan of the podcast. Sure I might not agree with everything they suggest, but it's nice to listen to them while painting or travelling and there are quite a few tactical gems in their episodes.
Also I like the odd tangents they go off on and the little talks about what they've been up to. I don't think I could listen to a podcast that was too serious. Keep up the good work guys :)

^. It's to fill the time while painting. I'm curious to know would be said about the twonks @ Point Hammered(being my fave cast to listen to at work).
 
xisor said:
I think the thing you guys are missing is that its a bad dice podcast episode doing a review of the vampire book. The 3 guys chatting about what they've been getting upto is part of the podcasts charm, if you wanted to listen to nothing but someone going through each unit telling you what it can and cant do like a robot then the bad dice isnt for you. To be honest id be surprised if a podcast that was that dull would get very many listeners at all.

I personally feel like the bad dice guys do a great job mixing actual tactical advice with a nice relaxed feel to their episodes. Having co hosted a much smaller podcast for the last 9 months i know how easy it is to go off topic but i think if you try and stick to a very rigid structure you'd end up with a very dull episode.

I appreciate the fact that there are some mistakes in there too but lets be honest how many times do we all get the odd rule mixed up.

Like most others i listen to bad dice while painting or doing the dreaded chores and i hope they continue to produce great quality episodes long into the future.

Cheers
Xisor

No one said they wanted a robot to give the review no but when you go off topic for 15 minutes on rubbish at a time on a 2 and a half hour pod cast and miss tonnes out it gets bad.
A few minutes here and there, bit kidding about is fine, thats good.
You get that With Wargamer Consortium Videos, Mantic Videos, hell even johnnys videos are not bad and he has done better on his drive to work. (Yes Johnny, I have watched them) ;)

Now I find this is a massively better interview by Beasts of War:

[video=youtube]http://youtu.be/1taWAiZQa9Y[/video]

Its not the same thing as its not a in depth look and it is short but thats how it should break down, easy listening which you can absorb and is interesting enough to listen too which gives you what you need to know.
(Will admit them said at 6:40 that necromancers can expand GG beyond starting size but just read skeleton rules and Necro so mix up in Lord of Dead ability but that are not claiming to be experts)


If Bad Dice Podcast give good tactical advice I will write that off as a bad example of what they do because that was terrible, irritating, uninformative and at times just plain wrong.

Either way from what I just heard I am going to take it if you know the army they are talking about you are better off not listening to it.
 
Hi Guys,

Thanks for all the feedback, the good and the bad!

What surprised the most me about this thread was the sheer anger at the fact that I would presume to inflict such an episode on to people, and the certainty that no-one in their right mind could possibly enjoy to listen to that type of episode. I'm not one to shy away from harsh feedback and criticism but I think some of the comments are a little OTT, especially when this format has been used for around 40 episodes.

Any how, like I said, I'm not one to let a few comments keep me down....

Corrections - Fair points on the crumbling error. Gareth asked if they all crumbled and I said no. My bad. The Ghoul King one Chris should have caught. I didn't spot it at the time. I'm always happy to bring up any errors we made in rules on the next show.

VC vs Armour - I'll back up Chris on that one. I asked my Daily Show listeners and twitter and facebook followers for questions for the review show and we had a load of questions for advice vs armour. It seems that the current meta game with an army with 8-10 units with high toughness and armour (of course backed with magic and magic attacks) is really hammering the VC in tournament gaming. I'm talking, Warriors, Empire, Ogres, High and Dark Elves with armoured builds and mobile characters. Even Bretonnia.

The lord can only be in 1 place, the Terrorghiest is an easy to bring down target and the banshee screams are unreliable. After that the VC have lots of low strength attacks that do not cut it. This is the experience of the Bad Dice guys facing VC, Chris playing with them and also a number of the top players in the UK both with and against VC. Grave Guard are not the answer to this. Far too many units in warhammer will destroy the grave guard very easily for them to be a worthy inclusion to the list as a counter to a small amount of units.

I don't want to turn this thread into a 'merits of Grave Guard' thread but am happy to debate it elsewhere. Send me an email with your counter argument and I will dedicate an episode of the daily show to it. bencurry @ baddice.co.uk (remove the spaces)

So, back to podcast formats.

I do not like to single out other peoples shows as examples but seeing as you raise Beast of War I will run with them. The episode you pointed out was part of a VC week. That episode looked at a few units and was 25mins. There are more in the series. well over 3 hours worth (probably closer to 4, across 14ish separate sections). If you ignore the unboxings and just focus on the gaming and rules reviews it still takes around 2 hours.

This biggest feedback I can take from that is the fact that I should timestamp my show notes so you can jump to segment. I know this but I do not do it as it takes too long. no other reason. If i get enough feedback then I might consider doing it again.

Funnily enough, I know that there are a good number of people that prefer a shorter show with no filler and I cater to that audience too. You guys might prefer my Daily episodes. Its a solo show (just myself and a mic and an occasional guest) that picks one topic and talks on it for 10 - 15 mins.

I have covered VC in the past, you might want to check out http://baddice.co.uk/daily51/ for an interview with Raf Harbinson at a UK event talking about his dire wolf list, http://baddice.co.uk/daily133/ this one is a look at filling your 600 points of core in a VC list and most recently http://baddice.co.uk/daily220/ What Would Curry Do, Vampire Counts. This topic came about from me often getting asked 'what would you do with xxx army' so I turned it into a regular feature.

Its late here so thats all for now, thanks for sitting through the show even if you did hate it. I'm 100% certain that if i got 8 mins into a podcast episode and it was so bad I would have switched off. i know this because I do it repeatedly. (here's looking at you Xizor ;) Love ya Chrissy!!)

Cheers,
Ben
 
We all get a bit critical at time so sorry if it seems a little harsh, nothing personal meant by it.

To be honest it was the first episode I have listen to of your pod cast and I can understand why as well.
None of the information was easy to get, very little if any is of use and a fair bit is wrong in addition to the background conversations like easter drawing it all out.

Now it was not easy but if it was horrible I would not of managed to listen o the full length, it just had a fair few issues.

Correction wise there is more than that but at a hour I decided against listing them as it was going to get stupid.
I think you major issue here lies with the fact it was painted as a expert over look which we were all expecting and it came across as a regualr job blogs look you would expect from someone who is not overly familiar with the army.

Against armour VC have one of the highest base strength armies in the game, certainly great than empire, bretonia, DE, HE and dwarfs.
However depending on the meta is where they excel or not.
Normally you will be looking at a terror ghiest, skeleton or ghoul filled core, a Black knight bus delivery system/ character bunker with some dire wolf deployment drops/ redirecters or the same list with master necro, a zombie bunker or 2 with crypt horror hordes.
Now the latter would have a few issues with armour but the former would carve through it like cheese.
Screaming is still the best way to deal with armour and regardless if they present a target to war machines you are always going to have risks.
Now for the same role you have GG, hex wraiths and BK and 3 screaming types in addition to vampire blenders and just a troll unit or 2 of spirit hosts to ruin peoples days with their expensive flanking units like knights (not chaos), mournfang, demigryph, hydra, etc.

Black knights are currently far superior to the old Grave Guard Bunker.
it all depends on the synergy of the list and at the end of the day if you write off our highest strength infantry choice and second strongest cav (for half the price of the strongest) you are then imposing this limitation and issue on yourself.
This is the issue however, Grave Guard are good in a none competitive environment, in a competitive one however black knights are the only option out of the two.



In regards to that episode, it was used as an example of VC easy listening, nothing more and only covered one part.
If yours was broke up on had a list of times for each part it would make for much easier listening.
 
Ben,
Thanks for doing the review - i enjoy your podcasts quite a bit. The team-effort of you three guys (and often your guests) provide a good spectrum of knowledge and familiarity. Plus you guys are very enjoyable to listen to - i appreciate the hard work and listen a lot.

I did want to post and say that the review was a bit hit & miss for me. Specifically, it felt very focused on the european comp tournament system. Obviously, if that's what you play that's what you know, but i felt that it was somewhat unfair to many of the unit choices in the book. The worth of a unit felt unfairly judged based on your tournament meta game.

I didn't think this was as much of a VC army book review as it was a "VC what's worth taking in England tournaments" discussion. I felt that your guest (who's name I can't remember - apologies) was very single-minded about what builds/units he thought viable (he might not be wrong); there weren't any counter arguments to his views. Don't get me wrong- some of the choices are just fluffy, but not talking about the Coven Throne at all is a disservice to any review. There were a other entries that were either ignored or not explored well. Almost no vampire powers were discussed or even questioned for viability. Thankfully Mark mentioned the Cursed Book (a fantastic item), but it would have gone undiscussed otherwise.

What got me is that your guest was so dismissive of much of the book, yet at the end he said it was one of the best books GW has made. That honestly surprised the hell out of me. I got the impression that he felt the book was rubbish if it didn't fit into a mounted Black Knight build.

I also felt some of the units were judged without considering their role. An example is the Black Coach - this one's a bit hot/cold for people. Sure - it's a 4wound chariot, but it's also T6 with a 3+ armor save, 4+ ward, can become ethereal and doesn't crumble - It's probably our most indestructible unit! It might not stack up point for point to other chariots but for its role in respect to the rest of the VC army it has a lot of value! Your guest talked about the fact that it's going to die if you're fighting 3 empire cannons but c'mon... what in the army isn't going to die to that? That's a terrible reason not to take it. Warhammer is a game of Rock/Paper/Scissors - everything has its counter. In this case, there is tons of value in taking something to be a lightning rod like that - plus it's what i'd want cannons shooting at - the only thing with a ward save that might live.

My point here isn't to defend the BC, but to point out that it wasn't a good discussion of what it can bring and how it can help. I felt it was judged on its merits as a "warhammer chariot" instead of how it fits into the army.

Also there was very little talk about how to use the army in general. Strengths, weaknesses, tactics. VC is a complicated and tough army to make work well. I think the review would have been far more valuable for less experienced gamers (and people new to VC) to discuss how the army works, where it falls down and what you can expect to deal with. A lot of that was touched on, but this is something VC players struggle with. Getting a couple of experienced VC players on the podcast to talk about that (with different views) could make this an astonishing review and very helpful. The Dwellers Below have a good review along those lines for Orcs & Goblins - I've listened to it multiple times for that very reason.

Anyways, I was wanting to give some CC on where i think this review was lacking. I definitely feel you guys had some fantastic info in here and was fun to listen to. I love the podcast and the daily which I listen to every day on the way into work! Keep up the good work and thanks for putting in the time.

-aki
 
You make some massive points there akiro27.

To be honest as i am UK based I know whats hot and whats not and why some things like the coven throne is ignored.
But you are right in saying the book was looked at very little in what it can do and most things ignored in regards to items and only focus on what it can not do which was mainly due to core deficiencies on low strength core.
Particular weakness's of certain types was the only point touched on as well and some dismissed out of hand without even being mentioned or laughed at.

You have hit it on the head though, next review get a pair of game veterans of that army to sit down and discuss a book bit by bit and take in their views, not just someone who has used the book just over a year who can still not get basic things straight and is geared towards elitism.
That is no use to any of us.
 
I thought it was a good enough podcast. Find comfort that if you could pick out the small details that novices would otherwise overlook, then you're totally not a novice :)

If I was new at VC I would be intrigued to try them out (I hope that's the point of the podcast, to promote and expand the hobby). Yes they left out some units but they got the majority I believe.

Here's a little message to all the GG lovers... it's time to embrace 8th and pony up some bucks for BK/CHs/Vargs, for reelz. Bad Dice were spot on that they're pretty laughable in the tourny scene. 4 mounfang can easily delete 30 in 1 round...

Ben: Thanks for attempting to answer my query on hexwraith movement. I supposse the rules on them differ depending on the tourny. I PM'ed Leggy on the Warhammer forum asking how he tabled the Italian triple hexwraith list with his double CH safe build... I have my theories :)

They didn't talk about allllll the filthy things you can do with VC to make them incredible, but good poker players never reveal their hands unless they're called on.

See you at 6 nations... whereever it may be!
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu