Banshee scream in CC

  • The masquerade of murder returns! A new game of Vampires Amongst Us has begun. Unmask the killers, trust no one, and try to survive the night. Find out more and sign up now!

eggsPR

Vampire Count
True Blood
Aug 28, 2011
1,136
Dublin
Zombies
878
Last night I was in CC with a unit, yet my banshee couldn't scream at it bc it wasn't in BTB contact with the unit.

I'll explain:

Regular restrictions are 8" and Line of Sight

However, in the rules, it is written that when the banshee is in Close Combat, it may only scream at the unit in contact, or soemthing (don't have the book with me).

Anyway, apparently if you charge a unit, and your banshees are in the 2nd rank, they can't scream at that unit you charged bc the banshees are in CC yet techincally not in the contact with the unit they're screaming at.

I know what 99.9999% of you are thinking.... "WOW what an @$$hole!!" I agree... however... such is life in the ultra competitive Warhammer world.

Thoughts?
 
Now i don't know if the unit you where fighting could hurt the banshee in CC. but couldn't you just make way so the banshee is in b2b then she can scream?
 
Unfortunately that's not the issue.

I'm talking about after a charge... shooting phase happens before CC.
 
Ugh... perhaps I'm messing this up.

It's my turn:

Movement:
My unit charges him. My banshees are in the 2nd rank.

Magic:
Irrelevant

Shooting:
I cannot scream at him bc Banshees are not in contact with the unit. The unit is in contact, but the banshees themselves aren't. They're still in 2nd rank. That's the issue

CC:
Irrelevant

I can Make Way, combat reform blah blah but that's a different story.
 
Damn... And here I thought you just needed LoS and 8", even in CC.

This is news to me and yep, I'll have to be extra specially uber wierd in my movement shenanigans and banshee placements.

Better I learn this than at the ETC!! Also, I need to tell my teammates as they'll surely be playing against banshees.
 
You might want to read shooting mate on page 39 under fire in two ranks, clearly states that the second rank has line of sight.
 
Banshee screams aren't shooting attacks.

If I'm the in the FRONT rank and say banshees are on either both corners of my unit. If I charge a single file conga line unit of 20mm models... If my banshees aren't in BTB contact with that unit, even though I can see them, I cannot scream at them.
 
I'm no way near as experienced as some of the other generals here but it would definitely seem to me that your opponent misinterpreted the rule on purpose.

In the AB: I f the Tomb Banshee is engaged in combat, her Ghostly Howl can only target an enemy unit in base contact.
Unit is not model, if we count her as being engaged in close combat it could be interpreted as her unit in close combat with enemy unit.
If it was a model in base contact, the distributed as shooting rule would be counter-intuitive.

Or, if we interpret that she is not in fact in close combat we still have the FAQ:

Q: Can the Ghostly Howl of a Tomb Banshee or the Death Shriek of a Terrorgheist be used against an enemy unit locked in a close combat that the Tomb Banshee or Terrorgheist is not themselves involved in?
(p31/48)
A: Yes.

I don't know, I've never gotten shit from my opponents with those arguments. :-)
 
Hmmm Couqonfeis... you may have a really good point.

For your 2nd post on this forum... that's some good stuff :)

:thumbsup:
 
Ghostly Howl: A Ghostly Howl is a special attack that can be used against a single enemy unit in the Shooting phase, even if the Tomb Banshee has marched, charged or is engaged in close combat. This attack has a range of 8 " and needs line o f sight t o its target. I f the Tomb Banshee is engaged in combat, her Ghostly Howl can only target an enemy unit in base contact.

To resolve a Ghostly Howl, roll 2D6 + 2 . for each point by which the result exceeds the target unit's Leadership, the target unit suffers 1 Wound with no armour saves allowed. Wounds from a Ghostly Howl are magical attacks and are distributed as if from shooting.
 
eggspr said:
Hmmm Couqonfeis... you may have a really good point.

For your 2nd post on this forum... that's some good stuff :)

:thumbsup:

Thanks! First post was in the introduction thread, it was pretty good too. :lol:
 
Playing Devil's Advocate:

The FAQ just clarifies what you can do when shooting it like a range attack when you are out of combat. Because of the whole is it shooting/is it not shooting thing.

The rule itself is pretty clear though, in combat the conditions you need to satisfy change. It says a unit needs to be in base contact. It's a special rule specific to her and not her unit. So she would indeed need to be in base contact with a unit. And it does say unit.
 
eggspr said:
Playing Devil's Advocate:

The FAQ just clarifies what you can do when shooting it like a range attack when you are out of combat. Because of the whole is it shooting/is it not shooting thing.

The rule itself is pretty clear though, in combat the conditions you need to satisfy change. It says a unit needs to be in base contact. It's a special rule specific to her and not her unit. So she would indeed need to be in base contact with a unit. And it does say unit.

I AM COMPLETELY WRONG AND SHOULD BE TOSSED IN A PIT OF SNAKES.

Q: If a Tomb Banshee wishes to use her Ghostly Howl attack in close
combat, does this have to be targeted against an enemy unit that the
Tomb Banshee model is in base contact with? (p31)
A: Yes.

Sorry for the confusion I caused.
 
Nah you're not far off. This means that if the banshee model was in BTB contact with something, it must scream at that target.

However that doesn't address if the banshee is NOT in BtB contact with something... Ya know?
 
eggspr said:
Nah you're not far off. This means that if the banshee model was in BTB contact with something, it must scream at that target.

However that doesn't address if the banshee is NOT in BtB contact with something... Ya know?

Yeah, I see it.

She is in close combat but not in base contact. Another interesting notion is the difference in wording between her and the Terrorgheists scream. The Terrorgheist may target a unit in base contact, and she can only the same.

The wording there and the errata makes me think that perhaps it is GW's point to make out that hers is supposed to be slightly weaker. Although that's... Frankly, that's a little much to ask for from GW.... :P

I'm torn here. The rules can easily be interpreted either way but my gut says that she's able to scream and anyone refusing that is purposefully misinterpreting the wording of the rules to gain advantage.
 
I'm reaching here but is there any chance that she's not in Close Combat yet because the CC round hasn't started? Therefore the rules for close combat don't apply until after the CC round has started and she's had the chance to make way?
 
Oppenheimer said:
I'm reaching here but is there any chance that she's not in Close Combat yet because the CC round hasn't started? Therefore the rules for close combat don't apply until after the CC round has started and she's had the chance to make way?

That is super-interesting.

I called GW to get clarification on this. Kyle answered like you said. If you charge then the shooting phase happens before the CC and she can scream as normal, if she wants to scream in subsequent turns she will have had to make way so that the Tomb Banshee model is in base-to-base contact.

I'll admit that he sounded a little... unsure when he said so, might just be that he's brittish though. xD

But that's how the GW employee interprets it and he said he'd take it up with the guys to enter it in the next FAQ/Errata
 
This will be my first post, ive played with a banshee in 2nd rank yesterday as a first. From the way i see it, it goes like this:

Banshee is ethereal and costs a whopping 95pts to field, the mere fact of her standing in a unit makes her part of that unit. This means to me that when the whole unit is in CC with another unit she is allowed to scream at the enemy unit in btb contact, regardless of where in the unit she stands. her attack being a ranged one.
For the sake of common sense, she is a weakling unit that cant have any hits. forcing to be front rank would make no sense as it is way too
vulnerable to magic weapon attacks from the enemy. her unit is in btb combat, that makes her able to shout from the back.
Remember, a 2d6+2-leadership.... its not always that great if ur facing something with a little higher leadership and your roll sux.
Her being as expensive as a 20-man skelly unit, i dont see why she should make herself prone to magic item hits by being itself in btb even tho she is really only ranged. it would completely defeat her purpose altogether and she will never be able to effectively use her skill if she had to be in front rank.
That guy you played against, played you. i would never agree to that interpretation and if it is like that, i would never ever take another banshee in my armylist. 100pts down the drain.
 
couqonfeis said:
I called GW to get clarification on this. Kyle answered like you said. If you charge then the shooting phase happens before the CC and she can scream as normal, if she wants to scream in subsequent turns she will have had to make way so that the Tomb Banshee model is in base-to-base contact.

I'll admit that he sounded a little... unsure when he said so, might just be that he's brittish though. xD

But that's how the GW employee interprets it and he said he'd take it up with the guys to enter it in the next FAQ/Errata

I don't know Kyle, but while he is no doubt a good guy, i am sure he is neither a game designer nor involved with writing the next FAQ. But he might have thought he was just helping out a small gaming group rather than being quoted in a major rules forum.

The interpetation is really problematic though. It basically imply that you can have models in a charging unit that does not count as being in close combat in their shooting phase.

So basically a unit of 2 rank pisotilers could charge a unit of 5 dire wolves. But then the 2nd rank of pistoliers could still shoot at something else in their shooting phase because they are not in close combat in before the CC phase? and how about the first rank. They are in base to base contact, but are they not in close combat yet? maybe they can shoot too? or be shoot at?

I hope you see the problem with Kyle's interpretation.
 

About us

  • Our community has been around for many years and pride ourselves on offering unbiased, critical discussion among people of all different backgrounds. We are working every day to make sure our community is one of the best.

Quick Navigation

User Menu